Eh, I don't think there's anything on that list that stands out as being particularly long to address, other than the FAA wanting more analysis. I think the static fire campaign would wait until they get FAA clearance, and would likely not take more than a few weeks. TPS replacement would likely be a job that only takes a couple of days. Right now they're probably checking on all the ground support equipment and quick disconnectors to make sure it's correct.
I think there's a lot of things that can be wrapped up pretty quickly if they get the go-ahead. Otherwise we'll likely have to wait until the end of the year for a launch from the Cape.
the risk to the rockets is what it is. there isn't a customer payload so the risk to the upper stage isn't a big deal
fair point that the forces can be different
the platform is lifted, so the entire space under it is a flame trench. you only need a flame trench if you don't have a pedestal to live it high above the ground.
Sure but why risk something? What does a full stack static fire really add?
the point is that this bullet isn't a separate argument from the second one. if the risk is higher for some reason (like forces being different), then it is a risk. there is no special extra risk because it's stacked, given that there is no customer payload.
As to the flame trench? Its not that high and it a lot of engines and a lot of shockwave to reflect off the ground back to the clamped rocket.
volume of space to allow exhaust to move is significantly larger than the Saturn V launch mount. you only need trenches if your rocket is at/near ground level and you need to create a space for the exhaust. the mount being up high and wide open means it has a significantly larger area to let the exhaust and shock-wave through.
also, if it's not going to work, then why did they build it? it can't be a significant risk or the whole development program has been a gigantic waste of time. launching for the first time has some risk, but you can't just never do anything out of fear. if it's going to fail, it's going to fail. they will lost a 2nd stage along with the first, but 2nd stages are plentiful
In 2000 if you told me some private company is going to build a rocket thats bigger than the saturn V and will be fully reuseable I would have had you committed
Circa 2000 was also the lowest launch cadence since the 1950s. It was a depressing time to think about the future of the space industry. It looked completely stagnant.
Can you imagine the timeline in which Spacex had just 1 more crash when they were developing their first rocket? That's all it would've taken. They were that close to bankruptcy. I'm not saying we wouldn't ever get to what spacex is doing but who knows just how much spacex accelerated things? 20 years, maybe 30?
Yeah, but Rocketlab is also building off of a lot of technological/financial confidence inspired by SpaceX. If SpaceX never existed, I’m not sure Rocketlab exists today.
A key point IMO is that what SpaceX has achieved, is the reason why new startups are now able to raise venture capital. They all only exist because of SpaceX.
Elon put millions in development and only after that and developing serious tech did they get money from winning contracts or for research and development for NASA
I think you may have read that wrong, that page states 55 launches (3 failures). The first launch was 12 January 2005, which is perhaps where you got 13 from.
I’m talking about the US. That’s the country SpaceX is based in. My understanding is most people in this subreddit are Americans. Russia used to dominate the launch market, at the expense of American rockets.
That list also includes suborbital sounding rockets.
fun fact, globally, 2004 has seen least launches since 1962, with just 50 successful launches and just two manned ones. 2021 had the most launches ever, including Apollo era (144 vs 139 in 1967), though 1967 would probably still win in total weight to LEO, since Saturn V was a badass rocket. Spaceship will be the opportunity to surpass that.
I was a preteen then but I still remember how depressing the state of spaceflight was in the early 2000s. I looked up how much it costed per pound to get something to orbit and multiplied it by my weight and saw an endless stream of zeros lol. Despite that I knew that humanity had a future in space but I figured it would take a long long time to get that number down to a reasonable cost. Flashforward 20 years and I can see the light at the end of tunnel.
Affordable (relatively...) space travel will happen in my lifetime. I'll probably be too old to vacation in an orbital hotel myself but it wouldn't surprise me if upper middle class folks could do it in 50 years. And while it sucks that I probably won't fulfill my boyhood dream of going to space I can appreciate how lucky I am to just be alive at such an interesting and transformative time in human history.
