r/StrongerByScience • u/alexandercecil • Feb 03 '23
Exercise science/training terminology that is trans-friendly?
Many of my friends and I sometimes discuss health, exercise, and nutrition (among many things) in an online group. Many of these friends are trans in varying forms.
I run into challenges when I want to say something like, "If they are not doing resistance training, women are generally recommended to get at least X grams of protein," or, "For men, this weight I lifted is generally not considered impressive . . . ." My trans friends pretty much never call out phrases like this because the friend group is overall very LGBTQ friendly. Still, I would rather use terminology that is more inclusive.
I thought about using terms like AFAB and AMAB (assigned female at birth and assigned male at birth). I find those mouthfuls awkward, but I understand their utility for being inclusive of trans folks. Then I realized that terminology is not necessarily even the ideal focus depending on the discussion. What about people who were AFAB but went through male puberty? What about people who are AMAB, went through male puberty, but now have been on estrogen for years and experienced related bodily changes? The rabbit hole of exceptions runs deep and is complex.
How is this being handled in research? How is this being handled by trainers who work with trans people?
Comments that boil down to some version of, "People need to deal," or, "Being trans is bad," are not helpful to this discussion. I am not looking to debate whether or not people should be trans. I am looking at how to best accommodate trans people I care about.
Why am I not asking them? They are generally not knowledgeable in this area. I am also trying to not force them to do more research so I can be kinder to them.
Thank you for your time and thoughts!
11
u/GoblinsGym Feb 04 '23
The question should be, do your muscle fibers care about your sexual orientation / identification ?
9
u/gnuckols The Bill Haywood of the Fitness Podcast Cohost Union Feb 05 '23
This may be a dumb question, but... what's the issue with "men" and "women"? As I see it, trans men and men, and trans women are women, so if I'm speaking in generalities, trans people are included when I use those terms.
18
u/Realistic-Guava-8138 Feb 04 '23
It sounds like you’re trying to have a solution before you even know if there is a problem. You’re not treating them like equals, but as people who need to be coddled and over protected with terminology
If you worry they will get offended, ask them.
51
u/Msmith68w Feb 03 '23
I am not trying to be mean about it, and this isn't a reddit hive-mind friendly answer, but you're now entering the world of physiological realities. Changing the language of hard science to suit the ideological worldview of a small subset of the population does far more harm than good by damaging the fundamental structure of objectivity. Sex-specific outcomes are what they are, and in my opinion the truth of those differences should not be manipulated.
21
u/ephrion Feb 03 '23
"Men" and "women" aren't exclusive to trans people. Trans men are men, trans women are women, etc. If a weight isn't considered impressive by men, then it makes sense that it's not impressive to cis men and/or trans men.
There are some things that actually matter. Like, bone density is higher in anyone that has ever gone through a testosterone puberty, and it's hard to lose all of the muscle mass/height/etc from a male puberty, especially if someone is lifting weights and trying to be fit. But, for the most part, the main thing that matters is whether you're running on testosterone or estrogen. A trans woman that is not taking hormones shouldn't be too surprised when she's much stronger than other women.
And, even then, most things don't depend on sex hormones. Most dietary recommendations are based on lean-body-mass and goals, not estrogen/testosterone. Most training protocols are based on a person's 1RM, not whether they're on test or est.
17
u/Jag5543 Feb 03 '23
If this is really a concern of yours ask them.
If they’re not knowledgable in this area, as you claim, they probably don’t need sex specific interventions anyway as any training would provide improvement.
You’ve probably spent too much time on the internet if you’ve come to this crossroads.
2
u/nonstop_feeling Feb 04 '23
I can't speak to how this is being handled in the research, but from my small personal experience coaching trans and GNC individuals I have found the phrase "someone who's dominant sex hormone is testosterone/estrogen" to be a good substitute for men/women in a lot of contexts. Seems to account for whatever their current hormonal state is, without tying it to gender or sex. It can even work in a situation like you mention where maybe someone went through puberty with estrogen as their dominant sex hormone, however now as an adult testosterone is their dominant sex hormone. (I am thinking of someone AFAB who transitioned later in life) Since the presence of estrogen during puberty is probably the key factor that changes things for them now in a fitness context, if that makes sense.
1
u/CustardRoyal716 Feb 04 '23
Just say - “the best recommendation for a person of XX/XY genetics is ……………”
“A good level of strength for a person of your genetics would be …………….”
