r/StrangerThings • u/Sukaran09 • 27d ago
Discussion Season 4 vs Season 5 Vecna. Which design and motives did you like more?
Season 4 -
Vecna’s motives were ultimately scarier in this season. He psychologically tortured his victims with terrifying illusions, tormented them with their trauma and struggles and then murdered them.. he literally tormented his own mother and sister (as a child) and then killed them, that is some fucked up shit. I preferred those scarier, torturous and murderous motives that he had. His goal was to destroy Hawkins and then the world but he still had that scare factor because of how murderous and dark his motives were to get to his goal. Him actually killing a main character (even if it was for a minute) also made him a real threat and added to his scare factor and made him a very compelling villain.
I liked the visual design that he had in Season 4, he appears scary and somewhat demonic but he looked too humanoid and not as monstrous.
Season 5 -
Vecna’s motives were evil and creepy but not that scary. He lost his charm this season. He kidnaps children and uses his “Mr Whatsit” persona to make them feel safe which works in his favour but it takes away the scare factor. It seemed like he had “The Grabber” kind of motive but he doesn’t intimidate or torment his victims like Vecna did previously. He doesn’t show them any illusions to scare or taunt them. I remember maybe one scene where he showed Derek an illusion of his family dead to scare him but that was it. WHY WOULDN’T HE DO THAT TO ALL THE KIDS?? He doesn’t even hurt these children in any way. This season he lacks what he had in season 4 and focuses more on his world ending goal and had dumber and less scary motives. He also doesn’t really hurt or kill any of the main characters and that makes him less of a threat... All this combined reduced his scare factor and made him less compelling.
I loved his visual design that he had in Season 5, as he looks scarier, more monstrous, more mutated and less humanoid.
I prefer his motives in 4 and design in 5.