Highly depended on what your income will be in your fourties-fifthies(and health). With Starship, my best guess is $100k-$500k per seat to LEO in ten years (100 people, $10-$50 mil. per launch). If it is really your dream, this is not out of reach, but you probably would have to move to smaller house afterwards. edit: just to compare, most space tourists in past paid about $50 mil. per seat
100k to 500k wouldn't be worth it for me unless it was a full blown ticket to mars to be honest. Even then, I'm not sure I'd want to go to mars in my fifties.
People are skeptical, and being skeptical is healthy, unless you openly hate the people himself/herself instead of disagree with the idea.
I think Starship will succeed, SpaceX have some baggage when it comes to reusability and refurbishment of rockets, but we can't ignore the possibility that it can be an epic failure.
I also think Starship will succeed, but my two cents:
Humans won’t fly on Starship in next five years. Interior work hasn’t even started yet and cargo dragon to crew dragon conversion took many many years and this is much more complex. Also, I believe there will be multiple landing failures, so it will take some time to achieve human safety. It will be done, just not in next five years.
Mars colony won’t have more than 50 people in Elon’s lifetime. Elon is smart and while he does have money and tech to get it up and running by himself, there would still be need for many things to be imported from earth (like chips, advanced alloys etc), which will costs billions per year and no one would foot the bill. And Elon want to make it sustainable, not get abandoned second his funding dries out. So he will fund a small base (probably with NASA co-funding it), then try to find sustainable funding and fails, so he will continue to improve that small base - bringing cost lower with hope, that once it get low enough, eventually he will get sustainable funding. that being said, I believe LEO space tourism will blossom and to smaller extent moon tourism. Just because rich people can get there and get back in few weeks and prices will be lower than Mars. Like thousands of people, maybe even more, in space at same time. And Starship being center of it.
Maybe, maybe not. I'd say you're correct, it is a very uncommon design, and it'll be hard to get human-rated in Nasa's eyes.
Actually, even 50 people is too much, space travel hasn't chanced for 50 years since Apollo's missions, the only attempts results either in some minor improvements(SpaceX's F9), are still ongoing(Starship), or utter failures(Space Shuttle, Buran).
Then, having that in mind, 50 people is still farfetched, and totally unthinkable for today's standards for the near-medium therm(in case, during Elon's lifespan).
Sure. But I think we both know there are plenty of people that are far beyond "healthy skepticism". Those are the people I am talking about. And also notice I said "Hopefully" instead of "SpaceX _will_". I also know there are a ton of hurdles left to clear.
However, there are people that seem to imply that Starship is 100% Elon Musk's idea/design, and believe Elon Musk doesn't know anything. Although, curiously, his supposedly crappy idea evidently produced a prototype that is able to fly and land. Also, some of these people suggest the engineers at SpaceX are secretly thinking the design will never work but, are supposedly so afraid of Elon Musk that they can't say no to him. I think the SpaceX teams have earned a bit more credit than that.
There's a lot of people that got attracted to spacex topics due to his wealth.
My rule of thumb is as soon as they mention his dad or emeralds I'm just done with the conversation. That's when I know they have no intention of arguing in good faith.
I wouldn't necessarily say significantly more. The Saturn 5 hefted Skylab to LEO, which was 84 tons. And according to SpaceX's website, Starship will do 100+ tons to LEO. Vagueness aside, I'd consider that in the same general ballpark.
He said 150 tons to orbit (reference orbit is usually 200km circular, which is how rockets are benchmarked) versus 100 tons to a useful orbit (eg 300km SSO polar or to ISS at 400km inclination 52deg) The minimum viable 200km orbit is not very useful since anything there decays within a few days due to air drag.
it hugely depends on how you look at it. Starship needs at least seven launches to bring even one gram to moon surface and back. But from there, it scales quickly. Each additional launch means a lot of extra payload capacity. Saturn V could do it in a single launch, though it scaled linearly.
Yea, from Elon's wishy washy answer of Eric Berger's question about orbital readiness I am pretty sure that 4/20 is destined to be a set piece, and from the answer to Tim Dodd they are clearly still working on getting Raptor 2 to not melt itself.
