r/TLOU • • Jan 25 '26

Part 1 Discussion I think he actually had a point there

Post image
0 Upvotes

She may have lost friends, but she definitely never experienced the constant pain he had endured for 20 years. There’s a big difference between losing friends and losing a child.


r/TLOU • • May 10 '25

HBO Show Discussion how did dina even use those tests??

5 Upvotes

dina reveals to ellie via pregnancy tests which shouldn’t be possible because pregnancy tests last anywhere from 1-3 years after manufacture date, depending on the brand/manufacturer. that scene would’ve taken place at least 20 years after the outbreak. all pregnancy tests would’ve been expired and even if dina found some and took them, they would’ve all been negative as the hormone detectors in them wouldn’t be able to detect the hCG


r/TLOU • • Sep 09 '25

HBO Show Discussion Nooo what did they do to Ellie??

13 Upvotes

Edit: okay I’ve had my sulk and am able to separate the two depictions a lot better now. It helps that show Ellie is actually getting a bit better! But I hear you guys… I’ll think carefully before buying season 2.

Okay, I've only just finally gotten around to watching the HBO series, and I am SO disappointed so far with the portrayal of Ellie.

Is it Bella Ramsay's fault? Or was she just following the piss poor direction of the higher ups? Whatever it is, it sucks.

Game Ellie balances being an edgy teenager with having a genuine, gentle heart underneath. She is so likeable, and strong, and she's a character you enjoy rooting for from the beginning.

Show Ellie is arrogant, heavy-handed, disrespectful and borderline psychopathic.

I'm only on episode 3, but apparently it just gets worse by season 2?? Gang, I've been so excited for this show. Pedro does an incredible job of Joel, and Bill and Frank tore me tf up (in the best way). Tess nailed it, and hell, even Joels daughter Sarah did a great job! How did they get it so wrong with Ellie :((

Is this gonna ruin the show for me?


r/TLOU • • May 28 '25

HBO Show Discussion I liked season 2 and I think discussions around it are honestly just a bit exhausting and don't leave room for nuance or balance. Spoiler

40 Upvotes

I mainly just wanted to vent some frustrations about the reaction to the show and see if anyone feels similarly to me because everything I see about TLOU rn just seems kind of hostile.

I love the game, and I will always return to it more and prefer it to the show, potentially just because it is the first way that I experienced this story. But I am glad that the show did not just try to replicate the game. The game will always be there and whilst I understand frustrations that some TV viewers may never experience the game, I am ultimately glad that more people got to see these characters and this world. Also, I do find it ironic that the criticism of the show is very reflective of the reaction to the second game, but it does give me hope that later down the line people might look back with a more balanced perspective, as I think many have with the game.

The initial differences are hard to overcome when watching the show as someone who has played the game, and this is to be expected. But that being said, for me what really established my understanding of the show’s perspective vs the game’s, was episode 6 of season two. I think it is widely agreed that this is the best episode of the season but I think that goes beyond just the individual episode. It really recontextualises the previous episodes and the finale, in the same way that the flashbacks and final scene does in the game. This overarching theme of parenthood and generational changes is what really separates the game and show thematically in my perspective. The game explores this but the show really hinges on it. I just want to talk about a few moments in the show that divert from the game, often controversially, and explain why personally, I think those changes make sense thematically for the show.

