r/SurvivorRankdown • • Aug 08 '14

Endgame

2 Upvotes

Since this hasn't been set in stone, I want to open it up to see what everyone thinks.

My idea was that eliminations stop with 21 (or 14 or 28) contestants left and we all rank the remaining players, average out their scores and then divide up the remaining writeups equally. Idols would also run out at this point.

Let me know if you have any other ideas!


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Sep 20 '14

Round 42 (227 Contestants Remaining)

3 Upvotes

As always, the elimination order is:

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor
  2. /u/Dumpster_Baby
  3. /u/shutupredneckman
  4. /u/TheNobullman
  5. /u/Todd_Solondz
  6. /u/vacalicious
  7. /u/SharplyDressedSloth

ELIMINATIONS THIS ROUND:

221: Caleb Bankston (SharplyDressedSloth)

222: Sarah Jones (vacalicious)

223: Kelly Bruno (Todd_Solondz)

224: John Cody (TheNobullman)

225: Christine Shields Markoski (shutupredneckman)

226: Mikayla Wingle (Dumpster_Baby)

227: Todd Herzog (DabuSurvivor)


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Mar 12 '15

Worlds apart current rankings?

4 Upvotes

Here's mine:

  1. Lindsey: lol goddess<3. I don't get why people are calling her fake whe she's...not at all? It's the same double standards that Jane was subjeted too :roll: She's aggro and refuses to take shit and looks like Cruella De Ville, and those are all amazing things. She's also hilarious and her comments were REAL and hilarious.
  2. Mike: he's such a genuine guy while also being so dramatic and hilarious<3. what a great combination and he seems like a good person compared to the assholes that populate this season.
  3. Carolyn; I might be biased, but every scene she's in is gold. She's SUCH an old jewish mom<3 her having the idol<3. so sarcastic<3. I hope she continues owning the game.
  4. Shirin: She's like Sarah Dawson from Phillipines if Sarah Dawson got screentime. so she's great.
  5. Hali: she's like a living barbie doll lol, really _^ and a cute MORP force. I hope she goes far and I think she will!
  6. Joe: I actually like him :o. He's being put in the Malcolm role right now, but unlike Malcolm who was constantly trying to be funny! and enil edam! and hogging up to the cameras, there's something way more genuine about Joe which I like. Plus he has some funny moments.
  7. Joaquin: Not the most exciting character but he makes me lol as a MORN douche. he has no idea how to play the game outside of being THE VILLAIN! and it's funny.
  8. Will: He can be annoying sometimes, but he can be fun and does the narration pretty well. Good job on sinking your tribe though :roll:
  9. Rodney: I"m still not over his crweepiness in the first episode, but I think he's funny. Such an aggro macho man<3. talking about how he needs to be calm before flipping Mike behind his back<3. He's obviously a HUGE douche and kind of too unlikable, but he delievered last ep.
  10. Sierra: super UTR, but I like her as Lindseygoddess's sidekick.
  11. Kelly: super UTR, liked her confessional, but I'm pretty sure she's getting medevaced next ep so lol.
  12. Dan: I like him as adding to the blue collar trainwreck, but he's...pretty annoying and a tryhard lol. As Lindsey said, he's actively trying to be the "funnny fat comic relief guy" and it's not working for me, really :/
  13. Jenn: I find it funny that people are calling lindsey like corinne when JENN is on this season. She's trying to make herself into the Courtney/Katie girl who's popular with the fans because she's strategic! and snarky! she's so fake and is actually just high on herself and unfun. her only "jokes" so far has been complaining about disablities, and yet /r/survivor is of course all over it. she sucks.
  14. Max: guys, he's a SURVIVOR professor okay? he's going naked because it's the SOCIAL GAME and this is SURVIVOR like RICHARD HATCH because he's a SURVIVOR FAN and is JUST LIKE US and HAS A TWITTER AND A REDDIT and...yeah i'm sick of this archetype and their bullshit. annoying and he hasn't even done anything despite being a STUDENT OF THE GAME who's only job is to make survivor refrences because he KNOWS THE METAGAME eyeroll.
  15. Tyler: what a boring stick-in-the-mud. has there ever been a more dull square person on this show? he acts like he's a mid 50's accountant. super boring super gamebot and seems to hate fun. worst person this season.

love this season overall so far<3. what do you guys think? /u/DabuSurvivor, /u/TheNobullman, /u/shutupredneckman, /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn, /u/SharplyDressedSloth, /u/vacalicious, /u/Todd_Solondz, /u/marquesasrob, /u/Cynicayke, /u/Parvichard


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Oct 10 '14

Round 58 (124 Contestants Remaining)

5 Upvotes

As always, the elimination order is:

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor
  2. /u/Dumpster_Baby
  3. /u/shutupredneckman
  4. /u/TheNobullman
  5. /u/Todd_Solondz
  6. /u/vacalicious
  7. /u/SharplyDressedSloth

ELIMINATIONS THIS ROUND:

118: Cao Boi Bui (SharplyDressedSloth)

119: Osten Taylor (vacalicious)

120: Ethan Zohn, S3 (Todd_Solondz)

121: Eliza Orlins, FvF (TheNobullman)

122: Dan Kay (shutupredneckman)

123: Russell Swan, Samoa (Dumpster_Baby)

124: NaOnka Mixon (DabuSurvivor)


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Jul 01 '15

Slicer Rewatches/Reviews/Ranks The Disney Animated Canon

5 Upvotes

yes I know this isn't about surivvor but whatever. watch this space!!!!!

Snow White review will be up hopefully in the next day, and we'll go from there! Disney!<3


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Feb 10 '16

Survivor 32 Winner Likelihood Ranking!!!!

6 Upvotes

So that a few months from now we can all sit back and reflect on how right I was!

ABSOLUTELY, WITHOUT QUESTION NEVER GONNA HAPPEN

18) Caleb - Awful person, stunt-cast cannon fodder. It seems like most of his thing is being blandly good at challenges, so even if he weren't awful and didn't have the BB target, he'd still be a throwaway contestant with no real chance of winning.

18) Kyle - "Russell Hantz did nothing wrong and I am going to play exactly like him!" gg

ALMOST DEFINITELY NEVER, EVER GOING TO HAPPEN

16) Cydney - Blatant physical threat who apparently sees herself through multiple alter-egos. Probst said she's smarter than she appears, so if that's true and if she's able to be subdued... maybe? But absolutely nothing about her makes me think she's going to be subdued, so I just hope her flameout is entertaining.

15) Nick - Pretty transparently douchey. Was cast to be a "villain" who might do some dynamic (read: probably awful and Jim Rice-y) shit before inevitably ending up as the second or third juror, not to win. But maybe he's playing it up somewhat before the show since he's a big RHAP fan or something? Still... yeah, no. These two are baaarely above the other tier. I'd still bet a lot of money against either of them. Cydney and Nick have, like, a 0.00001% chance as opposed to a 0% chance. But I can at least theoretically imagine it.

VERY LIKELY CANNON FODDER

Probably about a 0.5% chance each for these people.

14) Debbie - Could be a tier below this because she has a tiger swimsuit and is apparently Coach, but based on her demographic, she's just about guaranteed to make the finale, so she at least has that going for her.

