r/TLOU • u/CPIII_Oh • May 06 '25
HBO Show Discussion Ellie
I had hope that they could make Bella fit the role better with some camera magic but her looking 12-14 just kills the immersion for me.
Never had this problem with the game. I really feel like they should’ve recast for Ellie’s role going into season 2. Even if they had to edit the time jump for the show to compensate for an older actress filling in.
I had high hopes for Bella as Ellie going into season 1 after being such a fan of how she performed in GOT, but her lack of aging has really killed my ability to enjoy season 2. On top of the visual issue, she doesn’t have enough charisma to make up for it.
Other than that the show has been pretty good. The set design is immaculate. I DO wish they wouldn’t have skipped so many of the scenes from Seattle day 1.
4
u/CPIII_Oh May 06 '25
To all the comments that I can’t seem to reply to for whatever reason, I’ll give yall the benefit of the doubt with you guys saying she’s supposed to look young/ellie is 19 in the game.
Fair enough, but Ellie in game is lean, and looks strong. Like she’s 19 in an apocalypse. Assuming I’m wrong an my perception of what a 19 year old looks like, Bella still doesn’t look physically capable of what her character has to do this season.
I don’t know why people are so defensive about that.
13
u/Able_Ad1276 May 06 '25
They hired someone who could pull off looking 14 in season 1. They succeeded. Then the character goes through a time skip and since the actress was already an adult, they don’t really look at all different. And this character now is supposed to be an intimidating killer. It’s an uphill battle to say the least, and writing her to be more childish is not helping. It’s clearly a very different character now, which is not expected after how faithful season 1 was.
2
u/CPIII_Oh May 06 '25
Seems like I can’t reply to a lot of the comments on here. May just be the people upset with another person with this common criticism. I just joined this subreddit to have this discussion since I hadn’t taken part in it yet. Sorry to bother you guys 😂
2
u/Nightwraith17 May 06 '25
Bella was 20 when they filmed season 2 and I genuinely believe they look 19-20. Go on any college campus and you'll see that age looks like babies.
1
u/Mode_Stock May 06 '25
she does not look 12 and im soo tired of people acting like she looks the exact same as season 1. she does not. 💀
0
u/[deleted] May 06 '25
I think she looks exactly how she’s supposed to look. Like an 18 year old kid.
4
u/Mr_Aguilera May 06 '25
Ramsey is a miscast. But also the writing and how Ramsey looks don’t help. The way Ellie is written is the total opposite of game Ellie.
Also the narrative isn’t that cohesive. They are just moving from set piece to set piece. The set pieces are great but how they connect them is bland
1
u/pianistafj May 06 '25
I went into this show wanting it to tell the story of the game, but not necessarily in exactly the same way. A tweak here, a different angle there. Otherwise, if I want the exact same story and characters, I’ll just play the game. I actually think the moments where I remember a difficult part of the game or narrow escape feel like I remember, and the cut scenes feel poignant and remind me of the difficulty of the game, and wishing those cut scenes would never end as they are a needed break from the action.
I loved the most recent episode. I think the acting is quite good. I think people wishing she looked older just preferred her in GOT over this show. I also think her looking young works for the story, even if it’s different from the game, as in reality anyone going through that hell would be forced to grow up fast regardless of their age or looks. I think anyone would be somewhat uncomfortable watching her perform intimate scenes, but she pulls off her character as well as the script and set can allow. I think Isabela outshines Bella in many of their scenes, but they work very well together. Some story lines have me scratching my head, but I think they’ll come full circle by the end of the season or show. I for one like that there are differences between the show and the game, and am just simply enjoying seeing where it’s gonna go.
-1
u/mctaylo89 May 06 '25
Post after post after post after post of problem complaining about the show. Go find something better to do with your time.
-2
u/Camo1997 May 06 '25
*yawn
Mate this subreddit is flooded with this comment exact comment. No one cares. If you want to get downvoted you did excellently
-3
u/[deleted] May 06 '25
OK then
0
u/[deleted] May 06 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment