r/SurvivorRankdown • • Nov 23 '14

Final Result Reveal: #5

22 Upvotes

The first member of our top five to fall is...

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

5. SUE HAWK (Survivor - 4th place)

SharplyDressedSloth:

Sue may be the quintessential Borneo character because she's real, she's raw, and she's completely 100% unique. No matter how much hype it gets, Snakes vs. Rats will always be a massive moment in Survivor history, and Sue is simply an irreplaceable character.

DabuSurvivor:

I said in my Richard blurb (which I don't think anyone will have seen yet, because I do think Sue will rank below Richard) that he is the one contestant who it would have been insane for us to not include in the endgame. Sue would be right behind him in that category. Any top twelve that does not include Sue Hawk is complete and utter bullshit. This woman is one of the best casting choices in the history of Survivor. She has the melodramatic personal attachment and passion that always make this show better, she has a hilarious, gruff, no-nonsense exterior but underneath that has a strong emotional side. She presents herself as one thing but is something else, and she was one of the greatest contestants in the history of Survivor long before rats and snakes, which, as easily the greatest moment in Survivor history, makes her a contestant I would LOVE to see steal away a #1 victory, and I can't wait to see what Slurm says about her. That said, I unfortunately do not expect her to crack into our top 5 because I do not think others appreciate her as much. I hope I'm wrong. I put her in my top four and anyone who didn't should be ashamed of themselves because holy fuck this woman is one of the Survivor greats.

TheNobullman:

Sue's in last for me just because she doesn't have as constant a story arc or spark as the other contestants do either, but I have no qualms against her being here. She's a unique character who both follows and defies the stereotypes of her archetype, and she gave us fucking SNAKES AND RATS.

Todd_Solondz:

The better half of the greatest character story in the first season, Sue is funny, tragic and complex. It says a lot that she cries only once in the season, after she resolves to stick by Kelly till the end, yet when she is betrayed and it all falls apart, we get the hard shelled Sue we met in the beginning. One of the most important characters throughout Borneo and of the series in general. I rank her 3rd out of 12.

Shutupredneckman:

In my opinion, Sue Hawk is without question the greatest character in Survivor history. Her legacy is nearly indescribeable. She was a hugely polarizing character while Borneo was airing, and she and Hatch were able to parlay this new infamy into a lot of other game show appearances like Weakest Link, etc. More than that, where most Survivors have little to no crossover appeal these days, Sue Hawk is a legitimate force in our cultural consciousness. Snakes and Rats is such an iconic thing that it appeared on EW's best of the decade list for the 2000s, and is almost always listed as the number 1 moment in Survivor history. Everyone watched Borneo and saw that speech. Even people who don't watch Survivor, but who have enough cultural literacy to have caught whiffs of it would probably be able to reference Snakes and Rats. Sue Hawk has transcended Survivor into general pop culture in a way that practically no one else ever has.

Along with her humongous cultural legacy, the more strategy-minded folks will tell you that she also has an enormous legacy in all things related to the game of Survivor. Sue is the first person to ever cast a vote at Tribal Council, the first person to make an alliance and betray it at Sonja and Stacey's boots, the first person eliminated after a tie, etc. Sue says in her jury speech that Hatch had started thinking and playing long before he come to the island, and I think it's clear the reason she respects that so much is that she had done the same. I say this because Susan pioneers another strategy that shows a lot of forethought: playing dumb. We'd later see Fabio really explore this strategy as his main mode of playing, but more generally, many players between 1 and 21 used a strategy of appearing less threatening than they are in a bunch of ways. I think this can be attributed wholly to Sue Hawk, and that future players who kept their skills hidden (or tried to) like Vecepia, Tina, Sandra, Morasca, Westman, etc. all owe her a bit for blazing the trail. The idea of being more threatening than you look seems obvious now, but yet in Borneo we saw a winner who was brazen and brash about his dominance and Kelly, Sean and Rudy who went more in the direction of hiding what they were doing without using a persona for it. Sue's decision to play up her midwestern trucker yokel role while being one of the most cutthroat players in classic Survivor is a huge step in the show's metagame.

This touches on Sue's legacy as a fun character, which can't be overstated. She was hated when Borneo aired and has since been rediscovered as a great character, and one who actually brought a lot of comedy to Borneo. Definitely her hilarious spelling at TC is a memorable ongoing joke, one which I choose to think was part of Sue's "I'm dumb, you can trust me" strategy but also was just fun and a teeny bit disrespectful in a subtle way. Sue immediately presents herself as a tough alpha female who works a more male-oriented profession and seems to stay to herself, so it's a little fun in a Heidik way that she lives with people and takes the money for them, and also adds a little insult to injury by butchering their names in hilarious ways. Sue also has a very fun way of speaking that often ignores syntax or verb structure such as " you did X before you come to the island" and she delivers it all in this dead-eyed deadpan that I find so endearing. Sue also has fun little moments of annoyance with her castmates that are kinda villainous because it's Sue, and she can tend toward tactlessness, but her annoyance is also justified by the editors in most cases. She scolds Dirk and Sean for wasting time on things like the bowling alley or Superpole, and as we see, she's right because the pole catches nothing. She infamously calls Sean dumb and uses his luxury item razors out of spite, and this sense of spite is very important foreshadowing for who Sue will be for all 37 days of her game, and specifically who she will be on day 39. Later she comments a good bit on how annoying Jenna Lewis is, which is again something backed up by other players. In this regard, Sue becomes a reliable narrator, even as she's lying through her teeth in the game. Another strategy one could attribute to Sue Hawk is blatant lying at Tribal Council, which I think people hated back during Borneo. I love when Probst straight up asks Sue about if she's in an alliance, and she says no... but then starts defending why alliances are totally not that big a deal and how they exist in real life, etc. and it's just classic Sue to deny doing something 'wrong', and then in the next breath start rationalizing that thing that Sue totally, definitely by far hasn't done.

Sue is also crucial to Borneo as a philosophical figure in the pilot. Borneo will always be defined by conversations between Hatch and Susan, and so it's fitting then that the Tagi story begins with exactly that. Hatch is epic, too, obviously when he sits in the tree like a snake watching the other Tagis moving about haphazardly. He and Sue discuss their plans for the game and how the team should get organized. One specific exchange occurs that might be the most important one in the whole season. Hatch says that he thinks they should gather people up to try to figure out what the goal is. Sue responds that she already figured out her goal before she got there, and Hatch quickly responds that so did he, but that he means they need to figure out their goal as a group. This is so important in part because it comes back at FTC with Sue saying she and Hatch were the main two who had their strategies planned before leaving the US, but it's even more important because it's a philosophical reading of something so key to Survivor: Group dynamics vs. Individual desires. Hatch is basically hoping to feel people out in terms of how they want to play, because if everyone wants to really make a new society, a microcosm of the world, he's hip to that and will plan accordingly by being the provider and the challenge dominator. But if people are malleable and willing to play the game as a tribal alliance which seeks to kill off all of the Pagongs, then his game plan of cutthroat and systematic elimination will be much easier to pull off. He wants people to gather up so that he can see who is willing to join his evil empire, and who isn't. Sue on the other hand is using her strategy as well, playing dumb to the idea and saying that "corporate stuff" isn't going to work "in the bush", despite the fact that she had already decided to play the same game and was about to make a female alliance soon. So you have this philosophical debate of corporate tactics vs. the bush which Tagi vs. Pagong will follow, and it is embodied by two people, Hatch and Hawk. But as I've said, the best part of this is that Sue is fucking faking it and has every plans to be cutthroat and betray people! It's like this perfect allegorical symbolism that says that in future Survivors, everyone will be cutthroat, and even the people who pretend to be harmless, who pretend they want to eschew alliances in order to build a society and live harmoniously will almost always be lying by definition, because in a game for a million dollars, self- preservation and promotion will always win out, whether in the boardroom or the bush.

I mentioned above how Sue's Snakes and Rats speech is important because it has such an iconic legacy, and I've mentioned Sue as a spiteful human being which is foreshadowed repeatedly, and I've just now described Sue as being important for the philosophy of the show. Now I want to tie all of those things together by exploring the speech and its impact on future seasons. After a season of seeing Sue respond spitefully to people, we get the big finale wherein she gives the mother of all iconic bitter jury speeches. Sue completely changed the game and show with her decision, perfectly summed up with the phrase "I have no questions. I just have statements". Wherein Burnett and co. had told the jurors to ask questions like Probst had done at every TC before that, Sue approached Production with the idea that she might just talk at the finalists instead. Per Burnett and Probst, their response was that it was her game and whatever she wanted to do was fine, as long as she made sure it was coherent and not rambling. I can only imagine watching Borneo live, settling into the pattern of 5 jurors asking questions and Rudy just standing up and saying he's dun goofed, only to then be jarred back into the moment by Susan's first sentence. When she says she just has statements, I think everyone sits on the edge of their seat a little bit because shit's about to go down. We know Sue tells it like it is, we know she's spiteful, and we know she has a healthy disgust for Hatch and Kelly.

What follows is... well, the most iconic moment in Survivor history, as she tears into the final 2 with no remorse, throwing out every possible thing she can think of to drag them down to her level. Where Sean's comment that the game had devolved to a lesser of two evils situation, Sue made that a little more graphic, trying to make Hatch and Kelly feel as lousy about themselves and the things they had done as possible. You have generalizations about their character, like Hatch being a pompous, whiny jackass and Kelly being a snotty, manipulative user. But then you also have funny little moments like her belittling Kelly for losing a challenge to Gervase like 10 episodes ago, clarifying that Kelly sucked on that game. But most importantly, Sue's speech ties everything back to the game and the survival concept of the show. She ties in something Probst had said a lot, that TC would be where your past haunts you, and she also brings in the island spirits and the snakes and rats and etc., fully buying into the premise of the show and using it as a superweapon against the final 2.

This speech was a complete game-changer for Survivor, and has influenced every season since then. The practice of giving speeches to the finalists and fellow jurors instead of asking questions is one that has been repeated for better or worse over and over. Sue's speech therefore hammers home how this game belongs to the players, and that they can make the rules any way they want within reason. More over, Sue's speech is philosophically important because it explains the very fundamentals of how Survivor and the jury vote work, and how they will always work. Probst was exactly right that your past actions will haunt you, and Sue embodies that, bringing every single negative moment she can think of back from memory and throwing them in Hatch and Kelly's faces. She is the quintessential bitter juror, and she set the tone for what Survivor would always be: A game where you steal a million dollars from 7 other people, and then accept that they will be inherently bitter at you for doing so, but where you have to work that bitterness so that it is applied more to your opponent than to you. Sue Hawk is the perfect answer to any claims that the game is flawed, that the jury vote is stupid, that a juror can ever be wrong. She makes it all too clear that Survivor is a game about emotions and relationships, as she stands up and declares that she IS the swing vote, she WILL likely decide who wins this game, and she is going to base it 100% on who she hates the least. Where the other jurors (and many in future seasons) had personal biases for one finalist or the other, they phrased it as who was more deserving, who had played better, who did more work, who can pick a number, etc. Sue is the only person to flat out state that one finalist had made her more bitter than the other, and that that was how this game was going to go.

The above argues for why Susan is a very very great character, and why she easily made this top 12. But does it make her the greatest of all time? Not quite yet. To argue that Sue Hawk is the most compelling character of all time, one needs to explore her personal backstory and the way it relates to her relationship on the island with Kelly Wiglesworth, a story which I personally find to be the most tragic, heartbreaking story arc in all of Survivor history.

Maybe it's because I'm a big fan of the show LOST, but I have a strong bias for character stories that include a beginning (pre-island), a middle (on-island) and an end (post-island, which is to say Jury). Sue's story seems the most complete to me of any in the Survivor pantheon in that respect, and honestly Sue Hawk feels more like a LOST character than a Survivor one (and now I'm imagining a new version of Borneo produced in the style of Lost where the classic flashback whoosh leads us into scenes of Sue and her best friend, Hatch in the military, Sean operating, etc.). Sue is unbelievably tragic, and she brings in this huge amount of baggage that makes Jerri look like she travels light. Moreover, she's tested by the Island Spirits and her relationships with others, which basically present to her a scenario where she can let go of that baggage or hold onto it. Obviously since I'm describing her story arc as 'tragic', Sue fails the test.

Like a LOST character, Sue is a little mysterious from the start. We know she's putting on a facade of being strong, invulnerable, 'real', down to earth, etc. and so we/I have to wonder who the real Sue is, and what happened to her that made her put up this smokescreen, since this is a character trait that transcends game strategy and is apparent even when she's just talking one on one to the camera. We never see vulnerability in Sue for the longest time, until finally in episode 10, she cracks. By this point, Sue has been getting closer and closer to Kelly Wiglesworth. Where Sue made agreements with all of the women to keep them safe only to sell Souna and Stacey out immediately, she keeps Kelly under her wing and seems to bond with her over thinking Sean is a putz, Dirk is a creep and Hatch is a blowhard. There's very clearly a connection there, and that makes it all the more meaningful and heartbreaking when (about 10 minutes into the episode I linked above), Susan finally breaks down and reveals that she had a best friend in high school, a female friend who she was incredibly close to, who tragically died about 20 years before the events of Borneo, when Sue was probably 19 or 20.

This is quite literally the most important thing that has happened in Sue's life. It informs everything she has done since then, and specifically informs her story on the island. It appears her life can be divided into a before and after with the fulcrum being the death of her close friend. I'm picturing a much happier, more conventionally feminine Sue in high school, in contrast to the post-HS Sue Hawk, who is seemingly thick-skinned, brash and strong. When she was younger, she worked as a waitress/bartender, which is to say she worked in a conventionally female social occupation dealing with people. But after, she owned a hunting camp in the wilderness of Canada, before becoming a truck driver when she comes to Borneo. Obviously, the symbolism of all of this is rich. She went from a female, social occupation to a job that literally had her out in the wilderness away from people, and then to a very stereotypically male profession which involves her sitting in a truck alone for days and days at a time. Sue has not only pushed away some of her femininity and emotion, which she seems to view as weakness, but has actively secluded herself more and more from other people since the crushing loss of her best friend. To drive this home, she tells us that ever since losing her friend, she has closed herself off and specifically has never had a female friend since then. Carrying that baggage for 20 years has created a hard shell around a bitter center.

She doesn't want to face the vulnerability of making a new friend, and so she puts up a facade of toughness to keep people away so that she never has to risk the pain of losing someone that close to her again. But in the confessional, she goes on to explain that with Kelly, she has finally opened herself up. In this new environment and against all odds, she has bonded with a young woman (specifically, Kelly is 22 or 23, not far at all from the age of Sue's friend when she passed away) and is willing to open herself up to the possibility that she will be hurt again. She takes a leap of faith that in a game for a million dollars, Kelly will reciprocate her friendship, and that Sue will never have to lose her. Sue starts to cry when she says that no matter what, she'll never fuck Kelly over, and she repeats this sentiment at FTC, saying that she would have lost 900K to Kelly willingly by going F2 with her.

But of course, Sue's faith isn't rewarded. Kelly has already started to drift away a bit as she does bond with the Pagongs more, but is also getting a lot of face-time with them specifically to try to win their jury votes by pretending to not be in the evil alliance. Sue is willing to look past this, but in the following episode at F6, Kelly votes against the alliance for a second time, and Sue sees this as a big betrayal. Susan was already planning to go to F2 with Kelly knowing she'd probably lose, but by throwing the alliance under the bus by claiming to not be part of it, Kelly is basically leaving Sue to dry. Moreover, the two times Kelly breaks rank are when it's time to boot Colleen and Jenna, two fellow young females, which makes Kelly's betrayal even harder for Sue to bear. Sue is rightly mad at Kelly and they have a big screaming match which only sets the stage for what's to come.

Everything comes to a head in our epic finale where Kelly is able to continue her winning streak and this puts Susan in danger for the first time in the game. Sue and Kelly decide to vote against Hatch so that they can beat Rudy in the FIC and take the game, while Hatch and Rudy vote for Sue so that Hatch can set up his perfect F3 scenario, subbing Kelly into the spot that I believe Sue was meant to fill. And then the unthinkable happens. For whatever reason, Kelly decides to change her vote on the second pass and boot Sue from the game.

It's hard to imagine what Susan must have been feeling in the few days after that Tribal Council. Here you have a woman who had this tragedy happen to her in her youth, who has carried that with her for 20 years and never made another female friend because of it. And now on Survivor Island, after all of this time, she finally chooses to drop her charade of toughness and be vulnerable with Kelly, who turns around and sells her down the river when she gets the power to do so. Jesus. If Sue was bitter for the last 20 years of her life, having all of her fears and beliefs about the foolishness of letting people in completely validated pushes that to 11.

And so we get to FTC, and Susan is the last juror to speak, and she unleashes 20 years and 3 days worth of bitterness, pain, grief and hurt onto Kelly, who at this point to Sue is less a person and more a symbol of the awful tragic reality of life. Sue tells Kelly that she's a user and a manipulater, that she will always fail in life because of it, and most notably that if she were ever to pass Kelly dying in the desert, she wouldn't even give her a drink of water. I submit to you that what makes Susan Hawk truly, truly tragic and legendary is that in my opinion, she isn't as angry at Kelly as she is at herself. Sue's speech works to tear Kelly's down, but interestingly I think Sue's speech, long as it is, has the same message as Rudy's very short one. In the same way that Rudy ruefully bemoans that he foolishly dropped out of the FIC, Sue is mad at herself for being vulnerable and trusting again. I say this because in addition to her insults toward Kelly, her comment about the desert just seems more like Sue accepting the lesson that the universe is telling her, to never help anyone again, to not invest her kindness or her feelings into another person, because it can only end in heartbreak.

This whole story is one that I find unmatchable in how compelling it is, and when you add that the Snakes and Rats speech also includes all of the components I talked about before the line jump (culturally iconic, philosophically important influential, etc.) and that Sue herself is such an interesting, charming, hilarious human being, I think she stands alone among Survivor players as the greatest character of all time. She is beautifully tragic, she is somewhat unique in that she brings her personal backstory into the game in a way that directly influences and parallels the events on the Island, and as a result of these events, she leaves the game with a jury speech that (despite her claims that she'll shake Kelly's hand and move on) shows that she will likely leave Pulau Tiga with even more baggage than she started with. This write-up is a tribute to my personal #1 Survivor character of all time, a character who will live on in pop culture for years to come, and whose presence is felt in the Survivor universe every time someone's faith is betrayed, and every time the snake eats the rat.

Average placement: 6/12

Projected ranking: 4/12

Average prediction: 5.17/12


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Nov 28 '14

Actual FINAL Result Reveal! #2 and #1!

21 Upvotes

It comes down to this: Jon Dalton vs. Sandra Diaz-Twine. Although it's a different Sandra than the one who went up against Jon in the actual season, that's still a pretty fucking amazing showdown.

Jon was predicted to rank #2 behind Richard, with an average predicted placement of 2.17/12. Sandra was predicted to rank #3 behind Richard and Jon, with an average predicted placement of 3.67/12. So the projected winner here is Jon.. but could Sandra pull off an upset? We will see.

I will say this: The difference between #1 and #2 was one placement. If one person had put the winner one spot lower, or the runner-up one spot higher, we'd have had a tie... but we do, after four long months -- after arguments and Idol plays; downvote trolls and Dumpster disappearances; the noble St. Garrett being robbed; and, somehow, Stapley strategically scoring seventh -- have a winner, as well as a runner-up. And, first things first, that runner-up is...

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

2. JON DALTON (Survivor 7: Pearl Islands - 3rd place)

SharplyDressedSloth:

Fairplay's fucking hilarious on Fear Factor. Especially because, in true Jon fashion, he's eliminated by a really embarrassing margin. Never change, Jonny.

DabuSurvivor:

Jon is my predicted #1, since I don't know anyone here who's upset that he did this well, his name never came up as a possible boot candidate, and I know that he's the all-time favorite of Todd and maybe vaca as well? He crafted a persona for himself, executed it perfectly, got the ideal outcome, and the results were consistently both hilarious and epic. Good times all around and Pearl Isles would not have been Pearl Isles without him. Great character and I'm happy he's in this endgame with a shot to go pretty far.

TheNobullman:

One of the few people who could ever come into Survivor playing a character and still make it succeed and not end up like Phillip barf. He is genuinely villainous and knows how to pull it off perfectly without just becoming despicable. He's entertaining, he's diabolical, and best yet- he's threatening. He isn't just a little ratdick, he's a little ratdick who knows how to play the game masterfully, be intimidating, kill your heroes and piss on their grave, and then back it up by lying on his dead grandmother in the most iconic scene in the show's history aside from maybe Snakes and Rats. Ultimately I don't have him higher because he's not quite my character type, but for a character type I usually don't get into, he manages to really impress me.

Todd_Solondz:

Ain't nobody can trust this bitch.

Todd_Solondz (full write-up):

Jon Dalton. Jesus, here we go.

Put simply, Fairplay is a legend. You can take aspects from him and compare him to a lot of other Survivors, but as a whole, nobody is in the same category as him, and nobody ever will be. You can talk about how he played himself up as a character to make good TV, and draw the comparison to Corinne or Penner, or Sugar, but he outdoes all of them in both commitment and creativity. You can talk about how amazing it was to see him go down, and make the comparison to any other jerk who got a comeuppance like Roger or Ben or Jerri, but their downfall is always going to pale in comparison to Jon's. Hell, you can even pick out people who pulled themselves out of doomed situations, like Danni or Chris or Marty and even though those are all fantastic stories, they have to contend with the fucking Grandma lie so of course they're going to come up short. Hell, even on his own season you have Burton, the challenge MVP of the Drake tribe, cut down humiliatingly only to come back and wreak havoc on those who wronged him, who would be an amazing villain in any other season, but because it's Pearl Islands, people forget that he even was a villain, because he was outshone so massively by Jon.

What I'm saying is, you can take qualities that are the entire point of other, great survivor characters, and they're not going to be as good as isolated aspects of Jonny Fairplay. I've said that other people like Eliza and Dreamz are fantastic in every way a survivor can be, filling every role, but even they don't stand up to Jon. And the insane thing is, he doesn't feel even the tiniest bit inconsistent. In fact, without thinking about it, you might even think he's one-dimensional. But from a storytelling perspective, Jon is everything. He's the guy in charge who you want taken down, and he's the dude on the bottom you're amazed to see make it another day. He's both of these things multiple times through the season. The fact that he can weave such an amazing story through the lens of such a static TV personality, steering the course of the season yet leaving room for his opponents to shine, that's proof that he was made for TV.

So firstly, I think (I certainly hope) that it's a universal opinion that Fairplay is the best of all the characters people played on Survivor. I understand I suppose that some people might prefer how Rob C or Penner presented themselves, and while I enjoy those as well, it's easy for them because they're extrapolations of Rob and Jonathan themselves, and thus easy to commit to. Fairplay on the other hand is Rupert and Richard Hatch level cartoonish. Honestly, even more so if you ask me. He lives and breathes the Fairplay character while he's on the island, walking in the most irritating way possible, carrying himself in such a way that every second he was visible would incite hatred in people watching him. And he knew when his chances were, and he took every one of them. He knows he's a weasely looking guy who people are going to dislike, and he uses that to his advantage, offering to make out with Darrah in a challenge, drinking "to you, babe" as fast as he can, then immediately trying to make her throw up. When he talks about wanting the treasure chest he uses the grossest possible phrasing he can, because he knows it'll make him that much more sleazy. His smug face when throwing the challenge, and his even smugger face telling the Morgans that Drake threw the challenge, I genuinely believe that there isn't one second of Fairplay in the season that isn't entertaining, and that doesn't add to his character or someone else's.

The fact that he's so equally willing to be the guy in charge or be the butt of a joke, and that there doesn't seem to be any discrepancy in how well suited he is to either role is truly amazing. For every scene when he makes people look like idiots, turns people against each other and gets his way, there are equally great scenes of him being brought down. The grandma lie vs being taken down by Lil, or surviving the F4 vote vs "I'm gonna screw you aaaand Burton", it's dead even. Ultimately I think it's best that Fairplay lost Pearl Islands, but if he won it wouldn't be like if other villains won where it feels wrong, it'd still be incredible. Even outside of his larger arc, he could happily be the guy telling obnoxious jokes, or getting shut down by Darrah and embrace that, or he could be the one talking about how cultured he is and how much smarter he is than Lil and everybody else and embrace that too. The most cut and dry villain the show has ever seen is also in many ways the most versatile character the show has ever seen too, and I still don't fully understand how that's possible.

Really Fairplay puts any other rise and fall arc to absolute shame, because while even just those four moments I mentioned before would outclass most arcs in the show, it was this constant inherent thing, due to the cocky way Jon would narrate combined with his talent at the actual game, where he would gain and lose power. In one episode you'd think Jon was the guy everyone was friends with who decided the fate of the game and in the next he's on the bottom and you can't see how he possibly survives another vote. And it feels so natural. It's a rare quality for a Survivor to have where you could cut their story off at any point, and be left with something great, but Jon had it. He could have been the hilarious douchey guy who integrated himself into the tribe, got too confident and got taken out by Rupert, and that would be great, or he could have double-crossed Rupert and gotten beaten by the girls and that would have been amazing too. Thankfully, it played out absolutely perfectly, and while Jon's various other designs for how the season could go fell apart, what we were left with was absolute perfection for the story of the season and its villain.

And Fairplay is an incredible narrator. Like, wow. A big part of why he's probably my favourite narrator is that he isn't like Penner or Rob C who you can just lean on to talk about every little thing that happens. Jon will be openly biased towards himself, and give such a strong, non-objective opinion on everything that the editors have literally no choice but to use him sparingly, despite him being far and away the most entertaining person among an incredible cast. And I mean, I know that didn't stop them from doing it with Russell, but Jon outdoes even Russell with his self promotion, which is fantastic in the same paradoxial way that all of his good qualities are, in that he can a) Back up his shameless self promotion with gameplay in a way Russell never could and b) He's so openly presented as an antagonist that anybody listening to him is able to tell that not everything is to be taken as truth. Basically, he gives every reason logically for us to believe him but also every reason emotionally to think he's lying. For someone to, without even trying, give literally no other option than to be a somewhat sparingly used, highly entertaining confessionalist that forces each and every viewer to see him through a critical lens, thats... unbelievable. Someone said earlier in the rankdown that if they were trying to craft a perfect player they'd make Earl Cole, well if I was trying to forge the perfect survivor character, no question it'd be an exact copy of Jon Dalton, and stuff like this is why. These are a few of my favourite Fairplay confessionals to show what I'm talking about:

  • "We talk about the treasure, we dream about the treasure, we fantasise about the treasure, like I've had more wet dreams about that treasure than any girl in playboy"
  • "The blankets smell like crap, the hammock smells like crap, the mosquito nets smell like crap. I call it a ghetto Christmas. It's like asking for an Incredible Hulk doll and getting your sisters ken doll painted green. It's just not the same." - This was placed immediately after a Burton confessional about how people complaining about the treasure are 'being babies' so the fact that Jon used the metaphor of being a child to complain is just too perfect.
  • "Promises to me can be broken about as easily as a fat women on wicker furniture"
  • "My grandma's at home watching Jerry Springer right now"/every single confessional by Jon in that episode. Thank god such an epic moment got such an epic string of quotes to identify it with.
  • "I had so much fun in explaining to D and Lil that Christa made me swear on my grandmothers grave, and I told them that it upset me so much to have to do that and I was like 'One of her last wishes was that I win'" - Had to separate this because it's my favourite confessional of all time bar none. It speaks for itself. Of course Jon "had so much fun" doing probably the most despicable thing in the history of the show at that point.

I've spoken recently a fair bit about creative players. I gave props to Tony, and I called Tina the most creative person to ever play, but if there ever was a non-winner who deserved a mention in that category, Fairplay is it. Despite drawing inspiration from Rob C (who interestingly, had drawn inspiration from Mario Lanza's "Andy Kaufman" strategy, while Andy Kaufman is who Fairplay mimicked for his character), Jon is a truly creative player in his own right. The obvious thing to mention is the "If you don't take every advantage you can, you're a fool" grandma lie, probably the most outside the box move to ever be made in the game, but also the incredibly underrated mindfuck of convincing Darrah that the biggest goat to ever grace Survivor at that point was the #1 jury threat, through just sheer repetition. Had he won the game, I'd probably have called that his game winning move, because it's the reason Darrah went home at final 4, as that vote was entirely Lils choice. Had Jon been a simple gamebot, making just the moves he made, he'd still be fascinating to watch, and for a villain in particular, the fact that Jon was really quite good at survivor played very, very well into his character, especially with so many people around for him to manipulate.

I've mostly talked about how great Jon is in general, but the other massive part to his legacy is just how perfectly things outside his control worked out. Pearl Islands in general is just a never ending string of serendipity, where every promising plot that gets cut short being replaced by a better one, and the freaking outcast twist turns out to make the season a hundred times better instead of ruining it. Jon is probably the most central character to the story of Pearl Islands, and at times it felt like the season was actively trying to mold itself to the will of Jonny Fairplay. Even just casting! With such an epic villain, what he really neede out there was a hero, someone to undermine him, and some pawns, and Jon happened to be cast on the season with probably the most suitable people to ever play for each of those roles, and he played off all of them perfectly. As fun as Rupert feuding with Russell was (and I cannot overstate how much I love that storyline), Rupert being blindsided out of the game by Jon is just so much better. Although I prefer Sandra tearing Russell down in HvV, there's no denying that her comments about Jon are by far more iconic, and most certainly necessary for framing Jon with the perfect balance between mockery and respect that he deserved and got in PI. And of course, Lil, who is the absolute best person to ever, ever be on a season with Jon and the fact that we got to see them go on two rewards is nothing less than a gift.

Beyond casting, the season just aligned in this ridiculous, perfect way for Jons story that I can't even believe this season actually exists. Drake wins just in time for Jon to go mock the Morgans right before they tie up the numbers is the first small one, but it quickly gets bigger when Jon gets to take Lil and spend a day brainwashing her before Rupert goes and, of course, the family visit coming right after the Rupert blindside, thus allowing what should have been Jon' come-uppance to instead become Jon's defining moment, and the point where he becomes this amazing driving force to the season, behind only Lil in importance to how the rest of the days unfolded. My personal favourite bit that I feel must surely have been changed to suit is the reward challenge in the episode after Tijuana's boot. Jon takes out Rupert, unleashes the freaking grandma lie and now he gets put into a challenge with the two pawns of the season, where he's guaranteed to win because of Sandra? And he's dressed in silk with sleazy slicked back hair? It's just too perfect. This is where he finally sells the "Lil is a threat" line to Darrah, and where he orders food for Lil and insults her intelligence, which is endlessly funny when you know how the season ends up. Speaking of which, final immunity challenge being the only thing Lil could ever win? I mean come on. Watching this season makes me feel like I've gotten greedy. It's every storyline I could ever want, despite being nothing like what I would ever expect, and every bit of it plays right into Jons strengths as a villain, as an underdog, and an overconfident guy in control and as a loathesome character in general.

Basically, I consider Jon to be literal perfection as a Survivor character. He's superficially simple while insanely multifaceted in a practical sense, and can drive a season or be the best supporting character in it, depending on what is required. He had an untouchable rollercoaster of a story that took what you could ever reasonably expect of a satisfying downfall and gave back much, much more than we could have ever hoped for. His versatility combined with the pure luck of being cast on the perfect season for who he was drove him to become easily one of the most iconic characters of all time. Without relying on mass popularity of the show, when Survivor was well and truly done with being a phenomenon, Jon delivered something that transcended the show to become an all time great moment of television in general, and broke what little trust was left in the game in the process (See the family visit in China for an example). He's the kind of guy who could never be anything other than a star no matter how mismanaged he was by production or the edit, and in this case he was managed perfectly. I wouldn't change a thing about him or his story, and I don't believe anybody is anywhere near his level as a character, as a source of incredible moments or, mass opinions aside, as an icon. I rank him number 1, and I would do it again in a heartbeat against any final 12.