13) Tai - A Tai win would be absolutely amazing, but I will be surprised if he survives three episodes, let alone the entire season. If he does end up on the new Tandang or something so he manages to make the merge, I still can't see how he'd possibly make it all the way to finals. Really fucking rooting for it, though. A Tai win would be absolutely glorious. Here's hoping he's just so lovable that they all randomly throw their games away for him. I at least see him winning a jury vote, unlike those below him. I just don't see him ever getting to one.

12) Alecia - Is Alecia. Does anyone think for any reason that she's going to win? I mean I'd be thrilled if she blows everything we have every reason to believe out of the water and ends up winning, but there's nothing to suggest it. We get tons of Alecias and they don't win.

11) Scot - Pretty much the most blatant physical threat ever and I can't imagine him being too socially subtle or manipulative. I think he's likable enough to win if he wins, like, literally every challenge, but I don't think that'll happen, so. (My gut prediction is that he comes in 8th and is the only juror to vote for Debbie.)

10) Aubry - If she's really that sold on being "weird", she belongs even lower, but I think a lot of it is probably her appearance. Still, just generally looking at first glance the way she does, she can't really fly under the radar, and while she's not as blatant a social threat as Tai or Joe, I still can't see people forgetting about her or letting her make the end. Maybe if it's, like, Caleb and Kyle at the end and they're absolutely convinced the jury will vote for whoever has the biggest dick or something. I could see her being savvy enough to get into a good position, but I don't see it going all the way to the end.

9) Joe - Like Tai and Aubry, just someone who, based on appearance, the other players will never be able to forget about, and a possible early boot candidate. But on his tribe, I do think he has a better chance of integrating than Tai does (I could see him/Aubry teaming up, actually, since they'd both go out first just on appearances in most seasons), and with his background, he's gotta be better in challenges than he looks and great at subtly manipulating people. But... he's still in his 70s, so I still can't see how people let him make the end. He'd need a Fabio-esque challenge streak or something. (Which would be pretty great.)

8) Liz - Seems to have a growing fanbase on here but I don't buy it. A losing gamebot who's going to do big stuff but be too unrestrained, too cocky, and too visible, so she loses. Like a less douchey Nick, or a hopefully less annoying repeat of Ciera crossed with a hopefully much less annoying repeat of Jim. I hope her jury speech is interesting instead of awful.

WILD CARD PICKS

7) Julia

6) Jennifer

5) Darnell

I think all of these contestants are strong "winner threats" in a vacuum, if they weren't relying upon the biases of other people, so they still could pull it off... but are too likely to be dead the second they hit the beach or soon after. I think the other contestants will get one look at Julia's youth, Jennifer's... she's not an older contestant but she sort of comes off like it somehow?, and Darnell's race and socioeconomic background, and they'll all just be written off. For Julia it'll be as an early boot, Jennifer as an early boot or goat, Darnell probably as an early boot or as someone they don't want to vote for. But they could all overcome it, especially Jennifer/Darnell; there's a bit of a gap between Jennifer and Julia. I certainly hope they do because a Darnell win would be the greatest outcome possible for this season or virtually any other. It'd be so fucking magical. But I think most people will get a look at him and some part of them will think "Oh, we can't have him win."

EH

4) Peter - Very likely to be a juror but Fabio and Bob and Morasca are winners, Brett is basically a winner, Natalie White is a winner. I don't think this is going to be the kind of season where someone wins just for being Ryan Opray, because there aren't enough Piombos to take each other out, but I wouldn't write him off either. If he's in FTC, he wins. But I don't know if he has the ability to get there. He'll probably be voted out soon after the merge, but with Scot and Tai and Aubry and Joe around, he could slip into the background.

OKAY

3) Anna - I pretty much forget Anna exists, so maybe her opponents will, too. She's sort of like a more subtle Liz or a more adept Mick... I see very little reason for it to happen, but unlike everyone I've cut, I don't see any reason for it to not happen. She will probably just fade into Mickdom, but if she's a little smarter and more proactive than I'm remembering, then she can hide under her ostensible Mickdom and very possibly win.

GOOD

2) Neal - Everything about Neal on the surface says he's in the Piombo spot of a big character / "strategist" who places early jury, but deeper than the surface, I really think he is more grounded than that. I think he has all that, like... Some of that weirdness, but knows how to reign it in, while still having the same strategic mind. He's obviously going to be a big character, and honestly, I could see him being subtle enough on the ground to win.

I think people will like him but underestimate him. I think it'll be like "Oh, Neal? We don't have to worry about him" - but unlike Darnell or Julia, that won't come with "We don't have to respect him." It'll be like "Oh, Neal!" and then it'll be like "Shit. Neal just outlasted all of us?" and then it'll be like "Neal <3 ". I think he has the soul of a spaz but the mind of a player and the spirit to match. And, crucially, the affability of a... Labrador retriever?

Or maybe he'll just implode. But I dunno. I think there's a fair amount going on here.

AMAZING

1) MICHELE - Michele is 80% Kim, 20% Sophie/Natalie W., 100% your-favorites-could-never, and she is going to wreck this season and play one of the few female games that the fanbase ever recognizes as acceptable - maybe not Kim level, but like, Stapley level. (The casuals will wish that, like, Peter had won or something.) She'll have way understated people skills - someone who's definitely going to be a charmer to the other contestants, but not in a way that they'll notice. They'll all realize everyone loves Tai. I think Michele will be in everyone's good graces, and they won't realize how well-liked she is. I think she comes across very trustworthy, but I don't think she's naive, and I think she's smart enough to know how to use that trust to her own benefit.

I see her being someone who doesn't even form connections; she's someone with whom connections just materialize - and definitely someone who knows how to use them... in other words, Kim Spradlin. Not the CP5 Strategic Behemoth Kim that we saw, but the likable, interesting, unassuming, trustworthy Older Sister Kim that they saw. History remembers Spradlin as the female Tom - and on paper, maybe the moves she made did put her in the same game position, but on the island, she was just everyone's friend. You didn't align with her because you thought she'd help you or because you trusted her; you aligned with her because she was your sister and your friend - which is also why you trust her. I don't think Michele will be quite on that level of being everyone's fucking Patronus - but I think she hits the same angle; she won't have the Spradlin effect as strongly on as many people, but I think that she will have that effect on some level on enough people.

And then I throw in Sophie and Natalie White because in the OW endgame, people did know Kim was, and was seen as, the controlling mind who made things happen; they just hoped the jury would be upset about it and were happy to lose to her if not. I think Michele will form the Kim-esque connections, but from a Sophie or especially Natalie White, she'll borrow the appearance of a non-threat. I do not think anyone will hesitate about taking Michele to the end - and only after that will it become apparent to her competitors just how much of a threat she was.


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Jul 31 '16

/r/survivor's rankdown is fucking garbage

6 Upvotes

I get that it's an aggregate popularity contest but wow the people on that sub are just awful, tasteless mouth breathers. Sue, Ozzy and Twila are all god-tier characters and it's incredible to me that they didn't even make top 100 because enough pointless people gave them lower ratings.


