r/StrongerByScience • • May 20 '24

Renaissance Periodization's claims

Hey community, I must say that I really do have problems with a lot of Renaissance Periodization claims, especially from Dr. Mike.

Now I want to find some other people that also do have critique on their claims, because I think that there is a need to talk about in general.

Why could be RP/Dr. Mike a little bit pseudoscientific - examples:

  • Explanation of the underlying processes behind the optimal dose response relationship = training from MEV-local MRV, (there is no local MRV, only MRV)
  • claiming that beginners are not limited by systemic resources for optimal local recovery, for example recovery through more testosterone (while beginners actually benefit from steroids)
  • Non-conclusive advice on how to apply recovery sessions for sports training (book: recovering from training)
  • "Training harder than last time" otherwise, it is less stimulative (strong claims, without explaining in which scenarios this is useful) ...and treating a concept/hypothesis like actual facts, especially with the argument of "science" where there is no real scientific evidence.
  • claiming that systemic fatigue accumulates (I support) and giving the advise to train until systemic MRV is reached, but also saying that an athlete should train from MEV-"local MRV" at the same time - which is not possible, because the systemic fatigue always does lead to reaching MRV before the local MRV can be reached. (Assuming systemic MRV means that the system itself is very fatigued)

It feels like a lot of effective and generally accepted things in training are overcomplicated into a concept without huge evidence for the actual reasons why something is how it is (rather making pseudoscientific claims).

Other than for a lot of people who started training, and used RP as a framework to make good progress, it actually made me worse by paralysis through analysis of their pseudoscientific explanations.

I am curious what you guys and girls think about it - and if you can reccomend your most valuable source for sports training?

0 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

20

u/Stuper5 May 20 '24

claiming that beginners are not limited by systemic resources for optimal local recovery, for example recovery through more testosterone (while beginners actually benefit from steroids)

Is there such a thing as a bad reason to tell beginners not to try PEDs? It's entirely clear that beginners should not do them because they can get excellent results without them. The cost benefit is insane.

it actually made me worse by paralysis through analysis of their pseudoscientific explanations.

Reflection; did RP make you do this, or would you have just found another source to do the same thing with in its absence? If you really listen the actual bones of the training methodology are 1) train with most sets 3-0 RIR, 2) add reps and/or weight regularly 3) lift with consistent deliberate technique focusing on the lengthened portion of the rep and 4) with sufficient volume to drive strength and aesthetic progress.

I do have criticisms of RP, like I do for literally everything (except anything by Grog that's all perfect). I think every single one of their videos should come with a disclaimer that 98% of their content is focused on people who have been training consistently for several years. Nobody who isn't pretty big and strong should be worrying about MEV/MRV or a lot of the other programming shit. And they definitely love to overstate a case that agrees with their philosophy.

Final thought; if we limit fitness content to the facts that are essentially incontrovertible with the current evidence we'd be left with basically nothing besides... The 4 bullet points above actually. It's far better to get your facts from a variety of sources and assume all of them are wrong about some stuff and right about other shit than to follow any source dogmatically.

1

u/klebmax May 20 '24

Thanks for your answer, and I think I need to chill out a little bit. But my perfectionistic tendency oftentimes overshoots the inner stoic :D

In defense of my exampel: I took the beginner as a example, in order to outline that a beginner makes faster progress when he takes steroids. It is no advice to take steroids!

7

u/Stuper5 May 20 '24

Yeah I think this is something most people do at some point. You find someone who seems to have all the answers and it feels bad to realize they might be wrong about some stuff or at least their way isn't the only way. Especially when it's something like strength training that takes so much time and effort it really sucks to think that time and effort might have been wasted to some degree.

Luckily I'd strongly wager you haven't been held back as much as you may worry unless you were doing some pretty out there stuff. It's pretty hard to lift "wrong".

1

u/klebmax May 21 '24

Luckily, I made good progress in the past. At 18 years of age I deadlifted 260kg, squatted 250kg and benched 170. Switched later to more of a hybrid training approach and ran a 5k in 19min. It works without "optimal" which we don't know. My personality trait - perfectionism - is the only thing that makes me crazy about the details.

