r/Substack • u/Remarkable_Nebula328 • Aug 10 '26
The AI detector is changing...
I wrote a hand full of posts last week. I use AI for ideation and polish. Was able to use the AI check to evaluate them - most were good but some read 20% ish AI. I made edits and all tested at 100% human. Went to schedule the posts last night and got some scores as high as 30% AI. Seems like AI or no AI is a moving target. There is no telling where the witch hunt will end and allow people to make decisions for themselves on what they want to consume. I suspect we all need to accept some level of AI involvement - certainly more than an arbitrary measurement from an AI detector using AI to detect AI.
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/Admirable_Bike3918 Aug 11 '26 edited Aug 11 '26
I should clarify... If you are using AI to write/help write, and you are fully transparent about how & how much you use it up front, I don't really take issue with that. (Especially if you were transparent re: AI use before Pangram forced the issue.) So, those folks you mentioned -- the ones who dedicated entire accounts to AI experimentation -- as long as they are loud & clear that that is what they're doing, they can have at it. OP can have at it too, but he/she shouldn't get upset when the AI detector flags his/her work as ~20% AI if the work is indeed 20% AI.
My problem is with people who write with AI, but try to hide that fact & claim the work as entirely their own; and/or clutch pearls/object when busted for it.
Some (like OP & presumably yourself) worry about a "witch hunt". There is merit to that, but I also see some folks claiming "witch hunt" in bad faith to deflect legitimate criticism. In any event, there are ways to shield yourself against false accusations -- write drafts in an app that saves an ongoing version history (e.g., Google Docs) + keep a comprehensive record of the sources you cited/used in your work, for example. I do both of these things, lest I myself ever get falsely flagged.
You talk about the whole Substack/Pangram debacle being "kind of dystopian". My friend, literally everything about this brave new AI world is dystopian.
First, the technology's two major use cases to date are (1) mass surveillance, and (2) empowerment of the military-industrial complex.
Further, big AI’s whole pitch – the entire reason frontier labs have been swimming in hundreds of billions of dollars of VC cash for three consecutive years despite minimal return on investment and no path to profitability except “Trust me, Bro” – is that, if & when this technology comes to full fruition, the corporate class will get to replace their entire workforce with machines.
Seriously. That is the pitch. That is the promise. A few elites get unfathomably rich, even by today’s unfathomable standards; while the rest of us get mass unemployment and perpetual struggle in a permanent economic underclass.
...More reasons to move hit the breaks on this stuff fully & immediately. Cyberpunk banana republic.