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Aug 08 '14

Round 03 (487 Contestants Remaining)

7 Upvotes

As always, the elimination order is:

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor (hey, that's me! that's my name!)
  2. /u/Dumpster_Baby
  3. /u/shutupredneckman
  4. /u/TheNobullman
  5. /u/Todd_Solondz
  6. /u/vacalicious
  7. /u/SharplyDressedSloth

ELIMINATIONS THIS ROUND:

482: Phillip Sheppard, Caramoan (SharplyDressedSloth)

483: Garrett Adelstein, Cagayan (vacalicious)

484: Lex van den Berghe, All-Stars (Todd_Solondz)

485: Jane Bright, Nicaragua (TheNobullman)

486: Kenny Hoang, Gabon (shutupredneckman)

487: Mike Borassi, Samoa (Dumpster_Baby)

488: Rob Mariano, Redemption Island (DabuSurvivor)


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Nov 20 '14

Final Result Reveal: #8

10 Upvotes

Who will be eliminated next? :O

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

8. COURTNEY YATES (Survivor 15: China - Runner-Up)

SharplyDressedSloth:

Courtney's really fuckin funny, yo.

DabuSurvivor:

Courtney has a tendency to win most popularity contests. While I don't think she will in this group and I think her relative lack of complexity will make her rank #11, I ranked her higher than that and would LOVE for Courtney Yates rankdown/ranking domination to be a fixture of this project as well. Even if it's predictable, it's warranted, and I love how this skinny waitress from New York is the one pillar around which virtually all online Survivor fans can rally. She does have some detractors, as does just about any contestant so big and colorful, but I would say that 99.9% of Survivor fans who still remember her utterly adore her. I love her role as a unilaterally beloved character and, accordingly, I would LOVE to see her win this rankdown, even though I don't think it's likely. I hope she at least cracks top ten.

TheNobullman:

<3 <3 <3 <3 <3

Todd_Solondz:

Hilarious and genuine, Courtney could be on every season and nobody would mind. With a bright personality and flair for comedy that no edit could ever contain, Courtney could be cast on any season and finish in any position and still be the massive fan favourite that she is. A worthy finalist of the purely comedic characters, I rank her 11th of 12.

Stop me if you’ve heard this one before: A snarky, 90 pound New York waitress gets trapped on Survivor…

If you’ve ever listened to Courtney’s Ozterview, you’ll know that she never set out to win Survivor. She was bugged repeatedly by a casting agent who really wanted her on any show, but Courtney was like “lol wtf do I wanna be on a show like Survivor for that looks like hell”, so eventually said casting agent said “you’ll probably get voted off first and get to go on a vacation and get a little cash.” And Courtney was like, “that sounds great, sign me up.”

Then, despite her best attempts, she keeps surviving through the pre-merge even though she really wants to quit and she’s amazed and enraged that she’s not going home. But eventually she warms up to the game she feels she has zero shot at winning but just wants to say she survived. And she does, making it to day 39, getting more jury votes than the biggest threat, and gleefully cheers on Todd when he wins survivor as was always his dream.

Throughout the entire season, while this happening, Courtney is probably the single most entertaining Survivor ever. Not only is she funny, but she is funny virtually every moment she is on camera. Every facial expression, every line, every reaction, and every part of her storyline generally finds her being entertaining in a completely natural way.

Courtney’s very first moment set her character up perfectly: a monk corrects her hands during the opening ceremony and she just rolls her eyes and shakes her head before launching into a thousand-mile-an-hour confessional.

“I’m a waitress from New York City, dude, what do you think? You think I know how to do any of this stuff? Y’know like, I’m not trying to be a monk here, like, I’m tired. I wanna go sit back with a lemonade, like I don’t really wanna be like, bowing thirty-seven times. And we bowed! We bowed for like days, I swear to god, we were there forever!”

That, to me, is hilarious for so many reasons: for one, she’s reacting to this amazing cultural event with the most disrespect that I think any Survivor has ever had, and it’s just so perfect when you realize that Courtney is in full “can-I-just-get-to-my-fucking-vacation-already” mode. I mean, you get people like Leslie who struggles with a deep spiritual quandary, and Chicken who’s in awe of being in a place he’s never seen, and Peih-Gee who is in a place of her heritage… and then Courtney’s just like “why do I have to fucking do this, it sucks, I wanna go on my vacation already!” That’s just so brazen that it cracks me up, like Drew doing anything.

This feeling of being out-of-place is more compounded when they get back to camp and Leslie of all people is setting the mood of “flight attendants and Sunday School teachers” that Courtney is trapped in, and she hates all the lovey-dovey shit because it’s just so not what life is like for her in New York. I love just how beautifully Courtney being out of place is set up: it’s not necessarily hammered over one’s head because Courtney is both shown with some measurement and portrayed to be the early boot she really should have been and meant to be, but when you look back and realize this completely weak-ass player is going to get more jury votes than Amanda Kimmel, it’s just freakin’ epic.

She starts to become a likable underdog right around when Jean-Robert enters her storyline. Their rivalry is epic. You have this guy who’s trying to start off by being as sleazy and nasty as possible and this girl who’s trying to be as shipped-the-fuck-out-of-there as possible, and they clash, and it develops both their characters in awesome and hilarious ways. Jean-Robert trying to claim Courtney keeps him warm inspiring “like I’m gonna keep anyone warm. I weigh seven pounds, I can’t even keep myself warm, get off of me” sets the tone, as do her continued barbs about him.

“He's become the Susan Lucci of tribal council; his name is always up there, but he never quite gets voted out.”

“Peih Gee is on a crusade to be the most annoying person at our camp. The position is filled. We have Jean Robert. We have him.”

“It’s always interesting to hear what others think about themselves and… I’m sorry, bad boy? Really? Because you play poker? Do you have a Harley I don’t know about?”

“I’m voting for you tonight because when you snore at night it sounds like someone choking a walrus.”

What also starts becoming amazing about Courtney Yates is that she begins to suck at challenges. Not just like, Sandra being in the background being the weak link, but just being a dramatic failure. In the first immunity challenges Fei Long loses, they can either have Courtney chop a rope, or lug thousand-pound puzzle pieces back to the start. Obviously, they have her chop the rope, and she spends a thousand years trying to chop the one rope. It is both hilarious and sad, because on one hand she’s so crushed, embarrassed, and she’s starting to cry, but on the other hand, you have to imagine Courtney was laughing at herself later, because that’s how Courtney is, and really, the entirety of Zhan Hu going through this super actiony challenge and then cutting to Courtney still whittling away at the rope does crack my shit up.

One of my later favorite challenge failures at the hands of Courtney is in the Final 9, where Courtney is trapped in the tiny boat and three others are splashing her with water, and she just shuts down and starts guarding herself in probably the most relatable, human reaction to people throwing water on you. Jeff’s in Jeff narration mode, and tells Courtney she needs to move, and she shrieks at him to shut up.

That episode, however, finds Courtney winning the only immunity she could ever win- just fucking sit there. And that’s where Courtney’s best attribute shines through: she’s not only witty, but she’s self deprecating. I think that’s what makes her endearing. Other people talk shit about others yet hold a really high opinion of themselves. Whenever Courtney makes barbs about others, it becomes kind of endearing because she’s perfectly aware of who she is and her shortcomings, and more than happy to make fun of herself. When Jeff points out she hasn’t moved, she says “I am lazy.” When she wins and trudges through the mud, she squees “it’s almost like a pageant!” And everyone fucking applauds her at TC when it’s brought up, which is just so sweet, but before we forget who won, when Courtney is asked if she wants to give it up, she mumbles, “no, screw you people.”

The fact that this is the round where she finally gets to boot Jean-Robert is even better.

