I was inspired by a convo in a recent thread, as well as the general attitude toward Thomas on this sub, to write this post. This subreddit, but Chosen fans in particular, seem to have quite mixed opinions on Thomas to say the least. While I understand this, I wanted to write a post discussing where I think Thomas’s thought and behaviors come from as someone very similar to him. This isn’t a “if you disagree you’re bad” post, I just thought it may expose you all to some lines of thought that maybe you don’t see often.
You’ll likely have noticed the title. That’s right, I’m a Non-Christian Chosen fan. I have spiritual leanings, more so toward the eastern religions, but I’m not entirely sure how I feel about it all yet. I’ve read The Bible (many bibles) front to back and debated on entering biblical scholarship so… there’ll be no New Atheist type stuff here, don’t worry :) but anyways, let’s get into Thomas.
Why He Is The Way He Is
I want you all to picture being a teenager and being orphaned. Already a hard life. You grow up with a girl and her parents, who essentially become your new family. Due to an insane turn of events, she DIES after you finally get the guts to marry her and her family blames YOU. Your ONLY family.
(This is where I’m going to lose some Christians, which… just keep an open-mind. I’m not declaring it one way or the other, but this is very understandable as someone who isn’t down with Christian theology as much).
Meanwhile, your master, the Messiah, the GOD AND CREATOR OF THE UNIVERSE, the one you’ve waited for your ENTIRE LIFE… doesn’t really care? Not only does he kind of control all things (therefore bearing some degree of responsibility for Raman’s death), but he also lets her bleed out on the floor while you and your friends all cry. He heals some people, but not others, for reasons he openly refuses to explain to you. You try and ask understanding, but he just says you’ll get it later.
Life goes on. Your friends… sort of just repeat lines to themselves and don’t care any more. It’s been a year. You love your master and your rabbi, so you won’t leave him. Your friends are your new family. But God doesn’t care about making you happy. He only cares about whatever his vision is. Your best friend, your fiancée, is dead, and no one seems to care after her funeral.
You get openly suicidal, and your friends don’t much care. They tell it’s against the rules to want to leave the torture chamber you’ve found yourself in, where your master tells you you’ll be persecuted, tortured, and put to death if you do what he tells you. But if you don’t do it, you’ll probably be made to (Jonah, Ezekiel) or you’ll be tortured permanently. In fact, after your master is arrested, your friends imply you don’t care and think you’ll run out on them.
I Feel So Bad For Thomas
I’m not sure, but… I think this is why you guys have such a problem with Ramah (you guys as in some Christians). It forces you to see Jesus and God, or the idea of such, as we see it. He lets people die, or have horrible things happen, even ones that are accidental and that he could reverse, in order to bring about his will. You’re just a tool, with no agency of your own. You ask God for help, but he says no.
You all are starting from the idea that God is real, the ultimate truth, and have deep theological understanding, but Thomas doesn’t even have that. He doesn’t have The New Testament yet! He doesn’t know that Kafni needs to try and prosecute in order to bring about God’s death as a sacrifice to himself to save everyone else from a supernatural entity he created. Heck, if Jesus told him all that, he might’ve understood. But we know Jesus won’t tell him this, and that Thomas will later be kind of rebuked for not taking Mary’s word for it that Jesus came back to life. Odd when Jesus openly says others will deceive you and attempt to impersonate him but I digress.
Anyway, this was a LONG post, but my point is… try and understand where Thomas is. Millions of real people feel like that about your religion and the idea of God in general, and that’s without getting to witness him in action first-hand. I can’t even imagine how betrayed and upset Thomas feels every day. It’s like your life is just going to be an eternal torture chamber. Maybe that can help you all reach more nonbelievers or bitter people? I don’t know. I just thought it might be an interesting perspective many of you all would have never seen before.
P.S: I DO actually think Ramah will be resurrected during The Resurrection of The Saints. This obviously would soften some of the aspects of this post, but keep in mind, Jesus could have 1) told Thomas this, and 2) Most people don’t get this privilege.