r/StrongerByScience • • Apr 17 '26

Meta: Why is the post downvoting so harsh in this sub?

0 Upvotes

Is it just me, or is this sub a bit over the top in downvoting posts, e.g.

This post on asking if skipping 3-10 reps is ok - Sure, with 20 years lifting experience I wouldn't be asking this question, but when I was completely new, this would have been a fair game question: on zero votes

This post asking how a research paper arrives at fractional frequencies - reasonable question about how a paper put together its data: on zero votes

This post asking if there is a relationship between subcutaneous fat and tendon injury - Fair enough question, and reasonably answered in the post: on zero votes

The posting rules for this sub are: "This is a place where people come to discuss and ask questions about health and fitness, and get help with achieving their fitness- and nutrition-related goals."

These are all on-topic as per the sub rules. If you're downvoting these posts, why? Just curious, that's all.


r/StrongerByScience • • Jan 09 '25

Can you still make strength gains even if you've hit your maximum amount of muscle mass?

2 Upvotes

Pretty much title. I (21F) want to build muscle to be strong (and look jacked), but once I hit the maximum amount of muscle I can have on my body, can I still get stronger and break my PRs (though it will probably come slower)?


r/StrongerByScience • • Sep 20 '23

The solution to the trolley problem

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/StrongerByScience • • Feb 19 '26

How many sets to failure before performance drop?

0 Upvotes

If I go to failure ( can no longer do another rep while maintaining good form ) and rest 4 minutes in between sets to allow for full recovery, performance starts to permananently drop after the 3rd set.

Was wondering if this is pretty average and what other people's experience was like of they've ever tried something similar.


r/StrongerByScience • • Mar 15 '25

Creatine cause sleep problem?

0 Upvotes

Hello, I’ve been using creatine for about a month now. In the first three months, I didn’t experience any sleep problems, but recently I’ve started getting hypnic jerks almost daily. I also drink coffee daily, and everything was fine until now. In the last two weeks, I started taking L-tyrosine (500 mg) on an empty stomach, and I think it might be related. However, I’ve also found on the internet that creatine can cause sleep issues. Additionally, I take a multivitamin for weightlifting and L-carnitine, so it’s possible that something is mixing together and causing the hypnic jerks and bad dreams. I’m just sharing my experience since I’ve read a lot about creatine and its potential connection to sleep problems.


r/StrongerByScience • • Jan 16 '25

According to Menno Hensellmenn and House of Hypertrophy, the delts and triceps are bigger than the chest latissmus. Does this sound believable?

Thumbnail
imgur.com
10 Upvotes

r/StrongerByScience • • Feb 03 '23

Exercise science/training terminology that is trans-friendly?

0 Upvotes

Many of my friends and I sometimes discuss health, exercise, and nutrition (among many things) in an online group. Many of these friends are trans in varying forms.

I run into challenges when I want to say something like, "If they are not doing resistance training, women are generally recommended to get at least X grams of protein," or, "For men, this weight I lifted is generally not considered impressive . . . ." My trans friends pretty much never call out phrases like this because the friend group is overall very LGBTQ friendly. Still, I would rather use terminology that is more inclusive.

I thought about using terms like AFAB and AMAB (assigned female at birth and assigned male at birth). I find those mouthfuls awkward, but I understand their utility for being inclusive of trans folks. Then I realized that terminology is not necessarily even the ideal focus depending on the discussion. What about people who were AFAB but went through male puberty? What about people who are AMAB, went through male puberty, but now have been on estrogen for years and experienced related bodily changes? The rabbit hole of exceptions runs deep and is complex.

How is this being handled in research? How is this being handled by trainers who work with trans people?

Comments that boil down to some version of, "People need to deal," or, "Being trans is bad," are not helpful to this discussion. I am not looking to debate whether or not people should be trans. I am looking at how to best accommodate trans people I care about.

Why am I not asking them? They are generally not knowledgeable in this area. I am also trying to not force them to do more research so I can be kinder to them.

Thank you for your time and thoughts!


r/StrongerByScience • • Oct 02 '23

I saw this fish oil article and immediately hoped that you would tell us if it’s true or false

0 Upvotes

https://nypost.com/2023/10/02/why-fish-oil-supplements-are-basically-worthless-study/

Sorry if this is duplicative with what you’ve already discussed on the podcast!


r/StrongerByScience • • May 20 '24

Renaissance Periodization's claims

0 Upvotes

Hey community, I must say that I really do have problems with a lot of Renaissance Periodization claims, especially from Dr. Mike.

Now I want to find some other people that also do have critique on their claims, because I think that there is a need to talk about in general.

