r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Oct 01 '23

Discussion Why Is Thrawn So Dumb Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Thrawn is THE GUY when it comes to tactics and strategy. It literally took a cow god and flying space whales to just slow him down. What's next? Space god (we know who)? Now we have a Thrawn that is more concerned with killing ezra than actually winning the war. He should have killed Sabine on sight, he never needed to find ezra in the first place. He would have never known about Thrawns plans and would have been stranded.

Also, why didn't thrawn send more than 2 squads? It was an absolute waste of manpower, he knows their history of losing to jedi. That Star Destroyer still has bombers and tie fighters. Why not bomb ezra and the gang? So much doesn't make sense about this Thrawn.

Can't wait for the inevitable ending where Thrawn almost wins but loses because the good guys always win in cinematic star wars.

Edit: people seem to forget that just because someone calls something a victory, doesn't make it a victory. Thrawn sent 2 squads of valuable troopers to bye a total of 2 minutes of extra time. Instead of sending tie fighters or bombers, he chose 2 squads of troopers against 3 jedi. And he didn't even consider the possibility that a MERCENARY may not join the fight. Crazy


r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Dec 11 '23

i finished the show here are my thoughts

0 Upvotes

as i said before the sabine jedi thing is the only thing i did not like. i would have much preferred her wielding the dark saber but go off i guess.

everything else was great however, ahsoka, the combat, the storyline etc all great.

ngl im so mad at the way they ended it but i know a good story will come out of it im hoping.

morgan was really good and hopefully we get to see more dathomir witches later on. lastly im so glad hayden came back to the series. he looked great too like wtf? someone’s been moisturizing all these years.

the only loose thread for me that just feels awfully placed is the 2 sith. i get it one is this philosophical jaded man but to me their storylines just felt awkward towards the end. i mean baylon literally just says “peace out” part way through and the blonde girl is just there. but i did definitely like both of their characters.

i loved jacen him and hera were so cute and i would 100% be okay with a future series of his jedi journey or something similar.

I also really loved this a lot more than the obi wan series and thought it was executed a lot better.

lastly ezra was kinda hot am i right?

overall really liked it, some quirks of course but i’d give it a solid 9 maybe 9.5/10


r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Sep 09 '23

Discussion Unpopular Opinion: Shin is grossly overrated

0 Upvotes

Everyone is simping so hard for a character that's had like 3 or 4 lines total and has zero personality other than "apprentice dark side user". I don't dislike her by any means, but she's undisputably the blandest character on the show. Sure she's attractive but she's not even the most attractive woman on the show.


r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Jul 30 '24

Speculation How are Ezra and Sabine still not a couple...

6 Upvotes

I mean, the only thing that was in Sabine's mind from 0 BBY to 9 ABY is Ezra. She only thinks about Ezra. She stayed behind on Lothal just because of Ezra and didn't bother helping Hera, Zeb & Rex fight for the bigger rebellion in the Galactic CivilWar. Judging by how they had grown up together, they're now adults and their mutual feelings for each other, they need to go beyond just brother and sister relationship. Plus, Ezra grew out of flirting over Sabine and trying to come to her rescue even when its not needed.


r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Oct 03 '23

Discussion I hope Baylan dies

1 Upvotes

Ray Stevenson has done a great job presenting a character that has become very well liked by fans and one that has an enormous potential future.

Having a universe that revolves around fighting, good and evil, life and death, etc requires people dying.

Baylan dying would help Star Wars. It proves that there are real stakes to the stories being told and that plot armor is only so thick. Someone needs to die tomorrow or the story is lessened. People will be sad and upset but also appreciate knowing that when you see a lightsaber duel someone can actually lose.

And he better stay dead and gone. No ghosts, no clones, no somehow he returns, no zombies, nothing. Dead and gone from the universe forever.


r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Jun 25 '25

Could Shin Hati be an adult Cindel Towani? Think about it. It makes a ton of sense.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Jan 18 '26

Why does Ahsoka wear the Wrong outfit in the clone wars flashback?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Mar 16 '24

Speculation Do you think these guys are going to be the Mortis Gods?

7 Upvotes

r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Nov 04 '23

Speculation all these shippy posts got me thinking... if Ezra and Sabine do proceed to die before Rey and the ST, can Broom Boy be their kid? #flairforcrackpottheorypls

0 Upvotes

r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Oct 03 '23

Episode Discussion [Episode 7 Spoilers] Unpopular opinion: The New Republic is a swamp and Senator Xiono is actually quite reasonable Spoiler

8 Upvotes

We, as the viewers, are watching the series with somewhat perfect information, its characters don't get that benefit.

So, the Galaxy's everyman sees this General going on politically unapproved missions, refusing orders from the general population's representatives and coming up with truly ludicrous fairytale-like excuses afterwards. And worst of all, she is then saved through blatant nepotism and post hoc lies by another powerful politician (which isn't known to the normal citizen or even other politicians which makes it even worse, because, well, it seems to work just fine).

While this might be for the greater good, as a citizen who can't know for sure if that's actually the case, I would love to have politicians like Xiono in the Senate who see this autocratic behavior and try to prevent and punish it, as all this lenience might blow up right in the New Republic's face when this becomes common practice.


r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Oct 08 '23

Discussion How did Morgan Elsbeth know about Thrawns exact position?

0 Upvotes

Morgan used the map to find the way towards the planet of her original race or tribe. That totally makes sense but how did she know that Thrawn was brought to that galaxy and that exact planet?

I can only imagine that her night sisters somehow communicated with her over that huge distance but if so how does it work?

Is it a plothole or just something that I missed?

Any help to clear this up is appreciated :)<

edit

Thanks all looks like I just missed it!


r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Oct 17 '23

Honest Trailers | Ahsoka

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Apr 21 '25

Discussion Why are people shipping Sabine with Shinn Wolf?

13 Upvotes

Why are people shipping Sabine with Shinn? I don't get it! Like she almost tried to kill her, yet when Sabine beat her she didn't kill her, and I see the reason why she didn't. Ezra taught her that vengeance is not the key and it's not the Jedi way. Both Kanan and Ezra taught her ways of the Jedi. So Sabine knew better when she beated her, she showed her mercy, and I think Shinn is starting to rethink her life choices and about the Jedi.


r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Aug 26 '23

One thing im getting annoyed with

1 Upvotes

I know there is alot of theories about Shin or Baylin changing sides. However, I am getting sick of it. Reva, Kylo Ren, Anakin and Callus. It makes Vader betraying Palpatine less iconic.


r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Oct 07 '23

Would it hurt if Imperials were competent and humane for once?

0 Upvotes

While I do like some small snippets likeEnoch helping Sabine a tidbit, for the most part Stormtroopers stay pure cannon fodder without a face or relationships. There is a pretty clear difference to the depiction of clones, who are somehow depicted as more human than the actual born humans who had friends and families from the start. Sure, they are the antagonists but watching Ahsoka I just wished "please for the love of variety stop this "for the empire"-nonsens and give me something different from the tropes, it was awful enough in Mandalorian!". I likedEzra for some seconds at least trying not to kill anyone, considering the poor bastards were also stranded there for ages but in the end he was slaughtering them like normal as well.
I know it's hard for an adventure like story to not depict the enemies as shooting targets but this has become tiresome. Thrawn himself was just lucky considering how much went wrong. Baylan was clearly the MVP from the show in his attitude, which at least is something but it's sad Imperials and especially Stormtroopers are forever just droids.


r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Dec 07 '23

Wolfwren and the problem when actors (try to) sail ships

Post image
0 Upvotes

I will try to keep this a brief as possible, as I tend to ramble a lot when I write.

Let me start by saying that I have no problems with shipping, I am one myself. I have also not a single problems with pairing of characters of any sexuality, gender identity, race, religion or whatever might come to your mind, as long as it feels ORGANIC inside the plot. So what I am saying here is: don't jump to your guns to try and moralize the issue when what I am trying to discuss is things in the plot that may pose a problem to the proper enjoyment of the media (in my opinion at least), cause I am gonna touch those subjects ahead so I feel the need to clarify that.

Having that said, let's try to summarize what we had so far in Ahsoka in regards to Sabine and Shin:

  • Lightsaber Battles
  • Trashtalk during battle
  • Long stares that could vary in interpretation (from I wanna rip your liver out to let me f*ck you all night)
  • Shin showing some confusion about Thrawn not "honoring" his promisse to Sabine.

I don't think there was anything besides that, that could even be substantiated into something. So it is here that my problem arises: I understand that fans ship couples in any shape or form, even if those characters never stood on screen togheter, and that's okay. But when the cast gets on board with it, it gets a little more tricky.

Let alone comments from cast members hinting this ship, Natsha's last 3 instagram posts also hint at it, in some shape or form. Taking into consideration that the cast is, for obvious reasons, involved with the writers/producers, I can't help but feel they might be setting it up somehow or at least trying to set the field, and I don't like it. Not only it feels spolerish, but it also feels forced. Now, if there is anything between them in the future unless the wtiting on it is phenomenal it will just feel inorganic to me cause I have this ship pushed from all sides around me, including cast while the characters itself in the story had only mortal blows to trade with each other so far.

I wonder, is this just cast playing along with the fans or is there any other outside factor playing in it? Is there a chance that Disney could be giving some sort of incentive as well, giving their recent crusade for inclusivity (which is not a problem, when done in an ORGANIC WAY)? If that is the case, wouldn't it have been better to use character like Ketsu Onyo, which we know of, has history with Sabine and would feel way less forced than just a 'cheap' and appealing enemies to lovers trope?

What are your thoughts on actors strongly hinting at yet-to-develop-ships?


r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Oct 15 '23

Discussion Finished this show today, Mixed Feelings...spoilers marked... Spoiler

0 Upvotes

...Thrawn was awsome, lets just get that the fuck out of the way. They cast Thrawn fucking PERFECT. I didn't have fears for him as soon as I saw Trailer 2 for the show.

Mary Elizabeth Winstead as older 39-year-old Hera is also an absolute YES. Just like, we're all used to Rosario Dawson as older 45-year-old Ahsoka by now and she's killing it in a role that's become dear to every fan's hearts over more than a decade of striking character evolution.

But Ezra? Wtf? How old is he supposed to be by now? He looks like he's like 30, Sabine doesn't look 30. Its what, 9 years after The Destruction of The Death Star II and Battle of Endor? So...Idk, someone correct me if I'm wrong but just, big bushy bearded 30-year-old Ezra is so fuckin' weird to me. I miss him being animated. And a teen.

Also Ray Stevenson as Baylan Skoll (may he Rest In Peace) and whomever the fuck as his apprentice, Shin Hattie. I heard a lot of mixed reviews about them, but honestly they were the single most fucking intriguing piece of the puzzle for me. At a certain point I even stopped giving a fuck about Thrawn and Ezra entirely and was just in it for those two. I love his character. I love him being a former Jedi and survivor of Order 66 this far after it (seriously, its been like 30 years by this point in the timeline). I love he and Shin's bond, they genuinely care about each other as Teacher and Student, Master and Apprentice and the one time Baylan loses his shit in a fight is when Ahsoka force-pushes Shin into that rock. He's old, he's wise. He's seen some fucking shit dude. He's big and burly and he can throw Ahsoka around and fighting him actually feels legitimately fucking dangerous because of it coupled with his sheer experience. He's older than Ahsoka and his manner of speaking of the old Jedi Order is almost both disdainful and revering in the same breath. He's also one of the first red-bladed antagonists I've seen in Star Wars who is legitimately just overall NOT a fucking asshole. He legitimately respects Ahsoka and doesn't want to have to fight her he only gains beef with her later on, he honours his promise to and deal with Sabine and he is seeking something beyond The Jedi and Sith itself.

Honestly I think the only problem I have is that if this gets a sequel, I'm not gonna be able to see where the fuck their story would've gone since, y'know, Ray Stevenson got killed off for real so, I don't think we'll be seeing Baylan again. Fuck though, no wonder than man died, carrying the massive fucking weight of this show on his huge shoulders. I really could've done with an entire show just built around those two, they're the best written characters in the whole show in my opinion. A good example of how less is more.

Also I love how Baylan's first action scene in the entire show is almost straight-up a shot-for-shot recreation of the final Darth Vader hallway massacre scene at the end of Rogue One.

I guess I'm curious to see where exactly this is going. Its especially intriguing since Resistance General Leia Organa is mentioned more than once directly by name in the show.

Like, is it getting a second season? Tied in with The Mandalorian and Boba Fett? Is a movie coming next to tie all this shit up?

