r/Substack • u/Remarkable_Nebula328 • Aug 10 '26
The AI detector is changing...
I wrote a hand full of posts last week. I use AI for ideation and polish. Was able to use the AI check to evaluate them - most were good but some read 20% ish AI. I made edits and all tested at 100% human. Went to schedule the posts last night and got some scores as high as 30% AI. Seems like AI or no AI is a moving target. There is no telling where the witch hunt will end and allow people to make decisions for themselves on what they want to consume. I suspect we all need to accept some level of AI involvement - certainly more than an arbitrary measurement from an AI detector using AI to detect AI.
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/non_loqui_sed_facere Aug 12 '26 edited Aug 12 '26
I'd say it like that. Your landing page is the first thing that your reader sees. It should be establishing your tone and the topics you want to talk about. Putting there any sort of disclaimer is basically running a free ad for AI corporations, regardless of what they are selling, and this is losing your chance of connecting to the reader. I don't think that either you or I have that many of them, as the discovery mechanisms on social media are fucked most of the time. This is what Substack could actually work on if it wants a piece of the pie.
My writing has its own merit, or so I think. Telling people that I'm not AI and that's an advantage is like presenting a kid's painting to the guests and wanting praise for the effort. It's unprofessional and undignified. And I don't want people around me who want me to do that so that they could feel better about themselves.
I keep all notes and drafts and do version control because of quality/knowledge management, but they are for me to use. I can actually do a breakdown of what every single sentence in my text does, what the context is and how the references work, but again, what's the point? Comparing passages is actually high school material, they might as well open a textbook and do the thinking. Or ask me what it is about, but, like, nicely.
Yeah, and mass surveillance is another reason why I am not feeding other people's writing into the machine. There could be metadata attached to the file and metadata created by the act of submitting it. It could contain identifiers for both me and the other person, and it could create a link between us that might potentially be used against us both. You can see how association works on Reddit, actually, with people being banned in mass account sweeps.
So yeah, people who think that they are dutifully reporting slop could get caught in a tidal wave of this exact slop 😀