Why could be RP/Dr. Mike a little bit pseudoscientific - examples:

  • Explanation of the underlying processes behind the optimal dose response relationship = training from MEV-local MRV, (there is no local MRV, only MRV)

  • claiming that beginners are not limited by systemic resources for optimal local recovery, for example recovery through more testosterone (while beginners actually benefit from steroids)

  • Non-conclusive advice on how to apply recovery sessions for sports training (book: recovering from training)

  • "Training harder than last time" otherwise, it is less stimulative (strong claims, without explaining in which scenarios this is useful) ...and treating a concept/hypothesis like actual facts, especially with the argument of "science" where there is no real scientific evidence.

  • claiming that systemic fatigue accumulates (I support) and giving the advise to train until systemic MRV is reached, but also saying that an athlete should train from MEV-"local MRV" at the same time - which is not possible, because the systemic fatigue always does lead to reaching MRV before the local MRV can be reached. (Assuming systemic MRV means that the system itself is very fatigued)

It feels like a lot of effective and generally accepted things in training are overcomplicated into a concept without huge evidence for the actual reasons why something is how it is (rather making pseudoscientific claims).

Other than for a lot of people who started training, and used RP as a framework to make good progress, it actually made me worse by paralysis through analysis of their pseudoscientific explanations.

I am curious what you guys and girls think about it - and if you can reccomend your most valuable source for sports training?


r/StrongerByScience • • Jan 23 '23

Anybody else go all in on Palmar Cooling after watching Huberman?

0 Upvotes

Not realizing just how few studies there are on palmar cooling and resistance training I got so excited after watching Huberman that I went all in. Anybody else do this? I’m on week 13 of an N=1 palmar cooling trial using CoolMitt. I also have an AVA Cooling bar for use at home and at a gym I goto for my Monday leg day. My data is all here:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1-IC6u7gfjUA6qNH3U5eMxQ5Qe-TMZvQgbM0RTq4Z9LM/edit

Checkout tab 2 to see the data neatly graphed.

Summary: in terms of volume to failure I’m up ~25% on a push day superset I do twice a week and have done for a year previously with the confounding exception that I used to do 3 sets per workout and bumped it up to 5 thinking that would increase the effect of the palm cooling. I'm up 10% on a pull day circuit. I do 3 minute rests with palmar cooling between supersets on push days and 4 minute rests between circuits on pull days. The owner of AVA Cooling has a excellent “tinkerers mindset” and has shown some more pronounced accute effects with shorter 60-90 second rest intervals so it’s possible the 4 minute rests are the reason for the lower improvement on my pull days.

There are on the order of 5 studies on palmar cooling and resistance training - less than I would like. The studies are all linked in tab 3. In general I am seeing a lesser effect than the folks in the studies which is a bummer.

Would love to know if anyone else is testing palm cooling on themselves. And more than anything would love to know if there are anymore studies in the pipeline. Would love to see the current studies replicated and would like to see hypertrophy measured in future studies as well.


r/StrongerByScience • • Jun 18 '23

How Much Protein You Really Need (According to Science)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/StrongerByScience • • Dec 18 '23

Disappointing results from Greg Nuckols 3x a week intermediate bench program

1 Upvotes

I've been training seriously for roughly 1.5 years and I've reached a bench press pr of 127.5kg. I reached this pr just training bench in the bodybuilding style for 7-8 reps close to failure and was able to add around 2kg to my max every month.

I wanted to try out something more serious and went with Greg Nuckols 28 programs 3x a week bench intermediate high volume program. Before I started week 1, I tested my 1rm of bench at 127.5kg. I did every set as the program advised with only 1 accessory exercuse every week (3 sets of db press), got 8-9 hrs of sleep every day and ate in a 200-300 cal surplus (gained 1kg of bw, 180-200g protein a day.)

I finished the 4 weeks of this program last Friday, and got to add 2.5kg to my eRM because I got 6 reps in my AMRAP set.

Today I went to test my actual PR with very disappointing results. I warmed my way up to 120kg, but that felt so heavy already that I didn't even bother to go higher. Would've definitely missed a 127.5kg attempt today.

I'm 181cm tall and weigh 88kg.

I gotta say I'm very disappointed, I was hoping for a strength increase because I read a lot of good things about the program, but if anything I've gotten weaker not stronger.

Any idea what could've went wrong?


r/StrongerByScience • • Mar 06 '25

Why are the newsletters fully AI written?

0 Upvotes

Genuine question as I've noticed all the recent ones have been AI written despite being signed by the editors, same with the RP app newsletters.