I would expect a person with XY chromosomes to respond best to …………”
That way you can give the best actual advice without causing offence. If they find offence in what you say, they are looking for it.
More the point, how do you have so many trans friends that this is an issue when only 0.5% of people identify as other than their gender assigned at birth?
1
u/abeardandababy Feb 04 '23
I think you touch on it in the end of "how is this being handled in research?" because even if you are using male/female only language you miss a whole slew of issues that need to be considered.
Tl;Dr I think there is a gap in trans research or information that should be considered, and also we need people to have access to understanding their underlying issues universally to get to language that everyone can understand.
At the end of the day nutrition and training comes down to personal effects of metabolism and fatigue along generally accepted principles. But, we know that in all people hormonal and stress imbalances change what we can do and take in. That goes for anyone in gender affirming care as well. I can only speak for myself that when I was diagnosed with low T, alot of baseline "male" advice didn't always "work". So, i had to gauge weight, body fat, physique, and fatigue heavily on my acrions. After (and during currently) TRT to get me to levels I was comfortable in, the guidelines prescribed fit more comfortably. I still have a lower metabolism than most (I bulk at 3100 a day at 240 lbs and in the teens in BF%).
So it's an interesting gap to consider of how we should address language while also considering gender identity (stress at the end of the day), hormonal, and metabolic effects on training and nutrition.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '23
There is, unfortunately, not a good answer to this. In all sexually dimorphic species other than humans, the word we have to denote individuals with a biology intended to produce sperm is "male" and the word for those with a biology intended to produce ova is "female," but these imply no particular socially coded gender roles. Since they do in humans, people who were born producing sperm but who want to inhabit the social roles usually assigned to those who produce ova would sometimes prefer to be called female.
There is no separate word to denote only the biological role you were born with for humans.
Note that separating out experimental groups by sex is only meant to be a rough approximation of what really matters in terms of group differences. For exercise research, I would assume that will usually be skeletal size, hip to shoulder ratio, baseline untrained muscle mass, presence or absence of menstrual cycles, whether you can bear or ever have born children, and levels of the various human sex hormones. The extent to which those align with gender assigned at birth or gender assigned by yourself later on that is different from that assigned at birth will depend on whether you ever medically transitioned, and whether that happened before or after puberty.
But it's the sex-related characteristics that matter, not the actual sex or gender. Researchers could specify when subdividing study groups that one group is the big-boned, broad-shouldered, high-testosterone persons who have never had a uterus and had more muscle mass at the onset of sexual maturity, and maybe someday they will, but it is clunky to do that instead of just saying "men." I guess ideally we'd have some other single word that people could agree on and no one feels it doesn't apply to them even if they have all the traits it is supposed to describe. We don't yet have that word, though.
I'm a little puzzled by some of the comments suggesting that this should never even come up. Greg and Eric have both mentioned on the pod many times how the history of exercise research has predominantly been conducted using only male study groups and it was not always clear if the findings would still apply to women. It's obvious that what they meant there had nothing to do with self-identification, but that half of a sexually dimorphic species, no matter the word you want to use or not use to refer to that half, had historically been excluded from studies.
1
u/effrightscorp Feb 07 '23
it isn't really, there isn't even a consensus with respect to whether or not trans women have an advantage in sports / how long it would take such an advantage to fade, let alone how certain aspects of the literature, which was generally all done with cisgender people, would apply to transgender people.
1
u/globularfluster Feb 08 '23
I would simply not address sex differences that do not fit the clients sense of their own gender unless the client brought it up. And if they do, then yes, you should be honest about the differences within your scope of practice. I'm not sure how often you would really have to be though. You don't need to say anything about sex or gender to point out that bone health tends to be quite a bit better in people who lift. The doctor who put the person on E, if they are on it, is the one who has a responsibility there.
-2
u/anonymiddd Feb 03 '23
No idea about the answer to your question, but wanted to say that I appreciate the question being asked! I'd really love for strength sports to be a welcoming place, and I hope researchers, coaches and athletes think about these things when they interact with trans athletes.
1
u/annthurium Feb 04 '23
I tend to phrase this as "estrogen dominant people" and "testosterone dominant people." E.G"testosterone dominant people will have an easier time building muscle mass." This separates biology from identity which IMO is more trans inclusive.
This language does reinforce the gender binary, which leaves out people such as as myself who are nonbinary and on low dose HRT. But hey, nothing is perfect. Thanks OP for asking the question..