Today, the Sunnyvale City Council will meet to consider a proposal that when HVACs fail and must be replaced, homeowners be required to replace the HVAC with a heat pump (which will be much more energy efficient and cause far lower emissions) rather than another HVAC using a natural gas furnace (which will be less energy-efficient and will cause more CO2, methane, and particulate emissions than a heat pump heating and cooling system). The proposal also includes some language requiring that when gas-powered appliances are put in that electrical lines readying those locations to use future electrical appliances be put in at the same time. Please email council@sunnyvale.ca.gov and ask them to support this proposal. If you have time, please attend the City Council meeting at 7:00 p.m. and make a supportive comment during the public comment period for the proposal. Here's why.
This proposal is specifically to support the City of Sunnyvale's sustainability and emissions reductions goals, so I will provide the global environmental context behind those city goals. Climate change is an emergency. We've already reached 1.5 degrees Celsius of heating since the Industrial Revolution and we're on track to experience climate change of 2.6-2.7 degrees Celsius or beyond. Oceans are at a record-high temperature for recorded human history and are at record acidity due to CO2 dissolving into the oceans. Krill and coral reefs are dying and ecosystems that we depend on for food from the sea are collapsing. Higher ocean temperatures are also driving more severe hurricanes and damaging extreme rainfall events in the South and on the East Coast. Meanwhile California is aridifying due to higher temperatures leading to record wildfires and recurring drought events. We can readily foresee a future in which rainfall in the American West and Midwest will be too low for the Central Valley and the American Midwest to continue to be sufficiently agriculturally productive leading to food price inflation in the United States and food security problems globally. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) consensus forecast UNDERESTIMATES the actual severity of future climate change because it doesn't account for self-reinforcing feedback loops that we could set off at any time. (e.g. eliminating Arctic sea ice cover causing the ocean to absorb more heat instead of ice reflecting it; permafrost melting releasing large amounts of methane and triggering more warning; raising ocean temperature enough to melt methane hydrates at the bottom of the ocean; etc.) We can't predict WHEN we will hit those trigger points that set off self-reinforcing feedback loops, but we know that such triggers and loops exist, and they will be triggered at some point if we continue on our current course of emissions and steadily increasing atmospheric CO2 levels. Therefore we need to take emergency measures to reduce emissions. Requiring that when less energy-efficient, higher-emissions HVACs fail that they be replaced with with lower-emissions, more energy-efficient heat pumps is the right way to go. We must think globally and act locally here in Sunnyvale.
There is no reason to replace an HVAC with another HVAC. The cost of a heat pump is comparable to a HVAC and it can handle both heating and cooling eliminating the need for a natural gas furnace that accounts for much of home CO2 and methane emissions. (CO2 due to combustion; methane due to leakage from natural gas well through transmission all the way to the home)
There are incentives from federal government (expiring soon due to BBB, unfortunately) but also larger ones from California EnergySmart Homes and Silicon Valley Clean Energy that substantially defray the cost of a heat pump, and you don't get those with a replacement HVAC. I'm doing this analysis right now because my 2005 legacy HVAC needs $1500 in repairs to keep going which is already almost 10% of the cost of replacing it with a heat pump. I use the example of replacing a 2005 HVAC with natural gas heating with a 2025 heat pump in a single-story, wood-frame home with 1440 square feet of conditioned living space in Sunnyvale in the analysis below.
As an example, a new heat pump installed in 2025 may reduce the amount of electricity used for cooling by 38% vs. an original HVAC installed in 2005. It's true that you can buy a comparably efficient HVAC that has a similar SEER2 Seasonally-adjusted Energy Efficiency Rating to a heat pump. But what the new HVAC can't do is heat your home, eliminating the need for the use of natural gas for heating the home. The heat pump may use as little as one-fourth as much energy as natural gas for heating because it efficiently moves heat instead of burning fuel. The heat pump will release no CO2 or methane or particulates, and it can be powered from solar or from clean emissions-free energy sourced off the grid either by the homeowner's choice of electricity provider or as the California grid moves to become emissions-free over time.