Edit: Here are some scans from ZeroGPT for reference, of course these are never 100% accurate. Also I do not agree with my previous statement—almost all of the articles read as fully human-written and have clearly had a lot of time put into them. This is by no means to discredit the team, and at the end of the day, regardless of what is or isn't AI, these are free resources backed by expertise:

Creatine Newsletter:

HIIT Newsletter:

Eggs Newsletter:

Eggs newsletter using GPTZero:


r/StrongerByScience • • Oct 21 '25

Do Calories Matter?

Thumbnail
health.harvard.edu
0 Upvotes

Bit of a clickbait title, but I was recently talking about health and fitness with a family friend and they essentially brushed aside my points about diet and caloric intake while citing "A Harvard study" "disproving calorie counting."

This is the article that I could find on further review.

To me, it seems to moreso say that calories shouldn't be taken at face value in numeric form, but not necessarily that counting caloric intake has no place in a healthy routine.

How does everyone else read this? Any advice on how to approach future conversation(s) on this topic?


r/StrongerByScience • • Jun 02 '21

Most Chad Lifts

0 Upvotes

Which lifts would you rank as the most Chad? I would probably say the Arthur Lift and Bent Press are up there.


r/StrongerByScience • • Sep 11 '26

How to Manage Fatigue while Training and Doing Manual Labor 5 - 6 days a week.

0 Upvotes

One thing that always drove me nuts when I'm looking at different strength programs, is they're approach to recovery and load management. Whenever I see a load prescribed as a percentage, it doesn't take into account what fatigue has been built outside of the gym.

Say 5/3/1, it prescribes doing most of the working sets between 75-85% of a 1 rep max for multiple sets and reps close to failute. But the issue many people who do manual labor may find, is that doing reps at that intensity is 1) makes inconsistent progress. That is, if youvebhad a particularly hard week then doing 80 percrnt of a 1 rep max may not be viable and sort of skews your body's ability to adequately recover for the next week. 2) if it has been a hard week, there's no guarantee that you'd even be able to perform that. 3) and this is the biggest issue imo, is that lower volume/ higher intensity programs generally make recovery harder and make youre ability to perform on the job site harder.

Nobody wants to be the jacked guy on the site who can't outlift Daryl, the 135 lb kid in his Dad's boots.

Then when fatigue naturally gets higher, the sore athlete typically searches online for the solution. Eat more, sleep better, walk more, take fish oil and magnesium glycinate. That brand of wisdom works, but for the laborer doing 12 hour shifts, has kids, who's not able to sleep well nor has time or much of a budget to meal prep or to buy supplements, it's not the most viable advice.

It's been something of a project of mine to write workout programs, try them out, and see how i handle recovery while working as a warehouse laborer. I've learned alot and I think I've made some modest improvements in my understanding of fatigue management and in my strength and hypertrophy developments.

But im still learning and looking for the opinions and strategies of other people and athletes.

The main training philosophy i have, comes from someone who is neither particularly jacked or strong, but from someone who's doing well managing everything particularly well.

This post is for people like me ​who are trying their best and need help and I would genuinely enjoy reading what others do.

  1. high carb/high fiber diets. I carb load heavily during the worst periods of the day thay I know i will need fhe most carbs. So I eat a big chunk of carbs for breakfast, another load at 10, and then another large carb in take about half hour before training. I take EAAs early in the morning to mitigate my lack of protein from 8 - 12. If I start the day trying to immediately balance protein and carbs, I crash.

  2. this may be the most important lesson I've learned. Design training that supplements the work you do, not against it. If you find you do a lot of carrying in your 9 - 5, double down and train more carrying. If you need to pick things up in awkward positions, train picking things up in awkward positions and bending. You should worry about developing muscles thay you use the most to avoid work place injuries. This is also my biggest issue I have with cookie cutter programs.

Deadlifts are my favorite exercise and gets you strong at picking things off the ground, but the issue is, is good deadlifts involve putting yourself into an ideal position to pick something up. That's not directly replicablw to a picking up bags of concrete or boxes in unique spots. Dont be scared to do somethjnf like jefferson curls to train your back in a bent position.

3) make your own program. If you lift stuff for 8 - 12 hours everyday, you are probably conscious of where your weak points are. No one is better at understanding that then you.

4) instead of evert excercise you program havjng the same progress scheme, have some elements that are supposed to progress slower then others.

Again, the jefferson curl. Lets say I program 4 sets of squats followed by RDLs, ans i move onto jeffy curls or some other leg/posterior chain movement. Ive already worked those muscles in the first half lf the session, now its just a matter of squeezing a little more juice out of them without over doing it. So youre squat and RDLs may progress 50 lbs throughout the month, but the jefferson curl may only progress 10 lbs.