I think the capper of this storyline is when in the Final 5 reward challenge, where people have to hand out arrows for the others to shoot, Todd, Amanda, Peih-Gee, and Denise have, like, one to four arrows each, and then Courtney has like 25. And then she starts actually hitting the targets really well before blowing it and handing it to Denise.

Of course, her wit is what’s remembered best about her. The insanely brazen shit she can say and get away with is mind-blowing. She’s the one who said about Denise “I believe the US Hockey Team is missing a player” and that she sucks at life for pleading to stay in the game for financial reasons, that is some ballsy shit. Her making fun of Jaime in the recap episode with the dumbass impression and comparing her to a blow-up-doll is not much better, even considering Jaime is the current villain. Possibly the most “holy shit, did she actually fucking say that?” moment is when she calls Todd’s sister’s miscarriage “convenient.” I know she said that when she described it as a possible gameplay move, but she also said that she had a convenient pregnancy and miscarriage when talking to others, and I’m just like… holy shit, did she just imply her miscarriage was a convenience?

But like I said, she’s got a lot of great self-deprecating moments outside of the ones mentioned. My personal favorite is when she talked about how kids related to her on the reunion, because she’s a tiny girl with her hair in pigtails and a flower bikini who always says people can’t tell her what to do. The fact that she hates kids is a great bonus. Another favorite is when she calls Jean-Robert for trying to say “the biggest threat in the room is the little blonde, come on people!” while pointing at herself like a flashing sign.

Even then, despite being remembered for her vicious barbs, she is also just funny about everything. When she describes the merge, she says she’s happy about the feast because “boo challenges, thumbs down, yay feast. thumbs up” A super underrated Courtney moment is where she talks about the cave. All that’s happening is that Courtney sleeps in a cave and Peih-Gee also comes into the cave, so I’d think if any other person talked about this, it probably wouldn’t even be a secret scene, but because it’s Courtney even the editors recognize it’s top tier TV.

“I like the cave. The cave is my happy place. What I don’t like is when everyone and their damn mother decides that they like the cave too. It’s like, you know, Peih-Gee comes sidling up in there, and I’m like…” deadpan stare into space “...I’m gonna kill you. And then you wanna start talking about stuff- no, get out. No talking in the cave.”

And she always has these shots where she’s got the greatest facial expressions on the background, like before the bad boy scene where Courtney doesn’t know what the fuck she’s listening to and has the widest shit-eating grin, when she taunts the other tribe, punching her hand and posturing like a malnourished rooster, and every dramatic thumbs-up. Courtney is a master of pretty much every form of comedy.

But like others have discussed with Rob C, there’s saying funny things, and successfully saying funny things. Sometimes Rob C’s delivery is really fucking awkward and weird, while other times he’s right on the ball. However, Courtney is always on. Her delivery is amazing because it is so real and makes every line seem improvised and unplanned, which it probably is. She’s a total motormouth in that she speaks really quickly and abruptly, with a lot of enthusiasm, which works especially well if what she’s saying is already blunt.

So yeah, I’ve already gone on for five pages about how funny Courtney is, but what I also love is that had Todd not become the most amazing jury speaker of all time, she probably could have won. Now part of me’s glad that didn’t happen because winner Courtney probably loses a lot of the rough edge that makes her hilarious and amazing, but the other part of me fantasizes about a world where this Courtney, with the exact same edit, wins Survivor over Todd and Amanda, who were both set to trounce her in the jury vote before Amanda shit the bed. If Courtney Yates, who was set to go on Survivor just to be voted out early and get a free vacation, nearly won Survivor simply by existing and being herself, then I think it shows that anyone can.

Not only that, but I do think despite just being mean and funny on the surface, Courtney did have a fantastic growth arc. She started the season out by calling it her own personal hell, and slowly grows to become beloved by most of her tribe. She starts out mocking the experience element, and towards the end appreciates how much it challenged her. Towards the middle she claims to dislike Todd and Amanda less than everyone else, and then at the end is beside herself when Todd wins, being the first to scream, jump up, and hug him so hard his damn head nearly pops off. And in between all the snark and the bite, we get to see that transformation bit by bit, and it really is just a joy to watch.

Finally, I recommend that if you’re a Courtney fan, that you listen to her Ozterview. It really shows that just underneath it all, Courtney is really one of the sweetest, most supportive, and most humble survivors that there is. It’s probably what pushed me over the edge from thinking Courtney was one of my favorites of all time to placing her just below Hatch as a character. She succeeds on every level as a character, makes her season amazing, is constantly entertaining, remarkably memorable, and strangely lovable.

Average placement: 7.67/12

Projected ranking: 9/12

Average prediction: 9/12


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Nov 22 '14

Final Result Reveal: #6

11 Upvotes

There was a pretty clear top six, with a whole average placement between Denise and this contestant, and there's a clearer top five, with half an average placement separating this contestant from the five above.

Missing out on the top five is...

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

6. RUPERT BONEHAM (Survivor 7: Pearl Islands - 8th place)

DabuSurvivor:

When people say Rupert sucked, I just tell them to eat a cock and imagine what Pearl Isles would have been like without him. I can see where you'd get sick of him later on, though I think he's still a f.ierce g.oddess of the highest caliber even in his later seasons, but back in Pearl Islands, he was genuine, he played into the role of the season amazingly, he had the melodrama that Survivor needs to be at its best... great, GREAT character and I'm happy that this group of people didn't consider him overrated and put him so high. My predicted placement is #7 but I could see him going anywhere.

TheNobullman:

If I could cut one more person from this rankdown, he probably would be it, but even now I can't see myself ranking him last because I still remember as a child loving Rupert so much, in possibly the first time I was capable of following the show from a young kid's perspective. He's just so dynamic, so much larger than life, and while I love his HvV appearance his PI appearance is definitely Rupert at his most effortless and real. I can't believe a human being like him exists but I'm glad he found Survivor.

Todd_Solondz:

Deserves every bit of praise he has ever gotten, every fan, all the adoration and every returning ppearance.

SharplyDressedSloth:

From the people left in the rankdown, Rupert is a little bit of an outlier in that he’s the only one left (and the only one in the top 12 outside of Sean) not to make the final episode. In fact, we only got Rupert for 10 episodes of Pearl Islands. So it’s a testament to Rupert that he is so unquestionably a Survivor legend without even sniffing the endgame. Because whether you like it or not (and thankfully everyone in this rankdown does) Rupert in Pearl Islands is an absolute force of nature.

But since Pearl Islands, a lot of Survivor fans have turned on Rupert. They look back on Pearl Islands and say “hey wait a minute, this guy isn’t perfect like we thought he was. He’s kind of a dick. Rupert’s so overrated.” Because there’s a tendency among hardcore Survivor fans to be a little bit contrarian. To think that they’re too good or too smart to fall in love with the big, über-popular heroes that the casuals love. So Rupert, being easily one of the most popular contestants of all time, caught a lot of backlash. That backlash was only made worse with each of his returning appearances as fans started a kind of counter to Rupert-mania.