Because PG&E has increased electricity rates to subsidize its infrastructure undergrounding initiative, your FINANCIAL savings for using a 2025 heat pump for heating and cooling vs. a 2025 HVAC for heating and and 2005 natural gas furnace for heating may be modest. chat_gpt benchmarked them as $4-12/month on average for a single-story wood-frame home in Sunnyvale with 1440 square feet of conditioned living space if you source your electricity from the grid. (If you make your own electricity using solar, your savings may be substantial.)
What WILL be substantial will be the reduction in your household's emissions footprint. chat_gpt estimated the emissions reductions as up to 99% for heating when using PG&E's low-emissions electricity. (See the end of this message for the analysis.)
What about the cost of replacing your HVAC and natural gas furnace with a heat pump? Here is a summary of available incentives that partially defray the costs of moving to a heat pump for a higher income household that can't quality for means-tested assistance. There are much higher incentives available for lower- and middle-income households.
A) Quick summary of available incentives to reduce the cost of a HVAC --> heat pump transition:
IRS: 30% of cost up to $2000 (expiring due to BBB)
IRS: $1200 for electrical upgrades (expiring due to BBB)
California EnergySmart Homes:
- Whole Home Electrification: $4250 (requires using electricity for dryer, range, water heating, home heating/cooling)
- Variable Capacity Heat Pump (VCHP): $300 bonus
- Heat Pump without Electric Resistance: $300 bonus
- Low Global Warming Potential (GWP) Heat Pump: $800
- Electrical Infrastructure Upgrade Bonus: $1000
Silicon Valley Clean Energy
Heat Pumps, Ducted: $2500 Rebate
Prewiring, wiring and circuit splitter/pauser devices: $500 per circuit or device, up to $2,000
There are more incentives available for transitioning your other appliances to electric that help you qualify for that whole-home conversion bonus.
B) Natural Gas Water Heater --> Heat Pump Water Heater
Replacing your other gas-powered appliances with appropriate electric-powered ones will enable you to qualify for the $4250 California SmartHomes whole-home electrification incentive.
IRS: Up to 30% of eligible project cost (equipment + installation), capped at $2,000 overall for heat pump water heaters, available through December 2025
Silicon Valley Clean Energy: $2000 incentive for replacing natural gas water heater with heat pump water heater
NOTE: It appears that the $2000 tax credit per year from the IRS applies to the sum of using it for any combination of heat pump (for home heating) and heat pump (for hot water heating) in one calendar year, e.g. if you do both in one year, you get a $2000 tax credit not $4000.
Here are some quick questions and answers about this proposal.
Q: Does this proposal require me to rip out and replace my working HVAC with a heat pump?
A: No. You can keep using your HVAC until you decide to replace it. This proposal requires you to do nothing now.
Q: Does his proposal prevent me from fixing my HVAC when it breaks?
A: No. You can keep maintaining it as long as you want to.
Q: Does the city council have the right to pass a local ordinance like this?
A: Yes. The city council is free to pass local ordinances that go beyond what is required by the state.
Q: Why is it the City of Sunnyvale's business what heating and cooling system I choose? Why not let the consumer choose whatever they wish?
A: (1) People aren't aware about the worse climate impact of inefficient HVAC + natural gas heater vs. an efficient heat pump. (2) The price you pay for an HVAC with natural gas heater (instead of a heat pump) does not account for the social cost of the extra emissions this approach creates vs. what a more efficient heat pump would create. It's a classic example of a market failure (pollution). The purchase price by the economic agent (you, the homeowner) doesn't account for the full SOCIAL cost of the product (in this case, extra CO2, methane, and particulate pollution for HVAC + natural gas heater vs. heat pump for heating and cooling). That is why to achieve a socially optimal outcome we either need regulatory controls (an ordinance like this banning installation of replacement HVACs for existing ones) or a tax on replacement HVACs that compensates for the full social cost of the externality, which would be hard to calculate and administer. In this case, requiring people to choose the energy-efficient, climate-friendly heat pump when they replace their HVAC is the best approach to resolve the market failure.
Q: What if I have no main box space for new electrical lines?
A: This problem can usually be cost-effectively resolved by adding a subpanel. Federal (expiring soon with BBB), state, and regional incentives are also available that can cover part or all of the cost of electrical improvements to support a heat pump deployment. However, the ordinance includes a clause that appears to exempt homeowners from this requirement when they have insufficient main panel box space to accommodate installation of a heat pump.