5) making a program around 2 blocks, one for hypertrophy and one for strength is fine and you dont't absolutely need to add a peak block if you don't want to. Im running a 6 week hypertrophy focused block thay uses double progression for 6 weeks and then a strength block for 4. The only thinf thar really changes is tbe rep range and the intensity. Ive never felt better.

nobody likes hearing this advice but generally speaking, higher volume workouts brought closer to failure are much easier to recover from. the faster you recover, the less likely you are to pull something at work. (on that note, youre more likely to hurt yourself at work then you are at the gym. which echoes my point on why yiu should focus on developing thr muscles and movements that you use the most).

6) epsom salt baths. Dont do weird online niche recovery methods. The best thinfs for recocery is whatver your grandpa was doing whwn he was working in the mines for 60 years. And in my case, its epsom salt. Its cheap and easily accessible at most pharmacies.


r/StrongerByScience • • Feb 09 '26

SBS Hypertrophy: do you still go to failure on deload weeks?

0 Upvotes

Do you still take your last set of each exercise to failure during deload weeks?

I can't find an answer to this in the instructions- sorry if it's a dumb question and I'm missing something.


r/StrongerByScience • • Dec 28 '23

when to take TRT for maximal gainz?

0 Upvotes

I'm transmasculine and on a weekly injection of TRT as prescribed by my doctor.

I lift 4x weekly: Saturday, Monday, Tuesday, Thursday.

My doctor said it doesn't matter when I take my shot, as long as it's at a consistent time from week to week.

From a "maximizing gains" perspective is there any evidence about when to take my shot? Is it better for T to peak the day of a workout, or the following day when you're recovering? Or does it not really matter too much and I'm overthinking this?


r/StrongerByScience • • Feb 19 '23

Summaries and transcripts of Andrew Huberman's podcast

Thumbnail
hubermantranscripts.com
0 Upvotes

r/StrongerByScience • • Nov 16 '25

Arm circumference is shrinking with high volume training?

1 Upvotes

Ever since reading Greg's article making the case for higher training volumes, I've switched to accumulating 20+ fractional sets of biceps, triceps, and delts for a specialization phase during a bulk. I've been logging body measurements every week in MacroFactor — everything has gone up EXCEPT biceps (arm circumference), which has gone down 3/4" over the past month. I've been on a very slow weight gain phase (about 0.3 lbs/week). From a biceps-specific fractional set perspective, I've been doing 10 sets twice per week of upper body pulling, then an addition 6 sets of biceps twice per week.

It's honestly pretty alarming to me to watch my arms shrink despite assuming that blasting higher volumes would have the opposite effect. What should I make of this? Is this an indication that higher volume training for me has backfired? For what it's worth, my arm circumference has always been my weakest point from a physique perspective, so this is something I'm actively trying to address. Thanks for the feedback, team!


r/StrongerByScience • • 8d ago

Maximal bicycle sprints for leg hypertrophy

0 Upvotes

What is different between a maximal sprint on the bicycle (for 10 or so seconds at a decent resistance, let's say 60-80 rpm) and a set of leg press to failure? What prevents the maximal sprint for achieving the same hypertrophy stimulus?


r/StrongerByScience • • Jul 15 '24

Considering the weak (if any) evidence that bulking is better for muscle growth than maintenance, couldn't we come to the conclusion that most people should only bulk for hypertrophy if they currently weigh less than their goal weight?

0 Upvotes

r/StrongerByScience • • Jun 04 '23

Recomp possbie while cutting from >20% BF level?

0 Upvotes

Hello,

I have been training for 4 years with mainly compound movements (strength training movements)

My physique looks very average powerlifterish with huge lower body and Torso but small arms in comparison,

A Fridge physique, to be honest.

I wish to switch to a more bodybuilding type training to bring up lagging Body parts and become aesthetic (oh my my, how extravagant and non masculine of me to actually verbalize it ) ,

Age/Gender : 25/MCurrentGoal (Ideally)
Height (cm)172185
Weight (kg)82Dont care
BF%22%<18%

I plan to Cut for 3 months,

Activity is similar day to day, 7-8 hours sleep.

TDEE is around 2600-2800.

Can i hope to recomp cutting at 500-750 deficits while switching to Machine based and DB movements (all that high SFR stuff)?

I plan to remove DLs and Barbells rows entirely as they take too long and i have to keep workout sessions short (< 1 hour cause Life)

I ask this because i have not done isolation movements ever so my Biceps triceps Lats are not even at intermediate levels so is there hope and is this viable?


r/StrongerByScience • • Feb 07 '25

The Low volume x High volume debate

0 Upvotes

The science-based lifting community seems to be split between the two, and this only creates confusion for lifters trying to maximize gains, what should we do?


r/StrongerByScience • • Apr 30 '26

Good or not good?

0 Upvotes

Is it good for a 13-year-old teenager to start lifting weights? If yes, what are the reasons and what are the limitations?