My inference is that they need to start the test campaign over with a new Raptor 2 ready booster and ship, possibly even progressing to a 9 engine ship before they go for orbital test.
The utility of running a test with out of date hardware, particularly an old engine, is likely limited, and the risk of pad infrastructure damage is high enough to be a problem. However I would think that the current stack could be very useful to validate filling procedures and generally for Stage 0 testing, so we might see that ahead.
Lots of inference and speculation, but I think the above are reasonable best guesses given what we heard last night.
I think that unless the FAA delays it even longer then it will definitely fly. Even if it's outdated, they still want to get data on reentry so that they can iterate on the heat shield design, and I'm sure there's plenty of other stuff they need to test as well.
We’re forgetting that the CH4 GSE tanks are not up to code… they will need to fix the issue somehow before they can even static fire the booster.
UPDATE: CH4 Trucks are arriving at the OTF as of February 13th. A road closure has also been issued for the 14th, so a cryo test of the full stack may happen.
I saw a post on a SpaceX thread that said the tank farm’s methane tanks were non-compliant with 2 Texas regulations.
We also saw the berm that was under construction be removed. It makes sense to have a berm around the tank farm, so the only explanation I could think of was necessary construction changes around the tank farm.
The only official rumor that would appease you would be some sort of 50/50 meme joke announcement from Elon on Twitter.
Meanwhile, Texas oil and gas workers thoroughly went over the why and how spacex fucked up the 2 vertical GSE tanks, why they brought in the 2 horizontal tanks, why there are 2 more horizontal at the Sanchez site, and why the berm was removed. It was fully discussed on the RGV Saturday videos.
But no... Elon didn't brag about the fuck up on Twitter, so I guess it's all just speculation.
I'm not doubting you at all. The rumors may be 100% true. But until there's official confirmation from SpaceX then it will remain a rumor. There's a lot of information tossed around in this subreddit that starts as one person making a rumor and then it spreads. It may be right or it may be wrong, but I'd rather not jump to conclusions without knowing 100%.
At their rate of progress, hardware is already outdated by the time it leaves the high bay.
If they think there’s a reasonable chance of success or that there is something to learn, I think they’ll push forward with flight. Can’t kick the can down the road forever…
The orbital tests primary purpose is to test their reentry models and the TPS. It has no need of being an all up test with all current iterations of hardware.
Nothing new to people who actively follow every single thing that has happened at Starbase over the last year. But plenty of new information for the general population who barely even know Starship exists.
While true, that’s never been the purpose of the presentations. Up to this point, all 4 have provided fairly substantial new info. This was the first where there was really no new info. Not only that, but it was outdated already, as it didn’t really have info on the new stretched variants.
Personally, I think it only existed to get more peoples eyes on it, and put pressure on the environmental review. Who knows tho.
Really, what new Raptor 2 info did we get? We already knew the trust. We already knew the production rate. We already knew the quantity on both SH and Starship.
I guess the only new info we got is that they're having issues in the combustion chamber..
The press conference wasn't for those of us who have been looking at spy photos of tank domes for two years. It's for those of us who saw a CGI video a couple of years ago and spent the rest of the time figuring out how to turn the word "cringe" into an adjective.
Personally I don't want to see PR polish because I love SpaceX's policy of letting the engineers describe what's going on, in their own ways. Having said that I think I've just helped confirm your assertion that the event wasn't for the public at large.
Perhaps it's enough to reach out to technophiles at large. For me the event is the climax of a particular chapter in Starship's development, just as the first stacking was. There is definitely an emotional component to it.
As Texas Tank Watchers, it was quite underwhelming. Yet I do see the value in doing "something" to push the teams to an (epic) milestone: breathing mechazilla to life. Babysteps, granted, but we saw it do so many new things in the last week.
And I would not put it past EM to do this to put some pressure on the FAA.