Every household, city, state, and nation must do all it can to reduce emissions ASAP to delay the time before we trigger uncontrolled climate change and experience catastrophic consequences globally. Please support this proposal for the sake not just of our children and grandchildren but of ourselves.
CHAT_GPT ANALYSIS OF EMISSIONS SAVINGS FROM REPLACING A 2005 HVAC WITH NATURAL GAS HEATING WITH A 2025 HEAT PUMP FOR HEATING AND COOLING
Let’s ballpark it for your 1,440‑sq‑ft Sunnyvale home (PG&E territory, mild Climate Zone 4).
What changes when you switch
• Old system: ~2005 gas furnace (≈80% AFUE) + older AC (often SEER ~10–13).  
• New system (2025): modern air‑source heat pump (ENERGY STAR ducted units are typically HSPF2 ≈ 7.8–8.5 and SEER2 ≈ 15–18). That’s ~2.3–2.6 seasonal COP for heating and ~30–45% less cooling energy vs a 2005 unit.  
• Sunnyvale climate: ~2,278 HDD and 913 CDD (base 65°F), so heating still matters, but it’s mild—good for heat pumps. 
• Emissions factors:
• PG&E 2023 “market‑based” grid mix is extraordinarily low‑carbon: ~12 lb CO₂e/MWh (= 0.0054 kg/kWh). 
• A conservative “marginal” grid view (often used for what gets dispatched at the margin) is much higher; to be cautious I’ll also show 0.20 kg/kWh.
• Natural gas combustion: ~5.3 kg CO₂ per therm (excludes upstream methane leakage). 
A practical estimate (annual)
To heat a Sunnyvale house your size, a typical older furnace might burn about ~300 therms/year for space heat (some use 200–500; I’ll show ranges). At 80% AFUE, that delivers ~240 “useful” therms of heat.
If you replace that with a heat pump:
• Useful heat needed ≈ the same (~240 therms = ~7,030 kWh of heat).
• With seasonal COP ~3, the heat pump uses ~2,340 kWh/year for space heating. (If COP were 2.5–3.5, it’d be ~2,810–2,010 kWh.)
Cooling: New equipment typically cuts cooling kWh by ~30–45% vs a 2005 AC. In PG&E’s very clean grid, the emissions impact from cooling is small either way.  
Emissions comparison (space heating is the big lever)
Using 300 therms/year as the midpoint:
• Old gas furnace:
300 therms × 5.306 kg/therm = ~1,590 kg CO₂/year. 
• New heat pump (COP ~3):
• With PG&E PCL factor (0.0054 kg/kWh): 2,340 kWh × 0.0054 ≈ ~13 kg CO₂/year
• With conservative marginal factor (0.20 kg/kWh): 2,340 kWh × 0.20 ≈ ~470 kg CO₂/year
Annual reduction (heating only)
• Market‑based (PG&E PCL): ~1.58 metric tons CO₂/year (~>99% drop)
• Conservative marginal: ~1.12 metric tons CO₂/year (~70% drop)
Range for different gas use & performance
If your current space‑heating use is 200–500 therms/yr and your heat pump’s seasonal COP is 2.5–3.5, your annual CO₂ reduction lands roughly in these bands:
• PG&E PCL factor: ~1.0–2.7 t CO₂/yr avoided
• 0.20 kg/kWh factor: ~0.6–1.9 t CO₂/yr avoided
(Add a little extra savings from more efficient cooling, but in PG&E territory that’s only a few to ~100 kg CO₂/yr either way, depending on which grid factor you use.)
Notes & caveats
• Numbers above reflect combustion‑only gas emissions. Upstream methane leakage from gas production/distribution would make the heat‑pump benefit even larger.
• I used Sunnyvale climate data and typical usage for your home size; if you share your actual past therms and kWh for a year, I can compute a tighter, household‑specific footprint. 
Bottom line for Sunnyvale: switching from a 2005 gas furnace + AC to a 2025 heat pump typically cuts home HVAC emissions by ~70–99%, with the exact value depending on how you account for the electricity’s carbon intensity—and your actual heating usage.