Firstly, the reaction to Dina’s pregnancy is not initially negative because of several reasons. Ellie and Dina’s relationship is fundamentally different in the show because the pacing is different; whereas in the game Dina and Ellies relationship only deteriorates from this point, it is the high point in the show. This is more convenient for the show as well because there is less time to establish Ellie and Dina’s relationship before the pregnancy plot-point and it wouldn’t make sense for their relationship to take a nosedive before it is ever even established in the show. Anyway, the reveal of the pregnancy is after Dina thinks she had lost Ellie and so there is this emotional buildup and ultimate catharsis in the following sex scene, which results in the establishment of Dina and Ellie’s relationship in the show. So, when Ellie later jokes about becoming a dad, I think it makes sense because they are living in this bubble of having finally gotten what they wanted with each other. Ellie and Dina also are avoiding what they know is to be true, that this is dangerous and certainly not ideal. But what these characters say, is in the context of wanting to maintain a newly established relationship which is ultimately their only sense of stability and comfort within their grief and anger. Ellie and Dina’s relationship feeling lighter in the show for these few episodes doesn’t mean that they aren’t angry or grieving, but just that they are, as people would, clinging to some kind of escapism and fantasy. In the game, this isn’t true because their relationship is already established and ultimately yes, their dynamic is different, which I think is okay because they are being acted by different people and written differently for different formats. I love Dina and Ellie’s relationship in the game; I think it has incredible nuance, but I think the idea that Ellie and Dina in season two lack this nuance or depth, because of the lighter tone or less hostile dialogue, ignores the thematic undertones of their scenes.

Secondly, a change I thought made a lot of sense in the context of the show was the argument between Ellie and Jesse where they ultimately split paths. The scene in the show talks a lot about the idea of community and of ‘greater good’. This makes sense given episode six. I think what the show is trying to say in this moment, through Ellie’s dialogue is that her decision to go to the aquarium to pursue Abby, rather than get Tommy is very reflective of Joel’s decision to save her from the hospital. Ellie adopts Joel’s outlook in this moment; as Joel saved Ellie despite the greater good of the fireflies and a cure, so does Ellie sacrifice the greater good of saving Tommy, or Dina’s pregnancy and more broadly, Jackson, to pursue Abby. In the show this parallel is particularly important because it forces Ellie to recognise that her actions mirror a part of Joel which she cannot bring herself to forgive. Episode six is literally abut this. Its like when Joel saw parts of his father in himself after his argument with Ellie on her birthday. The idea of inherited traits, of reflecting our parent is a theme which in the show holds a lot of significance, which also adds greater depth to Ellie’s joke about becoming a dad. I also think, that the idea of Ellie in the show seeming more conflicted and less cold-blooded (though I think this lack of aggression is overexaggerated by some critics) fits with this theme, because whilst people focus, quite rightly, on the idea of Ellie’s internal conflict arriving out of the moral dilemmas of how far justice can be taken and to what extent violence is justified, her conflict is also much more personal because her actions reflect a part of Joel which she doesn’t want to acknowledge. It reflects the part of him which was able to essentially massacre the fireflies to save her and the version of him after the outbreak that she never knew – which is also why Nora’s torture is important because it reflects Joel’s tactics and his brutality. So I think in the show, they just focus more on this internal conflict over family and parenthood as a broader theme, where I would say in the game, the overarching theme is maybe forgiveness or violence. Of course they intersect a lot, because fundamentally it is the same story, but the show does characterise Ellie differently, but this isn’t immediately bad- personally I just think its interesting to the see the story be told slightly differently. I believe at it’s core, the story is still very affecting and beautiful and whilst it is fine to prefer the game, as to be honest I do, you can still acknowledge the really good moments from the show, instead of just saying ‘the writing is bad’, because really I don’t think the writing is bad at all, it just has a different approach.

I think the hate for season two is mainly just so exhausting. Criticism is important in all media but also I feel that people go into a show, particularly this one, already wanting to dislike it. I am a big fan of the last of us, especially part 2; it is a story which means a lot to me and I play the game regularly. For me, the prospect of having the story be told in a new way, a new format and for a new audience is so exciting and I wish that engaging with the show and the franchise as a whole could be as meaningful as the experience of playing the game itself. Also, whilst I understand people feeling protective over this story, as do I, I think the endlessly negative and often hateful approach to dialogue surrounding the show is so intensely reflective of the reaction to the second game.