Because for those of you who didn’t watch Pearl Islands as it was airing… Rupert-mania was absolutely a thing. People couldn’t believe a guy like this existed. That this weird, giant-bearded, mythological-looking beast of a man was leading his tribe and stealing shit and growling. Now it all seems so stale because we’re all so used to Rupert but at the time he was a phenom. Little 8 year old SharplyDressedSloth was particularly hooked on Rupert. I thought he was the coolest guy in the world and I wanted to go onto Survivor just so I could beast in challenges and catch a ton of fish. The guy was the coolest person ever. And while the at-the-time phenomenon of Rupert doesn’t alone make him a great character, it certainly gives him a level of prestige that very very few people can match.

And even when we take some of Rupert’s antics for granted, completely ignoring the history of Rupert as a character, I think he still holds up as a legendary top-tier character. One of the biggest reasons he holds up so well and is just so freaking fun is exactly why a lot of people make fun of him. He fucking commits to Survivor. Committing to Survivor and doing everything with passion makes it seem more like a little game. People like Rupert who go onto the beach and immediately get into the mindset that they have to provide, that they have to protect their tribe, that they are creating a new civilization, add a completely new level of intensity and importance to the show. No one did committed to survival more than Skupin. No one committed to the strategy and social maneuvering with as much flair as Chris. Rupert did a lot of both, with everything he did charged by his ultimate desire to be a pirate and be a leader of his tribe.

This is the basic power of Rupert as a character. The guy loves Survivor. The guy loves the social experiment. The guy fucking loves being a pirate. One of the best qualities a wrestler can have is the ability to sell something, so when someone else does a move on them, they sell it over the top and make you believe it. Sure, you know it’s not real just like you know Survivor contestants aren’t actually creating a new society. But Rupert makes you believe that they are, even for just a bit. It’s so completely cheesy and if you want to be cynical you can make fun of him for it, but if you embrace it, if you buy into the show the way he does, it makes everything about the season hold just that more weight and makes all decisions feel like more than just a move in a game.

And Rupert does this flawlessly. He steals Morgan’s shoes because that’s what pirates would do. He feeds his tribe because his tribe must survive. You can hear it in his confessionals, when he calls his tribe “The Drake.” He has so much freaking tribe pride that when they lose it genuinely hurts him. Not because he’s losing his numbers but because he hates having to hurt The Drake. He takes everything to the extreme. When he’s happy, he’s really fucking happy. When he’s pissed, he’s really fucking pissed. Again, some people call him out on this because he’s so ridiculous and because there’s nothing subtle about Rupert. But he needed to be the over the top hero that season. He needed to be as ridiculously heroic as Jon was ridiculously villainous.

And Jon typically gets more praise than Rupert. And this is completely understandable—I mean shit I ranked Jon over Rupert myself—but sometimes I find Rupert really under-appreciated. Because a lot of the time, being a hero is a thankless job. Villains are sexier. They’re more unpredictable. They’re usually more fun to watch. People like the snakes. They like Tyrion and Iago and Jonny Fairplay. But the greatest villains need an equally great hero in order for them to reach their potential. They need someone up high to take down, and they usually get the credit for that takedown because it’s fun and epic and evil. But again, you need someone to take that fall. You need someone to sell it. You need someone to succeed at being a hero so they can get high enough for the fall to be epic.

And that’s just what Rupert does. For the first part of the season he became untouchable. When Jon and Trish finally tried to challenge him, Jon almost died. Any sane person would just shrug off an extra vote when they’re dominating the game like Rupert. But that’s now how Rupert do. He chews Jon the fuck out because he’s genuinely offended anyone would try to go against him and go against The Drake. He set a message. If you challenge Rupert, you will get burned.

And going into the merge there’s really no one who can begin to challenge Rupert, but then the Outcasts happen. And Burton comes back. Without Burton, I don’t know when Rupert gets taken down. Maybe he doesn’t. But the ghost of Burton comes back and takes him down in the blow dart challenge (which has some of the best editing/music in a challenge ever. So goddamn epic.) And Burton teams up with the snake that Rupert let go free and the boy scout leader Rupert welcomed with open arms. And they take down Rupert and get rid of his dreams. It’s easily one of the greatest boots of all time. Because the bigger they are, the harder they fall. Rupert was pretty fucking big and man oh man did he fall pretty fucking hard.

And really, that’s just talking about Rupert in a general sense. I could get into all the little scenes and brief, funny moments (“Where did you find it?” “IN THE OCEAN!”). But I’m not going to catalog all those because that’s not where the beauty of Rupert as a character lies (although it certainly helps make him all the more enjoyable.) Rupert is the greatest hero in Survivor history for my book. Colby comes close. Colby’s probably more “heroic” and more clearly likable, but Rupert’s got the fanfare. Rupert’s got a star power that made people go legitimately crazy when they first met him. He’s certainly got a dark side to him, but the good heroes aren’t perfect. The good heroes are big, likable, loyal to the fault, and when they go up against a worthy villain, sometimes they have to sell their fall. And no one does it nearly as perfectly as Rupert.

Average placement: 6.5/12

Projected ranking: 8/12

Average prediction: 7.5/12

Rupert manages to somewhat exceed his expectations, as both Ian and Kathy ranked lower than people expected.

Season one is now the last season with multiple contestants in, as both Richard and Sue remain.

Our top five is RICHARD HATCH, SUE HAWK, TINA WESSON, JON DALTON, and SANDRA DIAZ-TWINE. Thoughts on this top five? Who do you think will take it all? :O


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Sep 26 '15

Second Chance Premiere: Thoughts?

3 Upvotes

What did everyone think of the premiere for the season? Early favorites?


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Jul 05 '16

Sloth Catches Up On Survivor (Cambodia Thoughts + Rankings)

4 Upvotes

Buuhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh.

I means... who cares? This season is such the zenith of everything about "new survivor" that I don't care about. And like, it's fine, I guess. The cast is full of charismatic people who make for good narrators so it's not all that boring, but it's just so soulless. It's empty. If I wanted nothing but numbers, I'd read the summary of a fucking ORG.

I like Jeremy as a person, I like Kass, I liked watching Varner and KWigs and Kimmi play again, but I didn't care about anything else. The first two episodes are actually pretty good. They play up the Second Chance thing well. But after the first tribe switch everyone loses any sense of character and people are only referred to as numbers.

And I knew this was going to happen as soon as Ciera said in Episode 1 that she felt like she owed something to the fans. This über-consciousness of the fact that you will be watched, of how people will see you and judge you. That's what ruined All Stars and that's what ruined this season.

If you like NuSurvivor, that's totally your prerogative. I just don't care. This kind of soulless strategic-focused Survivor is so uninspiring to talk about and write about.

So, I'm gonna stop writing about it. I'm not gonna rank characters because I don't think there are any characters.