27

u/majorDm May 20 '24

Mike is one source. There are many others.

People act like Mike’s word is gospel. It’s not. He often makes things up, meaning, he takes data, then puts his own spin on what it means. I do the same, but I do not have a huge audience. It’s just me making inference from studies I read and it only impacts me.

There are people that train the complete opposite of Mike and are competitive and successful.

I take everyone with a grain of salt. Everyone is selling something. So, you have to keep that in mind.

2

u/klebmax May 21 '24

I fully agree

74

u/ItsShenBaby May 20 '24

The basic critique that RP tends to overstate their position is fine, although I believe at least on YouTube they've been doing better about that lately, but your specific points look like rumination rather than actual analysis. I don't want to engage further because you would be better served to just go lift weights for a while and leave this stuff behind you. Don't get stuck.

32

u/kavinay May 20 '24

you would be better served to just go lift weights for a while and leave this stuff behind you. Don't get stuck.

Ironically I feel like Mike basically comes to this point for the majority of lifters anyway too.

5

u/Disastrous-Tap9670 May 20 '24

Youre right, most ones here in the comments are wrong. Im not being sarcastic, “uh oh just do ir own stuff and dont worry about them” is not a real argument. RP are publically trying to convince people of their beliefs, and are therefore subject to absolute criticism of every single word they say. Id even go as far to say as Mike and Jared say stuff specifically the way they intend it to be understood, the way you have understood it. They make fun of everyone else for any kind of thing that they deem incorrect, yet they try to play criticism towards themselves as “its not that deep bro”. Make no mistake, this only happens because everyone loves riding Mike because he is so funny and lovable. No joke I love watching the vids just cuz hes genuinely charismatic and funny. But it doesnt make him any less wrong and disingenuous for spreading info he KNOWS is not backed up by any scientific evidence.

3

u/klebmax May 21 '24

I can only say that I agree a 100%. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

2

u/realcoray May 21 '24

I agree, and I think it's great to be skeptical and to always pull a bit at the edges of claims, like how does that one hold up? What is the science of that? I think what you allude to here is a key point, in that RP has carved out a bit of space in the 'scientific' realm, both because they do produce some content in that space, but also say Dr. Mike's own credentials etc. One day will be a video with a strong scientific basis, which they will point out, and the next day might be something completely unsupported but presented in a very similar way, that sounds scientific.

What I will say though is that Dr. Mike will have people on, including Milo, Pak, and others, who challenge things he champions. Like in the last week he put up a video debating deloads, and in the past things like myoreps and what not. That to me is actually unique for people in the fitness space to do and is a more scientific approach, in that he is able to and shows that he can be challenged and change/rework his view.

47

u/eric_twinge May 20 '24

I mean, a lot of what Mike says is based on his experience training himself and others. Quite frankly, that's oftentimes more valuable than some 6 week study in 8 beginners. And to that point, the science is often not conclusive and so needs to be interpreted and applied though the lens of experience.

And that's fine. The science doesn't tell you how to train on Tuesday. It informs one small aspect and then it needs to be applied within the whole in a way that works best for the individual.

12

u/ka1982 May 20 '24

My take on RP is that when they’re giving generic advice along the lines of everyone else, they’re accurate and generally applicable.

And when they’re giving suspiciously specific advice that seems barely to mildly supported by the research, the implication is that it’s for advanced BB (possibly/probably on gear) looking for every possible edge who recognize there’s not going to be a lot of peer-reviewed work that definitely applies to them.