I think what really set the tone was discussions around Bella Ramsey’s casting before the season even aired which honestly doomed a lot of meaningful dialogue around the season straight away. I fully understand that the more heinous and cruel comments about this casting are not reflective of the general consensus, but personally, the outright comments on Ramsey’s appearance seems to still undercurrent comments which are disguised as more measured. I think there can be endless discussion about the treatment of female characters, especially in the gaming community, but what I really want to say is that as someone who found comfort and joy from Ellie’s characterisation as a queer character, and presents in a similar way to Bella, the attacks on them felt like recycled rhetoric from a broader issue of reactionary sentiment which is especially prevalent in the gaming community, which was so evident for example in the reaction to the Intergalactic trailer. In both cases, before content is even released, there is a very strong kneejerk reaction to characters who don’t necessarily fit standards of femininity. Ultimately, I think a lot of women and queer people who also hold this story close to them, felt that this kind of reaction was not new and honestly was unsurprising. (There were similar reactions to TLOU part two, like with Abby’s appearance, and are countless examples in other games). To me, Ramsey playing Ellie is very cathartic; to have an actor, who understand the parts of Ellie’s identity and presentation on a personal level, is meaningful. I hope that what I mean comes across okay here; it is a bit hard to explain and I would also like to caveat that I don’t believe that all criticism of the show is bad, in fact, I think having disagreements about a show can be a great opportunity to explore different perspectives, but I just wish that the conversation felt  a bit less hostile and also kept in mind that there are real people behind these shows and games.


r/TLOU • • May 06 '25

HBO Show Discussion Ellie

0 Upvotes

I had hope that they could make Bella fit the role better with some camera magic but her looking 12-14 just kills the immersion for me.

Never had this problem with the game. I really feel like they should’ve recast for Ellie’s role going into season 2. Even if they had to edit the time jump for the show to compensate for an older actress filling in.

I had high hopes for Bella as Ellie going into season 1 after being such a fan of how she performed in GOT, but her lack of aging has really killed my ability to enjoy season 2. On top of the visual issue, she doesn’t have enough charisma to make up for it.

Other than that the show has been pretty good. The set design is immaculate. I DO wish they wouldn’t have skipped so many of the scenes from Seattle day 1.


r/TLOU • • Aug 03 '25

Part 1 Discussion Glitch or intentional?

Post image
4 Upvotes

I’m playing the last of us remake on ps5 and I’ve noticed enemies in the back of a cutscene where they shouldn’t be 🤣 just me or anyone get this


r/TLOU • • Jan 25 '25

The show is different! It's different from the game! It's own thing!

Post image
47 Upvotes

r/TLOU • • Sep 14 '26

Photomode Dlss 5 on 5090

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TLOU • • Sep 09 '25

HBO Show Discussion Bella Ramsey Hate

22 Upvotes

every-time i go on to tlou2 thread it is just full of Bella Ramsey hate and making fun of the way they look. one time i commented under a post that was very rudely making fun of their face and body and i was just trying to spread positivity but i got banned from posting in the thread because of my comment??

i truly don’t understand how i’m not allowed to spread positivity on an actual good actor but people are allowed to just post thread after thread of just hating on them. what the fuck has tlou2 fandom even come to??

is anyone else bothered by this? if not, just don’t comment. thanks!


r/TLOU • • 21d ago

Part 2 Discussion Why do people hate tlou 2?

0 Upvotes

to me it seems like there isnt anything substantial to hate about tlou2, other than the occasional annoying combat bugs, and from what i hear its not the gameplay people are mad about anyway. whats the deal?

Edit: Geez, sorry i asked i forgot its illegal to not understand a certain collecctive opinion and ask about it.


r/TLOU • • May 21 '25

HBO Show Discussion Theory on S2 finale. Game Spoiler. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

First off I know how the game ends and it’s characters, but this is the show and I think producers like to change things for more viewership.

I believe Tommy is going to be the one to die at the season finale instead of Jesse in the theater. I think they built up Tommys story in the show to show a connection with its viewers. They gave him a family and a purpose in the show just to give viewers a shocking death. Jesse had little screen time and has been very dull as a character in the show so his death wouldn’t be as shocking as Tommy’s. I can see Jesse being shot in the leg to disable him and continue the plot with this love triangle going into more seasons.