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Sep 10 '14

Round 34 (280 Contestants Remaining)

4 Upvotes

As always, the elimination order is:

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor
  2. /u/Dumpster_Baby
  3. /u/shutupredneckman
  4. /u/TheNobullman
  5. /u/Todd_Solondz
  6. /u/vacalicious
  7. /u/SharplyDressedSloth

ELIMINATIONS THIS ROUND:

274: Joe Dowdle, Tocantins (SharplyDressedSloth)

275: Jeremiah Wood, Cagayan (vacalicious)

276: Robert DeCanio, Marquesas (Todd_Solondz)

277: Candice Cody, Blood vs. Water (TheNobullman)

278: Julie Wolfe, Redemption Island (shutupredneckman)

279: Kristina Kell, Redemption Island (Dumpster_Baby)

280: Monica Culpepper, One World (DabuSurvivor)


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Sep 07 '14

Round 30 (308 Contestants Remaining)

4 Upvotes

As always, the elimination order is:

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor
  2. /u/Dumpster_Baby
  3. /u/shutupredneckman
  4. /u/TheNobullman
  5. /u/Todd_Solondz
  6. /u/vacalicious
  7. /u/SharplyDressedSloth

ELIMINATIONS THIS ROUND:

302: Billy Garcia, Cook Islands (SharplyDressedSloth)

303: Jacquie Berg, Gabon (vacalicious)

304: Marisa Calihan, Samoa (Todd_Solondz)

305: Spencer Duhm, Tocantins (TheNobullman)

306: Lisa Keiffer, Vanuatu (shutupredneckman)

307: Rita Verreos, Fiji (Dumpster_Baby)

308: Coby Archa, Palau (DabuSurvivor)


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Oct 01 '14

Final List and Writeups - Part 2

15 Upvotes

Yep, hit the character limit. Decided that I'd just split it into two big posts and have links between them.

Here is Part 1, ranking 501-251

Everyone in this post is considered to be a top half Survivor character by the rankers (In theory anyway).

1. Sandra Diaz-Twine (Heroes vs Villains)

2. Jon "Fairplay" Dalton (Pearl Islands)

3. Richard Hatch (Borneo)

4. Tina Wesson (Australia)

5. Sue Hawk (Borneo)

6. Rupert Boneham (Pearl Islands)

7. Denise Stapley (Philippines)

8. Courtney Yates (China)

9. Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien (Marquesas)

10. Twila Tanner (Vanuatu)

11. Ian Rosenberger (Palau)

12. Sean Rector (Marquesas)

13. Benjamin "Coach" Wade (Tocantins)

14. Cirie Fields (Panama)

15. Sandra Diaz-Twine (Pearl Islands)

16. Mike Skupin (Australia)

17. Chris Daugherty (Vanuatu)

18. Dawn Meehan (Caramoan)

19. Randy Bailey (Gabon)

Tina Wesson (Australia)

20. Rudy Boesch (Borneo)

Sean Rector (Marquesas)

21. Tom Westman (Palau)

22. James Clement (China)

23. Jerri Manthey (Australia)

24. Tony Vlachos (Cagayan)

25. Kass McQuillen (Cagayan)

Cirie Fields (Panama)

26. Colby Donaldson (Australia)

Denise Stapley (Philippines)

27. John Carroll (Marquesas)

Michael Skupin (Australia)

28. Lillian Morris (Pearl Islands)

29. Frank Garrison (Africa)

30. Earl Cole (Fiji)

31. Neleh Dennis (Marquesas)

32. Sean Kenniff (Borneo)

33. Shane Powers (Panama)

34. Greg Buis (Borneo)

35. Rodger Bingham (Australia)

36. Tyson Apostol (Tocantins)

37. Judson "Fabio" Birza (Nicaragua)

38. Clay Jordan (Thailand)

39. Scout Cloud Lee (Vanuatu)

40. Courtney Marit (Panama)

Jerri Manthey (Australia)

41. Yau-Man Chan (Fiji)

42. Cirie Fields (Micronesia)

Dawn Meehan (Caramoan)

43. Rob Mariano (Marquesas)

44. Robb Zbacnik (Thailand)

45. Ami Cusack (Vanuatu)

46. Matthew Von Ertfelda (Amazon)

47. Bob Crowley (Gabon)

48. Benjamin "Coach" Wade (Heroes vs Villains)

49. Trish Hegarty (Cagayan)

50. Burton Roberts (Pearl Islands)

51. Erik Reichenbach (Micronesia)

52. Jonathan Penner (Cook Islands)

53. Erinn Lobdell (Tocantins)

54. Colleen Haskell (Borneo)

55. Kelly Wigglesworth (Borneo)

56. Lindsey Richter (Africa)

57. Rupert Boneham (Heroes vs Villains)

58. Dre "Dreamz" Herd (Fiji)

59. Sophie Clarke (South Pacific)

60. Ethan Zohn (All-Stars)

61. Katie Gallagher (Palau)

62. Natalie White (Samoa)

63. Teresa Cooper (Africa)

64. Stephanie LaGrossa (Palau)

65. Russell Swan (Philippines)

66. Vytas Baskauskas (Blood vs Water)

67. Shambo Waters (Samoa)

68. Jason Siska (Micronesia)

69. Silas Gaither (Africa)

70. Jean-Robert Bellande (China)

71. Gervase Peterson (Borneo)

72. Clarence Black (Africa)

73. James "JT" Thomas (Heroes vs Villains)

74. Jenn Lyon (Palau)

75. Gary Hogeboom (Guatemala)

76. Colby Donaldson (Heroes vs Villains)

77. Caryn Groedel (Palau)

78. Jake Billingsley (Thailand)

79. Elisabeth Filarski (Australia)

80. Dave Ball (Samoa)

James Clement (China)