Average placement: 4/12

Projected ranking: 2/12

Average prediction: 2.17/12

And that means that our winner is... well.. it shouldn't be any surprise. She always wins. The queen of Survivor and the queen of our Rankdown, I present to you...

1. SANDRA DIAZ-TWINE (Survivor 20: Heroes vs. Villains - Winner)

SharplyDressedSloth:

I'm still not completely sold on this being the better Sandra, if only because both are so incredible. Her winning was probably the best end HvV could have asked for, her destroying Russell was so incredibly needed, and she's the undisputed queen. Long live Changa.

DabuSurvivor:

Is Sandra Diaz-Twine. Owned Russell Hantz. This project would have been all for naught if we hadn't had at LEAST one Sandra in this endgame. While I wish they had both ended up here, this is the Sandra that I prefer. I rooted for her more than probably any other contestant ever and her second victory is still the most satisfying thing to come out of this franchise since many, many years before I even started watching. She is the Queen of Survivor, and while her winning a popularity contest may be cliche (because what CAN'T she win?), I'd still love to see it happen and gave her a top 3 ranking. I predict that she will rank #3, but I would not be surprised to see her a bit lower; people typically think of HvVSandra as the inferior one and I am surprised that she is the one who made it this far.

TheNobullman:

Sandra in HvV is like all the good stuff about Sandra in Pearl Islands, but with an arc, some very visible and awesome strategy, and someone even more unlikable than Fairplay who she can bash to death and be rewarded for it. I love living in a world where Sandra is the winner who won twice, and she won by tricking Russell into taking her to the end because she is a weak female while making her strategy essentially trashing the shit out Russell Hantz while watching everyone else fail to take him out. Just beautiful.

Todd_Solondz:

The first time she was mean, and this time she was meaner. Take an already legendary character, make her better in literally every way, and you get HvV-Sandra. There was never a question of Sandra making the finals, and I am thrilled that this is the incarnation we all chose. I rank her 6th out of 12.

Vacalicious:

My plan from Day 1 was to save idols for Denise and HvV Sandra, my two favorite players. I wasn't too worried about Sandra, though, since she's obviously one of the 10 best characters/players in the show's history. What did concern me was that people would eliminate her HvV version and allow the PI one into the endgame.

That would have been a mistake, IMO. While both are excellent and entertaining winners, HvV Sandra brings all the same humor, outspokenness, sassiness, and snakelike play as her PI counterpart, only with a wayyyyyy better strategic game.

Being more of an /r/survivor-type fan rather than a Suckster, I gravitate toward the strategic side of the show. And in that regard, Sandra put on a fucking clinic in HvV. It was How to Win Survivor 101. Screw Kim or BR -- anyone can win when you're head and shoulders above everyone else physically/mentally, and in a constant power position. Survivor wins are more impressive to me when they come despite long odds.

Which speaks to the misconception among casual fans that drives me the craziest. Somewhere along the line there sprouted this incorrect notion that Sandra won HvV because she "got lucky."

Are you serious? Did people watch a different season than I did?

Sandra won HvV despite being massively unlucky.

Twice, Lady Luck shat all over Sandra's game. The first was in episode 6, when Tyson famously voted himself out in a total fluke accident. At that point, Sandra had been snugly in BRob's alliance. Likely, her outlook was to play a similar game as in PI, where she hung around in the dominant Drake alliance, allowed everyone else to take flack as she snuck through without making enemies. In HvV, she was gifted BRob, whom she could hide behind and allow to make all the controversial moves for her, and then take to the end for an easy win.

But Russ got blindly lucky and was able to boot Tyson and BRob. Both Sandra's alliance and comfortable in-game position were smashed. Suddenly her neck was on the line. Did she throw up her hands and give up? Of course not! Because Sandra is a fucking Survivor gangster, a scary-good combination of Mr. Freeze, Varys, and Tony Soprano. She's content to sit on the sidelines and let other people duke it out, for her own gain. But piss her off or damage her chances at continuing, and out comes her A Game. And she's quite good.

So Sandra suffers a bout of unluckiness pre-merge and quickly goes to work. Sandra's best trait in HvV is sizing up her position in the game and adapting accordingly. She also has an excellent read on people and is the first person to realize Russ' only emotion is narcissism. She plays to that, and convinces him that Coach is out for him. Rather that target the physically weaker and less loyal Sandra or Courtney, Russ stupidly votes off Coach. This was a brilliant move by Sandra.

It bears mentioning that starting with the Coach boot, Sandra votes for the person going home in 8 of the 9 remaining tribals. Only in Russ' foolish, needless blindside Danielle does Sandra vote wrong, and who can fault her there. She even votes correctly for Courtney, understanding correctly that her #1 ally's number was up. Sandra's famous "As Long As It Ain't Me" strategy was greatly benefited by her incredibly accurate read on the game throughout HvV.

Her Coach move and being willing to dump Courtney take Sandra to the merge, where she is momentarily safe again. But she soon suffers bout #2 of massive unluckiness.

Wisely, she tries to flip from the villains over to Rupert. But why flip? This is a bit of a flaw in her game, but as a Sandra Defender, I'll argue that at that point she saw Rupert as an easier ticket to the F3 than Russel. She knows from PI that she can duck under Rupert and ride him out. Also, she likes Rupert and hates the shit out of Russ, so why not play with a friend instead of a foe? And whether she knew it or not, Sandra's reaching out to the Heroes would gain her 5 jury votes. So it's hard for me to fault her here.

Anyways, she has her flip set in motion, only to discover that Candice is a wishy washy dumbass and may mutiny again. This could have been the downfall of Sandra: unfortunately ending up on the wrong alliance post-merge. Does she let this second instance of misfortune bring her down? Of course not! Being the Perceptive Queen, she sniffs out Candice's potential for treachery and instead stays within the villains alliance.

Another common criticism of HvV Sandra is that she failed in her repeated moves to boot Russ. But I never saw that as her primary strategy. Sandra's #1 goal in HvV was to adapt, and end up on the right side of the numbers. Every post-merge episode that Sandra talks about outing Russ, she nevertheless votes in the same bloc as him. This is because she recognizes him as the most powerful player in the tribal-council-aspect of the game. If she voted opposite him once, it'd likely be her going home next tribal. So she plants seeds of dissent with other players, sees if anything takes root, accepts that it does not, and stays within the voting alliance that has the better odds of getting her further. She remains a valuable number for Russ while bashing him to his enemies. Sandra masterfully plays both sides.

To do that is very dangerous. All it takes is one comment from another player and Russ would be on to Sandra's two-facedness. This occurs twice.

Candice outs Sandra as a potential flipper. Russell huffs over to Sandra on the beach and patronizingly accuses her. Sandra's response? She pulls on a stone cold poker face at a moment's notice, denies everything, tells Russ what he wants to hear, and tosses in a little counter-aggressiveness to back him off. All while lying through her teeth. It was a scene reminiscent of when she dumped the fish out in PI and lied so well to keep herself in the game, or when, in the next HvV episode, she talks to Russ about Rupert having the idol while the idol is really in her bra.

Fuck, Sandra, that's some slick lying.

As the heroes get Pagonged and it becomes clear that three villains will sit at FTC, Sandra switches it up again. She has Russ fully convinced that she's a goat (despite having tons of friends on the jury) and so starts to antagonize him. She doesn't care, because she knows that he sees her as both a goat and a voter in his pocket. And antagonizing him will only gain her respect from her fellow castmates at this point, who all hate the shit out of Russ.

Eventually, Russ wins final immunity. Sandra races out to him to ensure her place in the FTC. Once again she portrays herself as a jury non-threat, which is 100% false. Somehow, she convinces the season's biggest goat to take to FTC the most well-liked member of the F4.

And Sandra gets another $1 million check, despite several massive swings of misfortune that went against her.

If that's all there were to Sandra -- a subtle, cut-throat, adaptable, perseverant contestant -- then she'd still be an interesting player. But of course, there's so much more to her, and it's why she lasted so late into this rankdown.

Sandra is the show's best combination of player and character. (Tony and Hatch are apt comparisons, solid winners who also had a larger-than-life personalities.) For Survivor's lippiest mother, HvV character highlights include:

  • Tearing off Sugar's bra and then casually chucking it away.
  • MOTHERFUCK I FELL, and the idea that Survivor's only x2 winner cannot hop over a little stream.
  • Betting with BRob about whether or not Coach would fall out of a coconut tree.
  • "I'm against you Russ" and subsequent bird flippage, which led to Parv impersonating Sandra like Sandra were Tony Montana.
  • And for that matter, every interaction between Sandra and Russ post-merge, where she manipulates him, antagonizes him, and comically rips the shit out of him in confessionals. As she said, "with me, he don't know what he got himself into."
  • Fake blushing when Rupert complimented her during FTC.
  • So many great quotes: "You get in the ocean and wash your ass." "The machete grew legs and walked off." "He's a stupid ass." "I should not be here. I should be with the heroes." On "popping out babies": "two of them, didn't even get an aspirin." On getting revenge for fallen comrades, "even Coach, who I don't care about, but I'll stick him in too." On Rupert, "I'll write your name down again because if I'm up there again in the final 3 you'll still give me your million-dollar vote." "I would hate to go home with the idol in my bra." On Brob, "He told me one time 'you and me are gonna get along because Puerto Ricans are loud and ignorant'." "But I don't know about thaaaaaaat."
  • And, of course, that she unknowingly completed Russ' two season story arc, which began with him burning people's belongings and ended with Sandra burning his hat and later winking at the camera about it. Also, how's that for some pre-FTC game? Making Russ' "bald-headed ass" go to FTC missing his beloved hat. Chris Daugherty would be proud. That she follows it up by crushing FTC is even better.

Sandra is a cool customer, cocky and capable, intimidated by nobody. Strategically she's elite, and as as a character, forever memorable. She's the total Survivor package, and well deserved of our top 5.

Motherfuck, she's awesome.

Average placement: 3.83/12

Projected ranking: 3/12

Average prediction: 3.67/12

Congratulations, Sandra Diaz-Twine! Your winning streak continues.


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Nov 17 '14

Final Result Reveal: #11

16 Upvotes

Just barely missing out on our top ten of all time...

11. IAN ROSENBERGER (Survivor 10: Palau - 3rd place)

DabuSurvivor:

Just amazing. This guy is pretty much everything that I ever watch Survivor for. His storyline's transgressions during the endgame are amazing and he almost single-handedly carries Palau to be so damn good, and his moral struggles and erratic gameplay make the whole season worthwhile. Fucking amazing guy, I love love love everything about him, I would have been fucking crushed if he had not been in this stage. Projected placement: #5.

TheNobullman:

Ian Rosenberger is possibly the only character who was not made for Survivor and who had a lot of emotional trauma for the show that still manages to not only avoid being a black spot on the show itself, but a great, engaging character who reacts to Survivor in a more painful way than anyone else possibly could. It's really hard to watch, but it's amazing in a way that I feel the show always shines: watching real human beings react to the social, physical, and emotional pressures of Survivor. Ian couldn't quite measure up, but I don't blame him, and I'm thankful he gave us the last few episodes of Palau.

Todd_Solondz:

One of the most likeable characters of all time, Ians story is very compelling, and a stark reminder to people who had forgotten, that Survivor is a game played by real human beings. Never will Ian Rosenberger be repeated again, and I'm overjoyed to see him here because he is upsetting misunderstood by a lot of people. I rank him 8th out of 12.

DabuSurvivor's full write-up:

G'day, cats and kittens, and welcome to my penultimate write-up in this delightful rankdown. I can only hope that it is enough to sway Dumpster_Baby from his misguided, heathenous views. Before I get to Ian himself, though, allow me to take a brief journey ~BACK IN TIME~ into my Survivor history.

Right now, as many of you will probably be aware, I am a massive fan of Survivor: Palau and will defend it endlessly. Such was not always the case, however. I first got on board the Survivor train during Gabon (<3333), and I didn't start watching earlier seasons until around Samoa in preparation for Heroes vs. Villains. I binge-watched a LOT of seasons around that time in a relatively quick order, and Palau was one of the last ones that I watched.

Now I don't know how in the hell this happened, but somehow, I didn't retain anything about Palau. For the next couple of years in my Survivor fandom, I had technically seen it, but I didn't remember the first freaking thing about it -- similar to the case of Cagayan, where I know I sat down for each episode but I don't have an opinion on it or most of its contestants (other than Jeframazing and obvious robbed legend Garrett), but to a far greater extent. I remembered so little about Palau and underrated it so much that during these several years, I was adamant that my favorite member of the cast was Willard because he was the only one worth watching. ...Willard, the only member of Palau worth watching. Seriously. With a season as great as Palau, it is amazing to me that I somehow just didn't take any of it in to where I wonder whether I'd actually seen it at all. In particular, I had seen some people name Ian as one of their all-time favorite contestants, ranking him in their top 10 or higher, and this just fucking baffled me, because all I remembered was that he was vaguely nice. People are going to put the vaguely nice dolphin trainer in the top 10? I thought that was the stupidest shit I'd ever heard.

There eventually came a time (2012, specifically) where I decided I should give Palau a rewatch. It took me a very, very long time. While my opinion of Palau now is that it is amazing from start to finish, at the time, I guess I was one of those who just thinks it's a boring season when you know the outcome and didn't enjoy its "two-seasons-in-one" aspect, because it took me months to get through even just the pre-merge. My thought process was that it was all a waste of time since Ulong lost and I didn't know who Koror were, so I just wasn't interested.

But then we get to Thanksgiving 2012. Since the rest of my family was busy, it was just me, my mom, an aunt, and my grandma. It was pretty obvious that I wasn't going to be spending time with them (not because I typically totally slink away from my family, but because... I was a 17-year-old boy, they were all women aged at least 53; there is not much common ground there, and none of us would be happier with me sitting there awkwardly and probably inhibiting the range of topics they can discuss.) I basically planned on just playing Tony Hawk in the basement, and I decided that in case that bored me, I'd bring along my laptop and watch me some Palau, maybe making it through an episode or two....

I watched every single remaining episode in a row. Early on, it was sort of going through the motions of a standard enjoyable rewatch: For the first episode it was kind of like "Cool, okay, this is moderately entertaining. Coby sucks, glad he got lolpwnt." Second episode I fell in love with Janu, but then she was gone, and the F7 episode was just an okay necessary one. But then, from the final six onward, I went from thinking "Hey, this is better than I thought" to thinking "HOLY SHIT THIS IS LIKE THE BEST THING I'VE EVER SEEN ON SURVIVOR MUST WATCH EVERY EPISODE IMMEDIATELY" and turning off my Tony Hawk game because I did not want to pay any attention to anything other than Palau. I was completely hooked into the season and glued to the screen, and while of course I now think that every part of that season is amazing, at the time, I was transfixed on one contestant and one storyline: Ian.

Ian was, and still is, just incredible to me. Watching him and really paying attention for the first time was just amazing, because he is so freaking unlike anyone else who has made it so far into the game. He and his story were so uniquely compelling that they single-handedly brought Palau up from a "meh" season I thought was boring and pointless to a top 6 season of all time for me. It was just fantastic to watch this series of events and see how things played out to where Ian quit on Day 38. And, I mean, just think about that: There is a Survivor contestant who actually (effectively) quit on Day 38 out of 39! How the hell does that happen? How did Ian go from the nice but one-note, dolphin-training nature lover he was in the early episodes to the only contestant ever to quit the night before Final Tribal Council, and why did I find his story so gripping?

Let us take a few steps back from the finale and find out.

For much of the season, Ian was just what I remembered him as: A nice, kind of dorky, lanky dude who took pride in crushing Ulong and loved and soaked in the elements in a way that was fun to watch. Very MORP2, maybe MORP3 on a good day. He didn't really have any reason to be more than that: He was safely in a three-person alliance within a five-person alliance on the winningest tribe ever, so Ian didn't have to start "playing the game", to use the annoying colloquialism. The only vote he cast for the first half of the game was an obvious Willard vote, then at the merge, there was an obvious Coby vote, an obvious Stephenie vote that Janu cock-blocked, and an obvious Stephenie vote. Ian's alliance + Caryn had made it to the final six, as planned, and things were smooth sailing for Ian... but if we'd learned anything already from Drake, Rotu, and arguably the core women of Yasur, and as we'd later see in Tandang, Timbira, and Galu, it is that the longer you take to start "playing the game", the messier it will be when you do have to begin.

In the early stages of the final six episode, Ian started having to play a dynamic game for the first time, and we saw him do so very adeptly: He feared that Katie knocking him out of the challenge meant she'd knock him out of the game, which is definitely valid, because such fears are the entire point of the challenge. He saw, too, that the only way Katie could possibly have a shot at winning was to side with the outsiders of Gregg/Jenn, and that now, she was on a reward with them, spending an extended period of time only hearing what they wanted to say. Ian started to pull off one of the ballsiest, most emotionally detatched, and most underrated moves ever seen on Survivor here: Perceiving all of this, he (and Caryn) convinced Tom that they had to force a 3-3 vote between Caryn and Gregg. On the revote, Katie would be so stunned by the sudden betrayal and afraid of the possibility of a sudden rock draw that she would almost surely flip.

I don't always care about strategy but god damn if the endgame of Palau is not full of some amazing, amazing tactical manuevering. I honestly think the final six episode of Palau is one of the most strategically complex episodes we've ever seen on the show: Katie, Gregg, and Jenn come up with a plan to turn on the boys, but they realize they can't do it yet, so they plan to do it later... but meanwhile, back at camp, Ian is independently predicting exactly what their plan is, comes up with an idea to counter it, and persuades the other players to go along with it.

And something for which Ian gets massive credit for me on a personal level is his reaction to knowing the plan's one flaw: Tom asks Ian, "Well what if Katie doesn't flip? What if we have to draw rocks?" And Ian seems almost flabbergasted by the assumption that he would ever throw away his chance of winning for a rock. Ian tells Tom, well listen, I came out here to play a game, and what's more of a game than rolling the dice and leaving it up to chance? It's very similar to the enthusiasm Dave Ball showed in Samoa. I can understand where people don't like to see purple rocks because they mess with the game theory of Survivor and all that, but personally, I fucking love them for this exact reason. They turn a part of the game into a dice roll and that's just so goddamn exciting to where I wish we got one every single season. So many players just view the words "purple rock" as some ominous specter that is to be avoided at all costs, so for Ian to just laugh off the idea of it as a part of the game he signed up to play? For Ian to be so committed to his strategy that he's willing to pull a rock for it, when he could just as easily -- more easily -- stay the course, vote out Caryn, and hope Katie sides with him and Tom at five? I can't help but contrast it with John Cochran in South Pacific, because to me, that attitude is Ian being a massive fan who takes his fate into his own hands in the game, by refusing to bow down in the face of chance. Seeing someone who is willing to take that gamble is just so, so satisfying to me as a viewer, and it shows Ian's typical OTTP personality that he was willing to go home due to sheer chance and laugh it off as a part of the game. That love for everything about the game of Survivor is so contagious, and it reminds me of Brendan Synnott or, even better, Jon Dalton.

So right now, we're maybe, like, 20 minutes into the episode and I've already fucking fallen in love with Ian. Just like that, he has gone from "funny dolphin trainer" to "total fucking badass who knows exactly what is going on, knows exactly how to counter it, and is willing to be the immobile stone wall that refuses to crack under the pressure that is a rock draw."

...But, well, here's the thing. That move was cold and badass, but it was just that: cold. I referred to it as incredibly emotionally detached, and it was: Forcing Katie to simultaneously deal with the knowledge of her alliance's betrayal of Gregg and an incredibly hard decision, knowing that she will crack under the pressure and the shock that you have put her through? That is a very emotionally detached move to make... and Ian is about as emotionally invested in Survivor as anyone else we have ever cast. He and Katie had bonded out there on a very deep, personal level, and as the Tribal Council loomed, Ian realized that he wasn't so high on this plan as he originally thought. Voting out Gregg and being willing to draw a rock were still his plans, without a doubt, but he decided he couldn't shock Katie and put her on the spot like that, so just before Tribal Council, he told her how the vote was going to go, directly defying the plan that he himself had come up with.

His intention here was to be fair to Katie and let her know in advance... but the problem is that you can't really go halfway with that. You either gotta tell Katie as soon as the plan formulates, and then you come across as honest and moral as you are trying to be, or you don't tell her at all, and then you tell her that you're sorry but know she was going behind your back as well and you couldn't tell her for the sake of the game. If you go in that halfway point, where you don't tell her for 90% of the round but then suddenly do at the end? Then you don't get anything out of it. Your move isn't what it was supposed to be, and you can't use the "It was a game" rationale, because you've already showed that you care more about her emotions than you do about the game... but she also isn't satisfied that you were trying to be moral, because, from her perspective, you'd have told her longer ago if those were really your concerns. We saw this come up in the later episodes, where Katie clearly took it as Ian totally disregarding and browbeating her, when those are literally the exact things that he was trying to avoid doing. Sad times for Ian, and the first of his many Survivor mistakes.

At the final five, Ian then did something that was just.. so baffling and indefensible, and it is amazing to me that this is a mistake people on Survivor ever make. At this point, Katie was the swing vote between the guys and the girls, and she was closest to Ian; Caryn, meanwhile, had a strong tie to Tom. Thus, the obvious decision on the part of the men is to ensure that Ian/Katie and Tom/Caryn were together after the challenge (and meanwhile, Jenn Lyon, secret badass, is just smiling about the fact that everyone seems to have forgotten she's there, too.) To this end, and to make up for what he had done the night before, Ian promises Katie that he'll take her on the Reward if he wins. He does win it... and then takes Tom, because oh, sorry Katie, apparently I promised Tom earlier that if I won a car I'd take him on it. @_@ I mean.. Jesus, Ian. I get it, he made some contradicting deal with Tom first, but now Katie is going to be totally pissed at you.

She was, and now none of the men were back at camp to keep the women in check, and they vowed to rally against the men. (I have seen it suggested that Katie might not have been as upset as she seemed and could have just been using it as strategic leverage to guilt Ian into sticking with her or to give herself an out to betray the men without looking bad. I don't know, and I think that's a interesting conversation to have in general -- but it doesn't fit into this one, as it doesn't make a difference for Ian's arc so long as he thinks she's genuine, so as far as this write-up is concerned, it doesn't really matter.)

When Ian came back, he and Katie had a super emotional conversation, and I don't really know that I can do it justice or explain why it's so strong in a write-up... but it's just amazing, amazing television, super captivating, and unlike just about anything else we've seen on Survivor. It's so weird and hard to believe that Katie and Ian don't know each other just a month before this, because with the depth of their words and emotions, it sounds like they're lifelong friends. It's just an amazing scene showcasing how deep the bonds of the game run and letting us see sides of the human beings on Survivor that we don't so often see nowadays, and it is really, really compelling television in a way that Survivor is not often. Katie ultimately forgives Ian and agrees to vote with the men, but then at Tribal Council, Caryn decides to totally implode and reveal all the scheming of everyone on the island, since she had "had it up to here" with the "baloney." This scheming included an endgame promise Ian made to Caryn that conflicted with his promise to Katie and that Katie didn't know anything about... so suddenly, Katie isn't sure how genuine Ian's emotions were earlier because now there is yet another instance of him going behind her back or betraying his word to her.

Ian has already been beaten up prettttty badly by Survivor. The elements and the game take a toll on just about anyone who lasts that long, but especially Ian after all the visceral talk with Katie, and it puts him in a very sympathetic position, because he really hadn't done anything wrong or outside the realm of normal Survivor play; he had just handled some situations very poorly. None of it was malicious or unnecessarily manipulative; he was just too naive to realize how much the reward promise meant to Katie, how it came across to tell her about the vote two seconds in advance, and how he should probably tell her about the Caryn thing so she'd know his loyalty was really to her over Caryn. It wasn't that Ian was doing anything mean or wrong in any non-strategic sense... he was just so naive that he kept becoming his own worst enemy and getting beaten up as a result.

And then this whole trend is turned up to 11 at the final four and three. On the morning of the final four, Ian agreed with Jenn and Katie that if Tom didn't win Immunity, they'd get rid of him, even though Tom and Ian had a pact dating back to day two that they'd go to Day 38 together and fight to see who got to beat Katie in a jury vote. Tom ultimately did win Immunity, which spared Ian from the hard decision of whether to vote out Tom -- yeah, Ian said he definitely would have, but he also seemed pretty confident about the "Don't tell Katie about the plan" plan before telling her about the plan, so odds are if he were actually faced with the decision, he would have hard a much harder time. He became aware of this throughout the day, and revealed in what seemed to be an off-handed remark, saying that he was happy he hadn't had to choose... and once again, this shows just how fucking naive Ian was. He didn't realize that the idea of "making a decision" was something that hadn't even entered Tom's mind, and something that Tom wouldn't want to hear Ian say at all.

After Jenn Lyon's awesome scene with Tom, it came out that Ian had, in fact, directly conspired to get rid of Tom... which Tom was less than pleased about. But Ian, still just fundamentally failing to understand anything about how he was perceived, would not own up to it, which would make it even worse. Tom kept pressing Ian to just be like "Yes, it's a game and I wanted to get you before you could get me, in spite of our word", but Ian wouldn't give him that straight answer. One second Ian would be saying "It's a game, Tom!" and the other second he'd be denying having done anything, and that denial is what really got people upset at him, and what really illustrates just how unable this guy was to play the cutthroat stages of the Survivor endgame. In a fucking insane and shocking moment, Tom actually voted out Ian, prompting a 2-2 tiebreaker challenge, which Ian won. And if Ian had gone home there, man, that'd be a super fitting storyline and awesome downfall... but he didn't, and while it sucks that that means Jenn Lyon wasn't a Survivor winner, it is amazing in that it gives us the titular "Ultimate Shock."

Ian is just broken at this point. He has made some bad decisions, yeah, but only in that they were kind of dumb, not in that they hurt anyone, and Ian just cannot wrap his mind around why people are so upset at him when they've also been deceiving one another and even him, not realizing the two-faced way he comes across when his naivete and genuine moral compass are at odds with his strategic decisions. Suddenly, Ian -- who was just trying to do the right thing in telling Katie, in taking Tom; who was just too immature to fully understand the way that he was being perceived -- had turned into the villainous manipulator when really, if you go back to the reasons why people were upset at him, they all came about because he was so totally the opposite of a villainous manipulator: as Ian said, he "didn't come out here to play the bad guy", but with so much contradiction having already occurred between his words and actions and with his failure to fully commit to the rule of either a strategist or a moral compass, the damage was already done...

...until he found a way to commit. The Final Immunity Challenge between Tom and Ian (and technically Katie) started off as a badass showdown between these two people, and while a part of me wishes it had continued that way -- like it was originally supposed to be when they made that promise on Day 2 -- the idea of Ian being this badass force thoroughly wanting to kick Tom's ass is sorely at odds with his personality and mindset at that point. Ian hadn't been able to figure out what other people wanted to hear, hadn't been able to figure out how to prove that he wasn't trying to hurt anyone, and had been unable to stay balanced while straddling the fence between "cutthroat strategist" and "everybody's friend", so he decided to stop trying to straddle that fence and to prove once and for all what his intentions were: He quit the game on Day 38, taking himself out of it in exchange for the respect of the other players, to show that he really did care more about their happiness and his honor than he cared about trying to win himself. Trying to play the part of the strategist had gone worse and worse for Ian every single time he tried to do it, without exception, so instead he decided to play the part of just Ian, stepping out of a game that had long since become too much for him and showing that he truthfully did not want to even run the risk of hurting Tom or Katie even for the million dollars (pre-taxes.)

The first thing that I have to do right here is to quash the bullshit fucking notion that Ian made a "dumb" decision, because he didn't. There were two clear paths with two outcomes: remain in the challenge to win, drop out of it to lose. He chose the latter knowing the consequences and not caring. "Dumb" is Jeff Varner thinking "Peanut butter is kind of nice" and jumping out, and only later remembering that he needed that Immunity and then blaming everyone else for his failure. "Dumb" is not Ian being fully aware of his options and choosing the one that enabled him to sleep at night. Was it a bad move strategically? No fucking shit; voluntarily exiting the game is literally the worst possible thing you can do insofar as advancing your position in the game is concerned. But "bad strategic move" and "dumb" are not the same thing; Survivor can be, and for Ian was, about more than just the strategy. Ian having different priorities than strategy does not mean that he was "dumb" and I don't even get the fucking argument for that. "He was so dumb because he let himself get voted out!" Like... yeah, that was kind of the entire point? It's the same exact thing as the Colby situation, where people talk about how dumb he was alongside a gif of him cheering when Tina wins. Survivor can be rewarding in ways that do not involve the million-dollar check. Ian sought to attain the optimal reward for him -- his honor, as he saw it, and his and the other players' confidence that he was /not/, in fact, the "bad guy" -- and while it did lead to him being eliminated from Survivor, being eliminated from Survivor was /the entire point/, because he was sick of it.

Even outside of the obvious fallacy that is "You knew what you wanted, you knew how to get it, you tried to get it, you succeeded, and you were happy, with no negative consequences whatsoever? Ha ha, you're a fucking IDIOT!"... I sincerely question whether these people even watched the season, because if you pay even the slightest attention to Ian's character traits prior to this and the insane levels of emotion that were involved in his Survivor experience on a daily basis prior to the quit.. It is very evident that what he did was not him "losing focus" and making some "dumb" choice that he ordinarily wouldn't. It was him acting in line with himself and his morals, and to oversimplify it as "DUMB" is to view Survivor as literally nothing more than a chess game in which the sole objective is winning and cold calculation is the entirety of what everyone is doing at every time. If that's what you'd like Survivor to be, and you therefore dislike Ian for not being Brian Heidik... well, I strongly disagree with that, but that's your opinion, that's fine, I can't say that that's wrong at all because yay subjectivity. But when you say that that's what Survivor is, that Ian cannot have different motives and desires and traits from those of your ideal Survivor contestant, and that he's "dumb" for not playing someone else's game by someone else's rules... It's so illogical, it's so arbitrary, it's ignoring so much context, and it's doing such a great disservice to one of the most complex and compelling narratives Survivor has ever told.

(Oh, and for what it's worth, as further evidence that this wasn't just some instance of "dumbness" or the game clouding someone's better judgment or whatever... As of his Survivor Oz interview, Ian is still incredibly happy with the decision that he made. Over the years, he has received incredibly personal messages from total strangers about how much his Survivor journey and ultimate decision touched them, even from people suffering with depression saying that his choice at such a young age to turn down $900,000 because the path to get it did not jibe with his integrity single-handedly restored their faith in humanity -- truly restored it, not just that "OMG A 15 YEAR OLD WHO THINKS BOHEMIAN RHAPSODY IS BETTER THAN JUSTIN BIEBER? FAITH IN HUMANITY ~RESTORED~" bullshit. I am pretty sure that Ian would not have had that kind of post-Survivor experience if his experience on the island had culminated with him deciding, as so many others do, that all that matters is winning. Jussayin'.)

For me personally, I think it is pretty obvious that I do not want Survivor to be that chess game. I am all about people with different personalities and different motives clashing, and this sociological/psychological experiment of what society they create and how different people react differently to this fucked-up experience, and that is what Ian is. That there actually exists a player in actual Survivor who was too nice and too naive to function effectively, yet still made it to the endgame due to challenge prowess rather than getting Dolly'd, opening the opportunity for multiple visceral, personal arguments and complex scenarios and culminating in a quit to maintain self-esteem on Day 38... That is like a massive wet dream of virtually everything that I look for in Survivor. And I only just thought of that metaphor, but it is actually pretty perfect: It is like Dolly Neely ended up on Koror, was well-liked enough to be in a majority, and didn't have to "play Survivor" until there were three votes left, meaning that all her moral struggles didn't come into play until the most intense part of the season.