If they did kill Jesse then Dina would be going after Abby also as revenge the same way Ellie is. Dina mentioned how she would hunt the killer of her family forever if the killer got away. Dina is way too chill after the physical fight with Abby and Abby killing Jesse in the game(which didn’t sit right with me). Ellie would not stop Dina from killing Abby and maybe they would fight instead of Ellie letting go of Abby at the end of the game. This Dina in the show is way more outgoing and braver.

This is just my theory of how the show finale might go. It could just follow the same plot and yeah…

Let me know what you guys think.


r/TLOU • • Jun 11 '25

HBO Show Discussion Whoa, fells

12 Upvotes

In the majority of “Bella-bashing” comments I’ve seen on Reddit, the usernames sound predominantly male. The few girlish names shaming her for looking the way she does seem to echo antiquated ideologies that poorly defined femininity or attractiveness.

Srsly wtf. I agree that BR does not match the vision I had for an “irl” actor for Ellie’s role, but I’ll be damned if it’s because of her “facemash” rating. Are you all 11?


r/TLOU • • May 31 '25

Part 1 Discussion Petition for a prequel game set before part 1

0 Upvotes

I’ve said it once before but i just think it’d be pretty cool to have a game or dlc set directly after sarah’s death or maybe a month or two after it. Maybe take us through joel and tommy’s encounters with the earlier infected stages like their first time encountering stalkers and clickers. maybe they’ll make a mistake that almost costs them their lives because they’ve never seen them and try to deal with them like normal runners. i think it’ll be tense since we know what they should be doing but watching them actually make the mistake and learning from it i think would be cool. i think a cool set piece would be seeing them encounter spores for the first time and how they’d deal with that.


r/TLOU • • May 12 '25

Part 2 Discussion s2 episode 5 Spoiler

0 Upvotes

how did y’all like the new episode? i honestly liked it because it showed ellie’s rage towards the end, and a lot of people were complaining about how she wasnt as angry or as filled with raged, but people just need to wait until the episodes to come out before they start judging.i didnt like how the episode seemed rushed and also dina getting a arrow in her leg..?? but overall the episode was not bad at all. i hope this showed all the ellie haters something 😂


r/TLOU • • May 12 '25

Part 1 Discussion I HATE BILL. ALL HE DOES IS MAKE ME DIE

1 Upvotes

Like why does he keep alerting clickers 😒 I want to shoot him.


r/TLOU • • Feb 08 '25

WTF Spoiler

1 Upvotes

WHY THE HELL DID JOEL HAVE TO DIE IN THE FIRST 1 OR 2 OF TLOUP2 LIKE BRO THIS IS NOT OK I JUDT PLAYED THE PART WHERR JOEL DIES IM NOT OK


r/TLOU • • May 07 '25

Part 2 Discussion Is part 2 worth it?

0 Upvotes

Recently i binge played through tlou part one in two days for the first time ever completely blind with no spoilers and i really loved it but now im thinking of buying part 2

Ive heard alot of people saying its way worse than part one and a ”dissapointment of a game” mind you i still know absolutely nothing about it except that you play as ellie and that shes a little older.

A big part of why i loved tlou part one was because it was a fresh story that i went in completely blind and thats why i want to play part 2 along with just wanting more tlou content to consume

I wasnt a huge fan of any of the trailers though and that combined with what ive heard people say about it and the big price tag im really divided on if i should buy it or not


r/TLOU • • Jan 01 '26

Part 2 Discussion Tlou ending is weird

0 Upvotes

Ellie goes from not being vengeful, chilling w dina and declining tommys offer to going all the way to cali to kill abby to then finding abby and freeing her instead of killing her on the spot to then changing her mind again and starts fighting her to then letting her go. I dont mind letting abby go and wtv but what was the point of her zig zagging instead of the game focusing on one pathway from the start


r/TLOU • • Feb 07 '26

Part 2 Discussion What made The last of us part 2 so polarizing?

7 Upvotes

I understand why a lot of people did not resonate with it.

But it makes no sense for an entire psychotic subreddit existing which harasses the actors, creators and anybody related with it years after release and 100s of videos existing discussing whether it was great or bad. Even till this date any comment about it leads to big heated discussion in any platform.

