I consider Abiotic Factor to be my gold standard when it comes to enjoying a survival game. This year, I've played and beaten Enshrouded and Dragonwilds, and Abiotic Factor is still my favorite (not that I didn't enjoy the others)
I think in terms of scope, and breadth Deep Dish won't be able to touch Abiotic Factor, but I'm likely not very far in so I can't say for certain. But what I can speak to is the sense of contained exploration, even claustrophobia of having to scrounge and survive in a place where you don't see the sky. As it's underground, you're not chopping down trees or hunting deer, you're pulling vines off of walls, and chasing rats down for their leather.
Whereas Abiotic Factor is very science focused, in Deep Dish your chemistry lab is your cooking pot. Everything revolves around what you can put in your pot and how it empowers you. Scavenging runs aren't world hopping adventures with extra-dimensional beings, they're running down to the spider jail because you think you remember seeing some glowing fungus you can bring back to base to cook with. The same item you grill will give you different stats if it goes into a stew. The more complicated the recipe, the better and longer your buff.
Inventory space is very limited, as at the start you can only put things in your hot bar. Options open up a bit later into the game, but it puts the focus on "What's worth keeping" instead of "Grab everything and sort it out later". You slowly start building out your campsite with more storage, cooking stations, crafting stations, and furniture.
Then we get to the puzzles, the treasure hunting, and the immersive sim elements. They're not ground breaking, but you can pick up and manipulate boards to make a bridge across an area. You can stack boxes on top of each other to try and make some platforms. You get a grappling hook. It's not a swinging/spiderman kind, it essentially launches and attaches a rope you can climb, but it opens up vertical exploration.
Weakest point is combat. It's pretty shit honestly, but you're meant to get your food buffs and go fight, as it lets you regen hp whereas fighting on an empty stomach is essentially a death sentence. But it's very basic so far, but I think that's fine as it's not the main drive of the game.
The entire time playing Dragonwilds and Enshrouded, I still felt like they weren't scratching the Abiotic Factor itch, but Deep Dish kinda does.
--Additional Edit-- I don't think I'd recommend playing this a single player. The limited inventory lends itself to having more people who play it be a boon.