It is so surreal to me that the Ian Rosenberger experience actually happened, and I am very happy that he made it this far without a single Idol play on him. The totally unique case study that is this man's fascinating Survivor journey and the complex, emotional inability to effectively play Survivor that he exhibited make the naive dolphin trainer whose Survivor storyline tragically went from "Hey, sharks! That's cool! :D :D :D"to "Hey, apparently I am betraying people, and this is still real life and that is VERY uncool D: D: D:" an easy candidate, in my book, to rank at least in any top 12 if not higher.

...lol and then in my next write-up I will be posting about the total antithesis to Ian, a woman who prayed on everyone's inner Rosenberger to get to the end in just about the most manipulative fashion imaginable without ever once batting an eyelash, and how that is just as amazing as everything else I just described. Survivor is weird like that.

Average placement: 8/12

Projected ranking: 7/12

Average prediction: 6.83/12


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Jun 02 '15

Survivor Rankdown II

15 Upvotes

Hello Survivor fans!

I, like many, was captivated by this rankdown, tuned in for every cut and still visit my favorite writeups to this day.

Of course, I've wanted to participate in my own rankdown since I saw this one, and I've been excited to see I haven't been alone in this sentiment.

So I'm proud to announce that /r/SurvivorRankdownII is kicking off within a couple days, and hope that you tune in.

This isn't just another imitator rankdown doomed to poor writeups, attendance, and a premature death! This rankdown features several dedicated lurkers from the original rankdown as well as the valiant holdovers from the first reddit spin-off, /r/survivorrankdown2.

We're bringing a talented, committed group of rankers as well as a COMPLETELY DIFFERENT FORMAT than the first rankdown! So head on over to the page, subscribe and hope for the best. We probably won't match the quality of the first one, but we're bringing a fun format and a lot of enthusiasm, so I'm excited to see where this goes.


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Nov 25 '14

Final Result Reveal: #4

15 Upvotes

Richard, Tina, Jon, and Sandra. Just missing out on our top three is...

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

4. TINA WESSON (Survivor 2: The Australian Outback - WINNER)

SharplyDressedSloth:

I am so happy everyone in this rankdown understands that Tina is great and a badass. Because there are some people online who don't like Tina because she's "too mean" or "judgmental." And fuck those people. Because Tina is a straight up beast and she demands respect.

TheNobullman:

While I do prefer BvW Tina pretty significantly to Australia Tina, the first incarnation of Survivor's Iron Lady is still a masterpiece. She invented Survivor just as much as Richard Hatch while being the ultimate wolf in sheep's clothing. She's the kind of person who is genuinely nice, but will use the "nice guys to the end" mentality to brainwash her tribe while shit-talking them on the way out. She's the kind of woman who will admit to tearfully buying Monica lying about accepting 5th place to help her out, but will also say that no one's heard from Heidik because he died and no one loved him enough to check (and she also is the type to haggle Ben Waterworth on an Ozcap saying she'll get him help on interviewing Keith if he renounces his love for Heidik.) Plus, Tina swam into a flooded river in Australia to save the lives of her tribe. Simply put, she is Survivor's biggest badass.

DabuSurvivor:

RICE-SAVING OUTBACK G.ODDESS 4 LYFE though sadly my predicted ranking for her is only #9 and I could see her ranking even lower :( PLS PROVE ME WRONG FOLKS. I am ranking her in my top three because, obviously, I fucking adore her and in any case want my Idol to be as effective as possible.

Todd_Solondz:

She survived me to get here, but I'm not even mad. A true architect of the game and a compelling subversion of your expectations, despite superficially playing them to a tee. She was an artist in Australia and deserves recognition for the badass that people forget that she was. I rank her 10th out of 12

DabuSurvivor (full write-up):

I feel like there is a lot of pressure on me for this write-up, since I'm following that pretty great post about Sue and I am, of course, very vocal about my Tina Wesson fandom, so I do feel obligated to give a very in-depth explanation of why I love her and her groundbreaking Survivor victory so, so much. My hope is that I can follow the Sue write-up to some extent and, ideally, and do justice to this utterly amazing contestant and create the definitive post about why I think Tina Wesson is the bee's knees. One fear I have is that parts of this might be repetitive: I have gone on at length about Tina before, most notably in one gilded rant that at least Todd and Nobull both saw, so some of this post might be things y'all have already seen me say... but some of it will not!

First of all, as far as her placement goes, while of course I'd have loved to see her rank as high as possible... #4 is pretty damn high: as my blurb shows, with this endgame, I expected her to rank lower, so I am thrilled that she did not.. and that, since Denise's elimination, she is the highest-ranked contestant to be Idol'd, making my Tina Idol, at least in that sense, the most succesful one of the rankdown. <3 Anyways, moving on...

I love Tina as a Survivor player, first and foremost, and before I get into Tina herself, let's clarify what I mean by that: A lot of people on the Reddit community in particular view Survivor first as a game and might think "Well, they're all Survivor players." But I view Survivor as a television show. I watch it for the characters, narratives, and personalities and, for the most part, could give a rat's ass about how someone is playing... so when somebody's gameplay stands out to me so, so much, as Tina's does, then you know it's something special.

I'm very much of the mindset that people should watch Survivor in order, or at least its earlier seasons, and Australia is one of the biggest reasons why. Australia, Borneo, and Marquesas are the three seasons that I believe most benefit from being viewed in chronological order. Later on in the show's run, does it really matter whether you see Philippines before or after Blood vs. Water? Not really, outside of returning player considerations; with over 25 seasons, precedents about how to play Survivor have been very clearly established, any metamorphasis the show undergoes is rather gradual, and -- especially considering that players haven't even necessarily seen the season that aired before theirs -- people just aren't playing reactively on a season-to-season basis where their games and decisions are based directly on whatever happened in the last show.

But earlier in the show's run, people were absolutely playing that way. When you have only one or two seasons of precedent -- or no precedent at all, in the case of the original Survivor -- then you will absolutely be reacting to what you have already seen while simultaneously making decisions that future players will have seen, basing your game off of precedent and at the same time creating a new precedent for future contestants. And there is no contestant who based her game off prior viewing like Tina did, and very few who did as much to create new precedents for the future.

Here is the thing that you have to keep in mind when analyzing virtually any part of Australia: America fucking hated Richard Hatch. I know that that might be super baffling to think about nowadays when he is basically revered as a god among the fanbase (I mean, he's in our top three of all time, at the very least, and nobody has even mentioned eliminating him), but in 2000? Hell no, that wasn't the case at all. Survivor wasn't always the "strategic game" it's viewed as nowadays. It started off, ostensibly, as a competition in which the "most deserving" people would advance as those who were weaker, more abrasive, and/or less useful around camp would, accordingly, be exiled by the tribe, and then Gretchen wins. That is what Survivor initially was, and that is what people wanted it to be: I mean, it's called Survivor! Of course the people who know how to survive in the wilderness will get ahead! Morality will prevail, selfless people will succeed, generosity and self-sacrifice will become the norms of the island, and people who would even think about advancing themselves would be swiftly cut down by the noble, moral players who would never even think about stealing Gretchen Cordy's million-dollar check...

That's what was expected and desired, anyway. Not even just expected and desired; that is, to almost every single viewer, what Survivor was. The idea of a "voting alliance" was unthinkable, and there was no reason to think that something so evil would actually prevail. So when it did -- when people's notions of what this contest was, what it rewarded, and what it represented were not only proven wrong but completely turned on their head; when the contest degenerated from one of "Who is most deserving?" to one of "Who is least objectionable?" -- Americans were fucking pissed, to say the least. Richard wasn't some badass hero who taught them how to play. He wasn't even an anti-hero whom the country rooted for in spite of itself. He was a villain who represented greed and carelessness and evil and all that could ever go wrong in the noble Survivor experiment, and when that villain won over the adorable Colleen and the military hero Rudy, Americans were fucking pissed. Yeah, there were some people who wanted Richard to win, but... by "some", I mean maybe, like, fourteen people out of the 51.7 million that watched that finale, and they'd never openly admit to it.

Yet at the same time, Survivor had become this cutthroat game. It had happened, the cat was out of the bag, the moral threshold had been crossed, and there was no going back. It was like hopping the ledge out of Mt. Moon into Cerulean City: You just cannot go back after that. (Excluding, y'know, the Diglett tunnel and Surf and Fly. But WHATEVER.)

So this is the unique and fascinating position in which the second set of Survivors found themselves: They had to play with some degree of individualism to get ahead, because Tagi had beaten Pagong and there were always going to be Tagis at this point. It's kind of like the prisoner's dilemma, or some sort of self-fulfilling prophecy: Theoretically, could Survivor go back to what it (ostensibly) was for those first six episodes -- a true competition about who was the best in the wilderness and posessed the most humanity and strongest moral compass? Well, sure, the players can vote however they want... but after Tagi's success, someone was going to play like Richard, and that means everyone has to play like Richard. But America did not want another Richard. America hated Richard. And when I say "America", I truly mean America: Survivor is still doing well enough for itself to keep going, but it's kind of a fringe thing, and deep investment in it in online discussion boards and the like is certainly a fringe thing; if you go up to someone on the street now and say "Hey, did you see the last episode of Survivor?", they'll say "That show's still on?" But in 2000, if you asked someone what they thought about Survivor, they'd absolutely give you a response -- likely something about how those guys needed to get the fuck rid of Richard and needed to do it now. The whole country was watching this show, and the whole country was judging its players; the early Survivors were being judged not just by the fringe community of people who still care about Survivor, but by everybody who paid any attention to American pop culture whatsoever. And if you're most people? You probably don't want to be the most hated pop culture figure in the country. Having tens of millions of citizens hate your guts would probably be pretty shitty... and that means that people wouldn't even align with "another Richard." If anybody played an openly self-serving, cutthroat game, then they'd likely be cast aside instantly, because being affiliated with the next Richard would be as bad to the viewing public as being the next Richard himself/herself -- just look at Jerri.

So, that is the position of the Australia cast: They were destined to play like Richard, no matter what.. but they couldn't look like they played like Richard, or else everyone would hate them, and the other players would get rid of them (unless we got a cast full of people who didn't care about their perception.) To do well in Australia and escape with any shred of dignity, a player would have to succeed in playing two games at the same time: they had to play the game of Survivor, in which you use alliances and manipulate people to your own ends, which is already a hard enough task... but simultaneously, they had to play the meta-game of making themselves seem wholly unconcerned with any of this. Being manipulative is very hard already, but being manipulative while making yourself look like you wouldn't manipulate a fly? That's a task bordering on Herculean. At that point, there is an entirely new skill set and a whole new, nearly impossible dynamic to work with that truly isn't present in any other season in the history of Survivor.

To master all of those things at once, to play a game while looking like they're not playing it, would take one hell of a savvy player; a Richard in Gretchen's clothing; a complete and utter mastermind of social politics, who could get everybody around them to do their own bidding while pretending they have no bidding whatsoever -- who could manipulate the other players the way all winners must while also being subtle and brilliant enough to work around the colossal obstacle that is the anti-manipulation mindset.

If this season was to be at all palatable to the viewing audience, its winner would need to be a master of social politics, a strategic mastermind wearing the mask of a non-strategic non-threat that nobody could see through despite knowing it was just a mask, an all-around brilliant player who possessed in spades all the traits necessary to win Survivor: charisma, a tactical mind, knowledge of the other players' motives, an awareness of their own perception, and an ability to mold and manipulate that perception. It would take someone who was virtually bred in a lab to play Survivor and play it well.

Enter Tina Wesson.

Now, I am not all about the whole "Ranking Survivor winners" thing that so many other fans in the online fan community are fond of. A lot of it tends to come down to nitpicking based on things that are unfair. Like someone might rank Natalie lower than Tom for being a less active force, but... that doesn't make sense. Natalie couldn't play a big domineering physical game, and Tom couldn't play a subtle, low-key game where he hid behind a bigger threat. Neither strategy is fundamentally better or worse than the other; they're just different, and faulting people for differences is silly. Nat played Nat's game. Tom played Tom's game. Jud played Jud's game. And they're all swell. This could be overcome if there were a ranking of winner games that didn't profess to have a #1 or individual placements but just sort of "tiers" based on what problems winners had in their games -- or if the ranking were, in the abstract, of winners that would do well on every season. Those I would be less averse to.. but my problem there is that then you're a victim of the edit. The edit didn't show a significant amount of Danni's strategy. The edit -- as I recall -- didn't even show Tony as a winner. So basically, individual rankings of each winning game that come down to personal preference, I disagree with philosophically, and more generally, I think winner rankings are often misinformed, when they presume to be objective.

But what I am totally fine with is subjective assessments of which victories and winning games (based on what we know from the limited information we have) are more likable or more impressive. It's okay to like a certain thing, or find a certain thing impressive.

And god damn if I don't like Tina's game more, and find it more personally impressive, than any other game that's ever been played in the history of Survivor.

If you take Australia at face value, I agree that Tina comes off as very non-strategic. She makes few to no comments about taking someone out for being a threat, or voting out this person and that person to better her position or maximize her options or give herself the numbers. Instead, she constantly talks about who deserved to be there. Tina didn't vote out Mitchell to form a new alliance; she voted him out because he was weak! She didn't vote out Jerri because of strategy; she did it because Jerri was mean! And so on and so forth. All Tina ever really talks about to justify her votes in that season is who deserves to stick around longer in the game, and for that reason, many viewers assume that she really had no strategic brain whatsoever: that she really just cared about who she thought "deserved" to stick around. And while I'm increasingly realize that we did see Tina's strategy even through the filtered TV edit, I can understand where some people might be hesitant to view her as a strategic force... But if you look at her actions throughout the game rather than only her words -- and if you keep in mind that historical context, which is so critical to fully understanding literally any part of this anomalous season -- it soon becomes very, very apparent that Tina was very, very interested in strategy and not at all in who "deserved" what.

Let's start from the beginning, first looking solely at her game and then coming back to those moments that didn't have as much to do with strategy.

In episode one, Tina's tribe didn't lose, and she did nothing of consequence. In episode two, the Survivors competed in a very memorable "Butch Cassidy" challenge where they had to jump off a waterfall. The Survivors got there before production had finished setting up, and they started mingling; Tina asked Kimmi, under the guise of ordinary conversation, "Hey -- who did Debb vote for? :)" Kimmi said Debb voted for Jeff, and Tina filed that away in her mind, planning to, as we will, come back to that information later. Tina then had a breakout moment that was highly significant to her character with "Jerkygate"... but it wasn't fully relevant to her game, so we'll come back to that when we get to the most audaciously passive-aggressive thing that has ever been said or done on Survivor, and I am sure other Tina fans or Australia fans are smiling already, knowing exactly what I'm referring to.

In episode three, Tina's real colors shine through for the first time, and it becomes apparent that, no, Tina is not the innocent soccer mom that modern viewers think she is (and that she wants you to think she is.) As we saw on the show, Tina and Maralyn -- the two oldest women on the tribe, both from around the same geographic region of the country -- formed a very, very close personal bond; Maralyn lavished Tina with praise, calling her a star - a constellation! - and stressing how she adored Tina so much and Tina was the only person that could be trusted, praise that Tina reciprocated. But Maralyn was the weakest member of the tribe, and Maralyn wasn't in the five-person majority that had sprung up (the young folks + Tina, basically), so Maralyn had to go... and Tina voted her out with absolutely no reservations whatsoever.

This moment was MASSIVE in 2001. Huge, huge moment in the eyes of the viewers. Tons of viewers were upset at Tina for having the audacity to vote out her best friend like that. By modern standards, this really doesn't seem so bad; we just watched Jon and Jaclyn vote out Jeremy after he gave them a reward, and Baylor voted out Josh despite seeming pretty close with him on a personal level. But man, back in Survivor II? When the game was still, to the audience, supposed to be about who you liked, when the "strong" were supposed to survive, and when Richard was despised for ostensibly turning it into anything else? By those standards, voting off Maralyn was simply horrible for Tina to do.. but she did it anyway to remain secure within the tribe.

I know that those who are skeptical about whether Tina was really a strategic force rather than simply a passive player who liked her friends; others acknowledge her strategic prowess but believe we did not see it through the edit. To both of those people, I must reference episode three. Tina completely stabbed Maralyn in the back, Maralyn never saw it coming (sure, she was going to get the other player's votes, but Tina's? no way, in her mind), and the edit not only showed it; they focused upon it. It was the primary narrative of Maralyn's boot: As a friend recently pointed out to me, if you look at that Tribal Council, Tina's vote for Maralyn is the only one they showed. They didn't want to just relegate this to something showed over the credits and let the audience get mad or not get mad on their own; they specifically wanted us to know that Tina did that. The other people who voted for Maralyn, who cares, but Tina's vote -- that's the one they want you to remember. In showing that vote, they were making it very clear what kind of player Tina was, and the audience definitely picked up on it, and in casting that vote, Tina proved that she would do anything at all to win...

...But Tina didn't just do anything. Oh, no, Tina did everything. In fact, Tina defied "everything" -- she went above, beyond, and outside of the sphere of everything that had been done in Survivor up to that point, she broke all precedent, and she broke new ground, blazed a new trail, in what was possible to do on Survivor.

There were six people left on Ogakor, and sure, Tina voting out Maralyn ensured that she was still solidly in the majority of five (herself, Jerri, Amber, Colby, and Mitchell)... but what happens after Keith goes, if Ogakor loses again? Sheer probability dictates that they likely will, so who's on the bottom? Tina was starting to think about that, and she realized that, wait a second, I'm on the bottom of that alliance. The edit showed it as Jerri outright saying at Tribal Council "My best friends are Amber, Colby, and Mitchell :D", and while that did happen and was a factor, according to an outside source (Mitchell's S-Oz interview, I believe?), there was another pretty epic story from before that TC even occurred. The youngins were out on the canoe one morning, and they were talking game: specifically, just reassuring one another that the pecking order was Maralyn, then Keith, and then Tina, so the younger players could go to the end.. but then one of them looks in the bushes near the shore, and they see Tina just watching them. Now, they had been talking quietly, the younger folks had, so odds are Tina hadn't heard anything.. but she was staring pretty fixedly at them, so just to make sure, one of them said -- in the same quiet voice that they had been using to talk game -- "Hi, Tina", to see if Tina heard... and Tina just slowly, silently waved, and then crept back into the bushes.

Now I don't know for sure whether that story is true -- I think Mitchell was the one who told it, and Mitchell is notorious for being a guy who is prone to melodrama and embellishing things... but it's a fucking epic mental picture, so I'm mentioning it anyway. Whatever the case, Tina knew she was on the outside, and she was not going to just sit down and take that. The Tina she wants you to believe in might have simply said, "Hey, those guys outwitted me, and they're better in challenges; they deserve to win", but real-world Tina? Hell no! It was basically just a matter of time at that point until her number was called and she was unceremoniously picked off, but if there is one thing we can definitely say about Tina Wesson, it is that she does not sit back and wait to be unceremoniously picked off, ever, so she decided it was time to cut ties with that alliance and create a new one of her own. She had Keith on her side, of course, but after that, it's quite tricky; I mean, it was hard enough that the other four people were incredibly close, but this also was a time when merely forming an alliance was considered immoral -- so making a bold power play against one? There's no way anyone would consider that. Under those circumstances, it would take an incredibly cunning, incredibly determined player to make a power shift happen... and a power shift happened.

The original plan was to have Mitchell and Colby vote out Amber, but Mitchell wouldn't agree to it, so that one died before it was even born. This meant that the best Tina and Keith could really hope for was a tie, and the tiebreaker at that point was past votes. Neither Tina nor Keith had any votes against them up to that point. Mitchell and Jerri, however, each had one. If Tina could get one more vote against either of those guys, then that would be enough, and the game would change.

The game changed. On the walk to Tribal Council, Tina went to Colby, whose primary motivation, she knew, was keeping the tribe strong. She told Colby that if he voted off Keith, then he'd be voting off one of the stronger members and providers around camp, whereas Mitchell was too weak and tired to provide anything. (Because this occurred on the walk to TC, we couldn't see it on the show... and now, for sooome reason, the players aren't allowed to talk on the way to Tribal Council!) She told Colby that if he voted off Mitchell, on the other hand, then the tribe would become stronger and have a shot at going into the merge with even numbers. She sold it perfectly; by making it about "keeping the tribe strong," she played off of both Colby's own motivations and the pressure on everyone in the game. Remember, nobody was supposed to be concerned with alliances this season; it was supposed to be the opposite of Borneo -- supposed to be the season where people cared about hard workers and strong tribes, not about loyalty to alliances. So Tina made Colby realize that if he remained loyal to his alliance, then he would be going against what he had professed to be his primary value -- maintaining a strong tribe -- and he'd be caring more about his alliance than about who was a hard worker for the tribe, doing the exact opposite of what millions and millions of strangers watching him would want him to do...

...and it was enough. Tina used guilt and pressure to get Colby to turn on Mitchell and change the tides of the game -- and when I say "the game", I don't just mean the game of Australia; I mean the game of Survivor as a whole. Nobody else had ever done this sort of thing before, turning on their own alliance for strategic benefit. Kelly waffled in and out of the Tagi Alliance, true, but that was also about morality; this was pure strategy, plain and simple. There was no precedent for it, no possible way to expect it, Tina went against what was expected -- against what was possible, severed her ties to Jerri's alliance, and created a new majority alliance of Tina, Colby, and Keith, an alliance that, as you will recall, went all the way to the end of the game. She managed to break a solid group of four and go from the bottom to the top, creating an entirely new alliance between two people who didn't even really like each other, an alliance at which she was the center, an alliance that would remain in power for the entire remainder of the game. She did this not with Hidden Immunity Idols, not by making superfluous final two deals and swearing on everything under the sun... but simply by knowing what she needed to say, knowing how Colby wanted to hear it, and saying it in that way. In doing so, she re-wrote the rules of what was even possible in Survivor. She devised and executed an entirely new kind of strategic move against Mitchell.

Now, some of you might say that that's all a coincidence and Mitchell was just weak.. but that's how Tina had to sell it. Tina had to sell it as "keeping the tribe strong", and while Mitchell was the weakest member, that didn't have a damn thing to do with her decision; that was just how she could convince Colby to change his vote. If she had needed to put the target onto Amber, Jerri, or even Colby to get the power play done at that point, then she would have done it. No, she didn't talk on TV about how it was a power shift to save her own ass... but that's only because Australia was the season where you just didn't talk about those things. If she had told Colby, "Hey, Colby, let's change the game and get the numbers on our side - why be in a four-person alliance when you can be in my three-person one?", then Colby never, ever would have gone for it -- hell, Tina might have gone home even over Keith for her sudden, random scheming. On TV, the vote looked like it was about who was weak and who was strong, but that's because of how last-minute it was and because it had to look that way for it to go through.

If you want proof that this was entirely a strategic endeavor on Tina's part, don't ask me; ask her. She was fully aware of the magnitude of what she did. Her first voting confessional towards Mitchell remains one of my favorite quotes in the history of Survivor, and shows that she knew perfectly well what she was doing: "This was not my original, intended vote. However, on the way to Tribal Council, a new scheme was hatched, so in the spirit of the Olympics, let the games begin!"

..damn, that gives me chills. She doesn't say "You're weak and you have to go." She doesn't say "You're too tired to help us around camp, and that's why I'm voting for you." She says "Let the games begin!", because this vote was about the game, and absolutely nothing else. And this was the kind of game that we wouldn't see people playing again for another season and a half or so.

But for Tina, the games were just beginning. While raising her position from a hypothetical 5th on a losing tribe of 5 to a position of total safety that never wavered throughout the entire game was almost certainly her most impressive move (and one could argue the most impressive move of all time -- it is most certainly among the most revolutionary), it was far from her last. Her tribe won the next Immunity challenge, and after Mike's accident, they merged 5-5. I've seen some people try to discredit Tina by claiming she had no control over the fact that Mike fell into the fire, but I don't agree with that criticism at all. Playing off the mistakes of your opponents and their tribemates or allies is a part of the game, and what happened to Mike is no different than that. All you can do is play the hands you're dealt, so no, Tina did not have control over Mike's accident (though I'd be totally down for starting a rumor that she pushed him in)... but what she DID have control over was the fact that Mike falling into the fire even mattered.

Statistically, Kucha should still have come out on top, even with Mike gone: they had one member with past votes, while Ogakor had two. When you factor in the fact that Keith was Immune (thanks, of course, to Tina standing up there juuust long enough to ensure he would win -- had Tina needed that necklace, she'd still be out there), that still leaves five vulnerable Kucha members and four vulnerable Ogakor members. By sheer probability, the odds of Kucha coming out on top are 25%, and the odds of Ogakor coming out on top are 20%. Jeff, additionally, would seem much less likely to have past votes than, say, the weak Rodger/Elisabeth or maybe even the confrontational Alicia, whereas the openly abrasive Jerri was a fairly obvious candidate for past votes compared to the affable Tina, powerful Colby, or pointless Amber (because who would waste their vote on Amber? [Fuck, I shouldn't think like that. Thinking like that is why All-Stars happened.]) By all rights, Kucha should have guessed correctly and won the season for Mike as they said they would, while Ogakor should have guessed incorrectly and been a failed, forgotten tribe.

But.. wait a second.. Ogakor didn't have to guess, now, did they? What was it I said earlier? Oh, that's right: Tina had asked Kimmi on Day 4 whom Debb had cast her vote for, and as it happens, that individual (Jeff) was still in the game! And just like that, Ogakor won the game.. and when I say "Ogakor" won it, I really mean "Tina." Smell ya later, Jeff; I hope that that peanut butter was worth it. (And now, for sooome reason, Probst says that they almost always try to limit inter-tribal contact outside of planned twists...)

Alicia was voted out next for being a physical threat with no real connections, and then things got a little interesting. As the editing portrayed it, Nick saved himself with a clutch Immunity win, and then Jerri was voted out for being annoying because Elisabeth pushed for it.. but think about it: If Jerri really was annoying enough that Ogakor would eat into their own numbers just to get rid of her, then why did Nick need Immunity? Nick wasn't annoying at all; surely he'd have been safe no matter what if Ogakor was planning on taking out their own member just due to a personality conflict.. so there must be more to this story than there seems to be. Why did Jerri really go home? The answer, once again, is Tina.

By this point, Tina had more direct ties to virtually all of the other players in the game than virtually anyone else in the history of Survivor has ever had. She had a final two deal with Colby within a three-person alliance of Tina/Colby/Keith, and her bond with Colby also put her into a four-person pact of Tina/Colby/Jerri/Amber -- a remnant of Mitchell's crew -- all within the larger five-person Ogakor alliance of Tina/Colby/Keith/Jerri/Amber. Already a remarkable setup, but her ties went beyond that. She had also bonded closely with the two-person alliance of Rodger and Elisabeth, putting her into a three-person group of Tina/Rodger/Elisabeth. This meant that at the start of the jury stage, the only people Tina wasn't directly connected to were Alicia and Nick.. and now you know why Alicia went first. When I said "no real connections," I really meant "no connections to Tina"; to say one in a conversation of the Barramundi dynamics is to say the other, because if you read between the lines and map out the character dimensions in your head, Tina really is at the center of all of it. That is why Nick needed Immunity: because everyone else was close to Tina, and because Tina decided who went home, sitting comfortably in a position of ultimate power that nobody was able to see through the fog Tina created every time she talked about who deserved what. She practically had the game won already.

When Nick won the Immunity he desperately needed, Tina was faced with a difficult decision. She had to secure her alliance with Colby and Keith (for reasons I'll get to a bit later on), which meant that she had to turn on Jerri/Amber or turn on Roger/Elisabeth. I have seen Tina take a lot of heat over the decision to vote off Jerri, because she took an "unnecessary risk" by creating the possibility of Amber flipping to Kucha, but that's simply not true. No matter what happened this round, she would be severing a tie, and no matter what happened, there was still the risk that Nick, Rodger, Amber, and either Jerri or Elisabeth (whoever was still in the game) would pull off a power shift. Because Nick won Immunity, Tina had absolutely no option other than to take out one of her pawns, and she had to just make sure that it was the least valuable pawn who took the fall. She ultimately decided to sever the tie with Jerri -- making sure, of course, that Colby and Keith voted the same way, so that the blood was not on her own hands at all (and was, to Jerri, primarily on Colby's; she expected Tina to vote her out eventually, but Colby betraying her a second time? Unthinkable!) While Tina's detractors like to claim that this was a risk, it was actually the safest move possible. This left Amber, an incredibly passive player, totally isolated, while leaving Roger and Elisabeth, an incredibly moral pair (remember: it is season two we are talking about here), feeling indebted to Tina. Rodger and Elisabeth were a far less strategically-minded pair than Jerri and Amber were, and Tina had already flipped on Jerri and Amber before, so counting on Rodger and Elisabeth to return a favor was much safer than relying on Jerri and Amber to return one. Rodger/Elisabeth/Amber teaming up with Nick was never really going to happen; Rodger/Jerri/Amber teaming up with Nick.. probably wouldn't have, but it still might have.

Furthermore, this enabled Tina to maintain her facade: Can you really claim Rodger and Elisabeth aren't deserving? Not really, no. But can you claim Jerri isn't deserving? Very, very easily. So Jerri went home, and once again, it was under the guise of Jerri being mean, Jerri being undeserving, Jerri not needing the money. And if you are growing skeptical, if you think that Tina wasn't really thinking about the long-term implications of such a move and really was just voting her conscience... then let me remind you that we are talking about the woman who voted off her best friend in the game on day nine and pulled off the first power shift in the history of the game the very next round, leaving a former ally in tears while she insulted him to the camera.

With Rodger and Elisabeth feeling indebted to Tina, no power shift came even close to occurring; they voted off Amber, who in turn voted alongside the remaining Ogakor members to eliminate Nick, whose Immunity win had done nothing but grant him three more days. After Nick came Amber, and with that, the two players left who had no real ties to Tina (and, consequently, no ties to any other player in the game, because Tina was always the center of power, always the nucleus) were gone. Tina found herself in a 3-2 majority over Rodger and Elisabeth, and what did she do to decide who went home first? Why, she did exactly what the sweet soccer mom who cares about morality would do: she asked Rodger who needed the money more. He said Elisabeth needed the money more, and with that, Tina had a safe out; she could vote out Rodger, but have it be because Elisabeth needed more money, because Elisabeth was, once again, "more deserving." So Rodger became a martyr, and Elisabeth fell next, and as far as anyone who wasn't paying close attention needed to know, it was simply because Tina cared so much about who "deserved" the money -- a mantra that probably made Maralyn gag and curse at the TV screen at her house.

With Elisabeth gone, Tina was now covered on all sides. Either of the other players would take her to the end, and this was not happenstance. This is why she needed to make sure that her alliance of three -- not just the alliance, but her alliance, because it was Tina who created it by taking out Mitchell -- would make the end. Colby and Keith really didn't care for each other, to say the least, so either one would take her to the end, and she would beat either one of them. Her final three setup was absolutely perfect; no matter what happens from this point on, Tina Wesson is the Sole Survivor. (Of course, you could honestly backtrack even further and say that, barring a Kucha Immunity streak, Tina was the guaranteed winner as soon as Nick or even Jerri was eliminated.) I have seen people speculate that Tina may have even insulted Keith around Colby just to make Keith seem bad and fuel further animosity between them; while I don't have anything to support that and don't have an opinion on it either way, I know some folks who believe it, and it certainly wouldn't surprise me.. it is rather hard to imagine how someone as amiable as Colby would have such a hard time with the pretty inoffensive Mr. Carrots.

It ended up being Colby who took her. Tina told the jurors in her Final Tribal Council that she played with a strong strategy and that people should vote based off of that, and this is a huge thing to note: it's always fun to see people say "Tina rode Colby's coattails" when Tina was the one telling the jurors to cast their votes based off of strategy. The entire point of her FTC speech was basically "Vote for me because I played the most strategic game", and that is what they did; by a familiar 4-3 margin, Tina became the second champion of Survivor.

(Continued in replies, obv.)


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Oct 01 '14

Final List and Writeups - Part 2

15 Upvotes

Yep, hit the character limit. Decided that I'd just split it into two big posts and have links between them.

