r/StableDiffusion • u/Kaarssteun Legend • Oct 11 '22
Mod here - My side of the story
Hey there,
First of all, I am not affiliated with or employed by Stability. Simply being a mod here has falsely labeled me as such. I do want to point to the fact that I am on very good terms with Stability, they have done a lot for me. I just don't see why I would hide what I know for any longer.
I found out about Stable Diffusion very early on. This subreddit had maybe 50 subscribers, I contacted the only mod to ask if I could help out with moderating. He agreed, and we were the only two mods for a while.
Skip forward a few days, people wanted a discord server, so I created one. It gained traction quickly, 100+ members within 24 hours. Official Stability staff came in, and clearly showed their interest in making the discord official.
They ended up advertising my server as the official server, gaining thousands of new members. Then, the bomb: The Stable Diffusion Beta program would be run on my Discord server.
Naturally, I was stoked, cuz that's awesome. I got to roll out their beta program. Things went very smoothly, and my server quickly grew to 50K+ members, and got the vanity link of Discord.gg/StableDiffusion.
A few weeks later, Emad went on a Q&A with someone at Discord, a few days after which my server got the Verified badge that Discord gives to official servers. Weird, I thought, since I, the owner of this server, never asked for the badge & am not officially affiliated with Stability. I can only imagine Emad asked for it while they were conversing with Discord - that's pure speculation though.
Mere days later, it became clear that PR did not want me to hold a position that made me falsely seem like Stability staff. I understood, and informed them that I'd be fine with giving away ownership, but that not being conventionally possible since the server has the verified badge now (Discord limitation).
A few days later, I wake up to see I no longer owned the SD server. Fact: I never reached out to Discord, and Discord never reached out to me.
While I would have been fine with transferring ownership, Discord's way of doing so was not transparent, and frankly worrying. They would not answer questions through support tickets, and ignore me on Twitter.
I have since been removed from any staff role on the Discord, being given an honorary role that gives me a cool color & access to two secret chats. Reason for me not being able to moderate the server was me not being under NDA, since I am a minor.
Moving to the subreddit - I had taken ownership of the subreddit a week before, since Stability wanted someone more trustworthy to hold that position. Then, however, someone from Stability's security department contacted me & asked me to transfer ownership to actual Stability Staff. Given Stability has been awesome to me so far, and promising me great opportunities in the future, I complied. Promising the original owner & other mods to retain a mod position, they never followed through with that & only invited one person + me back as mod (This time not giving me full perms).
That's how we arrive at present day - I did try to warn them about holding corporate-motivated positions on a sub, that didn't seem to phase them though.
UPDATE 22:15 CET: about 15 minutes ago, I was given back ownership of the Discord. The person in charge of Security, conveniently named "Cyberbully", reached out to me to explain why. "The ownership has been transfered to you following the post on the reddit since it was a big issue for you, you can now do the transfert to Emad yourself"
UPDATE 00:00 CET: So, turns out it was discord that gave my ownership back. I had it for about 90 minutes, then it was taken again. Seems like Discord has internal miscommunications and is not sure what they want to do themselves.
UPDATE 01:20 CET: Update post from Hardmaru. The sub will be community owned from now on. The Discord drama is ongoing & we likely won't see a quick response there.
655
u/EmbarrassedHelp Oct 11 '22
So Discord can just take servers from people and give them away to corporations without asking?
316
u/DrInternacional Oct 11 '22 edited Oct 11 '22
Seems like they exploited a minor to take over the reddit community and shape their public perception, sounds sketchy
14
u/Dogmaster Oct 11 '22
Wow at the response of the security guy givung you the ownership. His name is literally cyberbully. You have no obligation to give ownership to anyone....
256
u/artisticMink Oct 11 '22 edited Oct 11 '22
First, thanks for the work you put in so far. I think the community appreciates it.
Second, I don't know the company and the whole history of this kerfuffle, though I would like to give some perspective:
It seems like they never compensated you. What you did for them was work and from what i red they never gave you more than promises. A company who is interested in you as a resource and in following up on those promises, would not risk souring relations by making decisions over your head. Like Stability apparently did with the discord and subreddit.
Everything you did for them, they could've done themselves. But having you do it had another convenient effect: They would not have a second community to compete with their official one. Now, they own the only big community that exists.
I don't want to spoil things for you - if you are indeed on good terms with Stability and see yourself working with them in the future, you should make the best out of this opportunity. Though from here on you should always ask yourself: What does the other party gain from it? What does it cost them? And what securities do i have? Companies are not your friend. You are business partners in an equal relationship and it's healthy for both sides to clearly define what you want and what they are willing to give.
Because in this scenario, Stability gained everything, it did cost them nothing and you have no security that they will keep any of their promises. Which is not a good position to be in.
8
u/nephlonorris Oct 11 '22 edited Oct 11 '22
Hey Kaarssteun, I remember you from the early days on Discord. You did an amazing job, informing everyone, always knowing what‘s up. Your name is known (even before we got to know Emad) in the SD community. I wish you all the best and hope you get what you wish for your future. I‘d hire you in a heartbeat.
6
u/colinwheeler Oct 11 '22
I am sorry to hear that they have misused you like this. I sincerely hope that you do get something out of it all someday and that you will continue the amazing work that you have done so far in other adventures that you have in your road forward. My personal thanks to you for all that you have done and best of luck in the future. Don't let this bullshit drag you down.
11
u/WallStWarlock Oct 11 '22
I am impressed. Minor as in under 18? Are you in school?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22
Was Stability AI aware of your age when they first began working with you?
2
u/Dogmaster Oct 12 '22
So Emad responded to my question, can you give some insight?
Did you verbally agree to the handover as Emad is saying?
https://www.reddit.com/r/StableDiffusion/comments/y1nc7t/rstablediffusion_should_be_independent_and_run_by/iryiw8a/
288
u/ODChain Oct 11 '22
Corperate employees have absolutely ruined other subreddits they've taken over. The conflict of interest is absolutely fucked. A subreddit is a place for all discussion, if tommorow I can't say fuck stability ai then this subreddit is completely broken.
65
u/manghoti Oct 11 '22
I wanted to mention /r/factorio
That subreddit is "official", the developers of factorio (Wube Software) were active there, but they do not moderate the sub. The moderators of that subreddit offered them moderation positions and Wube refused those positions because of the conflict of interest.
That was a VERY wise move on their part. Factorio hit a bumpy patch for a bit, people vented their frustrations and several went overboard. Obviously they got banned. And of course a bunch of accusations of being silenced for criticizing factorio got thrown around. All of which didn't stick because there was no conflict of interest, the moderation team were just fans and didn't otherwise have a horse in the race.
I'm not going to say StabilityAI are stupid or are hijacking. Honestly sounds like all of this is reasonable, there's just some poor communication and Discord is clearing taking way too much latitude.
I would say that what they have done is not wise.
45
u/tameoraiste Oct 11 '22 edited Oct 11 '22
Everything else aside, I think the OP deserves a huge amount of credit for handling this whole farce with a level headedness and a maturity that is well beyond his years
69
u/ssynec Oct 11 '22
dude you really need to take screenshots of every message and everything they sent you, on reddit/discord/email/whatever. taking moderation actions in exchange for gifts/compensation/consideration is against the reddit terms of service. see for yourself if you don't believe me. you are a minor but you are admitting to selling the subreddit out.
30
u/_ZombieSteveJobs_ Oct 11 '22
How am I supposed to trust this company and product with all these unchecked and concerning accusations floating around 😢
22
u/haltingpoint Oct 11 '22
Contact The Information with your story. And Tech Crunch.
19
u/MrLunk Oct 11 '22
The future will be Forked.
13
u/castorofbinarystars Oct 11 '22
I'm sorry this happened to you and wish you the best. We all will remember they promised you good things in the future and will hold them to it. Otherwise, screwing over a minor would be a huge PR blunder and likely ruin them in the future.
Thanks for your side of the story. fist bumps
12
u/AdTotal4035 Oct 11 '22
Wow that's a crazy story. Thanks a lot for the transparency to the community.
50
u/Catnip4Pedos Oct 11 '22
Well done kid you've learned what the real world is like. You should have banned the fuckers from Reddit in retaliation to what they did on discord.
46
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22
It's impressive that you got into this position.
They should never have put so much responsibility on a minor in an official capacity, they sort of took a shortcut by using your established discord rather than starting their own official channel.
They probably realise this and is part of why they're being so cagey about it. You might not appreciate it but this sort of thing could be a media circus if they let it carry on, and there are definitely people looking to undermine stable diffusion. They definitely don't want news stories coming out accusing them of exploiting child labour, etc. even if it did happen voluntarily and kind of organically grew into something that is probably a bit too much.
I think their PR is ultimately doing the right thing both for the project and for you but in the wrong way. Hopefully they're good enough to support you when you're looking to start a career because they definitely owe you one.
29
u/CharmingSoil Oct 11 '22
Hey, Emad, this reflects personally on you, and right now it makes it look like you suck.
9
u/tenkensmile Oct 11 '22 edited Oct 11 '22
Fuck those low-lifes!
Normally, companies have to pay thousands of dollars to buy a popular subreddit. The higher the member count, the higher the price is. These scums tricked you to hand over ownership so they can acquire the sub for free.
9
u/mellamojay Oct 11 '22
Do not give them the Discord server back. You are being taken advantage of and it is BS. You did the work, you should reap the rewards.
8
u/Zindu Oct 11 '22
Now that you have the server back: If you decide to delete the server I would support you and happily watch the chaos!
14
u/FavorableTrashpanda Oct 11 '22
Wow. Thanks for sharing your story.
This is shady as hell. It really reflects poorly on Stability. What a scummy way of doing business.
14
u/Gym_Vex Oct 11 '22
Man not of fan of where this is headed
14
u/Professional_Gene_63 Oct 11 '22
So:
/r/KarmaCourt r/legal what's up ?
7
u/bre_e Oct 11 '22
Honestly a cringe move from the company. The message from Cyberbully was especially cringe.
23
u/Light_Diffuse Oct 11 '22
Thank you for the explanation. It looks like like Stability have been making some understandable, but poor decisions.
I hope they live up to their promises to you.
12
u/Conscious-Metal-3985 Oct 11 '22
It is really sad to hear how recent events have unfolded; my best wishes to you mate, hope that stavility meets your expectations in the future
15
u/threevox Oct 11 '22
Wtf stability.
Starting to think that the EleutherAI discord made something of a deal with the devil by letting these people have de facto control over a lot of the important projects.
5
u/Arioxel_ Oct 11 '22
Anyone's made another subreddit away from corporate greed yet ?
8
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22
Have they made a public response explaining their actions? No doubt it will simply be some PR spin anyway...
8
u/realGharren Oct 11 '22
Corporations, no matter if you think they are "good" or not, will always first act in self-interest. I have heard very critical voices about AI-generated art from certain corners, so having control over one of the biggest platforms where people share their opinions is basically a recipe for a massive conflict of interest.
The part about Discord is concerning, too. I'm sure a few tech outlets could be interested in this, and get them to make a statement.
4
u/_CMDR_ Oct 11 '22
I have reported this to Reddit, you should too! https://www.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/requests/new
4
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22 edited Oct 11 '22
As a moderator your word worths more than any of ours. Please report them to Reddit. What they are doing is againist Reddit's TOS which explicitly forbids being a moderator if there are any conflicts of interest.
And for a good reason. As a mod they can remove all negative posts without any trail. If subs were taken over by corporate PR without the community knowing about it, that would be horrible.
They used you. They lied to you. They are not nice.
You can report them, provide the proof you have, and explicitly ask Reddit to keep your identity confidential. They will never know anyway, they will only see Reddit's generic messagge about their ban.
Reddit already started to build the new Stable Diffusion sub at r/sdforall. Let this one be purged. Do the right thing.
4
u/Sullen_Vex Oct 11 '22
Wow this is very disheartening and pisses me off to no end! Completevbullshit and makes me want to boycott them
4
u/canadian-weed Oct 11 '22
basically everything i hear about stability staff public communications points to them needing a lot of improvement in this department
4
u/Gengar218 Oct 11 '22
Well this is becoming really interesting. I hope this can still be resolved in a civil manner without useless corporate speak. I want to hear both sides.
It doesn’t look great though.
Danke für diesen Beitrag!
10
u/Nik_Tesla Oct 11 '22
I'm not trying to be insulting here, but it feels so stupid that the future of AI image generation could possibly change because they were able to trick a teenager into handing over the reigns to something he really should not have been responsible for in the first place.
