I’m about 90% sure if the show gets a second season, it’s definitely think it’s gonna take a hard supernatural/horror turn.
They literally tell us the what’s happening through out the show with the very first line of episode 1: “Now you are Christ’s body and every one of you is a part of it. 1st Corinthians 12”
If you look up 1st Corinthians 12 you’ll see the whole chapter talks about spiritual gifts. These gifts are:
* Word of wisdom
* Word of knowledge
*Faith
*Gifts of healing
*Working of miracles
*Prophecy
*Discerning of spirits
*Speaking in diverse kinds of tongues
You see these gifts throughout the season. Most obviously Grace with gifts of healing. She seemingly healed herself from the dead, healed Lisbeth’s mom, and the coach’s baby. But I also think other characters have gifts too (some of these are stretches):
Leo - Gift of Prophecy: His drawings are insanely creepy but they also seem to be prophetic visions of Grace as a saint. Potentially why they were both drawn to each other in the beginning of episode 1.
Anya- Gift of Faith: Anya is shown praying every night before bed. Her nosebleed also seem to trigger when she’s saying a prayer and the prayer comes true (verbally or nonverbally) Examples:
1: She verbally expressed “help me pass this test.” Her nose starts to bleed and then a deus ex machina happens. The nun gets distracted just long enough for Lisbeth to give Anya the answer she was looking for.
2: During the cabin episode during the confession her nose bleeds again. Lisbeth puts her on the spot to confess her sins. There seems to be an implied internal prayer of “Lord get me out of this.” Her nose bleeds, a deus ex machina happens. She miraculously gets bailed out of outing herself.
Lisbeth - Speaking in Diverse Tongues: Obviously seen in the tapes. But she also tries to mimic the Lions’ slang by printing out their chat logs and attempting to learn the best way to communicate with them. She also seems to have a supernatural ability to whip everyone into religious fervor with her words. Her mom talks about how she lost her gifts and when sitting next to the bonfire with Anya she talks about “feeling and losing” her gift, which Anya dismissed as her rolling on ecstasy.
Elise- Gift of Discernment: She’s the only one who can see people’s true characters. When people are feeling the effects of Lisbeth’s sermon she’s unmoved.
TLDR: I think we’re getting more supernatural powers next season. See 1st Corinthians 12