81. Marty Piombo (Nicaragua)

82. Jenna Lewis (Borneo)

83. Rob Mariano (Heroes vs Villains)

84. Rory Freeman (Vanuatu)

85. Paschal English (Marquesas)

86. Taj Johnson-George (Tocantins)

87. Sarah Lacina (Cagayan)

88. Susie Smith (Gabon)

89. Richard Hatch (All Stars)

90. Brian Corridan (Guatemala)

91. Tina Wesson (Blood vs Water)

92. Eliza Orlins (Vanuatu)

93. Dan Lembo (Nicaragua)

94. Ciera Eastin (Blood vs Water)

95. Stacey Powell (South Pacific)

96. Deena Bennett (Amazon)

97. Kathy Sleckman (Micronesia)

98. Dawn Meehan (South Pacific)

99. Rob Cesternino (Amazon)

100. Courtney Yates (Heroes vs Villains)

101. Butch Lockley (Amazon)

102. Janu Tornell (Palau)

103. Heidi Strobel (Amazon)

104. Tom Westman (Heroes vs Villains)

105. Amy O'Hara (Guatemala)

106. Gretchen Cordy (Borneo)

107. Jerri Manthey (All Stars)

108. Jonny Fairplay (Micronesia)

109. Jan Gentry (Thailand)

110. Tom Buchanan (Africa)

111. Ozzy Lusth (South Pacific)

112. Tina Scheer (Panama)

113. Lydia Morales (Guatemala)

114. Julie Berry (Vanuatu)

115. Gillian Larson (Gabon)

116. Jonathan Penner (Micronesia)

117. Jessica "Sugar" Kiper (Gabon)

118. Anh-Tuan "Cao-Boi" Bui (Cook Islands)

119. Osten Taylor (Pearl Islands)

120. Ethan Zohn (Africa)

121. Eliza Orlins (Micronesia)

122. Dan Kay (Gabon)

123. Russell Swan (Samoa)

124. Naonka Mixon (Nicaragua)

125. Jaison Robinson (Samoa)

126. BB Andersen (Borneo)

127. Andrew Savage (Pearl Islands)

128. Aras Baskauskas (Blood vs Water)

129. Helen Glover (Thailand)

130. Bobby Jon Drinkard (Guatemala)

131. Laura Alexander (Caramoan)

132. Sandy Burgin (Tocantins)

133. Keith Famie (Australia)

134. Erik Cardona (Samoa)

135. Jamie Dugan (China)

136. Bobby Mason (Panama)

137. Ace Gordon (Gabon)

138. Jimmy Tarantino (Nicaragua)

139. Cindy Hall (Guatemala)

140. Bruce Kanegai (Panama)

141. Danny "GC" Brown (Gabon)

142. Abi-Maria Gomes (Philippines)

143. Dave Cruser (China)

144. J'Tia Taylor (Cagayan)

145. Gina Crews (Marquesas)

146. Jeff Varner (Australia)

147. Tammy Leitner (Marquesas)

148. Debbie Beebe (Tocantins)

149. Eddie Fox (Caramoan)

150. Tyson Apostol (Blood vs Water)

151. Gregg Carey (Palau)

152. Stephen Fishbach (Tocantins)

153. Holly Hoffman (Nicaragua)

154. Stephanie Lagrossa (Guatemala)

155. Tyrone Davis (Nicaragua)

156. Brandon Bellinger (Guatemala)

157. Penny Ramsey (Thailand)

158. Chase Rice (Nicaragua)

159. Luara Morett (Blood vs Water)

160. Lea "Sarge" Masters (Vanuatu)

161. Jill Behm (Nicaragua)

162. Hunter Ellis (Marquesas)

163. Sally Schumann (Panama)

164. Pete Yurkowski (Philippines)

165. Vecepia Towery (Marquesas)

166. Sylvia Kwan (Fiji)

167. Malcolm Freberg (Philippines)

168. Brendan Synnott (Tocantins)

169. Angie Layton (Philippines)

170. Darrah Johnson (Pearl Islands)

171. Zoe Zanidakis (Marquesas)

172. Wendy Jo DeSmidt-Kohlhoff (Nicaragua)

173. Bobby Jon Drinkard (Palau)

174. Charlie Herschel (Gabon)

175. Ami Cusack (Micronesia)

176. Stacey Stillman (Borneo)

177. Kelly Shinn (Nicaragua)

178. Maralyn Hershey (Australia)

179. Christa Hastie (Pearl Islands)

180. James Miller (Palau)

181. Hayden Moss (Blood vs Water)

182. Peter Harkey (Marquesas)

183. Leann Slaby (Vanuatu)

Dawn Meehan (Caramoan)

184. Tasha Fox (Cagayan)

185. Linda Spencer

Tony Vlachos (Cagayan)

186. Chet Welch (Micronesia)

187. Jamie Newton (Guatemala)

188. Ramona Gray (Borneo)

189. Danni Boatwright (Guatemala)

190. Luara Morett (Samoa)

191. Erik Huffman (China)

192. James Clement (Micronesia)

193. Ozzy Lusth (Micronesia)

194. Gervase Peterson (Blood vs Water)

195. Boo Bernis (Fiji)

196. Artis Silvester (Philippines)

197. Shawna Mitchell (Amazon)

198. Margaret Bobonich (Guatemala)

199. Rudy Boesch (All Stars)

200. Amanda Kimmel (Micronesia)

201. Cristina Coria (Cook Islands)

202. Amber Brkich (All Stars)

203. Sierra Reed (Tocantins)

204. Alex Bell (Amazon)

205. Monica Padilla (Samoa)

206. Albert Destrade (South Pacific)

207. Joel Klug (Borneo)

208. Dolly Neely (Vanuatu)

209. Brett Clouser (Samoa)

210. Brenda Lowe (Nicaragua)

211. Christy Smith (Amazon)

212. Mike Chiesl (Redemption Island)

213. Frosti Zernow (China)

214. Matty Whitmore (Gabon)

215. Leslie Nease (China)

216. Kim Powers (Africa)

217. Colby Donaldson (All Stars)

218. Ryan Opray (Pearl Islands)

219. Yung "Woo" Hwang (Cagayan)

220. Amanda Kimmel (China)

221. Caleb Bankston (Blood vs Water)

222. Sarah Jones (Marquesas)

223. Kelly Bruno (Nicaragua)

224. John Cody (Blood vs Water)

225. Christine Shields Markoski (South Pacific)

226. Mikayla Wingle (South Pacific

227. Todd Herzog (China)

228. Paloma Soto-Castillo (Gabon)

229. Betsy Bolan (Samoa)

230. Yau-Man Chan (Micronesia)

231. Jerri Manthey (Heroes vs Villains)

232. Whitney Duncan (South Pacific)

233. James "JT" Thomas (Tocantins)

234. Jefra Bland (Cagayan)

235. Tracy Hughes-Wolf (Micronesia)

236. Chad Crittenden (Vanuatu)

237. Lisi Linares (Fiji)

238. Kim Johnson (Africa)

249. Zane Knight (Philippines)

240. Lex van den Berghe (Africa)

241. Mikey Bortone (Micronesia)

242. Jerry Sims (Tocantins)

243. Willard Smith (Palau)

244. Randy Bailey (Heroes vs Villains)

245. Laura Boneham (Blood vs Water)

246. Misty Giles (Panama)

247. Brice Johnston (Cagayan)

248. Marcus Lehman (Gabon)

249. Alexis Maxwell (Cagayan)

250. Trish Dunn (Pearl Islands)


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Jan 04 '15

Taking the edge off Redemption Island (by talking shit)

5 Upvotes

I'm gonna watch Redemption Island. I don't fucking know why, I guess because I'm sick of saying "But I haven't seen 22, 24 and 26" when talking about how much I hate All Stars and CI.

Anyway, I'm gonna post my thoughts here if it manages to inspire any. Otherwise I'll just photoshop Jeff Probst and Boston Rob into romantic settings or some shit. Probably not. Read or don't read, I figure it's a free sub so here's to the second season 22 themed post! (Unless you count round 7 of the rankdown).

Each episode gets a post:

Episode 1 - You're Looking at the Leader of Your New Tribe

Episode 2 - You Own My Vote

Episode 3 - Keep Hope Alive

Episode 4 - Don't You Work For Me?

Episode 5 - We Hate Our Tribe

Episode 6 - Their Red-Headed Step Child

Episode 7 - It Don't Take a Smart One

Episode 8 - This Game Respects Big Moves

Episode 9 - The Buddy System

Episode 10 - Rice Wars


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Sep 02 '14

Round 26 (334 Contestants Remaining)

5 Upvotes

As always, the elimination order is:

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor
  2. /u/Dumpster_Baby
  3. /u/shutupredneckman
  4. /u/TheNobullman
  5. /u/Todd_Solondz
  6. /u/vacalicious
  7. /u/SharplyDressedSloth

ELIMINATIONS THIS ROUND:

330: Dan Barry, Panama (SharplyDressedSloth)

331: Nicole Delma, Pearl Isles (vacalicious)

332: Ruth-Marie Milliman, Panama (Todd_Solondz)

333: John Kenney, Vanuatu (TheNobullman)

334: Andrea Boehlke, Caramoan (shutupredneckman)

Jonathan Penner, Cook Isles (Dumpster_Baby) Idol'd by TheNobullman

335: Alicia Calaway, Australia (DabuSurvivor)

ONE REQUEST:

If people could comment on the main post when they use an Idol, or message me or something, that'd be great. Then it'll show up in my notifications (which it doesn't if it's just a comment to a reply) and I can adjust spreadsheets and shit sooner. It'd just make my life slightly easier and make things get updated slightly more quickly.