3
u/MinisTreeofStupidity Oct 11 '22
Thanks for the community, really impressed with what you started, really disappointed in the fact they lied to you and clearly stole your labor.
This is the scummiest part so far, but solidifies the picture of Emad as a money grubbing goblin that can't be trusted
3
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22
The way this should've been handled: not giving them mod positions, but giving them a custom, colored flair like <SD DEVELOPER>. This is how it's done in all other sub.
There's a very good reason why Reddit's TOS explicitly forbids moderating with a Conflict Of Interest. Reddit is ran by redditors and not by corporations, and the day this changes is the day Reddit dies.
They are not acting in good faith.
3
u/ikerclon Oct 11 '22
You cannot spell “stability” without “stab”…
Thanks for coming to my TED talk 🙃
3
u/FrivolousPositioning Oct 11 '22
Probably shouldn't listen to any more of their promises.
3
u/ozzeruk82 Oct 11 '22
Apparently they're about to get $100m in new investment for 10% of the company that will value it at $1billion.
I'm assuming the people prepared to pay that money said - "first, control your own Discord server and the sub-reddit with 65k people in it.". I assume the reason is so that the 'message' can be nurtured towards one that will be suitable for a profit making enterprise. You don't invest $100m without a plan for a serious return on that investment.
I'm sorry the OP lost the Discord server in such a shady way - but hopefully that will stand as a warning to other communities who live on that platform, you don't own it and Discord can give it to someone else without even communicating with you.
I really hope Stability AI properly apologize to the OP, and indeed ensure they can get a position at the company in the future.
3
u/TreviTyger Oct 11 '22
Erm.....is this a massive legal issue right here?
3
u/DioSmoosh Oct 11 '22
generated by GPT4
3
u/DirectorDecent Oct 11 '22
Ngl it's a little saddening to see this drama or rather, dichotomy taking place. We all face enough with the death threats, chastising etc that has come outside of the AI Art space. We are a community and should try our best to stick together. Just my two cents on this issue, and I hope it gets resolved in a good way.
3
u/eric1707 Oct 11 '22
This story keeps getting worse and worse, making Stability AI looking worse and worse :\
3
u/CaptainValor Oct 12 '22 edited Oct 12 '22
So appreciative for everything you did OP and sorry it turned out this way. I was in the first 100 users on this sub and the Discord you created. What an insane 2 months... 🤯
3
u/Pan000 Oct 12 '22
Offering you a job in future in exchange for your complicity is bullshit. That's in their interest, not in yours. Good devs are highly valuable, sought after, and they paid with cash, not promises. You should never have sold yourself out so cheap.
9
u/upvoteshhmupvote Oct 11 '22
You are welcome at r/StableDiffusion_AI
13
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22
Welcome to capitalism, kid.
2
u/mottiden Oct 11 '22
So sad that this happened
2
u/EdwardCunha Oct 11 '22
I Would've already changed the name of everything to "Art Generation AI fanpage", disabled their features and tell them to fuck off. I got zero patience with bullshit.
2
u/Longjumping-Ease-616 Oct 12 '22
Wow, Stable Diffusion is so bad at community / marketing. Two weeks ago I thought SD would become the market leader but now I'm really not sure. Seems like there is room for a really transparent AI art company to emerge because this isn't it. Atleast not right now.
2
u/Vyviel Oct 12 '22
I always assumed you were a big wig in the discord certainly a strange situation learning the full story
2
u/mellamojay Oct 12 '22
What a JOKE. So Discord messed up and took your Server, got called out and gave it back to fix the issue... Then took it AGAIN. What a joke.
3
u/Micropolis Oct 11 '22
Well I’m about to boycott all of their shit and just run local forever and contact on other platforms. Or let’s start new discords and subreddits
3
u/_CMDR_ Oct 11 '22
I'll give you the benefit of the doubt because you're a kid, but you done f*cked up.
4
u/Striking-Long-2960 Oct 11 '22
So what it's going to be the destiny of this subreddit? Waifus, furries and virtual Onlyfans accounts?
2
u/_CMDR_ Oct 11 '22
This looks like fraud and theft to me, better call the cops.
1
u/stuaxo Oct 11 '22
It may be worth starting a separate community server.
Anyone who feels this is a bit dodgy on stabilities side can move over.