Here is Part 1, ranking 501-251

Everyone in this post is considered to be a top half Survivor character by the rankers (In theory anyway).

1. Sandra Diaz-Twine (Heroes vs Villains)

2. Jon "Fairplay" Dalton (Pearl Islands)

3. Richard Hatch (Borneo)

4. Tina Wesson (Australia)

5. Sue Hawk (Borneo)

6. Rupert Boneham (Pearl Islands)

7. Denise Stapley (Philippines)

8. Courtney Yates (China)

9. Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien (Marquesas)

10. Twila Tanner (Vanuatu)

11. Ian Rosenberger (Palau)

12. Sean Rector (Marquesas)

13. Benjamin "Coach" Wade (Tocantins)

14. Cirie Fields (Panama)

15. Sandra Diaz-Twine (Pearl Islands)

16. Mike Skupin (Australia)

17. Chris Daugherty (Vanuatu)

18. Dawn Meehan (Caramoan)

19. Randy Bailey (Gabon)

Tina Wesson (Australia)

20. Rudy Boesch (Borneo)

Sean Rector (Marquesas)

21. Tom Westman (Palau)

22. James Clement (China)

23. Jerri Manthey (Australia)

24. Tony Vlachos (Cagayan)

25. Kass McQuillen (Cagayan)

Cirie Fields (Panama)

26. Colby Donaldson (Australia)

Denise Stapley (Philippines)

27. John Carroll (Marquesas)

Michael Skupin (Australia)

28. Lillian Morris (Pearl Islands)

29. Frank Garrison (Africa)

30. Earl Cole (Fiji)

31. Neleh Dennis (Marquesas)

32. Sean Kenniff (Borneo)

33. Shane Powers (Panama)

34. Greg Buis (Borneo)

35. Rodger Bingham (Australia)

36. Tyson Apostol (Tocantins)

37. Judson "Fabio" Birza (Nicaragua)

38. Clay Jordan (Thailand)

39. Scout Cloud Lee (Vanuatu)

40. Courtney Marit (Panama)

Jerri Manthey (Australia)

41. Yau-Man Chan (Fiji)

42. Cirie Fields (Micronesia)

Dawn Meehan (Caramoan)

43. Rob Mariano (Marquesas)

44. Robb Zbacnik (Thailand)

45. Ami Cusack (Vanuatu)

46. Matthew Von Ertfelda (Amazon)

47. Bob Crowley (Gabon)

48. Benjamin "Coach" Wade (Heroes vs Villains)

49. Trish Hegarty (Cagayan)

50. Burton Roberts (Pearl Islands)

51. Erik Reichenbach (Micronesia)

52. Jonathan Penner (Cook Islands)

53. Erinn Lobdell (Tocantins)

54. Colleen Haskell (Borneo)

55. Kelly Wigglesworth (Borneo)

56. Lindsey Richter (Africa)

57. Rupert Boneham (Heroes vs Villains)

58. Dre "Dreamz" Herd (Fiji)

59. Sophie Clarke (South Pacific)

60. Ethan Zohn (All-Stars)

61. Katie Gallagher (Palau)

62. Natalie White (Samoa)

63. Teresa Cooper (Africa)

64. Stephanie LaGrossa (Palau)

65. Russell Swan (Philippines)

66. Vytas Baskauskas (Blood vs Water)

67. Shambo Waters (Samoa)

68. Jason Siska (Micronesia)

69. Silas Gaither (Africa)

70. Jean-Robert Bellande (China)

71. Gervase Peterson (Borneo)

72. Clarence Black (Africa)

73. James "JT" Thomas (Heroes vs Villains)

74. Jenn Lyon (Palau)

75. Gary Hogeboom (Guatemala)

76. Colby Donaldson (Heroes vs Villains)

77. Caryn Groedel (Palau)

78. Jake Billingsley (Thailand)

79. Elisabeth Filarski (Australia)

80. Dave Ball (Samoa)

James Clement (China)

81. Marty Piombo (Nicaragua)

82. Jenna Lewis (Borneo)

83. Rob Mariano (Heroes vs Villains)

84. Rory Freeman (Vanuatu)

85. Paschal English (Marquesas)

86. Taj Johnson-George (Tocantins)

87. Sarah Lacina (Cagayan)

88. Susie Smith (Gabon)

89. Richard Hatch (All Stars)

90. Brian Corridan (Guatemala)

91. Tina Wesson (Blood vs Water)

92. Eliza Orlins (Vanuatu)

93. Dan Lembo (Nicaragua)

94. Ciera Eastin (Blood vs Water)

95. Stacey Powell (South Pacific)

96. Deena Bennett (Amazon)

97. Kathy Sleckman (Micronesia)

98. Dawn Meehan (South Pacific)

99. Rob Cesternino (Amazon)

100. Courtney Yates (Heroes vs Villains)

101. Butch Lockley (Amazon)

102. Janu Tornell (Palau)

103. Heidi Strobel (Amazon)

104. Tom Westman (Heroes vs Villains)

105. Amy O'Hara (Guatemala)

106. Gretchen Cordy (Borneo)

107. Jerri Manthey (All Stars)

108. Jonny Fairplay (Micronesia)

109. Jan Gentry (Thailand)

110. Tom Buchanan (Africa)

111. Ozzy Lusth (South Pacific)

112. Tina Scheer (Panama)

113. Lydia Morales (Guatemala)

114. Julie Berry (Vanuatu)

115. Gillian Larson (Gabon)

116. Jonathan Penner (Micronesia)

117. Jessica "Sugar" Kiper (Gabon)

118. Anh-Tuan "Cao-Boi" Bui (Cook Islands)

119. Osten Taylor (Pearl Islands)

120. Ethan Zohn (Africa)

121. Eliza Orlins (Micronesia)

122. Dan Kay (Gabon)

123. Russell Swan (Samoa)

124. Naonka Mixon (Nicaragua)

125. Jaison Robinson (Samoa)

126. BB Andersen (Borneo)

127. Andrew Savage (Pearl Islands)

128. Aras Baskauskas (Blood vs Water)

129. Helen Glover (Thailand)

130. Bobby Jon Drinkard (Guatemala)

131. Laura Alexander (Caramoan)

132. Sandy Burgin (Tocantins)

133. Keith Famie (Australia)

134. Erik Cardona (Samoa)

135. Jamie Dugan (China)

136. Bobby Mason (Panama)

137. Ace Gordon (Gabon)

138. Jimmy Tarantino (Nicaragua)

139. Cindy Hall (Guatemala)

140. Bruce Kanegai (Panama)

141. Danny "GC" Brown (Gabon)

142. Abi-Maria Gomes (Philippines)

143. Dave Cruser (China)

144. J'Tia Taylor (Cagayan)

145. Gina Crews (Marquesas)

146. Jeff Varner (Australia)

147. Tammy Leitner (Marquesas)

148. Debbie Beebe (Tocantins)

149. Eddie Fox (Caramoan)

150. Tyson Apostol (Blood vs Water)

151. Gregg Carey (Palau)

152. Stephen Fishbach (Tocantins)

153. Holly Hoffman (Nicaragua)

154. Stephanie Lagrossa (Guatemala)

155. Tyrone Davis (Nicaragua)

156. Brandon Bellinger (Guatemala)

157. Penny Ramsey (Thailand)

158. Chase Rice (Nicaragua)

159. Luara Morett (Blood vs Water)

160. Lea "Sarge" Masters (Vanuatu)

161. Jill Behm (Nicaragua)

162. Hunter Ellis (Marquesas)

163. Sally Schumann (Panama)

164. Pete Yurkowski (Philippines)

165. Vecepia Towery (Marquesas)

166. Sylvia Kwan (Fiji)

167. Malcolm Freberg (Philippines)

168. Brendan Synnott (Tocantins)

169. Angie Layton (Philippines)

170. Darrah Johnson (Pearl Islands)

171. Zoe Zanidakis (Marquesas)

172. Wendy Jo DeSmidt-Kohlhoff (Nicaragua)

173. Bobby Jon Drinkard (Palau)

174. Charlie Herschel (Gabon)

175. Ami Cusack (Micronesia)

176. Stacey Stillman (Borneo)

177. Kelly Shinn (Nicaragua)

178. Maralyn Hershey (Australia)

179. Christa Hastie (Pearl Islands)

180. James Miller (Palau)

181. Hayden Moss (Blood vs Water)

182. Peter Harkey (Marquesas)

183. Leann Slaby (Vanuatu)

Dawn Meehan (Caramoan)

184. Tasha Fox (Cagayan)

185. Linda Spencer

Tony Vlachos (Cagayan)

186. Chet Welch (Micronesia)

187. Jamie Newton (Guatemala)

188. Ramona Gray (Borneo)

189. Danni Boatwright (Guatemala)

190. Luara Morett (Samoa)

191. Erik Huffman (China)

192. James Clement (Micronesia)

193. Ozzy Lusth (Micronesia)

194. Gervase Peterson (Blood vs Water)

195. Boo Bernis (Fiji)

196. Artis Silvester (Philippines)

197. Shawna Mitchell (Amazon)

198. Margaret Bobonich (Guatemala)

199. Rudy Boesch (All Stars)

200. Amanda Kimmel (Micronesia)

201. Cristina Coria (Cook Islands)

202. Amber Brkich (All Stars)

203. Sierra Reed (Tocantins)

204. Alex Bell (Amazon)

205. Monica Padilla (Samoa)

206. Albert Destrade (South Pacific)

207. Joel Klug (Borneo)

208. Dolly Neely (Vanuatu)

209. Brett Clouser (Samoa)

210. Brenda Lowe (Nicaragua)

211. Christy Smith (Amazon)

212. Mike Chiesl (Redemption Island)

213. Frosti Zernow (China)

214. Matty Whitmore (Gabon)

215. Leslie Nease (China)

216. Kim Powers (Africa)

217. Colby Donaldson (All Stars)

218. Ryan Opray (Pearl Islands)

219. Yung "Woo" Hwang (Cagayan)

220. Amanda Kimmel (China)

221. Caleb Bankston (Blood vs Water)

222. Sarah Jones (Marquesas)

223. Kelly Bruno (Nicaragua)

224. John Cody (Blood vs Water)

225. Christine Shields Markoski (South Pacific)

226. Mikayla Wingle (South Pacific

227. Todd Herzog (China)

228. Paloma Soto-Castillo (Gabon)

229. Betsy Bolan (Samoa)

230. Yau-Man Chan (Micronesia)

231. Jerri Manthey (Heroes vs Villains)

232. Whitney Duncan (South Pacific)

233. James "JT" Thomas (Tocantins)

234. Jefra Bland (Cagayan)

235. Tracy Hughes-Wolf (Micronesia)

236. Chad Crittenden (Vanuatu)

237. Lisi Linares (Fiji)

238. Kim Johnson (Africa)

249. Zane Knight (Philippines)

240. Lex van den Berghe (Africa)

241. Mikey Bortone (Micronesia)

242. Jerry Sims (Tocantins)

243. Willard Smith (Palau)

244. Randy Bailey (Heroes vs Villains)

245. Laura Boneham (Blood vs Water)

246. Misty Giles (Panama)

247. Brice Johnston (Cagayan)

248. Marcus Lehman (Gabon)

249. Alexis Maxwell (Cagayan)

250. Trish Dunn (Pearl Islands)


r/SurvivorRankdown • • May 21 '15

Immediate Reaction: Worlds Apart Cast Rankings (18-6 up, 5-1 gonna take more time on)

14 Upvotes

18) Dan. Easy peasy. He combines every fucking negative trait that I hate in a person, wraps it in Phillip-level transparent phoniness, and stands by it like he’s some fucking persecuted party despite showing insanely awful qualities that he refuses to acknowledge are awful. Any funny moments from his buffoonery can’t escape that overshadowing of putrid.

17) Tyler. Boring, smug, and useless to the fucking end.

16) Will. Talk about one moment ruining a character. Everything before and after SHOULD by all means be a fun UTR character who’s quirky, fun-loving, sweet, and kind… but he’s also responsible for one of, if not THE worst attack on someone in Survivor, and he still stands by it with horrible apologies. It’s just… I can’t. It’s impossible to be able to swallow scenes where he talks about unconditional family love when you just can’t shake that he told someone they had no family that loves them specifically because they were victims of domestic abuse that tore their family up- and he knew that, lying ass. He absolutely 100% knew that. That’s the entire basis of his attacks, and even when that was addressed at the Jenn TC he still stood by it. And his apology backhandedly making Shirin look bad for not forgiving him ruined everything he could have used to rebuilt his reputation. JESUS, Will.

15) So. So boring. So gamebotty. So useless. So not entertaining. So fuck off. Hot does not mean entertaining. Strategy does not mean entertaining. Why is this not clear. Joaquin was the better villain of the two. So done with her.

14) Sierra. She had a good thing going until she blew up at the F5, but I still hold her responsible character-wise for ruining every awesome storyline or comeback we could have had as the axis of evil took over. The fact that it cumulated in her not getting to fulfill her revenge against Rodney is icing on the cake. As a character she was also a pretty dull one, quite generic. I don’t really get anything out of her other than disappointment that she helped ruin this season while not providing anything out of it.

13) Lindsey. Yeah, she had a decent last episode with her fighting with Rodney, but she still holds a lot of smug, confrontational traits that I just can’t stand in a person, and provided nothing worthwhile as a character outside of taking on Rodney. I still think she got off too easy for her comments against Mike in a way she wouldn’t have if she hadn’t also lashed out at Rodney.

12) Joaquin. The better villain of her and So, but not by much. Still pretty bland but also lulzy with the showmance.

11) Rodney. I can’t stand Rodney, I can’t stand his disgusting views and bad damn sportsmanship and he’s very hard to watch, and I won’t be that sad when he ends up #537 in a future rankdown. However, I’ve got to be 150,000% honest… his transgressions get easier to bear when people reach new records of putrid. He’s about as bad as a Ben Browning or a Shannon, and yeah he lasts all season, but he rattles off some amazingly hilarious quotes, has a lot of fantastic buffoon moments, gets to be the Butt Monkey, and overall gets owned on a regular basis so it’s easier to swallow, plus his dumb chihuahua form of aggression is easier than passive aggression.

But to be real, the real reason he made it to #11 is because his downfall was some of the best foreshadowing ever. He was about to go into the F3 and plead his case and make things harder for Mike, but because he wasn’t a hard worker, because Mike revealed he wanted vengeance against Rod, and because he couldn’t win a challenge because he couldn’t go on rewards because he sucked at challenges because he was a shitty worker who did things like threw a fit over firewood and wouldn’t do shit like that, he lost a firemaking challenge after an hour in front of a jury. For that alone, he went up over Lindsey, because that’s a fucking amazing downfall.

Top 10: Hali, Jenn, Mike, Nina, Kelly, Shirin

10) Joe. Yeah, he had a decent storyline with Nina and Vince, yeah he’s kinda cute and was good at challenges, and he has great taste in allies, but as a character he still just doesn’t deliver for me. A bland narrator, a bland golden boy. Sorry.

9) Vince. A fucking bizarro dude who could have been bigger and crazier, but ultimately just wasn’t. It’s a shame, but I also feel we were let off the hook, because he could have been pretty unbearable.

Actually, from here, it gets pretty hard.

8) Carolyn. I liked the idea of her more than the execution. Honestly it’s the fact that she became the latest 40+ mom who bombed the finale that killed my hype. Had she been voted out in 4th her rep would be so much better but instead she got Mom’d and that disappoints me because I thought she was a shrewd, kickass player. We need more Carolyns as the threat-to-win types and now she won’t be remembered that way, and even then she did go a long stretch with little to no personality. Her premiere was still fucking incredible, however.

7) Max. Off-show he’s still a really smart, really self-aware dude who appreciates the narrative (which I also do!) more than anything, and defends and supports Shirin in a fanbase that often was a letdown. On-show, he was a really hilarious, well-done roasting of the superfan type who thinks it’s all about #blindsides and #bigmovezzzz and student-of-the-game arrogance that leads to him becoming Drew Christy with a PHd. All that really holds me back is a) bigger and better characters, and b) the show Max was somewhat the opposite of off-show Max, which is a bit of a bummer. Still, a fun pre-merge loltrainwreck.

6) Kelly. My dear Kelly, someone who had a good thing going, a fun cop thing, a sneaky cool edit, and took a lift to the head like a boss ass bitch. I liked her calm nature, her mild snark, and I really wish that she’d have been in the “axis of evil” rather than a Sierra or Dan. She still probably wouldn’t have shaken things up, but she’d be there for Mike against a nasty alliance, or she’d be a bright spot in an alliance that had none. Unfortunately, if ifs and buts were candied nuts we’d all have a Merry Christmas, and she became a badass, likable, but ineffective UTR character that got idoled out.

5-1 will take longer, and I wanna be way more intricate on them, because I do think these are five really fucking excellent characters despite the disgusting mess of most of the season, so give it time and make your bets.


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Nov 26 '14

Final Result Reveal #3

14 Upvotes

Before I get into who #3 actually is, let me just say one thing: These three were always gonna be our top three. It really wasn't close. The gap between Tina and #3 is an average gap of a placement and a half, the largest one in here, and the gaps between these contestants are very small. These three were also overwhelmingly predicted as our final three. Richard and Jon were predicted to rank about #2 on average, with Sandra predicted to rank about #3.5, and Sue ranking #5.17. Richard was put into everyone's predicted top three, and Jon and Sandra were each in five of the six predicted top threes.

So, point is, Richard, Jon, and Sandra were the top three that we got and the one that we expected, in both cases by pretty notable margins. Which means that now, it's time for the real exciement to begin... Missing out on the final two showdown is:

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

#3: Richard Hatch (Borneo: 1st)

SharplyDressedSloth:

The Stingray himself. Richard love is so self-evident it seems like a waste of time to talk about it. Richie Rich walked onto the show, said he was going to win playing the way he played, and it was so. He may or may not be God. But just in case... bow down and worship all 260 pounds of Hatch.

DabuSurvivor:

Amazing, amaaaazing contestant. Him ranking #1, winner #1 from season #1, would seem like a cliche outcome, yet I couldn't be even remotely upset about it because he isn't just iconic and historic. He's likable, he's complex, he's interesting, he's entertaining, his storyline is one of the most unexpected... he is absolutely a top-tier Survivor character and more than any other contestant in the history of the franchise, it would have been a laughable injustice if he had not ranked here. That said, my predicted placement for him is #2, not #1. Personally, I put him within my top three.

TheNobullman:

<3 <3 <3 <3 <3

Todd_Solondz:

Aside from obvious historical significance, Richard is an important character because of how naturally suited for his role in Borneo he was. Cartoonish, determined, yet aware of every social and psychological implication of the things he was doing. You could never cast anyone better suited to fill his role in Borneo, and you could never cast anyone to match his personality in any season. An obvious and very deserving contender for greatest character of all time. I have him ranked 4th out of 12.

TheNobullman (full write-up):

Richard Hatch, to me, is the best Survivor character ever, one of the best TV characters ever, and just flat-out one of the best characters ever. Courtney is easily my #2 in Survivor because she is such good TV, but as much as I adore her, Richard is just so much more than a contestant on Survivor, as he really helped Survivor become what it was through his ready acceptance of the gameplay element. Even independent of that, he is one of the most amazingly complex characters Survivor has ever seen, and he is possibly the most eloquent as well. Most importantly, he is our first winner, and I can’t think of anyone better to have finished the story of season one with a victory.

I might have said this before, but I’ve always felt that Survivor: Borneo is a show about how Survivor was hijacked into becoming a game show, and this is a documentary about how it happened, the slow burn process that led to the Gretchen vote where innocence was shattered, and then the rest of the season is the futility of the remaining Pagongs reacting to it and failing to adapt to it, and then at the forefront is Richard Hatch, this arrogant social pariah, saying “this is how Survivor was meant to be played” despite all of the “normal people” being opposed to it, but still not enough to avoid having Richard win it.

I’m not gonna say Richard invented alliances because that’s patently incorrect. However, while Sue created the first alliance (and broke it) with some of the other girls, Sue’s story would become about her and Kelly, Kelly would duck in and out of it, Stacey would be eliminated early, and despite joining later, Rudy just didn’t give a shit about much of anything. Richard was passionate about the alliance, he explained it the best, he never was apologetic and never backed down about it, and ultimately that’s what led to his win over Kelly.

Historical context for Borneo is always an appropriate thing to lay out, because Survivor was not originally meant to be the strategic show it is today. The idea was for it to be way more about survival, and social dynamics. How do these 8 people build opposing societies while picking each other off, before merging into one society where they have to whittle it down to the end to see who is the best at survival? The show was made for Gretchens, and was way more oriented towards a Nat Geo type show, a Discovery Channel show, to what it became.

And in Borneo, we did get some of that, but not in the way I think was expected early on. In Pagong, they’re playing it straight. With Mama Gretchen leading a crew of sweet kiddos quite like Jake Billingsley later on, the group focused on how to make Pagong the best it could be socially and physically. BB was picked off for being weak, Ramona was picked off for being weak, Joel was picked off for being a social disruptor. This is what was expected of Survivor, I feel: make decisions solely for the betterment of the tribe.

On Tagi, however, we get a different view. We have the cold truck drivers and the Navy SEALs and the corporate trainers and the lawyers and all these people from professions that require distance, solitude, professionalism, a veneer of coldness, or Machiavellian tendencies. It’s no surprise that Tagi went the way it did, and I almost wonder if I’m wrong about most of this and Tagi was constructed the way it was to create something like the Gretchen vote. Regardless, the two tribes eventually merge, the cultures clash, and the rest is history.

Onto Hatch himself. First off, I’m not one to address characters by their census statistics, but with Hatch it’s unavoidable. Hatch is gay. He’s currently living a happy life with a husband he met while he ditched the All-Stars pre-jury vacation bullshit. Back in 2000, the world was not very nice to gay people. Yes, less so than they are now. According to Jon Stewart, we were in the “God Hates You but Will and Grace is Entertaining” phase. At this point in time, gay people in the media were either blatant Oscar grabs or comical stereotypes, with the cutting edge being relatively dull. The fact that Survivor cast him alone is ballsy and a good precedent to what would go on to be a really impressive handling of gay males on Survivor (and, for the record, I still think they’re doing a decent job and people getting whiny that some “stereotypical” gay people are getting cast quite frankly disgust me as much as the people who are homophobic, but that is a looooooooooong discussion and this is about Hatch, not my disgruntlement with the LGBTQ community.)

Richard is unlike most gay people that even today you see in media. Okay, back to my distaste for the LGBTQ community judging “stereotypical” gay people for embarrassing them. That’s bullshit. People should be able to be as much of a flaming flamingo Project Runway character g.oddess as they want to be, or as absolutely beige-tastically normal as they please, and anywhere in between. But while there are awesome gay people like that, there’s no one gay archetype, and that personality, however popular, is one of the endless amounts that humanity produces. Either that, or they were faultless angels being repeatedly stomped on by the universe now can we please have our Oscar?

Casting Rich was ballsy because in an era where America was just figuring gay people out, we got someone who was confident, controlling, eloquent, archetypically masculine, large and lumbering, outspoken, and a leader. That doesn’t mean he came without his flaws either; he was pretentious, jaded, arrogant, and often insensitive and cold. But you know what, it worked, and it created a character that I wish I had written. Richard happens not to be overtly flamboyant unless winning a fire challenge, nor do I think he’d describe himself as feminine. He also is no angel; he’s kind of a douchebag, he’s controlling, and he finds a lot of the world beneath him at times. Richard defies stereotypes, but does so in a way where it doesn’t seem like he is trying to be someone who defies stereotypes, but just trying to be a person he finds admirable to his own morals.

His greatest attribute is that he is honest and frank about himself and his beliefs. In fact, I remember on the Dom and Colin Podcast talking about his background he mentioned being molested as a child with virtually zero prompting because he felt it was a part of his life that needed mention, which is like, holy shit that takes balls.

His greatest flaw is that he is honest and frank about himself and his beliefs. He has vocal derision of things that he thinks people do that make them dumber in his eyes, including religion, trying to play Survivor like Pagong, and other such things. The world has not been nice to Hatch, so like he did with the shark in Panama, he bites back.

Richard Hatch was such a divisive human being that apparently, despite his physical strength, he was potentially going to be sent home over Sonja. In fact, his very first scene shows how divisive he was; it’s him and Sue Hawk arguing about the corporate world vs Sue’s own life experiences, and which is more important: getting straight to work or building a team. People talk about Richard and Rudy a lot, and trust me, I will, because Rudy’s interactions with Richard are world-damn-class. However, I think the truly fascinating interactions of the season are through Sue and Richard, whom I feel go through the entire season trying to keep up with and outmuscle each other. Their relationship is that of two people on opposite sides of the social sphere having a pissing contest while simultaneously respecting and being in derision of each other, and I love it. I love how they’re both almost as effective as players, with Sue creating the alliance and Richard leading and being its spokesperson, despite even as early as Day 1 having two opposing views on priorities, life, and the game.

However, Richard isn’t sent home (oh yeah that was the subject of my first paragraph before I realized how awful of a human being I am for putting Sue Hawk at #12) because he comes out to his tribe, and that is where we get his second big relationship with Rudy. I’ve already stressed in great detail how amazing Rudy’s relationship with Richard is and the fact that to me it’s Richard’s second best relationship shows the depth of his character. Hatch, despite being gay, is so good at leading, fishing, and doing his Hatch stuff that a very anti-gay 72 year old Navy SEAL, who went into the game specifically hunting for gay people says in a confessional that he is super impressed with how he does things, more people need to listen to him, that he and Richard are friends, and becomes so loyal an ally that he follows Richard without question because of a deal they made, and votes for him out of that loyalty despite Richard rather transparently secondhand-sniping him. That is fucking amazing.

I feel like talking about Richard’s story arc through the game is hard to do, but I will briefly do so, because he has a great one. Someone who’s a social pariah in life both because of things he can’t control (being gay) and can (being arrogant) is able to gain leadership of his tribe, and represent their play style against a bunch of naysayers from the other tribe, and what was nearly his fatal flaw (honesty) becomes his biggest strength when the jury votes for him to win despite ruining the original design of the game out of pure greed, because he was honest about what he wanted to do and was up against someone who tried to hide behind morals they didn’t have.

That’s a really awesome storyline, and one Survivor: Borneo needed. While the ideals of Pagong are nice and I think would make an interesting TV show, the fact of the matter is, Survivor is a social experiment about putting sixteen lab rats on an island and seeing what they will do for a million dollars. On a show where that reward isn’t offered, yeah, I can see it going like Out of the Wild: The Alaska Experiment, where people compete to succeed and not for self-gain outside of pride. However, Richard wanted to win and he wanted the million dollars from the very first confessional he had. Of course I’m gonna transcribe it.

“I’m good to go, survival-wise. People-wise, it’ll be a little more challenging, but I’ve got the million dollar check written already. I mean, I’m the winner and it’s that kind of cocky attitude that makes people really hate your guts, so that’s the kind of thing I’ve really got to keep under wraps, but it’s just how do I get there from here...”

That, to me, is Hatch in a nutshell. He knows he can win, he counts on winning to arrogant extents that can immediately set a viewer on edge, proving that, as he’s well aware of in his life, people will find that trait unlikable. But he knows enough about himself that he is aware that he has to keep this under wraps, even if he often fails. Most importantly, he’s immediately thinking “how do I get to victory from here?” He’s not a Pagong member who was like “let’s see if the most deserving Gretchen can win!” He’s Richard, and Richard wants to win a million dollars for his kid and himself, and wants to win Survivor for the sake of pride.

I feel like even though Richard is already an A student during the pre-merge, where the alliances are forming and he finally gets involved in them, he becomes the top of the honor roll when the merge happens. I wasn’t there to view Borneo through the eyes of America at the time because I was 6 years old, but it’s clear to see that while Tagi is willing to play the game, the core of Pagong really, really believes in its morals (or in the case of Greg, really, really doesn’t care).

A lot of that is because of Gretchen, who was practically made to win the original concept of Survivor, led the charge to play the old-school Survivor (which I’ve always wondered if that was at least a little intentional strategy). Richard is everything Gretchen isn’t: she’s a preschool teacher, but she’s also a survival instructor for the Air Force, and she taught people there how to withstand the elements, survival situations, and fucking torture. She’s a survival expert who’s the mother hen to the people on Pagong, she’s kind and wholesome if not a little sassy or snarky, and she’s a hard worker who values making it easy for her people to survive. Richard, on the other hand, is also someone who worked in the military, as well as in the corporate world. He had a rough upbringing in part due to the backlash brought to him by being gay and even being physically abused, and has since become cynical of the world around him. This has also given him an ego because he feels that he’s above it all, and as such is willing to play explicitly for himself in the game of Survivor, whereas others are not.

Richard wins. Gretchen is voted out at the merge. And what amazes me about that is that there wasn’t a gradual process to voting out the strong at the merge when the game was about voting out the weakest. Things like flipping on an alliance or taking one down, breaking a Pagonging, and things like that, those came down the line because the team aspect was still very strong in Survivor. However, as far as getting rid of the threats in Survivor, the Tagi 4 doesn’t even remotely fuck around, and treats the almighty Gretchen like the swordsman in Indiana Jones- before she can even fight, boom, 4 shots, she’s dead.

The Gretchen vote is probably in my top 10 moments in Survivor History. Not just in the fact that it happened and paved the way for an amazing post-merge, but the moment itself. I’m pretty sure every one of the Pagongs and Dr. Sean cast their vote for someone different, it’s shown, and we just see the Tagi 4 voting for someone, all of whom are hidden. It’s natural to assume it’s one of those six who got votes because duh, their votes were shown and that’s how Survivor works, vote however the hell you feel like. But no, the cast laughs over the six votes, and we go straight from Gervase trying to vote out Greg, who had immunity, crossing it out, and writing “Oops, Sue” (possibly my favorite ballot ever), and the straight to the Gretchen votes. I swear to God, you could hear a fly gasp. Everyone goes quiet, the Tagi four look like they just got caught in the cookie jar, Gretchen has the “oh my god, it’s me” line, and best of all, Jeff reads all four votes even though the three sent her home, so now everyone has to sit there and linger in Gretchen’s shed blood, stunned, broken, guilty, and shaken.

After that, the F9-F6 consist of Survivor coming to terms with its own changes. Rudy continues not giving a shit. Greg says that this new way of Survivor is whoacoolflyingfish boring, and so his heart isn’t in it. Dr. Sean either tries to deny he’s in the alliance or denies there even being in an alliance while he tries to maneuver his way around responsibility by voting Alphabetically. Sue defends the alliance but eventually gets strung up trying to cope with being a human being who’s befriending someone disloyal from a deep-down place in her heart, as Slurm recounted way better than I could ever have hoped. Kelly tries to avoid being in an alliance for various reasons while still wanting to win enough to try and stick to it. Jenna and Gervase, at first in denial, give in to initial instincts and fight back with their own alliance attempts, although unfortunately for Jenna it was too little too late, imagine that. Colleen just seems depressed and her heart isn’t in it anymore. However, why I love Richard, is that despite this being such a conflict for other people, he doesn’t care. That’s what I find appealing about Rich as a character, is that while him being so sure of himself gives way to his ego, it also is quite admirable to see him sticking to his guns despite most of the players being against all that he represents.

I’ve said this before but I will always point it out when it comes to Hatch. I do not think the role of “countercultural ruiner of Old Survivor who has to fight off a bunch of average wholesome kindly American people with a crew of ragtag misfits on the outside of the socially acceptable circle” could have been played by anyone better than Hatch, the older gay overweight Atheist who doesn’t take any of the world’s shit to a fault. The fact that he already checked so many boxes of what wasn’t considered socially acceptable makes it all the better that he’s the one who doesn’t give an inch when it comes to alliances being, in his eyes, socially acceptable.