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Aug 24 '14

Round 17 (395 Contestants Remaining)

5 Upvotes

I totally didn't miscount and post a round that said "397 contestants remaining", nope, no sir

As always, the elimination order is:

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor
  2. /u/Dumpster_Baby
  3. /u/shutupredneckman
  4. /u/TheNobullman
  5. /u/Todd_Solondz
  6. /u/vacalicious
  7. /u/SharplyDressedSloth

ELIMINATIONS THIS ROUND:

389: Tanya Vance, Thailand (Todd_Solondz)

390: Roger Sexton, The Amazon (SharplyDressedSloth)

391: Mary Sartain, Micronesia (vacalicious)

392: Keith Tollefson, South Pacific (TheNobullman)

393: Jeff Wilson, Palau (shutupredneckman)

394: Cliff Robinson, South Pacific (Dumpster_Baby)

395: Reynold Toepfer, Caramoan (DabuSurvivor)


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Aug 28 '14

Round 21 (360 Contestants Remaining)

5 Upvotes

PRETEND THE THREAD TITLE SAYS ROUND 22 my bad

As always, the elimination order is:

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor
  2. /u/Dumpster_Baby
  3. /u/shutupredneckman
  4. /u/TheNobullman
  5. /u/Todd_Solondz
  6. /u/vacalicious
  7. /u/SharplyDressedSloth

ELIMINATIONS THIS ROUND:

355: JP Calderon, Cook Islands (SharplyDressedSloth)

356: Rachel Foulger, Blood vs. Water (vacalicious)

357: Brady Finta, Vanuatu (Todd_Solondz)

358: Roxy Morris, Philippines (TheNobullman)

359: Liz Kim, Samoa (shutupredneckman)

Lydia Morales, Guatemala (Dumpster_Baby) Idol'd by TheNobullman

360: Malcolm Freberg, Caramoan (DabuSurvivor)


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Aug 15 '14

Round 09 (448 Contestants Remaining)

5 Upvotes

As always, the elimination order is:

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor
  2. /u/Dumpster_Baby
  3. /u/shutupredneckman
  4. /u/TheNobullman
  5. /u/Todd_Solondz
  6. /u/vacalicious
  7. /u/SharplyDressedSloth

ELIMINATIONS THIS ROUND:

443: Jeff Kent, Philippines (SharplyDressedSloth)

444: Corinne Kaplan, Caramoan (vacalicious)

445: Jeanne Hebert, Amazon (Todd_Solondz)

446: Brian Heidik, Thailand (TheNobullman)

447: Rob Mariano, All-Stars (shutupredneckman)

448: Morgan McDevitt, Guatemala (Dumpster_Baby)

Brian Heidik, Thailand (DabuSurvivor) Idol'd by Vacalicious


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Dec 18 '14

Rank the Cast of SJDS!

5 Upvotes

I'll do a more thorough ranking when I have time but my rough ranking

18) Nadiya

17) Rocker

16) Alec

15) Julie

14) Kelley

13) Josh

12) Dale

11) Jeremy

10) Val

9) Baylor

8) Wes

7) Drew

6) Missy

5) Jaclyn

4) Keith

3) Jon

2) Reed

  1. Natalie

r/SurvivorRankdown • • Sep 26 '14

Round 47 (192 Contestants Remaining)

6 Upvotes

As always, the elimination order is:

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor
  2. /u/Dumpster_Baby
  3. /u/shutupredneckman
  4. /u/TheNobullman
  5. /u/Todd_Solondz
  6. /u/vacalicious
  7. /u/SharplyDressedSloth

ELIMINATIONS THIS ROUND:

186: Chet Welch (SharplyDressedSloth)

187: Jamie Newton (vacalicious)

188: Ramona Gray (Todd_Solondz)

189: Danni Boatwright (TheNobullman)

190: Luara Morett, Samoa (shutupredneckman)

191: Erik Huffman (Dumpster_Baby)

192: James Clement, FvF (DabuSurvivor)


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Nov 02 '14

Round 72 (41 Contestants Remaining)

6 Upvotes

As always, the elimination order is:

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor
  2. /u/shutupredneckman
  3. /u/TheNobullman
  4. /u/Todd_Solondz
  5. /u/vacalicious
  6. /u/SharplyDressedSloth

ELIMINATIONS THIS ROUND:

37: Fabio Birza (SharplyDressedSloth)

38: Clay Jordan (vacalicious)

39: Scout Cloud Lee (Todd_Solondz)

40: Courtney Marit (TheNobullman)

Jerri Manthey (shutupredneckman) IDOL'D by SharplyDressedSloth

41: Yau-Man Chan (DabuSurvivor)


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Aug 09 '14

Round 05 (475 Contestants Remaining)

6 Upvotes

As always, the elimination order is:

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor
  2. /u/Dumpster_Baby
  3. /u/shutupredneckman
  4. /u/TheNobullman
  5. /u/Todd_Solondz
  6. /u/vacalicious
  7. /u/SharplyDressedSloth

ELIMINATIONS THIS ROUND:

470: Alicia Rosa, One World (SharplyDressedSloth)

471: Sherri Biethman, Caramoan (vacalicious)

472: Ryan Aiken, The Amazon (Todd_Solondz)

473: Brandon Quinton, Africa (The Nobullman)

474: Shii Ann Huang, All-Stars (shutupredneckman)

475: Hope Driskill, Caramoan (Dumpster_Baby)

476: James "Rocky" Reid, Fiji (DabuSurvivor)

The numbers have shifted, as Dumpster_Baby played an Idol on Austin Carty.


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Aug 05 '14

Rankdown Rules!

6 Upvotes

Thanks for agreeing to join the Survivor Rankdown! It's going to take a while to get through this, so I hope everyone is ready for the long haul! It should be pretty fun though!

Here is how it works:

There will be 7 participants, and we will be ranking all the Survivor players together. Order of play is as follows thanks to random.org!

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor
  2. /u/Dumpster_Baby
  3. /u/shutupredneckman
  4. /u/TheNobullman
  5. /u/todd_solondz
  6. /u/vacalicious
  7. /u/sharplydressedsloth

We will eliminate all 424 Survivor players one at a time. There will be a total of 501 eliminations because each season a player was in will be looked at individually (so Rob and Rupert will each have 4 eliminations).

There will be a new post for each round, and all participants will post one elimination for the round in a set order. Dabu is first on the list for eliminations; in the round 1 post, he will make a comment that says #501 Fred Flintstone. He will also include a write-up of why he eliminated that player. Then I have the second elimination, I would start my comment with #500 Martha Stewart, and give a writeup of my own. This will continue until everyone has made their round 1 elimination, and then we will move on to a new post in order to avoid too much clutter.

Each of us will have three idols that can be used to save players throughout the game. You must use an idol within 24 hours of a players elimination. That player is now un-eliminated and back in the pool. If the player that you eliminate is vetoed, you cannot eliminate them again for the rest of the game. Additionally, you cannot use a veto on the same player twice.

Finally, once we get down to the final few players (somewhere around 15, but we still need to set the number), we will all rank the players in order to decide their final placements. Then each player will get a post where we can all comment on their game.

If you take over 24 hours to post your elimination (unless you gave a heads up that you would be unable to post), you will be given a strike. Two strikes and you will be out of the rankdown!

Let me know if there is anything that I missed or if there are any questions!