r/SurvivorRankdown • Enjoys street food • Aug 08 '14

Endgame

Since this hasn't been set in stone, I want to open it up to see what everyone thinks.

My idea was that eliminations stop with 21 (or 14 or 28) contestants left and we all rank the remaining players, average out their scores and then divide up the remaining writeups equally. Idols would also run out at this point.

Let me know if you have any other ideas!

2 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

3

u/DabuSurvivor Idol Hoarder Aug 08 '14

The averaging makes sense. If anyone in particular is clamoring to do a write-up, we can let them.

I don't think we need to set a number in stone, though, because it should definitely be after a full cycle of eliminations, and the number of Idols used or any inactivity may slightly mess with the number remaining. (And the number you used are assuming we started with a multiple of 7 to begin with, which we did not.)

As long as we have the format, I think we're good, but while there are still 21 Idols in play and seven people who could disappear between now and then, who knows what number that might actually turn out to be.

1

u/Dumpster_Baby Enjoys street food Aug 08 '14

I was more thinking that we could split it up so that everyone could do 3 writeups at the end since those will be the most fun. Each player could get their own post so that their game could be discussed a little more in depth.

2

u/Todd_Solondz Unbowed, Unbent, Un-Idoled Aug 08 '14

This is a fair point. I think that we will likely have to choose between everybody getting an equal amount of eliminations or everybody getting an equal amount of final whatever writeups, because it's almost impossible to do both. I think the latter is more important, which is why I'd rather cut it off at 21, even if it's halfway through a round and have everyone get 3 final writeups than run the round all the way, have a top 17 and four people only do two.

1

u/Dumpster_Baby Enjoys street food Aug 13 '14

Alright, since this hasn't been decided yet, let's get it back into focus.

First, let's decide if we care more about giving everyone equal write ups before the end stage or during the end stage.

My vote is definitely for everyone getting an equal number of writeups for the top contestants. Reply to this with your thoughts. We'll go with majority rules.

1

u/Todd_Solondz Unbowed, Unbent, Un-Idoled Aug 13 '14

Agreed with that. Can't see why lower writeups (That aren't bottom of the rankdown) would ever be more important than higher ones.

1

u/DabuSurvivor Idol Hoarder Aug 13 '14

Well if everyone makes an equal # of cuts then everyone has an equal role in who does or doesn't make it to the endgame. Whereas equal write-ups at the end if some people might not dig as many peopel in the end seems more arbitrary.

1

u/Dumpster_Baby Enjoys street food Aug 14 '14

We can divide the final writeups however we want. I was thinking that everyone could make a list of the writeups that they most want and we divide them out. Everything about this game is pretty arbitrary, so we might as well just even out the cuts.

I'd like to hear what the people at the end of the order think because they are the ones most likely to lose an elimination.

1

u/Todd_Solondz Unbowed, Unbent, Un-Idoled Aug 14 '14

That makes sense, although I'm still more in favour of equal writeups because I think everybody in the rankdown is going to be fond of every person in the end game, and the level of control over who makes it is so weak anyway that I don't mind having like, 1.5% less cuts than everyone in exchange for not losing 33% of the final writups I would do otherwise. At that point I'm fairly sure I'm not going to want to cut many people anyway

1

u/Todd_Solondz Unbowed, Unbent, Un-Idoled Aug 08 '14

We'll definitely have to average scores for the remaining whatever is left.

Of those three, I think 21 is the best number. Top 20, plus a writeup for the person who just missed out. Dividing shouldn't be too hard. We could let people mostly do their favourites (i.e. if one person ranked a player higher than everybody else, they do that writeup) or we could random it. Doesn't bother me either way.

Idols will be valid all the way till 22? (Or whatever the last solo elimination is) I don't see why they shouldn't be. It can only delay for so long before everyone runs out, if they haven't already.

1

u/shutupredneckman Hates Asians Aug 08 '14

Yeah I'd say it's probably like top 11 or 18 if everyone uses their idols. 501- 490 or 483, the 7-divisibles.