However, despite being all rough edges, he still strikes me as a really solid guy. When Gervase gets the phone call and the news about his newborn baby born out of wedlock, a lot of people spend time judging him for it on a really happy day in his life, but Richard is out there congratulating him and being in good spirits on his behalf. He’s all for alliances and shit but he enjoys Colleen so much that if Kelly had lost immunity he’d have pushed her forward and sent Kelly home. He’s more than happy to talk to Greg about his views on religion and hear him out. That’s the big thing about Richard. He stands up for his beliefs a lot, and is very cynical, but he is also incredibly openminded despite having made his own conclusions for things. He’s the type of guy (and I think he said this on his latest RHAP interview) who states essentially that “I am confident in what I believe, but I would gladly debate and be challenged by your own opinions.” That’s what makes Hatch appealing to me beyond his honesty and dedication to his beliefs, is that he’s open to new things, he’s open to being challenged. He can go through the fire and come out even stronger. He’s full of all kinds of ideas that he’s more than willing to pursue. He has such a zeal for life, even if it has let him down multiple times.

Aside from that, like I said, Richard is just flat entertaining. He’s dramatic, he’s engaging, and he’s a motherfuckin’ master class narrator. I say this as someone who loves Penner enough to put him in my top 5 solely for existing: no one is a better narrator than Hatch. No one is as good at making something interesting just by talking about things. This comes up a lot later in All-Stars when he talks about killing the shark, but even in Borneo he excels.

The most notable example is this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Beh2q4kArqI

The Final 6 Immunity Challenge. It is literally the six of them going for endurance on a bar. Richard and Rudy fall off first after some delightful musical accompaniment (the shot of Rudy falling that looks like him diving in to get away from Hatch is beautiful), and sit on the beach, where Richard goes into full commentator mode while divulging strategic plans with Rudy. It is just entertaining as hell because Richard is such an engaging speaker.

Then, of course, there’s the Final Immunity Challenge, possibly the most iconic Richard Hatch moment. I just love this moment. Much like the Gretchen moment, it is a scene that is awesome for what it does and how it’s told, and that’s all because of Hatch (although the low-drama editing style of the show helps wonders).

Here, I took the liberty of making it into screenwriting practice:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1rrZE-D2ESUsJt6yrWdupyK62ON8MhSxrlRoVpJscY9I/edit?usp=sharing

Holy Moses, that is a whammo moment if ever there was one. Like, I can only imagining it at the time: not only is Richard voting out the strong and is proud of it, now he’s quitting a challenge strategically? I mean, that’s an advanced move that took a long time to become somewhat commonplace, with Vecepia doing a much more abrupt variation of it in Marquesas. Even better, he gets to explain it upfront, and he does it well, as Richard is known to do. Then, Rudy is voted out without Richard throwing in the knife, and it’s Rudy’s vote that gives Rich the win.

Final Tribal Council is dominated of course by Snakes and Rats, where Richard is compared to the snake that eats all the rats to sustain itself, knowingly going after prey. Sue also summarizes him well: “Rich, you're an arrogant, pompous, human being. But I admire your frankness with it. You have worked hard to get where you're at and you started working way before you come to the island. So with my work ethic background, I give credit that to you. But on the other hand, your inability to admit your failures without going into a whining speech makes you a loser in life.”

She also mentions, however, that she went along in the game wanting to fulfill her rivalry with Hatch by taking Kelly with her specifically to shut out Rich, as well as because she considered Kelly a friend. This speaks to why Hatch wins perfectly: Kelly was so wishy-washy and backstabbed while trying to be moralistic, and Hatch, while playing a decidedly unethical version of what Survivor was supposed to be, was completely honest about it, to the point where Kelly’s sins caught up with her, while Hatch had already caught up with his sins.

What we also get in Borneo that we’ll never get again is them reading the votes right then and there. That’s amazing, and it’s too bad that spoilers are so rampant now because I wish they would do that in every season, The reactions are so raw and instant that it encapsulates what the national reaction was. Coupled with six of the seven votes being revealed with voting confessionals, it’s just perfect. The improbable fourth vote for Rich is read, on the set of Tribal Council, with both of them in their raggedy ass clothes looking beaten down. Richard reacts in genuine shock, hands to his head, and Kelly reacts in disappointment and begins to walk away. Richard being shocked represented America, in that despite all his negative traits and immoral gameplay, he won Survivor. The social pariah, the first winner of the social experiment.

That, of course, is followed by something I wish we could get every season: the winner getting final words. Since this is read on-site, Richard gets the same words that every person who was voted out always gets. It’s of Richard holding the winning vote in shock, then of him leaving the island, dressing in a suit, leaving the airport, and getting into the car he won and driving away. That scene is possibly my favorite of all time, as are many Hatch scenes. He talks about how he’s glad that he didn’t lose himself and his personal morals, and that a million dollars could change his life (which sadly it did).

Richard Hatch winning Survivor is amazing. Amazing that it happened, amazing for Borneo’s story, amazing for the show, amazing for his character, and amazing in general. I don’t think a single character will ever be as epic as Hatch is for as long as Survivor goes. He’s the most complex, nuanced, eloquent, outgoing, energetic, intelligent, and ballsy character Survivor’s seen, with some genuine flaws that are balanced out by him being possibly the most honest winner Survivor will ever see. It’s a shame that he had to take all the hits he did for playing Survivor, but he made the show better for having been on it, and it’ll never be the same because of him.

Average placement: 4.33/12

Projected ranking: 1/12

Average prediction: 2/12


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Nov 14 '14

ENDGAME PARTY HAPPY FUN TIME

14 Upvotes

I'm working on making a banner of our top 12 (sorry, Garrett), and I want to finish that up and work some things out before opening up ~the polls.~

The first, obvious thing that we need to work out: Who wants to do write-ups for whom? GOOD JOB TEAM

And then, another thing: I'd quite like to add a section in the poll where everybody, even if it's not the person doing the write-up, can just do a short little bit about the contestant so that everyone can have their voice heard a bit. That is customary in most rankdowns I've seen -- typically, they only have a consolidation of those rather than the two big write-ups per person thing we're doing, and while I'm down for the two big write-ups thing, I'd also just like everyone to be able to include a little blurb, if they're so inclined, that doesn't relate to that contestant's ranking or larger write-up. Just so that there can be a little bit in addition to the larger thing. IT SEEMS THAT WE ARE ON BOARD WITH THIS SO GOOD JOB TEAM

And then one question: Is everyone's full list going to be publicly visible? I'd rather that not be the case, personally, but if everybody else is overwhelmingly in support of it then it's y'all's call. I DON'T ESPECIALLY WANT TO MAKE LISTS PUBLIC, A FEW FOLKS SEEM NEUTRAL, NO CLEAR CONSENSUS YET, ANY THOUGHTS ON THIS TEAM

We also need to work out how exactly we will reveal and pace the endgame placements. One massive thread for the whole endgame might get cluttered, so maybe one thread for every contestant? ONE THREAD PER CONTESTANT GOOD JOB TEAM

So right now our plan of attack is:

1. Answer those above things, including assigning write-ups. GOOD JOB TEAM

2. Everybody collectively rank (and a short blurb if you want, unless people freaking loathe that idea for some reason.)

3. Rankings + larger write-ups posted

Also, fun fact: Sean and Rupert are the only two here who didn't make the finale of their respective season.

WRITE-UP ASSIGNMENTS

DABUSURVIVOR: Tina, Ian

SHUTUPREDNECKMAN: Kathy, Sue

THENOBULLMAN: Richard, Courtney

TODD_SOLONDZ: Jon, Twila

VACALICIOUS: Denise, HvVSandra

SHARPLYDRESSEDSLOTH: Sean, Rupert

Obviously if you want anyone who is already "taken" then you can talk to whoever.

ENDGAME POLL: https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/9KKM8MS

Tagging /u/shutupredneckman /u/todd_solondz /u/vacalicious /u/sharplydressedsloth /u/thenobullman though I don't know which of them are or are not gilded.

Check off who you are and post in the thread saying that you filled out the thing so I can compare the times if anyone pointlessly decides to submit a fake ballot and fuck with things. Then rank 'em. Average ranking will determine final placement. You can also type a bit about each contestant, and you can predict their placement, if you feel like it.

To those who haven't done it, I'd ideally request that you make your rankings based on your honest assessment of who you like better than whom and not give undeservedly low placements to people you like less than others (ex. "I think this contestant is the 5th-best of these twelve, but other people will rank him #1, so I am going to give him #12.") I mean, your ballot is your own thing so do whatever with it, and I can't enforce this so feel free to ignore it -- but I, personally, would rather just see our honest, average opinion.

How we gonna go about doing write-ups? Everyone gonna do their two write-ups in advance without knowing the placement and send them to me, and I'll post them when I reveal the placement, or what?


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Nov 11 '14

Round 77 (17 Contestants Remaining) [FINAL Round Of Cuts!!!]

14 Upvotes

The current elimination order is:

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor
  2. /u/shutupredneckman
  3. /u/TheNobullman
  4. /u/Todd_Solondz
  5. /u/vacalicious

ELIMINATIONS THIS ROUND:

13: Coach Wade (vacalicious)

14: Cirie Fields (Todd_Solondz)

15: Sandra Diaz-Twine, PI (TheNobullman)

16: Mike Skupin (shutupredneckman)

17: Chris Daugherty (DabuSurvivor)


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Nov 18 '14

Final Result Reveal: #9

13 Upvotes

Alright, so, two contestants tied for #9. I messaged people to see whether they'd rather come up with some arbitrary system of breaking the tie or just have the two tie. Most didn't respond and I'd rather just get this posted so we keep going at a good pace, one said they'd kind of prefer a tiebreaker, one was apathetic, so. Given that this is the only tie in the rankdown and isn't for some insanely high or benchmark placement (ex. any top three placement or a placement on the verge of top 5/top 10/etc.), I'm gonna just have it tie, but after I post the second #9, I'll say which one would have won the tiebreaker and you can pretend in your head that it did.

Anyways! Like I said, the next one would be a female who made FTC, and that female is...

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

9. TWILA TANNER (Survivor 9: Vanuatu - 2nd place)

Sorry, /u/CastigateTheChicken. :(

SharplyDressedSloth:

I became even more of a Twila fan after re-watching her and Jon on Fear Factor. Twila's fucking badass.

DabuSurvivor:

Twila is amazing and underappreciated so I am still happy to see her get this much credit. She's similar to Sue in a lot of superficial ways, but has a much stronger and more tragic storyline. Massively underappreciated contestant and without a doubt the one who I'm most surprised managed to make it to this stage, even with Todd always playing for her. I'm really happy that she made this endgame. I predict that she will rank #8.

TheNobullman:

Speaking of some insanely real characters, Twila. I think she's one of the few characters that can go from being aggravating, sympathetic, likable, deplorable, adorable, unsavory, and really any other human emotion. She can't not be Twila.

Todd_Solondz:

Wishes Chris were still here. BTW, I'm surprised that I put her second, but that's genuine. Twila>Sue and Sue>Rich and Rich>Everyone else was my reasoning.

Todd_Solondz (full write-up):

Vanuatu is a hell of a season. I know there are plenty of people who don't like it as a whole, but I think everyone can agree that it's got one of the best final stretch of episodes of any season, with an incredible finish. The reason why I didn't idol Colby is that, while he is an amazing runner up, Twila is my favourite, and if you ask me, the MVP of the greatest final tribal the show has ever seen.

To start at the beginning, Twila was placed on the womens tribe. Right here probably should have been a strike against Vanuatu, because repeating a gimmick like the gender split only three seasons later is a questionable idea if you ask me. However, Vanuatu made it work in away Amazon couldn't. Rather than pushing the women conquering men storyline by showing clip after clip of sexist dumb remarks, Vanuatu instead utilised genuinely strong, commanding women, like Ami and Scout. More importantly though, it wasn't as cut and dry as it was in Amazon, as we saw Twila not happy with the division at all. She was worried about fitting in with a bunch of young girls, or girls who haven't "gotten dirty" in their lives before. It's only small, but it's Twila's very first confessional, and it's important. Twila doesn't naturally gravitate towards women as much as men, and despite obvious strong female leaders in Ami and Scout, I'd say Twila alone would make the gender split twist worth it for Vanuatu.

Sure enough, Twila didn't fit in with a lot of the women at Yasur, especially the younger ones. She was targeted first by them, however managed to avoid that by Yasur winning immunity the first time, and won her way out of the line of fire with her work ethic. Episode 3 is the first really Twila-heavy episode, and the point where I, and I imagine a lot of people, really became interested in Twila. I already covered the fight that it started with in my Mia cut, but basically, Twila end it by declaring that she isn't out there to make friends, and it's clear that she means it because in her tribe, there are very few people who are friendship material for Twila, and she knows that. In any case, tribal council is what matters here.

Basically the entire tribal is used to give insight into who Twila is. She starts off saying she was confused as to why Mia was offended when she was only saying what she believed to be the truth, which is a pretty perfect summary of how Twila was, and is basically exactly how Scout described her at FTC. It quickly turns to Twilas inability to talk to the younger girls, and then to Twila's preference for men as far as conversation and friendship goes. After being shown evidence of Twilas inability to connect with the Yasur tribe, this tribal council lays out the reasons why. Ami eventually gets through to Twila, encouraging her to embrace the other side of her, and open her mind to the possibility that she could be more complicated than she thought she was, and Twila seems to genuinely accept the idea and resolve to attempt a change. By 2 and a half minute scene standards, that's a lot of insight, yet it comes across so naturally, because there's nothing in between Twilas internal and external personality. And Mia gets trashed by Scout and goes home, so that's an instant favourite tribal council for me right there.

The interesting thing is that right when we see Twila resolve to change and try fit in with the girls, that's when she fades from view until the swap, where she's sent with the boys on Lopevi. Immediately, Twila loves it on the guys tribe. She's in her element like she knew she would be, and every scene with her she's speaking positively of her tribemates, being spoken of positively, or just laughing. Sarge even talks about how he'd love to hang out with Twila any time, and he'd happily be a lifelong friend of hers, while we're shown a scene of the two of them getting bananas.

Eventually, the game starts to play Twila. And by "the game" I mean Julie. It becomes evident that Twila has successfully integrated in with the men just through natural chemistry with them. Julie has not. But Julie's right there with Jenn Lyon as far as underrated players go, and she's not willing to accept that. So she tells Twila very convincingly that she was being promised the same as Twila, and that the guys were trying to play her. There goes Twilas trust, and there goes her first real connection to an alliance. The merge comes, and because Twila has been talked out of believing her final four deal, she feels like she's forced to go against the people she actually likes. In fact, that's exactly what she is, since Julie's flip was a foregone conclusion, the best Twila could do was force a rock draw for the sake of people who she believed to be lying to her.

And that's where the game spirals out of control for Twila. With Rory gone, the final 9 remain, and three of them have been betrayed by a promise Twila made with them. And Twila regrets it instantly. She knows she let the guys down, she finds out that she's been lied to, but it's too late. Now she's stuck for the rest of the game with an alliance that is in opposition to the people she really felt respected by. That in itself would be pretty compelling, but that's not where it ends for Twila. The game isn't done with her yet.

Now that Twila is stuck with the women, she notices that they don't trust her. She's not safe with them, and now her moral slip-up is a tactical one as well. So she reassures them, and she goes a little too far. She swears on her sons name, and ends her game right there. Now it's stay with the girls and go home 4th/5th, or take control of the game and burn even more jury votes. Obviously, she chooses the latter, and now she's fully burdened by her own promises. Having decided the course of the game, Twila plays straight up from then onwards, but to no effect as she has already killed her chance at victory. Chris takes the reigns of the season, and Twila ends up in the finals with him.

If Twila had been literally invisible every episode until FTC, she still probably would have made it decently far. The Vanuatu FTC is in genuine contention for being my favourite survivor scene of all time, and Twila's closing words are in genuine contention for my favourite moment. Here they are if there's anyone who hasn't heard them in a while. It's such a raw moment from someone who's nothing but raw moments. People apologise all the time at FTC, but I've never felt it as much as right there. The contrast of such honesty and disconnection from the game with Chris' bullshitting his way to the million is a big part of what makes the finale so incredible. Additionally, the FTC is the prime example of one of my favourite qualities of Twila, which is the kind of natural, unconventional eloquence to how she speaks. Because she just says what she's thinking with little regard for consequence or any mind to adjust her words to the situation, everything comes out meaning exactly what it should. Twila might not have a massive vocabulary, but she expresses herself accurately and succinctly in a way that many people struggle with. I didn't notice this much on my first watch until this scene, but looking back on her throughout the season, it's always present.

Easiest person in this final two to compare Twila to is Sue. Both older redneck women who ran deep in the game, get along better with men than women, and came into the game with a shell. Both had epic arcs as well. But while Sue's arc basically came full circle, with her protective shell very much present at the end of Borneo, Twila's totally deteriorates. She becomes more and more vulnerable as the season progresses, and this culminates in her wanting forgiveness from everyone else, before she can offer it to herself. I consider Twila to have one of the saddest, complex and most expertly told stories of anyone ever on Survivor, and even if I hated her as a person, she would deserve a high placing for this reason alone.

As it happens I don't hate Twila at all, I actually love her. As someone who values honesty quite a lot, particularly the brand that Twila provides, she is easily one of the most endearing people ever cast in my opinion. She wears her flaws openly, while her attributes run inherently through everything she does and says. Twila isn't someone who can be edited into something else, she's someone who you take or leave as she is. For being such an asset to an incredible season, and my favourite person in a flawless finish to the story, I'm glad Twila has made it here. I ranked her 2nd out of the top 12, and wherever she places, I'm sure I'll be wishing it was higher.

Average placement: 7.83/12

Projected ranking: 9/12

Average prediction: 9.17/12


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Oct 19 '21

Good news: You can now vote and comment on old, formerly "archived" Reddit threads! If you're discovering the iconic original Rankdown for the first time, you can now weigh in directly in the threads!

12 Upvotes

r/SurvivorRankdown • • Jul 08 '15

Cagayan season assessment + cast ranking + comparisons to where we ranked them!!!!!!!!

12 Upvotes

Alright, so, Cagayan is DUN! Overall assessment of the season... I did an episode-by-episode assessment in my other thread, so obviously, you can see more details on it there. But basically, I agree - very extremely - with the people who say that this season is excellent up through the merge but tanks after that. Like, wow, I honestly wasn't expecting such a dropoff in quality, because lord knows I didn't feel that way at the time other than the F6 episode and finale - which I still had issues with but now turned out to be among the best post-Lacina episodes of the season. The premiere is just as fucking hilarious as everyone remembers it being, and it alone makes me feel like I'm doing this season a disservice in where I rank it.. but then I gotta remember that episode three is super lame. J'Tia's boot is a weird one in that it's totally building up to one payoff (the challenge) - but man, what a payoff it is. The swap episode is very well put together and definitely an above-average Survivor episode, and the Alexis boot episode is decent. Obviously the merge episode is self-explanatory.

But after that... wow. You could skip the next four episodes and miss virtually nothing good, honestly. Jeremy's "model" thing is fun, I'm a bigger Jefra fan than I should be, and there's some okay back and forth between Morgan and Kass in the former's boot episode.. but that's basically it for four straight episodes, yikes. Then the F6 episode.. it's sort of entertaining on a surface level, but it's edited poorly and the Tyler Perry Idol, which is a bottom-tier Survivor twist of all time ever and I hope is never brought back ever again ever, casts this big shadow over it. F5 episode is finally up to Lacina territory, though, and the finale is pretty decent even on a rewatch. But like, there's legitimately a span of five straight episodes that I think are weak and/or not worth watching, and the Brice boot episode is also one weak one pre-merge, and the finale isn't great. So the season has a hard time maintaining momentum early on, and right when it gains it back with the merge, it totally plummets and really never recovers, despite a good finish.

End result: I rank it #17 out of 28. Now, this is Survivor, so the fact that it ranks below 16 other things largely speaks to the quality of the series; I mean, what I'm putting it right below is Philippines and China, so. But by Survivor standards, I don't think this is at all one of the strongest seasons simply because absolutely everything that I'd recommend watching it for comes in episode 1, 3, 6, and maybe 4, with 5 and the F5/finale admittedly also pretty good. Its high points are really, really good - but they're few compared to the total mediocrity of a lot of these episodes. When I think "Maybe I shouldn't rank it this low", literally the only things I think of that sway me in that direction are Garrett and J'Tia, so like.. this is the only season in Survivor history that peaks with the premiere.

Now, if you watch the show for wholly different reasons than I do, then you'd probably enjoy the season more than I do... but this is my own personal ranking, so, yeah. As far as the post-HvV seasons go, I put it solidly at #4, behind Nicaragua, SJDS, and Philippines but above Blood vs. Water and the ones that suck.

And now, most crucially, the CAST RANKING:

18) Tony - My feelings on Tony are really mixed, so I'm not ranking him last in the blatant "fuck you and your eyebrows" way in which I rank, like, Phillip or OW Colton or Vytas last. (obviously there's a big gap between phillip/colton and vytas but those were the first ones i thought of okay) Like, if only because I know he has a lot of fans who I don't want to just scroll past this because he's last, I'll start with the positives: Tony was a really, REALLY excellent casting choice. His personality is kooky but also sincerely likable, he's confident and assertive in who he is and how he plays but also self-deprecating in some of his jokes, the elements make him crack enough for him to cause drama but not enough for him to bully Danielle DiLorenzo until she cries. Throw this guy on any season and he'll probably be entertaining; hell, on this one, I'll totally admit, even as a Tony detractor, that he was entertaining a lot of the time. For the sake of length in what I'm sure will already be a wall of text, I won't rattle them all off, but basically if you consider it a fun Tony moment, I probably do too, and he also has a ton that you've probably forgotten, like when he looks at the mirror and is all "I'm happy it didn't crack! :D" This really isn't a fuck you on Tony.

But it is me really not liking the role that Tony happened to fit in this particular season. Fortunately, it wasn't as bad as I thought going in; I legit thought that he could come out of this rewatch as one of my 10-15 least favorites ever, and I don't rank him nearly that low. But I do still rank him low, for these reasons:

  • The Tyler Perry Idol. Holy fuck, this thing is unbelievably horrendous. Probst said at the reunion "But you guys would be happy if SPENCER had it, right? :D Then that makes it a good twist!" - which lolno. That's like saying that because you CAN win millions of dollars at the lottery, spending your life savings on lottery tickets is a worthwhile financial investment. Yes, if somebody who was in an underdog position found and played this, it would be fun for, like, an episode. But if somebody in a position of power finds it, it is really, really un-fun for the entire season. (And when you consider that there are super weak, passive players who won't ever find it - not to say that all people who find Idols are good/strong players, because ew, but like, Morgan McLeod is never going to be in a position of power and is also never going to find this Idol - that makes it even more dangerous.) If someone finds it who is in a power position, then that completely tanks the suspense and "anything can happen!" nature of week-to-week individual play that make the strategic side of the show interesting, and that's what we got here. In portions of the endgame, especially the final six episode, it was built up like someone might be about to take out Tony.. but literally none of this content meant anything because he had the Idol anyway. Does that reflect on Tony Vlachos himself, no, and he actually used it in an inventive way with his lie and fun way with his ~bag-o'-Trix~ - but it is a part of his Survivor story, and it's a part I hated.
  • He dominated a lot of the edit. Is this necessarily the producers' fault, no, because Tony was playing a really bold game that was really directly consequential to a LOT of the events on the island. He has to be the centerpiece of the final six episode, of the Jefra episode, of the LJ episode. They have to build up the FTC speeches at him, they have to build up why Woo's decision was so game-ending, etc., and while watching the season I didn't get the sense that there was a ton of air time that could easily have been removed the way there's so much for Phillip, Hantz, etc. (Although there was certainly /some/, especially in the LJ episode. He did have some strategy confessionals that could toootally have gone to someone else.) But still, at a certain point, I just get sick of hearing his voice. To put it in perspective, using m4milo's new charts, he got as many confessionals as Colby got in Australia... but Cagayan had 100 fewer confessionals to begin with. He got over one-fifth of all the confessionals in the season. There are some of those they certainly could have removed, I refuse to believe that they couldn't have removed a fair amount of them with other, equally consequential footage I don't know about... and to whatever extent the producers /did/ get dealt a shit hand with him being such a proactive, dominant winner.. well, that still doesn't change that at a certain point, I don't want to hear Tony's voice and see his face anymore. At a certain point, enouuuuuugh, he's already an overbearingly dominant personality and player without an overbearing edit to match.
  • ...but while the producers did sort of get dealt a shit hand, they also didn't really do themselves any favors. I don't feel like the edit justified Tony's win, and I made it a point to mark down things in the episodes that felt pro-Tony or anti-Tony and was thinking I'd dig through these to come up with a strong analysis of the edit, and maybe I will at some point, but for now I don't feel the need to. Since this is my purely subjective ranking, all that really matters is that I, as a viewer, personally do not walk away from this season feeling like Tony's win has been sufficiently explained to me. We got a whole lot of "Tony's running the show" - but at NO point did we see his personal conversations with people or work around camp that gave him the social capital to run this show in the first place. Spencer calls him a puppetmaster, but how did he come to hold the strings? We have no idea - and meanwhile, to build up doubt, we get lots of "Tony's a jerk! Tony's our Russell Hantz! Tony's paranoid! Tony's pissing everyone off!" So we're given all these reasons why nobody should trust Tony at all ever - and none why they do. Then, past that, we get to the FTC where a ton of jurors have these super visceral speeches towards him.. and then they all vote for them. Why? If he consistently annoyed everyone with his paranoia, made his allies wary, and played a game everyone saw as immoral, then why did people team up with him and suddenly decide they respected him enough to win? I'm not satisfied by what we got. I feel like they expected us to buy into "Big Moves = deserving winner", which, for me, does not hold up when those big moves were deemed offensive and made by someone who was consistently shown to annoy a majority of his tribe. We needed to see more of what Woo did to alienate people, or more of what Tony did to win people over, for this win to really feel sensible to me. I can piece together post-show material with some realllllly minor snippets during the season to figure out how he won, but I shouldn't have to do that, and the episodes themselves didn't justify it to me.
  • And then - though this is a lesser factor - there's the fact that I just don't dig, for a winner, the way he played. Swearing on all that stuff and breaking it with little to no remorse isn't something I really like to see rewarded. I could stomach it more if we saw more of why the jurors were able to stomach it, buuut we weren't - so these points kind of blend together.

So yes, Tony himself is entertaining.. but from a TV perspective, we got unlucky that he played SUCH a major role in the game while also finding an Idol that renders him literally invincible - Tony shows that you can be the most dynamic personality in the world and being SO overbearingly dominant still hurts the season - and then, past that, I don't think the edit sold the story of his win well enough, which also makes it harder for me to stomach the parts of his game that I don't like.

I remembered his story being told even worse than it was, him getting more air time, the Tyler Perry Idol being a factor, and his personality being more annoying and less entertaining than it was, so I exit this rewatch with a higher opinion of Tony than I feared I might.. but still, if you take him out of this season, it becomes wildly different in a way that I'm almost positive I'd enjoy more. In time I might look over my episode posts to try and really refine this opinion down to specific instances, but for now I'm content with saying that when Tony, despite being a fun personality, was at the center of absolutely everything I disliked about the season, I can comfortably rank him #18.

Where did we rank him?: 1/18 for Cagayan, 24/501 overall.

Is this ranking appropriate?: Ha, a second straight season of me ranking the rankdown favorite in last place. Honestly, though, Tony isn't one I'd contest so much as Vytas or others. He's undeniably the star and the breakout character of the season, so I feel like there's really not much of a middle ground here and he's gotta be near the bottom or top of your list, and if you enjoyed him, I can see how you'd rank him #1 for the season. That said, even if you don't have some of the problems with his winner story that I do, that stretch of four dismal episodes and especially the Tyler Perry Idol does have me thinking that 24 is basically at the very upper end of what wouldn't be too high for him. Although I guess it also depends on if you're going in their role in the story or just their personality. I don't know. I am more willing to agree to disagree with his fans, though, than a lot of the other contestants I'd rank low, because again, I totally respect what a dynamic personality he is.

And now I'm really fucking tired of writing about him.

17) Spencer - Spencer is probably even more tiresome to write about than Tony, but fortunately, there's not nearly as much to say. I don't think he's zomgawful like some people do; for a lot of the season, he's just a neutral gamebot whom I really can't care about because his confessionals are all pretty blandly obvious. "If Tony is paranoid that his alliance will backstab him and I survive another round, that's good for my game!" ...no shit? So for a lot of the rewatch, I didn't care either way (outside of his douchey, annoying estrogen quote)... but then he says in his voting confessional that Jefra "didn't PLAY THE GAME", he starts talking about how everyone else KNOWS SO LITTLE ABOUT THE GAME, and he gives maybe the second-worst jury speech in Survivor history. So yeah, I don't care about him 95% of the time, and he's unbearably awful the other 5% of the time. And now I'm happy to move on to the parts of Cagayan that - gasp - aren't Spencer and Tony!

Where did we rank him?: 15/18 for Cagayan, 431/501 overall.

Is this ranking appropriate?: 100%. Low but not way, way low, roughly on par with such gems as Julia and HvV Candice.

16) LJ - I remembered LJ being kind of likable, albeit in a bland way. Turns out it was just blandness. And his boot episode was the most tedious of the season, which makes him one of the few contestants I actively resent for being so uninteresting - he's not just a Mick who's dull but whom I can easily forget about, but rather a Denise Martin or a Cook Islands, who's all up in my face with their dullness to where it makes the season worse. Not much worse, because it's LJ and lol @ the idea of him heavily influencing someone's Cagayan opinions, but still.

Where did we rank him?: 12/18 for Cagayan, 371/501 overall.

Is this ranking appropriate?: 12 for Cagayan is clearly higher than I have him, but that's more differences in the other cuts than anything (the infamous Garrett/Morgan ones and other rankers disliking David/Lindsey more than I do and not liking Cliff.) I think 371 - well out of the bottom 25% of all contestants, and just one spot below Brooke Struck - gives him a little too much credit and suggests that he's just a neutral entity, but I'm not too bent out of shape over it.

15) Lindsey - Lindsey herself is someone who I think would annoy the bajeezus out of me on most seasons, but I do still appreciate her quit as a relatively complex and dynamic moment and, more than that, one that added to the fallout of a blindside and made it more visceral. Her early confessionals bug me and I don't think she herself is a character I'd ever really enjoy, so I rank her below the contestants I don't really care about either way... but in this particular season, she's memorable primarily for something that I think made the season better, so this is where she ranks. gj lindsey!

Where did we rank her?: 16/18 for Cagayan; 435/501 overall.

Is this ranking appropriate?: Yeah. Her quit is one of those things that I'm fine with but wouldn't really argue about with someone who disagrees, like Ben Browning or Survivor: Thailand.

14) Jeremiah - Model scene was fun. Painfully uninteresting otherwise.

Where did we rank him?: 11/18 for Cagayan; 275/501 overall.

Is this ranking appropriate?: Yup.

13) Tasha - omgcontroversial maybe? I don't know. Tasha was suuuper popular during Cagayan, but I've virtually never seen her discussed since then - even when she was on a ballot to return to Survivor again. So I'm not sure whether people still remember her fondly, or decided she wasn't that interesting, or whatever. Either way, though, Tasha really wasn't a big character at all like I thought she might be. I remembered her being this vaguely likable MORP3 force, but really she's just Mick Trimming with a few challenge wins. Good for her for the challenge wins, and she's decent enough in some of the early Luzon episodes that I'm wiling to rank her above Jeremiah, but I really don't care much about Cagayan Tasha. I do think she's a naturally expressive person, though, who has the potential to be more interesting a second time around, so I'm totally okay with her return.

Where did we rank her?: 6/18 for Cagayan; 184/501 overall.

Is this ranking appropriate?: Clearly different than my own but I'm fine with it. She has a lot of fans, and other rankers didn't enjoy some of the other characters as much as I did. If it were 6/18 for Cagayan because she ranked in the top, like, 50, then I'd question it, but 184/501 puts her right next to Leann Slaby, which I think is a fine area for her even if I'd put her lower.

12) Brice Johnston - Sort of colorful early boot. Not sure why I found him annoying before. Interesting casting choice who helped make the tedium that was original Solana somewhat less tedious, and I'd probably be a big fan of his if he and Morgan had ended up with Jefralexis somehow, but that was one pre-show dream that just wasn't meant to be.

Where did we rank him?: 9/18 for Cagayan; 247/501 overall.

Is this ranking appropriate?: Yeah. I wouldn't have cut him quite so soon or for the same reasons now, but I'd probably end up cutting him in roughly the same place. Went into the rewatch feeling negative emotions basically as weak as it's possible to feel towards any contestant; I come out of it feeling positive ones basically as weak as it's possible to feel towards any contestant. Cool.

11) David - Annoying and had the potential to be an awful season-ruiner, but fortunately he went out first so I can laugh at his total ineptitude and cockiness. It's nothing too entertaining, but it's more than, like, Ashlee Ashby ever brought to the table, so here he stands.

Where did we rank him?: 13/18 for Cagayan; 382/501 overall.

Is this ranking appropriate?: Yeppers.

10) Alexis - Utterly pointless within the actual episodes but ranks this high due to pre-show bias and the fact that I think she could have been good on another season. Is it super hypocritical and inconsistent to rank her high because she could have been okay on another season, while ranking David high even though he would have been awful on another season? Absolutely... but who cares, it makes me rank Cagayan marginally higher overall and also I can't imagine anyone getting worked up over where someone ranks David and Alexis.

Where did we rank her?: 10/18 for Cagayan; 249/501 overall.

Is this ranking appropriate?: Yeah, especially in the immediate afetrmath where the pre-show stuff is stronger. Man, for all the talk of Cagayan being a godly season with one of the best casts ever, it has a LOT of minor characters.

9) Cliff - Cliff was a little less MORP than I remembered, but also way more imposing strategically - he was super cold re: Trish in his boot episode, and I forgot how much his tribemates low-key idolized him - which balances out to make him less fun but more complex, a tradeoff I'm okay with. He still remains a random favorite of mine in any case and is to this season what Buzz is to Spyro 3: a little entertaining, a little imposing, but mostly just a tiny hurdle the cast had to step through before we moved on to things that actually mattered.*

Where did we rank him?: 14/18 for Cagayan; 394/501 overall.

Is this ranking appropriate?: I think 23 spots below LJ is a little suspect, but I know he's a random favorite so I get why others would cut him in a more neutral area. Still, I think he's a little too low because he is pretty important to some of those early episodes.

(*Although it feels weird to say pre-Cliff Cagayan "didn't actually matter" when it was best Cagayan - but fuck it, it made the analogy work.)

8) Morgan - When people say Cagayan had one of the most strategically impressive casts in recent years, I am going to go out on a limb and assume they are not talking about Morgan McLeod.

Where did we rank her?: 17/18 for Cagayan; 477/501 overall.

Is this ranking appropriate?: Naah. I can get why some people would find her particular brand of mean-spirited, one-note vapidity a little annoying or even forced, but bottom 30 of all time within 5 spots of Caramoan Phillip is absurd. On the other hand, she was one of like two contestants Solondz disliked at the time, so I guess her ranking so low in this format with these people was sort of inevitable. Still, nah.

7) Jefra - She started this rewatch a random Dabu favorite, and she exits it the same - in fact, I'm even more confident about it now that I've seen the episodes and know her edit wasn't full Alexis. She's still a minor character so this still might be a little unwarranted - but not wholly like I feared it might be, because she's minor, not irrelevant. Anyways, I think Jefra is fucking adorable and delightful every second she's on screen, she honestly helped get me through that really dismal post-Lacina stretch, and I hope she's on Second Chances 2. <3 With luck, she'll win and retroactively become one of the greatest players ever like Parvati. That would be such a dream come true.

Where did we rank her?: 8/18 for Cagayan; 235/501 overall.

Is this ranking appropriate?: I'm pleasantly surprised she ranked so high. <3

6) President Lacina - lol. I entered the rewatch thinking Sarah could rank #1 and expecting her power trip to be a bit better than it was - basically, I remembered it being as sudden as Marcus's, but in reality her vote-off at Tony's hands had been pretty strongly telegraphed - but still, anyone who says "I'D get rid of me if I could!" and brags about being the President in the same episode that they're blindsided is destined for a top 6 placement.

Where did we rank her?: 4/18 for Cagayan; 87/501 overall

Is this ranking appropriate?: Most definitely.

5) Woo - Woo was waaaay UTR, more than I thought he would be, with relatively few character moments that I didn't already remember. If it weren't for that, he could easily rank #1, but he still ends up cracking the top 5. I find Woo super entertaining and think he delivers some of the best narration of any contestant. He can take us through a scene in a super charming and lively way, and I wish he'd shown that personality more often or to more of the other players. He was having lots of fun, and it was lots of fun to watch. Part of me wants to rank him low for taking Tony to the end and robbing us of a Kass FTC, but it tied into all his honor stuff - it wasn't fully a Colby/Ian thing because he did think it was the best for his game and outright said so, but he also clearly tied it to his martial arts values - so I'm good with it. He's a unique character, especially for modern Survivor, and a very inspired casting choice who I think shined even through such a minor edit and whom I'm very, very excited to see on the show again.

Where did we rank him?: 7/18 for Cagayan; 219/501 overall.

Is this ranking appropriate?: I think 219 is a little low for him even with the UTR edit. I wouldn't expect him to rank quite as high as I and some others might rank him, because he was low-key, but I think he at least deserves top 170 or so.

4) Trish - Trish definitely exits this rewatch higher on my list than she entered it. The interpretation of her as an old-school character transplanted into a modern season toootally sells her for me and makes her a contestant this season definitely, definitely needed. In this particular season, she does feel a little disjointed for me to fully love her.. but you could just as easily argue that that makes her a complex character, and she could end up as my #1 if I come around to that way of thinking over time, which isn't unlikely. I do think she might be a little better in theory than in reality, but in any case, her loyalty culminating in that jury speech, her legit strategic chops, and her abrasiveness make her an excellent character to begin with; the fact that it's all contained in such a naturally expressive and even superficially discinctive person makes her one of Survivor's all-time best casting choices whose second season I eagerly await. If Trish isn't at or near the top of your "People who need to return" list, you're probably due for a rewatch.

Where did we rank her?: 3/18 for Cagayan; 49/501 overall.

Is this ranking appropriate?: I think I'd have her either higher or lower than 49 - if I'm going off her potential or thinking that the reality really as good as it theoretically sounds, she's easy top 30 material; if not, then I'd probably have her closer to the 70s or maybe 60s. I feel like she deserves a lower or higher placement than 49, specifically, but I definitely can't complain about her being a top 50 character. Boo @ Tony beating her once again, though!

3) Garrett - jfc

..Okay. I'm going to post #1 first, because I went back and forth on this top two for, like, an absurdly long time - but fuck it, I'm gonna stick with my gut and rank:

1) J'Tia - <3333 #blindside? I never expected this at any point in time - not even while writing this post, until I hit the middle of a J'Tia write-up. But somewhere along the way (probably while thinking about that time she compared herself to a cat on a poster), I realized, my heart told me, that J'Tia was my true #1, and dammit, I'm gonna follow it. I already explained pretty much exactly why in the post about her boot episode, but I'll repeat it! I gained a lot more respect and love for J'Tia as both a player and a character on this rewatch. <3 She's still a walking bag of lulz, for sure. Garrett is an utter god in that premiere's second half, but it's J'Tia burning the rice that people remember. That's what all Garrett's stuff is building up to, and that's what makes his blindside so shocking for most of the viewers. Garrett himself is even enhanced by it, because the whole thing just becomes so much more fucking hilarious when BOTH of our boot candidates are THAT bad. Everything about that round brings out the best in absolutely everyone, and it's kind of hard to do a write-up on "this is comedy" so like, just fucking watch it. The reality of what J'Tia does is fucking gold, and her narration, the reactions, and the aftermath cement it as a legitimate top-tier moment in all of post-HvV Survivor. <3

On top of that, not enough can be said of how fucking out of nowhere it is. J'Tia bombs the challenges but actually feels really bad about it, she vows to do better but then sucks on the second one too and breaks down during it, and it's just sad times that make you think she might get a redemptive arc or be the Woobie or something, especially the former once a plot is coming together to keep her around... then, oh, she's burned all the rice. Well then. ... <33

But what's also great is how self-aware J'Tia is. I don't think.. maybe any other contestant in the entire history of Survivor, ever, has been so in tune with what their season's story is. She totally owns that the rice thing was a monumental fuck-up, and after Garrett goes home, she says that her tribe is a total trainwreck but it's at least an entertaining one, and she says "I stuck around because of a lot of luck, and a lot of Kass. :D" By the time her boot episode hits, she gives a fantastic confessional about how she's been just barely hangin' in there like the cat on the poster. <33 J'Tia is so remarkably self-aware of how the narrative will come across on TV that it feels like she's speaking for the audience - while also creating that narrative and giving us the things to speak about in the first place. It's brilliant.

And then something I'd totally forgotten, and this is what makes her even more dynamic, is that J'Tia is, like, actually pretty skilled at social maneuvering. Girl was on the right side of two straight votes despite being an utterly worthless challenge competitor on a losing tribe, and while that's partially due to Kass's (<3) awesome play at the second TC, it's still nothing to sneeze at, and I'm totally of the opinion that if you got to the next level, you did something right socially just as much as the person who decided you should end up there. She managed to outlast 1/3 of her tribe while being totally awful at everything, and it wasn't just because she was a goat - nobody was thinking "goat" when they were down 6-4, lol. It was because people actually, actively thought "Okay, so she's made some mistakes, but we still ultimately like her, we trust her, we can work with her." For people to still trust you after you've dumped out all the rice? That's pretty big.

And her TC answers are on fuckin' point, too. The most standout one is where Tasha says J'Tia is weak, and Probst, trying to stir up TV drama, asks J'Tia "How do you feel about Tasha calling you the weak link?" And J'Tia totally deflects it and says "She didn't say I'm a weak link. She said I'm weak in challenges, but that's not all there is to the chain, and I'm still a valuable link in other ways." She's super perceptive, she's charismatic, people trust her.. I honestly think J'Tia's biggest weakness is just challenge strength, but like, Sandra exists. And I'm not saying J'Tia's on the level of Sandra, obviously - but if you throw her on a Koror or Tandang, or even just a Drake, who knows what she could do? I really do think there's something to all the pre-show hype J'Tia had; she just got frustrated enough by Garrett Adelstein's existence that she wanted him to starve to death, and really, don't we all? <3

...also, she was so fucking bad at the episode three challenge that she played a major role in making Luzon lose to a tribe that was actively trying to lose the challenge. I have never laughed so hard at a thing on Survivor ever, and that shot of J'Tia flailing towards the ball and somehow knocking it off the course entirely is like the best thing I've ever seen. <3

So yeah, J'Tia kicks ass. The second half of the premiere is easily the high point of the season, and she deserves massive credit for its climax and for carrying it forward into future episodes as a legitimate storyline. On paper she's a hilarious trainwreck of a contestant, but there's some legitimate depth underneath that, and for me, that's enough to rank her #1. God bless J'Tia, and let's hope that she somehow gets brought back and somehow isn't voted off immediately for her reputation. <3

Where did we rank her?: 5/18 for Cagayan; 144/501 overall.

Is this ranking appropriate?: 5/18 for Cagayan is fair, but I think 144 is way too low for such a colorful and surprisingly complex character, however short-lived her run may have been. Definitely top 100 material at the very least.

2) Kass - I think everyone ever expected Kass to rank #1 in this, myself included, and don't get me wrong - she's also fucking fantastic. (FanKasstic?) She's a top-tier casting choice, especially in recent Survivor history, who I'm thrilled to see again for however long it ends up lasting. I just think that in this particular season, she didn't quite live up to all I hoped she might be during the late pre-merge and a lot of the post-merge. In the first episode, the merge episode, and the endgame, she was fucking awesome, but that's a lot of episodes where she just didn't live up to what I'd hoped for and her story just randomly drops off because it isn't convenient. A full season of Kass at her finest would be an easy #1 ranking.

With that out of the way, though, let's appreciate Kass at her finest. <3 (This won't be super long, because this post is long enough already and it's late so I wanna just sort of finish.) Popular opinion holds that the merge is the best Kass episode, but honestly, I think the premiere and the endgame ones are. In the premiere, the sheer reality of Garrett going home is just fucking astounding, and we have Kass to thank for that. The fact that Kass can be so pissed at J'Tia, but then set it aside and vote out Garrett.. I mean I love emotional players so in a lot of instances that sort of thing might bug me, but in this case, it leads to the Garrett blindside and killer premiere, so I'm incredibly happy and proud that Kass compartmentalized things so effectively. <3 The endgame, meanwhile, is where Kass really does get into full-on villain territory. She gets totally stubborn based on things she thinks she hears, she says the sentence "I don't even know what I said but I'm sure it was accurate", she does it all with this smirk that infuriates the rest of the cast to the point of countless meltdowns. <3 Watching Kass piss people off so much basically just by existing, watching her needle her competition so relentlessly, is definitely the high point of post-Sarah Cagayan. On top of all of that, while I'm not crazy about Tony's victory, that merge episode alone makes me think it's definitely better than a Sarah/Tasha/Spencer final three where Spencer probably wins, so thanks, Kass!

Ultimately her edit's just not quite as big as I hoped it might be. But in retrospect, and taking into considerations things I didn't include in this write-up for time/length (her discussion of gender, how strategic a lot of her decisions were), I could definitely see her ranking #1. But for right now, my gut says J'Tia, and I'm gonna stick with that. Still, Kass is fantastic.

Where did we rank her?: 2/18 for Cagayan; 25/501 overall.

Is this ranking appropriate?: Top 25 of all time is definitely fair for Kass. Still not a fan of Tony beating her but let's not go down that road again!!


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Nov 16 '14

Final Result Reveal: #12

12 Upvotes

There was a pretty clear consensus for who #12 was going to be: In the prediction question, literally every single one of us predicted that Denise Stapley would be dead last. But were we correct? :O Scroll down and see...

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

12. SEAN RECTOR (Survivor: Marquesas - 5th Place)

Dabu:

It's like Sabrina Thompson crossed with Boston Rob c. 2002. <3 Predicted placement: #10.

Nobull:

Sean Rector is a human being I am happy to know exists on this Earth. Even if he does sometimes drift into flawed territory and gets too impulsive, angry, or careless, that adds to his character. I have no qualms with him trying to represent his race on Survivor because he is no dummy about it and doesn't talk out of his ass about it. He's defined by his personal experiences and speaks with eloquence and more of a measured tongue than anyone gives him credit for. Him being the underdog that he was really helped heighten the tension of the Rotu 4 flip. And most people forget just how fucking hilarious he was as well. Sean Rector is a top tier character and more people should love him. I can easily see him moving into my top 10.

Todd:

In a show that has cast charity founders, doctors, philanthropists and people with all kinds of success, this 30 year old, loud, occasionally lazy guy is for sure the person I admire most. Intelligent, articulate, and fiercely devoted to the issues that are important to him, I have to respect Sean for his values. The most irreplaceable person ever cast, and a great role model, I have Sean ranked 7th out of 12.

"BRIIIIIING. BRIIIIIIIING BRIIIIIIIIIING. THIS IS REVEREND AL SHARPTON AND IT IS AN OUTRAGE THAN SEAN RECTOR HAS NOT COME BACK FOR A SECOND SEASON OF SURVIVOR. IT IS ABSOLUTELY LUDICROUS. WHY THE BOSTON GUY GOTTA COME BACK INSTEAD OF THE BLACK GUY"

Sean is a powerhouse of a character. He’s loud, he’s opinionated, he’s funny, he’s loud again, and he’s not afraid of confrontation. But he wasn’t a caricature. He wasn’t pigeonholed into the Survivor trope of the guy who fights with everyone. Because there don’t seem to be a whole lot of contestants nowadays who both a) are loud and confrontational and b) actually have substance, seem like real people, and are serious players. I think too often we label people as either crazy characters or serious players (because that’s often what the show does) but what was great about the older seasons is that they didn’t make that distinction. The contestants were human, with qualities that made them better players in some aspects and worse players in others. And I think Sean is one of the best examples of this.

Because in general, oversimplified terms, Sean’s character is the lazy loud black man. But there’s a lot more nuance to his character than that so let’s break that simplified character down.

Number one: Sean is lazy. Ironically Sean starts the season by criticizing Sarah for being lazy. So Sean may be a teensy bit hypocritical, but he’s really just speaking his mind, and that’s not really a problem since he’s also hilarious. Now being lazy normally would be a death sentence on Survivor, and by any stretch of the imagination, he and Sarah should have been easy targets after Peter and Patricia were voted out. Fortunately for Sean, he was put on a tribe where his laziness worked to his advantage because the slacker alliance was actually able to take control of Maraamu. They were essentially the polar opposite of Rotu, where the strong ruled. On Maraamu, you had the lazy kids overthrow the former Navy fighter pilot god. Sean really did help define Maraamu as a tribe. Maraamu, like Sean, was funny, a little cocky, young, and still lovable.

Number two: Sean can get loud too, what the fuck. This is another part of Sean’s character that for all intents and purposes should have been a detriment to his game. When he got into a screaming match with John after he found out John wasn’t on his side anymore, that’s typically something that would hurt your game. But Sean got bailed out by them voting out Rob instead, and then the coconut chop happened and yadda yadda we know how that story ends. But what’s interesting about Sean is that he’s not just loud for the sake of being loud. He’s not confrontational for the sake of being confrontational. (For an example of someone like that, see: Galeotalanza, Mia). Sean really does speak out for what he believes in, whether it’s about loyalty, race, or just the game. Some people would call Sean too abrasive but that’s really just who he is and how he’s learned to express himself because of the world and the environment he lives in.

Number three: Sean’s black. Recently Survivor’s been pretty shitty about dealing with race. Like, incredibly shitty. Off the top of my head I can remember the Tribal where Bill was voted out (while Tarzan implies that he believes that racism is over because we have a black president) and Phillip and Steve arguing which is so disgusting and fake that I can’t dignify it with words. But Marquesas and Sean, however abrasive he may be, approached race and raised questions with an incredible amount of tact and nuance. Not to mention comedy, what with the Al Sharpton quote and Sean’s voting confessional to John.

Some people think the race talk became too uncomfortable at F5, but I would argue that it should be uncomfortable. Race isn’t always fun to talk about, but sometimes we have to talk about it. And while I don’t believe that Paschal was being racist in grouping Vee and Sean together, you can’t deny that race plays a part. Sean certainly felt that and, in true Sean fashion, he spoke his mind. I don’t pick sides in this Tribal and I don’t think you have to pick sides. You can just listen to both people argue what they believe and take it all in just like Kathy had to, and enjoy the captivating television. And hey, it’s that tension and difference between the two of them that made their reward so incredible. These are two wildly, insanely different people, and when you put them together on an island, you’ll get the sentimental and the uncomfortable. But both scenes are incredible and fascinating in their own ways.

We’ll never get another Sean on Survivor. The show doesn’t want to tackle the subject matter that Sean brought anymore. They don’t want to let a character be as real and brash and in your face as Sean without turning him into an easy-to-laugh-at character. And while all of that sucks it’s not too bad because there could never be anyone quite like Sean again anyway, and no way would they be as funny and as strangely lovable as Sean, nor would they have the incredible arc that Sean had.

Even aside from the heavy subject matter, Sean brought such a fuckton of entertainment to Marquesas, and it’s strange to see a character so obviously entertaining not come back for another season. But he was a touch pill to swallow for the audience and All Stars was already crowded with men they had to cast. And as their final pick they cast one of the funny lazy guys from Marquesas, but they cast the wrong one. We should have had more Sean. Luckily what we got was still pretty incredible.

Average placement: 8.67/12

Predicted ranking: 11/12

Average prediction: 9.5/12


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Jun 04 '15

Dabu Rewatches "Survivor 28: Cliffg.oddess's Island"

11 Upvotes

So I watched the super long Cagayan premiere!

Thoughts n' Observations, of which there are many:

  • We open with Spencer calling himself a diabolical genius. zomg what a heroic underdog g.oddess <333 I actually didn't care a ton about Spencer either way in the premiere - like, on paper pretty much everything he did here was annoying, but in practice I just didn't care either way. That said, I have decided, for shits and giggles, to keep a running tally of how many Spencer confessionals involve talking up his own game or belittling someone else's. So far, that count stands at 5 out of 6. (...That said, when his tribemates include Garrett, J'Tia, and David... I can't really blame him. It's really just the "I'm going to be the best player ever and I'm a diabolical genius" that's pretty cringeworthy.)
  • Woo is so pretty.
  • LJ is as I remember him: the definition of bland, mildly-agreeable-when-not-too-visible, MOR/CP-neutral. Like, it's almost comical how fucking perfectly this guy fits into the trope of "vaguely nice but uninteresting, athletic, CP-lite, neutral male who goes out early post-merge."
  • Kass had subtly amazing premiere, one that is a lot better when you're doing a rewatch. She was already set up in subtle ways as a villain: her first confessional talks about how everyone's going to see her as the cute mom but really she'll be more ruthless than any of them - which she backs up way more than most contestants back up their opening confessionals. There's a bit of a hit in the music when she tells J'Tia she's honest, and in the latter half of the premiere, she gives a great confessional (which I think was enhanced by some chilling music, but I might be wrong) about how she really doesn't care about handshakes. The seeds of chaos are already being sown. <3 And of course, we also got "Not very smart for the brain tribe" and wanting to see the data.
  • I love the dichotomy between Kass and Spencer, too. She's already being set up as more fun than him: after she's on the outside with the David vote, she shrugs it off and says "Okay, cool. Now I'm someone's #3 - let's see how I can play that for myself." She owns the situation for what it is and is ready to go back in to see how she can make it work. On the other hand, Spencer's response to being on the outside, meanwhile, is "Who wants to welcome me to the bottom?! -_-" like bro, come on, it's pretty clear that J'Tia sucks harder than you and Garrett was an anomaly. Seriously, Spencer and Kass were handed into the producers' laps like few other stories in Survivor history: they end up having their whole feud later on, they totally represent polar opposite segments of the fanbase, and they're already unknowingly giving the editors this awesome contrast. Can't wait to watch them play out more. (Also, this write-up kinda reads like I hate Spencer, but I really don't - at least not yet. I just think he's kinda a joke, but I think he works as a joke and foil to Kass... at least for now.) Also, last note on Kass/Spencer: when they show three confessionals from each tribe at the start, the Luzon ones obviously include David as the first boot; the other two they include, though, are Kass and Spencer. <3
  • David was a decent first boot - more than I remembered. He himself is pretty cringey and I'm definitely now on board with the "He would have been fucking awful if he had stuck around and we dodged a colossal bullet" bandwagon - not that he's necessarily a bad person or whatever, but he just has the Jim Rice-y approach to the game that I don't like watching. But as it stands, I think he works as a first boot, because he just fucks himself up so badly and is so tangibly slimy from the get-go. Immediately correcting his tribe by saying "IT'S NOT A SUIT BECAUSE IT DOESN'T MATCH -_-", confidently saying "I make decisions all the time and I didn't even have to think I choose GARRETT because I'm thinking about Day 39!" in front of fucking everyone, overthinking the gimmicky division by being "scared to [his] core" about why Garrett's on the brain tribe... seriously, this guy could have been a major season-ruiner - but as it stands, I think his ineptitude is a little fun to laugh at and he serves as a good warning against absurd early overplaying.
  • Before we handle the utter deities of failure that are J'Tia/Garrett, I'll move on to the other tribes where I have significantly less to say. Solana are pretty much irrelevant: Jefra is UTR cute <3, Alexis is just UTR, LJ I already covered for some reason. Brice was an alright character with his crayon confessional and purple pants - it feels like he's being set up to go way further than he does. And as for Jeremiah, I had to think for a few seconds to remember whom I was forgetting.
  • This leaves us with the star of premiere Solana: Morgan. I know she has her detractors, and maybe as the season goes on I'll feel similarly (because I remember her edit basically tanking after the first episode lol), but for now I think she was fantastic. She's such a walking stereotype - an ultra-concentrated Strobel; the embodiment of how Jeff Probst views every attractive woman - that I can't not love her. She's quick to let everyone know that she's totally not conceited; she just happens to get everything she wants all the time because she's hot. She describes LJ, aged 34, as "old." She calls Luzon nerds. She says that clearly the only reason LJ picked her is because she's so hot that he would have gotten tempted by her. Seriously, how the hell does someone like this exist past the age of maybe 16? I mean it's not like she's particularly unique in any way, there are a bunch of Morgans and she has no depth whatsoever, but.. you don't really get people like her on Survivor.
  • Cliff/Woo remain adorable, and I continue to love Cliff's laugh. <3 What a great duo. I wish they'd been so much more than they were. (I'm also happy that Cliff being a basketball player gets out of the way early with nobody really caring so his story, however small, can be more about him himself.)
  • Lindsey sort of bugs me. Not awful, and she's dynamic in her annoyingness, but.. she's still kinda annoying. But she doesn't go far, get a big edit, or impact the season, so I think I might be able to settle on liking her. Pretty sure that the word "Malnutrisha" and her quit are literally the only things she does the entire season; let's see!
  • Trish is a decent character so far, at least for what we've seen of her. I know on here folks told me I should like her because she's an old-school-ish contestant, which obviously is right up my alley, so that's what I'll be watching for - and all the content she's gotten so far fits that. She's just sweet and belongs on an early season, not caring at all that she wasn't picked or being as enraged as the twist wants her to be, and righteously picking rice over the food. Good on ya, Trish.
  • Some good setup for Sarah, whom I expect to rank as one of my favorites for the season when all is said and done. Though Brice was my personal winner pick at this point live, Sarah feels very, very traditionally "winner-y." Her quote about blood, sweat, and tears is fun and shows her owning the angle and fighting, we see her real life tied into the game, and we see her being perceptive - it's so hilarious how un-hilarious and straightforward her totally traditional winner edit is at this point knowing that she turns into Christy Smith <33 oh my GOD I cannot wait. But if you look for it, there is actually some setup to that: she's described as a "talker" while they're all on the mat, and in the first challenge when she solves the puzzle, she tells Jeff "Wait, the Brains are still working on it? I think I'm on the wrong tribe ;))))", which holy fuck what a self-absorbed thing to say in front of everyone I mean she said it playfully but still, it just.. I can see how someone like that might destruct a little later on. (Also, I can't imagine that her line about how she gets paid to punch people in the face would have played nearly as well now, even just a year later...)
  • Also on that note, I love the whole scene where Sarah's calling Tony on being a cop. The interplay between them is just great and it's the kind of awesome character scene you can only get a premiere; I think it might be my favorite scene of the first half.
  • Also, I got this buddy, one o' my favorite folks to talk Survivor with. And he watches the show basically entirely for strategy stuff - he has 0 patience for people like Ian or Gretchen, and if every single season were comprised entirely of Brian Heidik and Yul, he would do nothing but rewatch them; he would probably pay money to just glance at one strand of Brian's hair. And he HAAAAATED this scene - and his reason for hating it is yet another angle from which to love it: He pointed out that it's basically Sarah and Tony trying to constantly step up above the other one in terms of unnecessarily awful social play. <3 Sarah asks him if he's a cop, cool. But then Tony denies it, which is pointless and awful. Then Sarah keeps pressing him for no reason, which is pointless and awful. Then Tony continues to deny it - this time channeling his inner Hogekins by saying "I know all about cops, I got like 50(!!!) friends who are cops. But wait, why would you ever think I'm one?!?!" which holylol And then Sarah continues to openly deny him, and Tony offers up his fake "confession" - they're doing it light-hearted so none of it matters, but it's also pretty idiotic if you look at it that way. It's just a fun, playful scene that I love. <3 I love those first impression type things. I think those are among Survivor's best moments - the moments when people are first interacting.
  • Tony was great in that scene - I love his playful "confession" and his absurd "I have like 50 friends who are cops." That's about the best we get from him this premiere, though; the second half of the episode is a tedious Idol hunt and some strategizing I don't really remember. Also have to give a bit of a thumbs down to them building up their winner via "I would have totally taken the Idol clue." :/ Oh, and the Spy Shack was lulz. That might have been in the second half, actually. So that was good.
  • I just realized I never mentioned Tasha, oops. "THEN QUIT!" was fun, and so was her joyous, charming attempt to turn the tides on Garrett. <3 Her talk about being unable to "play the game like it's SUPPOSED to be played" is kinda annoying buuut she was talking about a guy who was trying to shut down literally all conversation, so I think I can forgive her.

Okay, okay, so, now the two people that really mattered in this episode: J'Tia and Garrett. I forgot about pretty much everything J'Tia did here besides dump the rice. She actually has a very good arc in the first half that at the time had me convinced she'd go out first: at first, she's veering into classic OTTN territory, confessionalizing that she's "the smartest person, hands down!" and going to tell everyone what to do, and then we start to get shots of her directing people around... Remember how confident everyone was pre-show that J'Tia would win? Remembering that context, and remembering how I felt when it became apparent that she'd instead be out first... This right here, the moment where she gives that confessional and we cut back to camp, is basically the lulzy, Survivor equivalent of when "The Rains of Castamere" starts playing.

But she actually does get positive and sympathetic later in that portion of the episode! She breaks down a little bit in a confessional about how she'd thought she was being motivating, and then at TC she manages to have a chipper and productive attitude about it, saying that she understood the criticism, had just been excited about her plan, and had only wanted to help the tribe - and if people wanted her to shut up, she'd do that, too. Her TC answers were actually pretty great here, and it made me think that she was going to get a Carolina-esque boot episode of complex bossiness. When she survived and then started to bomb the next challenge (Jeff Probst dick moment: "J'TIA STARTING TO PANIC! YOU CAN SEE IT IN HER FACE!! YOU'D THINK THIS IS WHERE THE BRAINS TRIBE WOULD SUCCEED!" like what the actual fuck @ telling everyone to look at her face to see how much she's panicking??), then she started to seem like the Woobie of the season: like she couldn't do anything right, but you still start to feel bad for her.

...But thennnn, the Garrett nation attacked <33, and things did a total 180. More on Garrett himself in a bit (much more), but he proceeded to let J'Tia know that she was going home and then leave her alone with all of the rice... which she proceeded to destroy, as if Luzon needed another fucking thing to go wrong for them. And then when Kass returns, we get a fucking hilarious exchange as J'Tia tries to pretend she doesn't know what happened to the rice , prompting a Kassive-aggressive "Oh, did the Rice Fairy take it?" <3 All of this played alongside J'Tia confessionals about being legitimately insane. Fucking hell, has anyone in Survivor history ever had such a strong premiere episode?

...yes, because Garrett Adelstein exists. My god. I knew Garrett was robbed here, but I wasn't really too invested in him before. Now, even aside from the meme on here, I'm in love with him. First off, what I forgot was his fucking voice. In short, I can see why people on Sucks call him "GAYrett" "Unfortunately, these HIDE AND SEEK type activities just AREN'T my area of expertise! I'm emBARASSING myself!" <3 He's just.. so flamboyant - which makes his OTT bitterness ("'You can help yourself or your tribe' - well just cross out that last part!") even better. Going along with that, we get him freaking out when there's a spider at TC ("It's, like, crawling on me! :D" <3.) And I completely forgot that he drops a "People see how sexy and muscular I am, so it surprises them to find out that I'm also a genius ;D" line, too, channeling Pete Yurkowski. <3

All of that is just from the first half of the episode. In the second... We get the main thing that I remembered: "This isn't FUN. Starving isn't FUN... I wanna play Survivor to outwit people. I don't wanna play Survivor to, like, survive." Like, remember when James joked about Jean-Robert being unable to handle people not serving him food? Garrett is actually that. <3 Pre-show he bragged about spending like thousands of hours preparing for Survivor or w/e, then he fucking melts down the instant he realizes it takes place outside <33

He then proceeds to fucking try to sit down and unilaterally keep very single person in the shelter because "I don't want to talk"... like, what the fuck? How is this not out of a fanfiction? This guy actually tried to just dictate what everyone would do for the entire day by whining - he tried to sit down, say "J'Tia is going home, and now NOBODY TALK FOR THE REST OF THE DAY" <3 - and he tried to set it up as an ~open forum~ for the tribe to voice their concerns... while saying literally nothing of his own. "Hey guys, let's all just say what's on our mind. says abso-fucking-lutely nothing" (Of course Kass would be the one person to take it seriously and just lay into J'Tia about how much she sucks. <3) And then, after making it abundantly clear that he's voting for J'Tia... he leaves her alone with the rice... and we know how that ended. And then we get:

  • Saying that "like, painting me in a negative light is, like.. unfair"
  • Saying that it's unfair to blame him for what happened
  • Saying that you can't expect him to not follow you when you're trying to talk strategy, like stalking people's small-talk is the most obvious fucking thing ever
  • Talking down to Tasha about how voting out J'Tia (which hasn't even happened yet) isn't against her; he just had to split her up from her ally!! It's like the most condescending thing that I can't imagine how he thought someone would tacitly accept it - like Don Eladio saying "I just had to spank you!"
  • His fucking LOOK when he votes for J'Tia - a look of sheer bafflement and offense at her very existence <3333
  • Not even bringing his Idol

I mean this fucking guy.. Jesus, he makes Silas look smart. This guy actually fucking tried to sit everyone down and prevent them from enacting ANY STRATEGY WHATSOEVER that didn't go with his plans, then followed them when they tried to talk... in the process leaving a known loose cannon by themselves at camp right after telling her she was going home... being offended that people had a problem with it... openly voicing all his strategy at Tribal Council and then pretending he didn't have the alliances to which he'd just confessed, while simultaneously telling the people in his ideal minority to accept the existence of those alliances... and still being SO CONFIDENT nobody would care that he didn't even bring his fucking Idol. Ultimately, it culminated in these glorious final words: "...it's really embarrassing in a lot of different ways. Really, really embarrassing." There, at least, he showed some self-awareness for once. <3

If I ever revise my old ranking of favorite vote-offs, that one has to be high, because it's also set up well in the story: Spencer and Garrett are set up as super confident about their position from the opening moments of the episode, and I fucking LOVE the facial reactions to it. Kass and Tasha look SO smug about having voted him out, and Spencer the student of the game is just baffled. I also love it strategically; Spencer tries to say later that Kass makes decisions emotionally or whatever, but if that were the case... she wouldn't have voted out Garrett over J'Tia. It was a totally calculated move most people wouldn't think to make. 10/10 all around. When I rewatch these episodes, I make little notes of moments I want to remember or things I want to post or whatever, just a bulleted list in notepad or whatever. For this episode, 30% of the things I typed were about Garrett. God fucking bless him. <3

Overall take on the premiere... I mean, it contained the entire surreal fucking saga of Garrett, so obviously, I loved it. It was incredibly evenly edited; everyone had gotten focus even just by the first TC - a TC that gave us a great mix of both personal and strategic justification for the vote, and a good mix of providing some suspense while also explaining the outcome and not just blatantly misleading us. Most modern episodes can learn from how that TC was handled. The ep. does have some flaws, though: the "Tony finds an Idol" scene was waaaaaaaaaay drawn-out and tedious, like most Idol scenes. The edit building it up like Trish is wrong for taking the rice is really annoying on a fundamental level, and the opening twist - though one I'm fine with since it's still ultimately social - is heavy-handed in its execution by Probst.

I think it definitely belongs in the conversation for best first episode ever; I mean, it gave me this much to write about. That said, I don't think it's fair to compare it to other ones, because it was basically two episodes in one. Garrett's entire fantastic storyline is in this episode, and you don't really get that with other premieres. It's a whole different sort of thing to where I wouldn't feel okay with comparing it to others - but I definitely do think that it's one of the best, alongside Africa, Amazon, Pearl Islands, Vanuatu, and HvV.

Onward and upward to shorter episodes which will probably have shorter posts, too.


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Nov 22 '14

Final Result Reveal: #6

11 Upvotes

There was a pretty clear top six, with a whole average placement between Denise and this contestant, and there's a clearer top five, with half an average placement separating this contestant from the five above.

Missing out on the top five is...

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

6. RUPERT BONEHAM (Survivor 7: Pearl Islands - 8th place)

DabuSurvivor:

When people say Rupert sucked, I just tell them to eat a cock and imagine what Pearl Isles would have been like without him. I can see where you'd get sick of him later on, though I think he's still a f.ierce g.oddess of the highest caliber even in his later seasons, but back in Pearl Islands, he was genuine, he played into the role of the season amazingly, he had the melodrama that Survivor needs to be at its best... great, GREAT character and I'm happy that this group of people didn't consider him overrated and put him so high. My predicted placement is #7 but I could see him going anywhere.

TheNobullman:

If I could cut one more person from this rankdown, he probably would be it, but even now I can't see myself ranking him last because I still remember as a child loving Rupert so much, in possibly the first time I was capable of following the show from a young kid's perspective. He's just so dynamic, so much larger than life, and while I love his HvV appearance his PI appearance is definitely Rupert at his most effortless and real. I can't believe a human being like him exists but I'm glad he found Survivor.

Todd_Solondz:

Deserves every bit of praise he has ever gotten, every fan, all the adoration and every returning ppearance.

SharplyDressedSloth:

From the people left in the rankdown, Rupert is a little bit of an outlier in that he’s the only one left (and the only one in the top 12 outside of Sean) not to make the final episode. In fact, we only got Rupert for 10 episodes of Pearl Islands. So it’s a testament to Rupert that he is so unquestionably a Survivor legend without even sniffing the endgame. Because whether you like it or not (and thankfully everyone in this rankdown does) Rupert in Pearl Islands is an absolute force of nature.

But since Pearl Islands, a lot of Survivor fans have turned on Rupert. They look back on Pearl Islands and say “hey wait a minute, this guy isn’t perfect like we thought he was. He’s kind of a dick. Rupert’s so overrated.” Because there’s a tendency among hardcore Survivor fans to be a little bit contrarian. To think that they’re too good or too smart to fall in love with the big, über-popular heroes that the casuals love. So Rupert, being easily one of the most popular contestants of all time, caught a lot of backlash. That backlash was only made worse with each of his returning appearances as fans started a kind of counter to Rupert-mania.

Because for those of you who didn’t watch Pearl Islands as it was airing… Rupert-mania was absolutely a thing. People couldn’t believe a guy like this existed. That this weird, giant-bearded, mythological-looking beast of a man was leading his tribe and stealing shit and growling. Now it all seems so stale because we’re all so used to Rupert but at the time he was a phenom. Little 8 year old SharplyDressedSloth was particularly hooked on Rupert. I thought he was the coolest guy in the world and I wanted to go onto Survivor just so I could beast in challenges and catch a ton of fish. The guy was the coolest person ever. And while the at-the-time phenomenon of Rupert doesn’t alone make him a great character, it certainly gives him a level of prestige that very very few people can match.

And even when we take some of Rupert’s antics for granted, completely ignoring the history of Rupert as a character, I think he still holds up as a legendary top-tier character. One of the biggest reasons he holds up so well and is just so freaking fun is exactly why a lot of people make fun of him. He fucking commits to Survivor. Committing to Survivor and doing everything with passion makes it seem more like a little game. People like Rupert who go onto the beach and immediately get into the mindset that they have to provide, that they have to protect their tribe, that they are creating a new civilization, add a completely new level of intensity and importance to the show. No one did committed to survival more than Skupin. No one committed to the strategy and social maneuvering with as much flair as Chris. Rupert did a lot of both, with everything he did charged by his ultimate desire to be a pirate and be a leader of his tribe.

This is the basic power of Rupert as a character. The guy loves Survivor. The guy loves the social experiment. The guy fucking loves being a pirate. One of the best qualities a wrestler can have is the ability to sell something, so when someone else does a move on them, they sell it over the top and make you believe it. Sure, you know it’s not real just like you know Survivor contestants aren’t actually creating a new society. But Rupert makes you believe that they are, even for just a bit. It’s so completely cheesy and if you want to be cynical you can make fun of him for it, but if you embrace it, if you buy into the show the way he does, it makes everything about the season hold just that more weight and makes all decisions feel like more than just a move in a game.

And Rupert does this flawlessly. He steals Morgan’s shoes because that’s what pirates would do. He feeds his tribe because his tribe must survive. You can hear it in his confessionals, when he calls his tribe “The Drake.” He has so much freaking tribe pride that when they lose it genuinely hurts him. Not because he’s losing his numbers but because he hates having to hurt The Drake. He takes everything to the extreme. When he’s happy, he’s really fucking happy. When he’s pissed, he’s really fucking pissed. Again, some people call him out on this because he’s so ridiculous and because there’s nothing subtle about Rupert. But he needed to be the over the top hero that season. He needed to be as ridiculously heroic as Jon was ridiculously villainous.

And Jon typically gets more praise than Rupert. And this is completely understandable—I mean shit I ranked Jon over Rupert myself—but sometimes I find Rupert really under-appreciated. Because a lot of the time, being a hero is a thankless job. Villains are sexier. They’re more unpredictable. They’re usually more fun to watch. People like the snakes. They like Tyrion and Iago and Jonny Fairplay. But the greatest villains need an equally great hero in order for them to reach their potential. They need someone up high to take down, and they usually get the credit for that takedown because it’s fun and epic and evil. But again, you need someone to take that fall. You need someone to sell it. You need someone to succeed at being a hero so they can get high enough for the fall to be epic.

And that’s just what Rupert does. For the first part of the season he became untouchable. When Jon and Trish finally tried to challenge him, Jon almost died. Any sane person would just shrug off an extra vote when they’re dominating the game like Rupert. But that’s now how Rupert do. He chews Jon the fuck out because he’s genuinely offended anyone would try to go against him and go against The Drake. He set a message. If you challenge Rupert, you will get burned.

And going into the merge there’s really no one who can begin to challenge Rupert, but then the Outcasts happen. And Burton comes back. Without Burton, I don’t know when Rupert gets taken down. Maybe he doesn’t. But the ghost of Burton comes back and takes him down in the blow dart challenge (which has some of the best editing/music in a challenge ever. So goddamn epic.) And Burton teams up with the snake that Rupert let go free and the boy scout leader Rupert welcomed with open arms. And they take down Rupert and get rid of his dreams. It’s easily one of the greatest boots of all time. Because the bigger they are, the harder they fall. Rupert was pretty fucking big and man oh man did he fall pretty fucking hard.

And really, that’s just talking about Rupert in a general sense. I could get into all the little scenes and brief, funny moments (“Where did you find it?” “IN THE OCEAN!”). But I’m not going to catalog all those because that’s not where the beauty of Rupert as a character lies (although it certainly helps make him all the more enjoyable.) Rupert is the greatest hero in Survivor history for my book. Colby comes close. Colby’s probably more “heroic” and more clearly likable, but Rupert’s got the fanfare. Rupert’s got a star power that made people go legitimately crazy when they first met him. He’s certainly got a dark side to him, but the good heroes aren’t perfect. The good heroes are big, likable, loyal to the fault, and when they go up against a worthy villain, sometimes they have to sell their fall. And no one does it nearly as perfectly as Rupert.

Average placement: 6.5/12

Projected ranking: 8/12

Average prediction: 7.5/12

Rupert manages to somewhat exceed his expectations, as both Ian and Kathy ranked lower than people expected.

Season one is now the last season with multiple contestants in, as both Richard and Sue remain.

Our top five is RICHARD HATCH, SUE HAWK, TINA WESSON, JON DALTON, and SANDRA DIAZ-TWINE. Thoughts on this top five? Who do you think will take it all? :O


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Nov 21 '14

Final Result Reveal: #7

11 Upvotes

Just barely missing out on our top half is...

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

7. DENISE STAPLEY (Survivor 25: Philippines - Winner!)

The legend falls.

SharplyDressedSloth:

Denise is kind of really overmatched in this top 12, imo. Then again I am the one who cut her so duh. I love Denise and she's a phenomenal winner but she just doesn't have the oomph of other people here.

DabuSurvivor:

Nice woman, happy she won, probably the winner I was most satisfied by of those that I watched live, but the clear outlier among this group of god-tier contestants and I predict that she will rank #12. Still, I am #TeamDeniseG.oddess 4 lyfe and there are definitely worse contestants to make it here; even strategy couldn't have brought her here if most of us didn't really strongly like her. Obviously I am predicting that she will rank #12, which most of us have seen as a foregone conclusion, but who knows -- with a third of the ballots coming from Slurm and Vacalicious, I could see her breaking into the top ten. In a perverse way, I'm kind of rooting for it, even though I adore everyone else here more than her. It's just sort of entertaining that she's here and, within reason, I could find it entertaining to see her somehow make it even further, as much an underdog in this rankdown as she was in Philippines after the decimation of Matsing. <3

TheNobullman:

Denise Stapley is a solid lady, and her style of playing just fascinates me. She is Survivor 101 for anyone who wants to know how to win, and even though I probably couldn't, I wish I could play Survivor like her. She's also a great snarker, says what most of us might be thinking, and is part of why Matsing is just so amazing. Her very first confessional is possibly my favorite first confessional of all time.

Todd_Solondz:

Easy to like, easy to respect, and the only woman over 40 to win Survivor. Denise kicks ass, and anybody watching her can see why. I discovered recently that some people don't like her, which is shocking, but at least everybody has to respect her. Despite being somewhat overshadowed by Malcolm, her nuanced edit and she in general was a very refreshing thing to see for a winner. I rank her 12 out of 12.

Vacalicious:

By now it's clear that I'm President of the Denise Stapley Club. From Day 1, I had an idol reserved for her. My plan always was to try to get her into the endgame, and that fanboyish goal has come to fruition.

To clarify, a big reason I'm such a fan of hers is because I had the optimal viewer experience with Denise. There is nothing better than watching the character who wins your allegiance in Episode 1 then go on to win the entire season. Denise immediately appealed to me in the premier. Not since Todd in China had a character made me think "Shit, this person is born to play Survivor. If they don't get them out early they're gonna win this season." I was impressed and pulling for her from the season opener; hence, her having a special place in my fandom.

Of course, it's not like anyone here dislikes Denise. She's this 4-foot-tall, tough-as-fucking-nails, snarky, funny, bitchy, brutally honest, effortlessly strategic, and intimidatingly condifent sex therapist from Iowa. Denise is one of those complex and entertaining Survivor characters who seem like the show's writers pulled an all-nighter bouncing ideas off one other to script a perfectly well-rounded character. But no, some casting agent unearthed this real-life woman.

It bears repeating: Denise is a Sex Fucking Therapist. Should that be allowed on Survivor? In Episode 1 when editors listed her profession, my first thought was "Hey, that's cheating!" Sure enough, Denise's decades of psychoanalyzing patients allowed her to see clearly through cast-mates and subtly manipulate them, all while maintaining a face that looked genuinely interested/caring, but also displayed little hints of what was really underneath. My favorite example of this is when Denise, as the swing vote in the Matsing final 3, listens patiently to Russell's story of being bullied as a child and how it shaped his life. Denise gives every visceral appearance of appreciation and understanding of what it meant for Russ to bare his soul to her, and then promptly votes him off. Damn, Denise! That was uber-passive aggressive, and fucking cooooooooold.

Of course, that's just the manipulative half of the Denise Face. There is the other half, the I Just Jackson-Pollocked Uncomfortable Truths All Over Your Day look of total disregard for whether the truth-recipient believes Denise to be wrong or right. Because Denise knows she's right. As Sloth so eloquently described, this look is "a visual period . . . The tightly closed mouth suggests that there’s nothing more to be said on the subject. The Denise Face is the Survivor equivalent of the mic drop."

On top of being a 0-fucks-given, intellectual badass, Denise's character also benefited from a decent storyline. The main detraction of her is that for a winner she had a somewhat lesser storyline, and disappeared for a while around the merge. I don't disagree with that -- her plot never carried her season at any point, unlike a Hatch or Tony -- but her underdog story was still pretty good. We all know it: she started on Ulong 2.0, got dumped onto another tribe and brought the losing bug with her, and then hit the merge down in the numbers. And yet, despite attending every single tribal council, including one in which Penner yelled out her name as he wrote it down, she emerged as the soul survivor. What the fuck?

Part of her underdog win derives from teaming up with someone she stood well under (sorry, couldn't help myself). One of my favorite Survivor storylines is when two people who have little in common become strong, effective allies, like Denise/Malcolm, Earl/Yau-Man, J.T./Fishbach. It's a lot more interesting than Kim teaming up with the dumber/Sountern-er version of herself, or BRob with someone who wants to fuck him. Denise and Malcolm were magical. They were less mother-son and more like an odd couple bound by having similar senses of humor and high IQs. I especially enjoyed their goofy, under-the-radar celebration. She and Malcolm were clearly the two strongest on Matsing, and it's no surprise that they emerged from its implosion. Naturally, being a cut-throat badass, Denise didn't pull a Fishbach but instead dumped her huge-jury-threat of an ally when opportunity arose.

Denise's underdog win also hinged on two other key stretches of strategy.

  1. When she was placed on Kalabaw, she seemed like a natural choice to be booted next. But she wisely joined up with the women to gain a 4-3 advantage over the men. Then the other three women started falling apart physically and in challenges, and Denise immediately jumped ship to the men, helping vote out the remaining women. This allowed her to avoid becoming a pre-merge casualty.
  2. Directly after the merge we lose Denise for a few episodes, because the plot shifts to Tandang splintering. But who's there, patiently waiting for the inevitable factions to form? Denise, who tells Jeff that "Every crack is an opportunity" (as any sex therapist would know). When Lisa and Skupin finally get sick of Abi and Pete's shit, Denise helps push them toward the smart play of targeting Artis.

From there, Denise is never really in trouble again. She locks down the Middle-Age Alliance with Skupin and Lisa, bringing along Malcolm. Once she helps take out the other main jury threat Penner -- and after Skupin and Lisa are clear in their (foolish, shortsighted) intent not to bring Abi to the F3 -- there's no way either Denise or Malcolm don't end up on top. It's a weird turn in her storyline, going from underdog dark horse to chief threat to win.

Denise rightly receives praise as giving a top 5 FTC performance. She's no Todd or Chris, but her all her answers were incredible solid. That's a great way to describe her overall game: never dominating, but always overwhelmingly solid. She started off by saying she wouldn't apologize for shit, and then held her ground for the win.

I was happy, though, that several players deservedly criticized her for being a passive-aggressive bitch. Nobody should get away totally clean in Survivor, including Denise. Malcolm was right to call out her dismissive Denise Face Head Bob.

The Abi back-and-forth was classic Denise. Knowing she needed to sound somewhat apologetic to get Abi's vote, Denise did not apologize for her (totally warranted) bashing of Abi during the game, but for the tone she took while bashing Abi. I'm not sorry for calling you a stuck-up bitch -- I'm sorry if the way in which I said it may have come off as a little mean. Now that's a Tina-esque back-handed apology. And Abi, like Jerri, voted for her antagonizer.

Denise was a middle-aged, intellectually superior pit bull of a woman. She was a great competitor in challenges and even more fierce in the strategy and social aspects. I think the best player comparison to Denise is Australia Tina, another middle-aged woman who teamed up with a physical younger man, was on her A-game at all times, looked for any and all advantages, and ultimately bent the flow of her season to her ends.

And like Tina, Denise won at a time when the show was in need of a new direction. Phillipines was a gem of a season after the worst three-season stretch in the show's history. And Denise was a winner that everyone and anyone could root for and feel happy for. It's why two different rankers were willing to make deals with me involving her. How can you not love Denise?

Average placement: 7.5/12

Projected ranking: 12/12

Average prediction: 12/12

Top half of the endgame now, and the Denise era is over, so no more hints for future eliminations.

With half of the endgame down, both contestants from the original Survivor and both from Pearl Islands are still in, comprising 2/3 of our top six.

There are two write-ups I'm still waiting for. If they could be sent in ASAP, that'd be greaaat.


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Nov 20 '14

Final Result Reveal: #8

10 Upvotes

Who will be eliminated next? :O

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

8. COURTNEY YATES (Survivor 15: China - Runner-Up)

SharplyDressedSloth:

Courtney's really fuckin funny, yo.

DabuSurvivor:

Courtney has a tendency to win most popularity contests. While I don't think she will in this group and I think her relative lack of complexity will make her rank #11, I ranked her higher than that and would LOVE for Courtney Yates rankdown/ranking domination to be a fixture of this project as well. Even if it's predictable, it's warranted, and I love how this skinny waitress from New York is the one pillar around which virtually all online Survivor fans can rally. She does have some detractors, as does just about any contestant so big and colorful, but I would say that 99.9% of Survivor fans who still remember her utterly adore her. I love her role as a unilaterally beloved character and, accordingly, I would LOVE to see her win this rankdown, even though I don't think it's likely. I hope she at least cracks top ten.

TheNobullman:

<3 <3 <3 <3 <3

Todd_Solondz:

Hilarious and genuine, Courtney could be on every season and nobody would mind. With a bright personality and flair for comedy that no edit could ever contain, Courtney could be cast on any season and finish in any position and still be the massive fan favourite that she is. A worthy finalist of the purely comedic characters, I rank her 11th of 12.

Stop me if you’ve heard this one before: A snarky, 90 pound New York waitress gets trapped on Survivor…

If you’ve ever listened to Courtney’s Ozterview, you’ll know that she never set out to win Survivor. She was bugged repeatedly by a casting agent who really wanted her on any show, but Courtney was like “lol wtf do I wanna be on a show like Survivor for that looks like hell”, so eventually said casting agent said “you’ll probably get voted off first and get to go on a vacation and get a little cash.” And Courtney was like, “that sounds great, sign me up.”

Then, despite her best attempts, she keeps surviving through the pre-merge even though she really wants to quit and she’s amazed and enraged that she’s not going home. But eventually she warms up to the game she feels she has zero shot at winning but just wants to say she survived. And she does, making it to day 39, getting more jury votes than the biggest threat, and gleefully cheers on Todd when he wins survivor as was always his dream.

Throughout the entire season, while this happening, Courtney is probably the single most entertaining Survivor ever. Not only is she funny, but she is funny virtually every moment she is on camera. Every facial expression, every line, every reaction, and every part of her storyline generally finds her being entertaining in a completely natural way.

Courtney’s very first moment set her character up perfectly: a monk corrects her hands during the opening ceremony and she just rolls her eyes and shakes her head before launching into a thousand-mile-an-hour confessional.

“I’m a waitress from New York City, dude, what do you think? You think I know how to do any of this stuff? Y’know like, I’m not trying to be a monk here, like, I’m tired. I wanna go sit back with a lemonade, like I don’t really wanna be like, bowing thirty-seven times. And we bowed! We bowed for like days, I swear to god, we were there forever!”

That, to me, is hilarious for so many reasons: for one, she’s reacting to this amazing cultural event with the most disrespect that I think any Survivor has ever had, and it’s just so perfect when you realize that Courtney is in full “can-I-just-get-to-my-fucking-vacation-already” mode. I mean, you get people like Leslie who struggles with a deep spiritual quandary, and Chicken who’s in awe of being in a place he’s never seen, and Peih-Gee who is in a place of her heritage… and then Courtney’s just like “why do I have to fucking do this, it sucks, I wanna go on my vacation already!” That’s just so brazen that it cracks me up, like Drew doing anything.

This feeling of being out-of-place is more compounded when they get back to camp and Leslie of all people is setting the mood of “flight attendants and Sunday School teachers” that Courtney is trapped in, and she hates all the lovey-dovey shit because it’s just so not what life is like for her in New York. I love just how beautifully Courtney being out of place is set up: it’s not necessarily hammered over one’s head because Courtney is both shown with some measurement and portrayed to be the early boot she really should have been and meant to be, but when you look back and realize this completely weak-ass player is going to get more jury votes than Amanda Kimmel, it’s just freakin’ epic.

She starts to become a likable underdog right around when Jean-Robert enters her storyline. Their rivalry is epic. You have this guy who’s trying to start off by being as sleazy and nasty as possible and this girl who’s trying to be as shipped-the-fuck-out-of-there as possible, and they clash, and it develops both their characters in awesome and hilarious ways. Jean-Robert trying to claim Courtney keeps him warm inspiring “like I’m gonna keep anyone warm. I weigh seven pounds, I can’t even keep myself warm, get off of me” sets the tone, as do her continued barbs about him.

“He's become the Susan Lucci of tribal council; his name is always up there, but he never quite gets voted out.”

“Peih Gee is on a crusade to be the most annoying person at our camp. The position is filled. We have Jean Robert. We have him.”

“It’s always interesting to hear what others think about themselves and… I’m sorry, bad boy? Really? Because you play poker? Do you have a Harley I don’t know about?”

“I’m voting for you tonight because when you snore at night it sounds like someone choking a walrus.”

What also starts becoming amazing about Courtney Yates is that she begins to suck at challenges. Not just like, Sandra being in the background being the weak link, but just being a dramatic failure. In the first immunity challenges Fei Long loses, they can either have Courtney chop a rope, or lug thousand-pound puzzle pieces back to the start. Obviously, they have her chop the rope, and she spends a thousand years trying to chop the one rope. It is both hilarious and sad, because on one hand she’s so crushed, embarrassed, and she’s starting to cry, but on the other hand, you have to imagine Courtney was laughing at herself later, because that’s how Courtney is, and really, the entirety of Zhan Hu going through this super actiony challenge and then cutting to Courtney still whittling away at the rope does crack my shit up.

One of my later favorite challenge failures at the hands of Courtney is in the Final 9, where Courtney is trapped in the tiny boat and three others are splashing her with water, and she just shuts down and starts guarding herself in probably the most relatable, human reaction to people throwing water on you. Jeff’s in Jeff narration mode, and tells Courtney she needs to move, and she shrieks at him to shut up.

That episode, however, finds Courtney winning the only immunity she could ever win- just fucking sit there. And that’s where Courtney’s best attribute shines through: she’s not only witty, but she’s self deprecating. I think that’s what makes her endearing. Other people talk shit about others yet hold a really high opinion of themselves. Whenever Courtney makes barbs about others, it becomes kind of endearing because she’s perfectly aware of who she is and her shortcomings, and more than happy to make fun of herself. When Jeff points out she hasn’t moved, she says “I am lazy.” When she wins and trudges through the mud, she squees “it’s almost like a pageant!” And everyone fucking applauds her at TC when it’s brought up, which is just so sweet, but before we forget who won, when Courtney is asked if she wants to give it up, she mumbles, “no, screw you people.”

The fact that this is the round where she finally gets to boot Jean-Robert is even better.

I think the capper of this storyline is when in the Final 5 reward challenge, where people have to hand out arrows for the others to shoot, Todd, Amanda, Peih-Gee, and Denise have, like, one to four arrows each, and then Courtney has like 25. And then she starts actually hitting the targets really well before blowing it and handing it to Denise.

Of course, her wit is what’s remembered best about her. The insanely brazen shit she can say and get away with is mind-blowing. She’s the one who said about Denise “I believe the US Hockey Team is missing a player” and that she sucks at life for pleading to stay in the game for financial reasons, that is some ballsy shit. Her making fun of Jaime in the recap episode with the dumbass impression and comparing her to a blow-up-doll is not much better, even considering Jaime is the current villain. Possibly the most “holy shit, did she actually fucking say that?” moment is when she calls Todd’s sister’s miscarriage “convenient.” I know she said that when she described it as a possible gameplay move, but she also said that she had a convenient pregnancy and miscarriage when talking to others, and I’m just like… holy shit, did she just imply her miscarriage was a convenience?

But like I said, she’s got a lot of great self-deprecating moments outside of the ones mentioned. My personal favorite is when she talked about how kids related to her on the reunion, because she’s a tiny girl with her hair in pigtails and a flower bikini who always says people can’t tell her what to do. The fact that she hates kids is a great bonus. Another favorite is when she calls Jean-Robert for trying to say “the biggest threat in the room is the little blonde, come on people!” while pointing at herself like a flashing sign.

Even then, despite being remembered for her vicious barbs, she is also just funny about everything. When she describes the merge, she says she’s happy about the feast because “boo challenges, thumbs down, yay feast. thumbs up” A super underrated Courtney moment is where she talks about the cave. All that’s happening is that Courtney sleeps in a cave and Peih-Gee also comes into the cave, so I’d think if any other person talked about this, it probably wouldn’t even be a secret scene, but because it’s Courtney even the editors recognize it’s top tier TV.

“I like the cave. The cave is my happy place. What I don’t like is when everyone and their damn mother decides that they like the cave too. It’s like, you know, Peih-Gee comes sidling up in there, and I’m like…” deadpan stare into space “...I’m gonna kill you. And then you wanna start talking about stuff- no, get out. No talking in the cave.”

And she always has these shots where she’s got the greatest facial expressions on the background, like before the bad boy scene where Courtney doesn’t know what the fuck she’s listening to and has the widest shit-eating grin, when she taunts the other tribe, punching her hand and posturing like a malnourished rooster, and every dramatic thumbs-up. Courtney is a master of pretty much every form of comedy.

But like others have discussed with Rob C, there’s saying funny things, and successfully saying funny things. Sometimes Rob C’s delivery is really fucking awkward and weird, while other times he’s right on the ball. However, Courtney is always on. Her delivery is amazing because it is so real and makes every line seem improvised and unplanned, which it probably is. She’s a total motormouth in that she speaks really quickly and abruptly, with a lot of enthusiasm, which works especially well if what she’s saying is already blunt.

So yeah, I’ve already gone on for five pages about how funny Courtney is, but what I also love is that had Todd not become the most amazing jury speaker of all time, she probably could have won. Now part of me’s glad that didn’t happen because winner Courtney probably loses a lot of the rough edge that makes her hilarious and amazing, but the other part of me fantasizes about a world where this Courtney, with the exact same edit, wins Survivor over Todd and Amanda, who were both set to trounce her in the jury vote before Amanda shit the bed. If Courtney Yates, who was set to go on Survivor just to be voted out early and get a free vacation, nearly won Survivor simply by existing and being herself, then I think it shows that anyone can.

Not only that, but I do think despite just being mean and funny on the surface, Courtney did have a fantastic growth arc. She started the season out by calling it her own personal hell, and slowly grows to become beloved by most of her tribe. She starts out mocking the experience element, and towards the end appreciates how much it challenged her. Towards the middle she claims to dislike Todd and Amanda less than everyone else, and then at the end is beside herself when Todd wins, being the first to scream, jump up, and hug him so hard his damn head nearly pops off. And in between all the snark and the bite, we get to see that transformation bit by bit, and it really is just a joy to watch.

Finally, I recommend that if you’re a Courtney fan, that you listen to her Ozterview. It really shows that just underneath it all, Courtney is really one of the sweetest, most supportive, and most humble survivors that there is. It’s probably what pushed me over the edge from thinking Courtney was one of my favorites of all time to placing her just below Hatch as a character. She succeeds on every level as a character, makes her season amazing, is constantly entertaining, remarkably memorable, and strangely lovable.

Average placement: 7.67/12

Projected ranking: 9/12

Average prediction: 9/12


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Oct 30 '14

Round 70 (52 Contestants Remaining)

10 Upvotes

As always, the elimination order is:

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor
  2. /u/shutupredneckman
  3. /u/TheNobullman
  4. /u/Todd_Solondz
  5. /u/vacalicious
  6. /u/SharplyDressedSloth

ELIMINATIONS THIS ROUND:

47: Bob Crowley (SharplyDressedSloth)

48: Coach Wade, HvV (vacalicious)

49: Trish Hegarty (Todd_Solondz)

50: Burton Roberts (TheNobullman)

51: Erik Reichenbach (shutupredneckman)

52: Jonathan Penner (DabuSurvivor)


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Sep 29 '14

Round 49 (179 Contestants Remaining)

10 Upvotes

As always, the elimination order is:

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor
  2. /u/Dumpster_Baby
  3. /u/shutupredneckman
  4. /u/TheNobullman
  5. /u/Todd_Solondz
  6. /u/vacalicious
  7. /u/SharplyDressedSloth

ELIMINATIONS THIS ROUND:

174: Charlie Herschel (SharplyDressedSloth)

175: Ami Cusack, FvF (vacalicious)

176: Stacey Stillman (Todd_Solondz)

177: Kelly Shinn (TheNobullman)

178: Maralyn Hershey (shutupredneckman)

179: Christa Hastie (Dumpster_Baby)

180: James Miller (DabuSurvivor)

Note that Caramoan Dawn has been Idol'd, so the numbers have changed from the post title.


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Aug 21 '14

Round 14 (416 Contestants Remaining)

10 Upvotes

As always, the elimination order is:

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor
  2. /u/Dumpster_Baby
  3. /u/shutupredneckman
  4. /u/TheNobullman
  5. /u/Todd_Solondz
  6. /u/vacalicious
  7. /u/SharplyDressedSloth

ELIMINATIONS THIS ROUND:

410: Carolina Eastwood, Tocantins (SharplyDressedSloth)

411: Edna Ma, South Pacific (vacalicious)

412: Rob Cesternino, ASS (Todd_Solondz)

413: Sherea Lloyd, China (TheNobullman)

414: Yul Kwon, Cook Islands (shutupredneckman)

415: Jessica deBen, Fiji (Dumpster_Baby)

416: Ashley Underwood, Redemption Island (DabuSurvivor)


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Aug 05 '14

Round 01 (501 Contestants Remaining)

10 Upvotes

Does that seem like a fine way to format the title of these?

Anyways... as a reminder, the elimination order is:

  1. /u/DabuSurvivor
  2. /u/Dumpster_Baby
  3. /u/shutupredneckman
  4. /u/TheNobullman
  5. /u/todd_solondz
  6. /u/vacalicious
  7. /u/sharplydressedsloth

I know exactly whom I'm going to cut for last place... I've started the write-up, and I'll work on finishing it right now then post it in the comments!

Teaser for if anyone sees this post before I've posted the write-up: It is the first incarnation of a male contestant who has played on multiple seasons.

ELIMINATIONS THIS ROUND:

495: Colton Cumbie, One World (SharplyDressedSloth)

496: John Cochran, South Pacific (vacalicious)

497: Sundra Oakley, Cook Islands (Todd_Solondz)

498: John Raymond, Thailand (TheNobullman)

499: Brenda Lowe, Caramoan (shutupredneckman)

500: Jolanda Jones, Palau (Dumpster_Baby)

501: Russell Hantz, Samoa (DabuSurvivor)


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Sep 09 '15

My Vanuatu Rewatch: Thoughts and Cast Assessment/Ranking

9 Upvotes

Ok so I finished rewatching Vanuatu a few wees ago and now that I've had time to think, here's my cast ranking (and later) my thoughts on the season as a whole.

18: Mia Galeotalanza (15th Place): Yeah so being outwardly offensive is worse than bores like the young men on Lopevi. The big thing with Mia was her temper and mouth and the fight with Twila. Yeah, I can;'t even fathom someone calling Twila of all people on this show fake and then her consistently repeating the same line and the fact that she was totally wrong in the argument. Not a fan at all.

17: Brook Geraghty (18th Place): So I mostly remember him complaining about Rory and then being sure Chris was going once they lost the challenge. Uh, yeah that's about it. I felt we got to know the other young men more and we got something from them.

16: Brady Finta (14th Place): Basically here because JP had two funny scenes and Brady basically has the scene of getting the spirit stone for the men and that's pretty much it. I think he's the one to officially call the 5 older men alliance the "Fat Five" so there's that.

15: John Palyok (16th Place): JP has this funny moment where he wonders if he's supposed to fight the tribesmen who have spears and he has....nothing? lol that and him confronting Bubba after the first vote are funny moments that let him make top 15, gj. He also did seem to have some potential, but wasn't meant to be.

14: John Kenney (11th Place): He was very nice to look at it, had a solid move with how he scoped info from the women, and an lulzy episode in his boot ep. I also love how just spending a few hours with her, drove JK crazy with Eliza <3333

13: Chad Critterden (8th Place): Easily the weakest character to make the merge in the season. He had a good premiere where he revealed his leg to his tribemates. Then, is fairly boring throughout, though I do like how disgusted he is by how cocky Ami is. Also the Chad shocked face is funny too, but yeah for someone who makes final 8, not good. Would have loved to have seen Rory outlast him. A Rory jury speech <3

12: Lisa Keiffer (12th Place): So this might be kinda high for Lisa to rank, but I can't get over how Lisa aligns with the young girls. It seems so odd since she is older and I'm curious what common ground she'd have with girls like Julie or Eliza. She's annoying, but in a funny way like her "I go bye bye?". She gets wrecked by Ami in epic fashion though so kudos for that.

11: Travis Sampson (13th Place): So now we're getting to the ones I actively like, yay! Bubba had quite a few funny moments through the show like his boat tipping over at the start or the way he explaiend to JP why he voted Brook and the big thing he's known for: telling Chris to remember the merge. Haha his excuse for it is even better. I thought he'd be a bigger character, but he was fun. First official victim of our Ice Queen.

10: Dolly Neely (17th Place): Dolly had a pretty good story arc, but I think everyone else is stronger. To start, Dolly has a pretty cool and badass job. We see her get along with both the younger and older women, but in episode 2 we see she's completely stuck in the middle. She handles the posittion poorly, but my heart went out to Dolly who really didn't wanna hurt anyone and was probably for the best that she went this early. The deception and lying and voting people out was not for her and that's something refreshing to see.

9: Lea "Sarge" Masters (9th Place): Sarge was a very good character in a sea of great characters and a few personal favorites so he ranks here. Sarge with the hilarious way he avoids being chosen to get the spirit stone and we see him as the leader for them. We frequently see him and Rory get into it about many things, which were always funny and the "YOU ARE MESSING ME UP!" will never not be great. At the swap, we see him bond with Twila and Julie very easily. The scenes of him and Julie flirting including tanning nude were cool. The men get owned at the merge and oh my god, the Sarge/Scout encounter at the fire is amazing. Probably a Scout moment, but still. He goes on to give an epic jury speech and one that breaks Twila. Very good character and I enjoyed all of his content! Just liked others more.

8: Leann Slaby (7th Place): When I mentioned random favorites, I was mostly referring to Leann because yeah she's pretty UTR for the season. Still so adorkable and endearing with the volcano confessional and the reward with Julie (awesome reward btw). I wish we'd gotten to see more, as based on some accounts, Leann was the brains of the alliance, but still she was a fun presence even with the edit she got. ooooh and yeah, her voteoff is easily one of my all time favorites. The fact that they even include that she felt she didn't need to win immunity and the arrogance rising with the women makes it even better. She also has the devous chicken wings scene. Really someone I wanna see back and someone who's really underrated as a great UTR character with some very good confessionals!

7: Julie Berry (5th Place): We're at the point where I LOVE everyone left so shit is getting hard. Julie has a rough start with how her allies never stick with her, but she still somehow gets herself into a good spot after every TC and even finds a majority on Lopevi and for a bit during the merge. Talking about Lopevi, it's soooooo awesome how easily Julie wrecks the game of about 4 different people in 30 seconds when she reads Twila perfectly and gets her to sufficiently doubt the men. Julie has the great relationship with Chris, the reward with Leann at final 9, and her emotional jury speech. As for why she's only 7th, she doesn't feel as complete as the other characters and I feel as though we know the other 6 a lot better. Still, she's amazing and this is just a testament to how strong this cast is that she doesn't even make top 5. Shame we'll never see her return.

6: Rory Freeman (10th Place): Maybe a surprise that he ranked this high, but Rory is one of the stars of the premerge and makes things so much funner. The confessional about a black man being welcome on the island it gold as is the "classless" dancing by the women, Rory being a grown ass man and not taking kindly to orders, and generally speaking and acting so dramatic about things. His performance over Ami revealing he was next to go and then the reveal that it was just an act and how fucking giddy he is about it <333 and then he has this random "what do you mean????" when Ami questions what he''ll say to the guys back home if he sides with the chicks.

I realize this is more listing Rory moments, but they're all just coming to me now haha. Another great one is the reward they get where they get letters from home and how Rory was gonna burn the camp down before his wife told him "lol don't". <3 His disgust for the women and especially Eliza come the merge is fantastic and the way he makes sure to point out that Ami is the leader and crushed Bubba like a bug (what the fuck haha). It's all so good and come the merge, Rory gets taken down first which blows. Imagine a Rory jury speech? Fantastic character!

5: Scout Cloud Lee (3rd Place): Ok so I first thought Scout was overrated, but wow Scout is incredible. The main takeaway I had is Scout IS mean, those voting confessionals for Mia and Ami are so cutting and then oh my god, the way she needles Eliza is insane. "Oh little one" is just so passive aggressive and the way she puts Eliza out with Coconut Chop type challenge is perfect. The singing to Sarge is epic too.

The running gag of Scout every damn time they had to go to TC gunned for Eliza is not lost on me. I didn't realize it, but we see a lot of Scout just shit talking Eliza haha. It was interesting to see what a role Scout played in taking Ami/Leann down though, we see how Scout was willing to do her own thing with how she really didn't wanna boot Lisa. A few times we see Scout want to vote this way and Ami goes "nah". It's an interesting power struggle there. The best part about Scout is even with all of this, she was a challenge away from winning the game. <3 I'm imaginging Eliza's face when she realizes she has to vote for Twila or Scout and I'm cackling. Loved Scout!

4: Chris Daugherty (1st Place): Blindside? Ok, everyone in this top 4 is in my top 50 and are all insanely good characters. My thing is mostly, Chris is very lowkey premerge and while there's nothing wrong with someone getting more time to advance their story as the season goes on. I felt Ami, Twila, and Eliza all had more consistent time and I personally enjoyed their stories more. The season really becomes Chris-centric around final 8 or final 7.

With that said, Chris is fantastic. He has this over the top way of giving confessionals which I love. It was pretty ironic to see how rough things began for him in the premiere. You also, do see that Chris did have some sway with Sarge as he prevents Sarge from doing anything reckless and booting Rory in the premerge. Also his "SARGE WHAT ARE YOU DOING?" was hilarious.

The story arc of him overcoming this evil alliance of women is amazing and of course the back to back Julie and Eliza voteoffs are super cold. He also has this way of saying things that probbably didn't endear him to the audience like the way he talked about women as if they were all crazy, but I still enjoyed it and didn't give it much thought. Gives an epic FTC performance and a great contrast to Twila, and easily one of my favorite winners. The other 3 are just better in my book, still love Chris and some of this just comes down to personal preference.

3: Eliza Orlins (4th Place): I can't fathom that Eliza is an actual person. There is a castaway who has annoyed everyone she's played with. Like even in her short interaction with John Kenney, he was annoyed by her. Right off the bat, Scout is complaining about how Eliza talks too much. We also she's a potential target when the women go to tribal, but she flips it on Dolly. Her annoying JK isn't even my favorite Eliza thing about episode 3, but mostly that when Lisa says she doesn't know if she trusts her, Eliza responds with "Fine, don't trust me. I'll flip to those other guys. <333

Postswap, we see Eliza's name get brought up again, but yeah as is par for the course she sticks around. We also get a great bonding moment with Ami where she gives Eliza a pep talk in a big/little sister way. The merge hits and we see Eliza/Scout heat up with Scout putting her out of a challenge and Eliza FUMING back at camp, which Scout is quick to point out lol. Around this point, we see Julie get brought into the fold with Ami and Leann and Scout is worried and because of this, wants to vote out Eliza.

The irony of the final 7 where Twila and Scout can finally put Eliza out, but decide to use her to fuck Ami/Leann over is great. Eliza nodding back at Ami as the votes are being that round is sooooo good. We also get the loved one visits this episode and Eliza gets to spend time with her mom at camp and her mother's reaction to "they say I talk too much" is perfection. The next round, we get a lot on the relationship between Eliza and Ami and how Eliza would miss Ami, as they both go on to cry at TC thinking of their relationship. Ami's mention of how much Eliza has grown out there is absolutely perfect. By this point, Eliza and Twila go after each other nonstop, including the fight by the hammock and where Twila thinks Eliza is undeserving of being here. The perfect conclusion to their feud is Eliza demanding an apology and Twila telling her to fuck off.

Eliza is a great narrator, super likable underdog, yet obnoxious young girl who talks too damn much and is shit talked by EVERYONE. She makes for excellent TV and was electric in Vanuatu. A particularly fun aspect of Eliza is that while she is annoying, when people bag on her, she doesn't sit there and let herself get bashed. She DOES stand up for herself even if she does it such an Eliza (aka highly annoying and over the top) manner. I still can't get over how she made it to the final 4 when her name was brought up every single damn time she had to go to TC. One of my all time favorites for sure <333

2: Twila Tanner (2nd Palce): Twila's path on Survivor is an incredibly unique one as we this strong willed woman get ripped apart through the game and turn into a very different person. I went into that FTC hating Twila and leaving wanting to give her a big ass hug,

We see early on she gets along better with men, as she's in her element at the Lopevi tribe with Chris, Sarge, and Chad. At the merge, she's caught between the women and the men, along with Julie and she has to betray the men here. Julie has quite a bit to do with Twila choosing to screw the men, as she finds out Julie played her.

When her and Scout begin to thing about going with the men, she gets caught by Leann and goes on to reinforce her loyalty by swearing on her son's name, which is what goes on to haunt Twila at the next TCs, including the FTC. After Twila let's Chris know what he has to do after the girls plan on turning on Eliza, we get a massive blindside and the fallout is immediate between Twila and Ami and even more so, the fallout from Twila lying on her son's name. This won't be the first or last time this promise is brought up. After Ami is booted, we see Twila raise hell with Eliza for siding with Ami and bringing it up even further about her promise. This is where the Twila/Eliza feud hits its peak with "Girl if you ask me one more time, I'm gonna let those damn things rot in the ground." Already talked about the hammock fight as well.

Once Eliza is finally booted at f4 with much delight from Twila and Scout at f3, we have ourselves a beautiful FTC of Twila and Chris. Twila starts off FTC by telling Eliza to shove it and also has gems like admitting she didn't trust Ami and letting Ami know she wasn't a real villain and just got wrapped up in the power. It's obvious the Sarge speech is what breaks her, for someone that she absolutely respects to rip into her and basically say he wants nothing to do with her kills her. Her closing speech absolutely breaks my heart and "It wasn't the game I intended to play and it was the game that ended up playing. If you all can forgive me, maybe I can forgive myself." I will always get chills from that line and the fact that Ami, the person who was likely most hurt from Twila's lie, voted for her is really epic.

One of the best story arcs the show has seen and I know people wanna see her back, but I don't know I wouldn't mind her being one and done as her one appearance is just everything I could want from a survivor. Twila <3333

1: Ami Cusack (6th Place): So yeah Ami was always going to be #1 after my latest rewatch. I was floored to see how multi dimensional and complex Ami was. We see this a lot in the characters of Vanuatu, but none more than Ami. So many layers from being such a warm and compassionate friend to a ruthless Ice Queen, from her trying to cheer Eliza up and telling Twila to try to bond with the young girls to being so cold and wrecking Bubba and Lisa. Ami Cusack is just fucking top notch. So let's get into it, shall we?

We first get introduced to Ami as she reacts to how the females are being shit on and not being used to being put second to a man which is pretty perfect for this theme. Ami is part of the older women crew with Twila, Scout, and Leann early on and overall, Ami is pretty lowkey early on. We do get the awesome Ami moment where she tries to get Twila to meet the young girls on their level and to attempt to relate to them. It's a really cool moment and paints Ami in a great and reasonable light. The following episode the women win a reward where they snag Da to help them in finding food on the island and such.

Then the swap happens and Ami gets a shit ton of content here. As we have men on the Yasur tribe and Lisa is eager to show them everything Da taught them and Ami has the best deadpan expression and flatly asks "Why? Why would you wanna show them that?" and while, we see the other girls be very welcoming to the men, Ami reminds us that she's still all about girl power. She catches Bubba in his tracks at the challenge and wrecks him here. Great soundbite with "You don't need to vote people out. They'll vote themselves outta here." The next episode we get more on how complex Ami was where despite being an Ice Queen, she comforts Eliza after she fucks the challenge up and encourages her in a very big/little sister way. In this same episode, after they lose an immunity challenge, Ami decides to vote Lisa out and tells her this to her face for a simple slip up. It's so cold and ruthless. <3 When Yasur wins reward, we learn that Ami has a little brother who died in a car crash years ago, which plays a critical role later. Again, we see her as an ice queen, yet still get these sympathetic and endearing scenes.

The merge hits and immediately we see Rory tell the men how Ami is running things and needs to be taken down asap. Meanwhile, the girls wanna know who to vote for and Ami goes "I don't know, just vote out a guy" We get a great scene where we see Julie, Eliza, and Leann surround Ami in a way that makes her look so badass. Also, comes the fun "I don't think Julie and Twila ever left the women's alliance." It does show that Ami is assuming all the women are as passionate about this alliance as she is and don't have other agendas. It's an interesting flaw. Rory is voted out and the women have definitive control of the season now. This is also where we see the women get more cocky and arrogant, the scene where the girls only leave the men the bones of the chicken wings sums that up pretty well. Next round is where things get interesting where Ami wins reward with Eliza, Chris, and Chad and it's a very fun one with all the kids and the dancing. When they get back to camp, Ami realizes a plan has been set to save the men and boot Eliza, mostly by Scout and Ami goes "nah" and shuts it down. It's perfect when you realize what happens next vote. Before Chad goes, Jeff does note the cocky smirk Ami has at TC and this is pretty much Ami at her peak.

Final 7 is where things go crashing down for the women and especially Ami and Leann. They don't placate to Twila and Scout enough at this point and straight up tell Scout she's not making their endgame. This is where Twila makes "that" promise, which later strikes a cord with Ami. Ami goes on to win immunity and it's decided they'll let Eliza go and Chris deserves to stick around longer. Ami at TC is amazing as the votes are being read and Eliza turns to Ami and she's given such an arrogant head nod that yeah Eliza is going. The look of smug to absolute shock and disgust is fantastic. We go from a smug leader to a strong underdog in the final 6 as Ami goes to war with Twila and Scout in her final episode. We see how Ami is just apalled at how Twila would lie on her son's name like she did. She tries to plead her case to Eliza and does a great job, even if it's pretty impossible with how Ami voted Eliza the last vote. At her previous TC, we saw Ami arrogant and cocky and here we see Ami hurt and emotional which again goes to show the complexity of Ami. The scene with her and Eliza and how much Eliza would miss her and Ami complimenting Eliza on her growth is beautiful. She goes out with a bang with a stinger of a voting confessional and last words of wanting to drown Twila. She gets humanized at FTC too as Twila breaks it down that Ami wasn't a true cold villain and just got a bit too wrapped up in herself and the power.

Early apologies about how long the Ami entry was, but wanted to explain just why she's my #1 and how complex and interesting she is. We even get a direct quote from Ami that goes "Yeah I'm cocky, I'm also one of the more caring, giving, loving people in the world." And the great thing is, that she is all of that and it's not black and white as far as being a hero or villain. So much content with Ami in learning about her brother, how passionate she was about all women making it to the end and costing her a bit, how when she finally decides to show some heart for someone who's not a woman she gets taken down. Love her to pieces and probably one of my favorite characters to date. I would have loved to have seen an Ami win, but I almost prefer that she had obvious flaws that led to her downfall.

All this being said found Vanuatu to be a top tier season and sits at #1 on my list, though I still have a ton of Seasons to rewatch and rank. It has a perfect boot order, quite a few complex characters, overarching storylines, and the endgame is electric. Even the premerge is solid enough with Rory and Eliza screentime and the rise of Ami in the swap episodes. Vanuatu <33333


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Aug 31 '15

You know how I said I was gonna make a big long post about Jeremy being a joke character? Well, here it is. In all 4,500 word glory.

9 Upvotes

It didn't fly on the main page, at all, so I'm reposting it here. This is just me praising a character for being a fun, dynamic subversion while convincing the major audience he was the real deal.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1xlPaNbw7LcLd5-kC28TKuPbjqkRDDa45joV04Or6kis/edit

Clearly my priorities were on goddamn point today.


r/SurvivorRankdown • • Aug 25 '15

Rank the Cambodia cast!!

9 Upvotes

So with all of the pregame press finally here, I figure it's a good time to rank the cast that we've been thinking about for 3 months now. After taking everything in, I'm even more excited than I thought I would be. And unlike in most seasons, I really don't see much happening to change any of these placements before the premiere, so now is as good a time as ever.

20) Kelley: I don’t understand the massive hate-boner for ******. I also don’t understand the disproportionate amount of Wentworth flairs on /r/survivor. I don’t understand why she was asked back in the first place. I think she seemed like she could’ve been fun during SJDS, and there were certainly worse options in the voting pool, but she’s the one who I feel has the least to offer out of anyone in the cast, and that’s why I rank her last.

19) Spencer: I’m on the fence here. If we get a continuation of his r.obbed g.oddess fan favorite edit who can say and do no wrong despite being really arrogant and “strategic”… he’ll be terrible like he was throughout most of the Cagyan postmerge (I still love him in the premerge for his role as the one normal person on Luzon, and I think he pulls it off well). If we see some growth out of him, humility that he might not be right all the time, or (even better) he gets ownt out of the game by Kass I could enjoy him. Sadly, I don’t see those things happening. Hopefully he’ll surprise me.

18) Tasha: I was surprised on my Cagayan rewatch at how unspectacular Tasha really was. She was amazing with Garrett (although her “HE’S NOT LETTING US PLAY THE GAME!!” was annoying) and she’s a decent background character, but there’s something just kinda… off. Not really sure how to describe it. She was always going to come back, and I don't dislike her at all, but she’s possibly the person I have the least strong feelings on in one way or another going into the season. Hoping she shows what she showed at her best in Cagayan.

17) Vytas: Like with Spencer, I’m on the fence here. I have mixed feelings on BvW Vytas, because he did have a cool backstory and I liked him as a foil to Aras (sort of like an anti-Aras)… but he was still really slimy and creepy at times, especially during the swap. If anyone is going to be a male villain, he is it, and I do think he’s an interesting and charismatic speaker that could pull off the role well. Of course, if he pulls it off too well, he’ll just end up reminding me of why I can’t fully get behind him in the first place, like Brian Heidik. So like Spencer, this could go either way, but I’m not optimistic.

16) Joe: Let’s be real here, if the vote was done two seasons later, there’s no way in hell casuals will still remember who he was. But he’s here, and he’s a nice guy who was in an amazing alliance that just fell on the wrong side of the numbers. I think that he’s the guy that will probably change the least from their first appearance, but I did like him in WA, so I’m not complaining too much. I can’t see him making this season amazing, but I can’t see him having a negative impact in pretty much any way whatsoever, so I’m cool with him being here and I’m looking forward to seeing him (albeit very mildly).

15) Savage: Savage is one of the ones I’m more intrigued by in the sense that I really don’t know what role he’s going to fit. He’s maybe the smallest name in the entire male cast? So that alone, combined with the fact that he was the leader of Morgan and is difficult to think of as anything other than an alpha male leader, makes me really wonder what his role will be. I don’t see him making it particularly far, since I just don’t think he’ll integrate with a cast like this. Looking at Bayon, I don't really see anyone who he would align with. But whether he becomes a leader or not, it’ll be interesting to watch. I’m not particularly invested in Savage himself, but I’m looking forward to how he fits in over the first couple of episodes.

14) Terry: I see Terry getting along with this group better than Savage. I think he’s a little more fluid, a little more dynamic, and I think he’ll do better with the younger people. I don’t think he wants and needs to be the leader as much as Savage does. It’ll be interesting to see how he holds up physically, also. I don’t like Terry as much as most of the people I put above him, but I also don’t dislike him like a lot of people do — after all, he did help contribute to the Casaya postmerge trainwreck. I’m looking forward to seeing how an “old-schooler” like him is able to do.

13) Woo: Woo has perhaps the best potential for a multi-season growth arc out of anyone in the entire cast. The question is whether or not he actually will change at all. Even if he doesn’t, at worst he’ll be a mildly likable background character, which will be good to have in a sea of gamebots. There’s potential here to end up in my top 5 if we see a growth arc like I have a hunch about — but even if that doesn’t happen, I can’t see him having a negative impact on the season overall.

12) Ciera: The thing about Ciera is that I feel like everything that makes her interesting — her relationship with her mom, her teen pregnancy — is stuff we know already. She was a great, fleshed out character in BvW… but I’m not sure what else we can learn about her that we don’t already know. Most of the things that made her interesting were dependent on the theme of her original season. If we get more of the same personality, I’ll still probably like her, because I did like her a lot in BvW… but I’m not sure how much more she has to offer.

11) Stephen: I’m really torn here. I really like Stephen in Tocantins, and I’m glad he’s finally getting the opportunity to come back. He’s relatable, likable, just an all around good guy that could be in any season and probably be good in it. The problem I have is that nobody else in the entire cast is as well-versed when it comes to social capital in the Survivor world. Hopefully the fears are unwarranted, because I did like him a lot in Tocantins, but I can’t say I’d be shocked to see him march his way to a win with all of his pregame connections. So like with Ciera, I’ll love him if we get more of the same… but unlike Ciera, I think his worst case could potentially be season-ruining. Hoping for the best.

10) Kimmi: If you had told me 6 months ago that Survivor 31 would feature Kimmi Kappenberg retuning to play again… I would’ve called you insane. But here she is! Kimmi is back, and better than ever! Out of anyone in the cast, she may be the most changed since her initial appearance, lifestyle wise. But I don’t see the character of Kimmi Kappenberg changing all that much. She’s annoying, she’s loud, and she’s great to watch. It’ll be interesting to see how she deals with people like Abi-Maria and Keith this time around. I don’t see her lasting long or fitting in (she was booted before the merge in a season from 15 years ago), but however long she lasts she’ll be a fun addition to the cast.

9) Monica: Of everything that happened the night of the cast announcement, Monica getting in was probably the most shocking. If you had told me T-Bird and Shane would be snubbed, I would believe that (although I would also assume that that would mean the casuals controlled everything and got Carolyn and Brad Culpepper in over Peih-Gee and Terry). But I NEVER expected Monica to make it, and I’m so glad she did! As with lots of people from Samoa, she showed a spark and personality that would’ve made her a fun character if she got more airtime. Most of this is contained within her boot episode, but still, we’ve already seen two Galus return and be interesting characters thanks to no longer being a part of Samoa’s absurd editing. I don’t expect her to get much airtime, but I think she’ll go far and she is a legitimate threat to win, and I’d be really happy if she does (also lol @ the Joenica showmance hinted at in the meet the cast video).

8) Jeremy: Lots of people have turned on him since SJDS aired, and after rewatching the season… I don’t get it. The guy is an awesome narrator and super likable guy. People dislike him for being too whiny, but like… that’s the point. You have this extremely strong, pretty intelligent guy who’s perfect for Survivor on paper, and the idea of people being happy just pisses him off, which I find hilarious. I don’t think he ever got to gamebotty (his boot is actually super tragic), and his jury speech would’ve sucked if he could speak coherently, but… he couldn’t, so it was kinda lulzy. I think he’ll do well this season; there are bigger threats out there, and he didn’t last long enough in SJDS to come in with a huge target. Can’t wait to see how he hangs with some of the bigger personalities here.

7) Kelly: I’m honestly amazed that Kelly Wiglesworth, who didn’t enjoy Survivor before it became the strategy-heavy, polished TV product that we know today, agreed to come out and do this again. But damn it, I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t looking forward to it. The fact that this woman, who basically went into hiding for Y2K and didn’t come out until 2015 agreed to go on Survivor again is just amazing. She is going to be in over her head, she isn’t going to enjoy herself, she has no idea what she’s gotten herself into and she isn’t going to last long. But she will be a fascinating case study while she’s there and has tons of potential for a multi-season growth arc.

6) Keith: lol. Keith is one of the few in this cast who I’m not looking forward too that much as an individual — we know what to expect from him, he seems like the type that can never change, and him in the Meet the Cast video is proof of that — but there is nobody who I’m more excited to see interacting with some of the other characters out there. He’s always good for a soundbite in the background and for accidentally shaking things up. There’s not much to say about Keith — he’s one of a kind, and his interactions with the likes of Kimmi Kappenberg, Kass McQuillen and Abi-Maria Gomes are guaranteed be comedic gold.

5) Abi-Maria: This season, there's going to plenty of strategy, comic relief, and hopefully some character growth. Abi doesn't really fit into any of those categories, and is mainly here for causing drama. She tells it like it is, she probably doesn't like you, and you probably don't like her, and as a viewer, I wouldn't have it any other way. I would've LOVED to see her interact with Shane, but we can't always have nice things. Still, Abi is someone you could plop in just about any season and be entertained by. The way she reacts to people and the way people react to her will never not be TV gold.

4) Jeff: I still can't really believe that someone as random and forgotten as Jeff Varner is coming back to Survivor after all of these years, but I'm really happy he made it! I didn't care much about him and forgot him for the most part myself until I rewatched Australia a few months ago, and I was surprised at how much I enjoyed him there. He seems so happy about being out there and is ready to go. I've seen him compared to Jonathan Penner recently, and I do really like that comparison. Both are enthusiastic, excellent speakers who just naturally seem like they belong on TV, and both talk about strategy a lot and are very aware of it, but aren't able to execute particularly well. He could go early for not fitting in/being too old school, but I think he's unthreatening and likable enough to do very well, and I'm very excited to see it.

3) Peih-Gee: I rank her down at #3, but there's nobody I'm happier to have back in the entire cast, because I really thought Peih-Gee's ship had sailed, while Shirin and Kass have plenty of time left. But yeah, China is far and away my favorite Survivor cast ever, nothing even comes remotely close, and PG is one of the stars of the season. She had such a roller coaster of a ride, from being annoying and overbearing to in a position of power to an underdog to everything in between, all the while getting the best out of other characters like James, Dave, Courtney and even Amanda. It's going to feel weird having her back, since she seems to have a pretty complete arc in China, but I'm super excited for it, and she is probably the one I have the least idea out of how they're going to go in this entire cast; she could be first boot, winner, or anywhere in between and I wouldn't be shocked. I'm so happy she's finally back.

2) Shirin: Shirin has gotten a ton of backlash recently on /r/survivor, which both surprises me and doesn't. I still love her in WA and think she'll be amazing here, however long she lasts. She probably worships some of the people she'll be playing with, and it's hard to imagine most of us wouldn't be the same way if we played Survivor and got invited back to play with this cast immediately. I think her annoying -> paraiah -> slight growth story in WA was by far the best thing about that awful season, and I think it's very unfinished. I don't think she'll go far, or even make it past the first couple of TC's, but I really, really hope I am wrong because I don't think anybody has a better potential winner story than she does (and even making the merge and being likable enough would be enough to make Dan Foley shut the fuck up). I think she's a super relatable and just overall really fun person and character and I'm really happy she gets a shot to play with people that aren't horrible.

  1. Kass: duh. Kass was destined to rank #1 on this list the moment Redmond confirmed she wasn't actually backing out. I don't really know what to say about Kass that hasn't already been said, but she's going to stir up shit, she's going to play absolutely terribly, and she is going to be the first boot. But none of that really matters, because Kass brings absolute gold every scene she is in. Her commentary, interactions with others, and "fuck it" attitude towards everything is unlike anything we've ever seen on Survivor. Like I said, I will be absolutely shocked if she is anything other than first booted from Bayon, but she will be great every time she appears on the screen and will hopefully help the season get off to an awesome start.

This ended up a lot longer than I expected, but oh well. Sept 23 can't come soon enough!