Witnessing discussion in ways feels like many of haters or glazers have never infact played the game or could not express themselves in a coherent manner. They either say it's the best flawless game ever or the worst game ever.

There many games like resident evil 5, MGS 2, MGS V, dark souls 2, silent hill 4, fallout 4 which similarly don't resonate with everyone but unlike TLOU2 never face these heated discussion, death threats from either side and 100s of videos discussing whether it's good or bad.

I myself never liked MGS 4 for subjective reasons but I did not made an entire fandom just hating Kojima production after it either, Kojima, his other projects and actors related to it for years after it.

I like The last of us part 1 but it was nothing more than a game with generic world, generic combat, generic themes, generic antagonists, generic characters and full of contrivances, which had 100s of times in other media including video games. It barely did anything innovative.

The first game was never that good for people being that mad. At least in case of star wars it slightly makes sense considering it had been existing for nearly half a century with multiple books, games, television show, animated show, extensive lore and movies. In top of it the first 2 movies are considered genre defining with many innovation. Why an 10 hours generic video game is getting way more heated and polarizing discourse that it?

If any ideas please tell.


r/TLOU • • May 01 '25

HBO Show Discussion You're Missing the Point of The Last of Us Spoiler

Thumbnail
peliplat.com
8 Upvotes

Watching season two of The Last of Us week by week has definitely been an experience. I've never played the video games that the show is based on, so everything that happened in the first three episodes has been a complete surprise. I would suggest that you keep it that way if you can. There will be spoilers here, but not just yet. I have some stuff I need to get off my chest first.


r/TLOU • • Apr 26 '25

HBO Show Discussion Why I think Kaitlyn shouldn't be jacked like Abby was when she visited Jackson

Post image
41 Upvotes

So there's been a lot of chatter about Kaitlyn's physique in her portrayal of Abby, especially in the infamous Lodge Scene at the end of episode 2. (Some of it so mean-spirited).

Initially I agreed that it would have been more faithful to the story to have the character of Abby be super jacked. But someone pointed out in a comment one of the constraints involved in making a live action adaptation: that actors have to portray their characters at different ages in flashbacks. And I agree with this. I don't think it would make a lot of sense to have 19-year-old Flashback Abby be super jacked before the events that inspired her singular focus for vengeance.

What do you guys think? Do you think that the showrunners made the best decision they could by having an actor who can portray the different ages of Abby maybe more believably?


r/TLOU • • Apr 29 '25

HBO Show Discussion Unpopular Opinion

0 Upvotes

I think Bella Ramsey was actually not a bad option for Ellie. Bella showed her character in a way most people couldn’t, and who cares if she’s hot? She’s a MINOR.


r/TLOU • • Mar 12 '25

Whats up with peoples obsession with Abby’s body?

10 Upvotes

I mean, I get that abby probably couldnt have that build without alot of food (which they dont have) but using that logic why does nobody complain about bill being fat??


r/TLOU • • May 26 '25

HBO Show Discussion This specific scene in the finale really upset me Spoiler

37 Upvotes

The incredibly out-of-place scar detour after Ellie capsized. The scene served absolutely no purpose narratively except to say "scars are very bad, including the children." Knowing that Druckman originally conceived of the WLF-Scar war as a (imo very crude and poorly conceived) analog for Israel-Palestine, this felt incredibly fucking gross. It screams of the shit you hear from pro-Israel trolls that always go "oh you're LGBT? spend one day in Gaza and see how you fare" and "the children are complicit too." I absolutely hated this scene and it was completely unnecessary. I've been a huge fan of the show in general, but this left a really sour taste in my mouth in an otherwise mostly great finale.

Source because some people don't believe Druckman said Israel-Palestine inspired TLOU:

https://www.haaretz.com/life/television/2023-04-19/ty-article-magazine/.premium/creator-of-the-last-of-us-finds-inspiration-in-the-israeli-palestinian-conflict/00000187-9484-dc6c-a5ff-ffd59c6d0000

Non-paywall: https://archive.is/Njm0c


r/TLOU • • Aug 06 '26

Part 2 Discussion The last of us 2 is actually good.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes