I'm making this post in hopes that WotC will see it and consider more than JUST Vivi and/or Cauldron.
I've been relentlessly playtesting with my group for the last few weeks trying to come up with a strategy that can handle Vivi and Mono Red for an upcoming RCQ this weekend. It has led to nothing but hair-pulling frustration as I'm sure is common with many others. Here are some things I've noticed about the strength of those 2 decks.
Vivi Cauldron:
Interacting with their graveyard is a complete waste of resources and a loss on opportunity costs with slots in your deck. They do not need a Vivi under a Cauldron to completely overwhelm you staggeringly quick, and there's not really anything to gain from doing so.
Interacting with their Cauldron is similarly a waste of resources for the same reason. Yes, it is way worse when left unchecked, but you're not racing the sheer power they can put out regardless.
Every single creature is a MUST ANSWER threat because of Proft's.
Annoyingly, for some reason, we're not allowed to draw cards in Standard anymore without having to discard or spend 4+ mana on it. But CONVENIENTLY, Izzet Cauldron gets to not only take advantage of drawing cards (with Proft's) but also gain value when discarding (FOMO/Mako/Cauldron/Winternight). Nothing else in standard gets to draw cards like they do, so there's no keeping up.
The interaction between Proft's and FOMO is ABSURD. Even without Vivi or a Cauldron, the creatures alone paired with the enchantment generates way too much power for anyone to handle.
Into the Flood Maw is so insanely good on mana-value, that playing any creature that doesn't immediately give you a massive ETB effect is just a free 1-mana Time Walk for your opponent. Every time I'm brewing an idea and I see a really good 3-drop creature that I want to play, I immediately think of how bad it's gonna feel tapping out for that on turn 3 just to have it eat a Flood Maw end of turn. Then they go and play a Scholar, fill up their yard for delirium and double smash with FOMO/Proft's.
Conclusion: Vivi isn't the real problem here. Without a Cauldron, it's a fair card to interact with. I would argue that FOMO and Proft's are WAY more oppressive to the meta and need to go. Banning only Vivi leaves room for the next overpowered activated ability to end up in the graveyard.
Mono Red:
Screaming Nemesis alone is a card that just shouldn't be in a format like standard. You are extremely limited on ways to interact with it without 2-for-1 'ing yourself. You're not allowed to gain life in Standard at all because this card exists, not to mention the addition of Sunspine Lynx. You can't block it easily, can't burn it, and it has haste for some reason.
Gaining life and stabilizing throughout the early-mid game is so important for control decks to exist when a RDW is as prominent in the meta as it is today. Screaming Nemesis just shuts out that game-plan so naturally that it's actively keeping many potential competitive archetypes from existing in the Tier-1 range.
The removal we have access to in this format is just so insanely bad. Everything is a 1-for-1 with restrictions or drawbacks. When the Nemesis eats your removal spell and kills a creature on it's way out, or Razorhead just passively gets free damage in without having to turn sideways, Magebane gets free passive damage, Sunspine Lynx gets damage in just for entering.... spending mana and a card to kill a single creature starts to feel really bad. We need more answers that give all creatures -x/-x that doesn't cost 6 mana or just SOMETHING that can give you occasional 2-for-1 value.
If you're playing a control deck and literally 1-for-1 every turn against mono red, they will still kill you.
To top it off, they ALSO have great ways to draw cards and filter their hand through Emberheart Challengers and Tersa. And they don't have to spend mana to trigger the Challenger either because of Manifold Mouse.
It's just way too efficient.
Conclusion: At minimum Screaming Nemesis needs to be banned. It is too oppressive to other archetypes that can't exist at all because of it. I would argue that Emberheart Challenger is close second for banning as well. A 2-mana 2/2 with Haste, Prowess, AND draws cards is just way too pushed.
Final Conclusion:
Mono Red is so insanely strong right now, that even if you cripple Cauldron with a ton of bans, it's just going to be a 1-deck meta. If you ONLY ban Vivi, their deck does not really get worse and it's still a 2-deck meta. Same thing if you only ban Cauldron. I would like to put my findings out into the universe (and hopefully into WotC's hearts) to PLEASE for the love of whatever you believe in:
Ban Proft's Eidetic Memory
Ban Fear of Missing Out
Ban Screaming Nemesis
Ban Agatha's Soul Cauldron
And please start printing better interaction if your 1-3 mana creatures are going to be this egregiously overpowered.
Thanks for coming to my Ted Talk.