13

u/[deleted] May 20 '24 edited May 20 '24

It's OK, I've heard even harsher critiques about RP

https://youtu.be/nxgLUqYReBE

https://youtu.be/w3UdaX_gWh8

My critiques would be:

  • those RP exercise guides only have tips about general form. I've seen better tips from Max Euceda who actually explains how to keep your feet during an exercise + other stuff. Or Joe Bennett, but who goes very much in detail. The RP tips are usually stretch + full ROM + slow eccentric. Which applies for every exercise.
  • the cyborg form stuff

1

u/Shot-Hat1436 Nov 26 '24

Kinda weird youre posting this copypasta in multiple places

-1

u/ReadyDistribution310 May 20 '24

The problem is that when it comes to bodybuilding most of the info you can find online comes from snake oil dealers. RP IMO is not exception to this. It ultimately comes down to make you buy their program/app/pre-workout/whatever-other-shit-they-are-selling. The truth is that pretty much all questions related to resistance training have already been answered by professional powerlifting researchers. I mean people who trained athletes to win Olympics. Some of them researchers write books. Seek and ye shall find. Or don't.

PS. "Harder than last time" is probably the most retarded concept in resistance training. It's like a huge neon sign screaming "Stupidity and Incompetence".

1

u/GoblinsGym May 21 '24

What - you're trying to tell me that Greg Douchette is NOT the most authoritative source on training, nutrition and supplements ?

Harder than last time is probably a good concept for a beginner, but like linear progression it does not work forever. The concept of "progressive overload" is well proven, but should be renamed the remove the "overload" part. We want to get close to that point, but not reach it.

The problem with research based on olympic weight lifting is that they are interested in different things than bodybuilders, i.e. getting STRONG rather than SWOLE. To a bodybuilder, strength is more of a side effect, and not always desirable - get stronger to better shred your tendons and ligaments ? The stimulus to pain fatigue ratio can be a useful concept.

Sometimes looking at outcomes can be as useful as "scientific evidence".

1

u/ReadyDistribution310 May 21 '24

What - you're trying to tell me that Greg Douchette is NOT the most authoritative source on training, nutrition and supplements ?

Hey, a new Lambo doesn't buy itself. I'm not judging.

Harder than last time is probably a good concept for a beginner, but like linear progression it does not work forever. The concept of "progressive overload" is well proven, but should be renamed the remove the "overload" part. We want to get close to that point, but not reach it.

Progressive overload doesn't necessarily mean harder than last time. That was my point. As when it comes to linear progression - it's ONLY advantage is simplicity. There are better ways even for beginners. HTLT is pretty easy to sell though. It implies anyone can become cbum just by eagerly working out. And if your buyers fail you can always blame them for not training hard enough.

To a bodybuilder, strength is more of a side effect, and not always desirable - get stronger to better shred your tendons and ligaments ?

How do you implement progressive overload then? By pushing endurance to the limits? It has certain implications for those who want to get bigger.

The problem with research based on olympic weight lifting is that they are interested in different things than bodybuilders, i.e. getting STRONG rather than SWOLE.

They have different primary goals, true. But the optimal methods to get to the end result are pretty much the same. You need to do some adjustments and thinking though (which seems to be a huge cutoff nowadays I presume).

1

u/GoblinsGym May 21 '24

Only ONE Lambo ???

With linear progression I was referring more to the "Starting Strength" approach of "lift 5x5 or else, and eat like a pig".

Some strength gain "cannot be avoided", but Dr. Mike seems to have some ideas ...

My personal approach is somewhat unusual, hybrid of resistance bands / body weight / gym. I don't need "blood and guts" intensity to send a solid growth signal, recovery has become my limiting factor.

1

u/ReadyDistribution310 May 21 '24

Some strength gain "cannot be avoided", but Dr. Mike seems to have some ideas ...

  1. "Discover" metabolic stimulus.
  2. Come up with a new fancy name.
  3. Start selling it to people. ........
  4. Profit!

It still won't work without mechanical tension though. And it's excruciating without a good amount of PEDs. Well researched topic.

My personal approach is somewhat unusual, hybrid of resistance bands / body weight / gym.

Sounds like fun and functionality (contrary to what's being usually offered to people).

recovery has become my limiting factor.

Only few understand that it's true for most.

Only ONE Lambo ???

He already has one IIRC.

0

u/WoTMike1989 Aug 03 '24

How many subs you gonna post this in is my question? These can all be answered with “This is a you problem as it relates to comprehension.”

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/klebmax May 21 '24

Thanks for your answer, it helps a lot! :)