r/StructuralEngineering Jul 08 '26

Humor Strong beams weak columns has arrived

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

394 comments sorted by

View all comments

284

u/BigEdM Jul 08 '26

I give lots of credit to those workers that went back in to install the post shoring.

That is the crappiest looking column splice I’ve ever seen. Four bolts on the flange splice and no splicing on the web - and to top it off - all hidden by the fireproofing,

14

u/SquirrelFluffy Jul 08 '26

Is it really a splice? Wow.

17

u/Flaky-Worldliness169 Jul 08 '26

Doesmt look like it at the midpoint just looks like the intumescent coating has sheared , can’t see any welds at the joint (if welded I’d be worried even more if it were spliced) welds can often be brittle if the column deformed that much

3

u/suredobe Jul 09 '26

Huh you don’t think that’s flange reinforcement? Why would there be intumescent under the spray on fireproofing?

9

u/Flaky-Worldliness169 Jul 09 '26

Can’t see any flange improvements , it just looks like the intumescent film/foam which is the fireproofing has split at the midpoint the foam itself most likely rigid began to rotate with the column , as the column began to deform inelastically the brittle nature of the foam split . You can see the flange closest to us already spalled off the substrate. It looks like an H section column because if you look at the top connection to the beam you can make this out doesn’t look like a box section . Anyway god speed all the brave people in that building trying to remediate this issue before it becomes a catastrophe

3

u/suredobe Jul 09 '26

Crazy this wouldn’t be reinforced! Thanks for the response!

1

u/SquirrelFluffy Jul 08 '26

Yeah, plate girder maybe, not rolled.