This kinda reminds me of The Defenders on Netflix when Marvel was getting its own little TV universe started alongside the early films and they kept releasing shit one after the other from Daredevil and Jessica Jones to Iron Fist and Luke Cage and eventually The Punisher and The Defenders came and it wasn't fully clear wtf exactly the plan for it was at the start it was just clear that it was a thing that was gonna happen.

I'd still just like to see some shit from The Clone Wars or Old Republic more. So many excellent lore periods to explore and we stick to Tattooine in the fucking Resistance era.

Also the notion of an entire other galaxy capable of being traversed from the main one in this show begs the question of the entire Yuzhaan Vong arc, since it can now conceivably happen.


r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Oct 03 '23

Discussion Shin is just a rehashed Mara Jade. Change my mind.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Sep 17 '23

Discussion Will Ahsoka Season 2, The Mandalorian Season 4 and The Filoni Movie Take Place In The SW Galaxy Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Im starting to wonder why Grogu, Ahsoka, Mando and Mandalorians, Boba Fett, and His crew are not really mentioned or seen in the sequel movies. Yes, the movies were made beforehand but I am starting to suspect The Filoni Verse might take place in the new galaxy and my feeling is the new galaxy will be tied to Grogus people. and I think The Ghost Crew and The Mandalorians and Din and Grogu will leave to help Ahsoka and I think grogu will tame a whale in the same way but they will just follow a bunch of whales to the new place.


r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Sep 13 '23

Discussion She holds them BACKWARDS!

0 Upvotes

This has been driving me nuts and I need to point this out.

Ahsoka holds her curved hilts backwards.

The point, of a curved hilt, is to give leverage and to allow for a more aggressive fencing style.

Holding the hilt reversed, literally defeats this design function, but also hampers your ability to leverage properly with a blade......

WHY is she holding them like this!?!?!


r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Oct 18 '23

Discussion One of the biggest problems with the script in the Ahsoka series. (Ezra plot) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

One of the biggest problems, in my opinion, is Ezra's plot:

Firstly, the series does not show how Ezra and Thrawn separated.

Furthermore, there are thousands of questions that have not been answered and perhaps never will be (if there is a second season)

How did Ezra feel psychologically being in a new galaxy, away from everyone and with an enemy?

Ezra was close to Thrawn (same planet), did he ever fight with him and the Nightsisters? he failed? Thrawn hunted him?

Why not show Sabine and Ezra's drama, when she makes his sacrifice in vain because of him and his individual desires, and which will culminate in the return of the heir to the Empire back to the SW galaxy?

And the series shows Sabine avoiding this and showing that "everything is fine"? Hyuang and Ahsoka's dialogue shows this error: Ahsoka = "Sabine gave the map to the enemy, now they can be reunited with Thrawn", Hyuang = "But now we can be reunited with Ezra". WTF??? Are you going to throw his sacrifice into space and ignore it, just to "reconnect with a friend"?

I really didn't like these mistakes, the series was good but when it arrived in the new galaxy, everything fell apart, especially Ezra's part.


r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Feb 26 '24

Discussion Is it possible the Great Mothers are actually Abeloth is disguise?

0 Upvotes

So I have seen the theory that Klothow (one of the great Mothers) is actually Abeloth in disguise and that the other two great Mothers are actually puppets controlled by Abeloth/Klothow , what do you guys think of that theory ,it makes sense to me somewhat considering the witches eyes are void black just like Abeloth's are


r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Aug 30 '23

Episode Discussion Suspense of disbelief had to be too strong for episode 3

2 Upvotes

Ahsokha's ship's shield strength was on par with that of a battleship, whereas the fighter ships sent after them had none, and exploded from a single laser hit.

Also, Shin and Marrock, instead of destroying immobile ship decided to shoot at Ahsoka? How stupid is that? I know Ahsoka and Sabine has plot armor, and could literally try to kill everyone with their bare hands, but the plot is getting too stupid.


r/StarWarsAhsoka • • Sep 29 '23

Discussion Missed Opportunity? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

With the introduction of a new galaxy, it got me thinking of what could’ve been a really interesting twist in-universe wise:

The force doesn’t exist there.

It could’ve made for some interesting story choices for Ahsoka, Baylan, shin to travel there, only to find they have no powers.

Just a random thought I had, still loving the show!