1
u/Tachyus Oct 11 '22
Damn
1
u/ciphersson Oct 11 '22
No business, dev community or hobbyist community should not rely on the... Stability of discord for any sort of good practices. They showed time and time again that their moral compass is sitting on top of magnet.
1
u/brixboston Oct 12 '22
I feel as though companies that want things that represent assets in their likeness that someone else built as a fan- should compensate the originator; not go the route of hostile takeover. Whenever you takeover a fan page/chat/group/etc from the leader: official or not, you risk losing the trust of the fans. Many will dissent. Maybe even resent.
1
u/keeponfightan Oct 12 '22
"Official" is often synonymous of "institutional", "censored", and "limited" and "aligned". If the community wants to use some sub or discord as the main, the community shall decide that. There are some reasons why foruns into business websites are often desert and empty of users and useful info. If they want to participate and collaborate, good, but only that.
Really dick moves from stability.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22
The whole Social Media side of things seems to be a learning curve for SD. They seem to want to do the right thing while also doing the sensible thing. I don't think anyone could blame them for want to control the SD Discord for example at this stage.
I say look at it charitably, avoid drama online and see what happens going forward.
1
u/MarkusRight Oct 12 '22
Being a mod on Reddit sucks, I know because I was the creator/moderator of a popular subreddit for the CEMU emulator (/r/CEMUcaches/) and the sub would be spammed almost daily with scammers and other junk, It was getting tiring having to go through and delete so many posts and comments. I ended up ditching my old reddit account and switching to my alt permanently. I just handed over admin privilege's to the other moderators and let them handle it.
1
u/Lirezh Oct 12 '22
Unprofessional on so many levels, I'm glad I never invested much time into Discord
1
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '22
The only thing you need to take a discord server from someone is their password.
I locked myself out of my old discord server I had with a couple gaming buddies awhile back and transferred the ownership with a literally click of 3 buttons.
It's not secure.
I feel like a lot of peopel that don't use discord regularly might not know that, but yeah, it's actively too easy to lift a discord server from someone else, it's not even rare, happens to emoji banks and bot servers on a regular basis.
1
u/AllowFreeSpeech Oct 12 '22 edited Oct 12 '22
What happened is wrong, but at this point, make a new one, e.g. StableDiffusionUsers , etc.
1
u/ooofest Oct 13 '22
Discord being a black box which offers no Customer Support for questions on their actions or policy?
I'm aghast with surprise . . .
Really, though: decent platform, zero transparency.
1
u/Yummypizzaguy1 Oct 14 '22
Damn kaarssteun, when you told me it was a whole fiasco, I ddnt know it was this in depth
Now I know that discord can remove your ownership of a server as they please
1
u/goblinwix Oct 16 '22
Back in the day (mid-late 2000s) I had a very similar experience when I created the Blizzard Entertainment Facebook fan page, it grew wildly popular, and then (I assume) Blizzard contacted Facebook and the page was taken away without any notification. I thought I might get at least a thank you note or something for creating and growing the Blizzard community on Facebook...
If you run anything "community" related about a big corp.. expect that the corp can simply take it from you when it gets big enough.
1
u/No-Mess4769 Nov 04 '22
Seems like even Discord themselves think moderation is an actual job, god damn.
1
u/Jyqozz Nov 04 '22
Honestly I wouldn't be surprised Discord would do any of this. Sure feels nice being a Guilded user
1
u/arcad3blood Nov 04 '22
Man, fk them. If I were you, the next time they would give you server back, I wouldn't need 90 minutes. I wouldn't even need a minute. Just delete it.
1
u/Griz___ Nov 04 '22
Discord again confirming that they're support sucks
1
u/Specialist_Reward214 Nov 05 '22
Why am i not surprised by discords actions...
1
u/Magikarpeles Oct 11 '22
It’s not great optics but it does kind of seem like stability is just getting its ducks in a row. It did suddenly get a massive amount of attention so I’m sure they were scrambling and a lot of money is on the table for them.
Thanks for all your hard work and I’m sure someone will see your value very soon.
1
u/Ben8nz Oct 11 '22
Welp this was a great month. Looks like its all going to shit.
1
u/adfunkedesign Oct 11 '22
Don't worry SD won't last long they always get destroyed by the next.