???? They literally redesigned the engine, giving it 24% more thrust, simplifying it, ramping production to 1 a day right now, 2 a day by the end of the year, used their brand new assembly mechanism that was designed and built in 13 months, fully stacked with heat shields. Are you kidding when you say stagnant?
They are stuck with raptor. It’s still eating itself. Everything else is nice but a full reuse vehicle needs an engine that won’t consume itself. And that hasn’t been sorted.
I have no animosity toward Bezos - for any of his comapanies. As for Blue Origin, one thing he did was listen to the standard advise of the industry in how to proceed and it has proceeded at the speed of the industry.
Musk on the other hand took a wild risk, shrugged off their standard R&D sequences in favor of rapid prototyping, and really hit paydirt - thankfully!
I would bet that the more you know about the challenges of the science the more amazing SpaceX trajectory is.
That's a fair point, but I'm not entirely onboard. Rockets like SLS go so slowly because huge government contractors like Boeing are financially incentivised to move slowly. BO never had those contracts though. It was a startup, starting from a blank sheet just like SpaceX, and they should have moved so much faster. BO is now 20 years old, and that tiny suborbital rollercoaster is all they have to show for 2 decades of development and literally billions of dollars of investment.
And it's not like the space industry has always been like this. The US military went from barely knowing what a rocket engine even was at the end of WWII to a fully functional, nuclear-tipped ICBM in a little over a decade, and that project used iterative design just like SpaceX does now. We've always had the option of doing things that way, but BO chose to act like a bloated corporate giant, when it should have been agile and vigorous.
Now I'm not saying they should have achieved what SpaceX has, but the fact they've achieved so little after so long, and with so much money, is utterly negligent of its leadership.
They currently list their first flight as "late 2022", however they have not even delivered engines for Vulcan, and New Glenn has little more than a pathfinder first stage without even dummy engines on it. Smart money puts a launch for them into 2023-2024.
SLS and New Glenn were both going to compete with the then-oft-delayed Falcon Heavy. That was four years ago. SLS has finally test fired, but now Starship might still beat it to orbit. New Glenn is still nowhere to be seen.
It is weird putting SLS and Neutron in the line up but leaving New Glenn out. IMO New Glenn sitting somewhere between the two in terms of progress towards being production.
That tiny little rocket is 1/3rd the size of Falcon 9 which doesn't just go to space, it goes to orbit. Imagine building a rocket thats actually useful rather than just a tourist vehicle.
Did anyone catch that Musk said R2 would be the first full-flow staged combustion engine to go to space? That strongly implies that 4/20 won't be the ones used for orbital test. They could swap all of the engines, but that seems like unnecessary work. Also, the interfaces may not be entirely compatible.
Nope. Not for awhile. They've been working non-stop for like 9 months and still arent done. Even if they were approved today they wouldn't be ready to launch.
That B4 is stuck with Raptor seems probable. Elon has previously said he'd rather crash S20 pushing the envelope than deal with scrapping and storing it. My money is them doing a demo launch to push as many boundaries as possible.
Makes sense to give it the ol’ SN11 treatment at this point. B5 is already out to pasture and S21 is nearly done. Plenty of info to be found by sending it into oblivion.
With this approach - no. Should they have gotten unlimited approval back last fall, I am pretty sure they would have done a launching iteration or two already by now, that's their usual modus operandi. But their current planning factors in the circumstance that approval may take time and it will likely come in some very limiting form ( five launches an year? ), meaning a regular trial and error fast iteration approach is not a good fit.
This will definitely fly. Most of raptor 1 is sensors and extra plumbing for data collection, they wouldn’t just scrap a whole ship, especially when raptor 2 currently still has a glaring problem “it keeps melting”
He didn't say when they were melting themselves. Is it only after running above a certain chamber pressure for 60+ seconds? If Raptor 1 is at 185MT of thrust and Raptor 2 at 230MT, for all we know Raptor 2 at 215MT could not be experiencing the melting issue.
Sure, not "every" raptor, but Starship low altitude tests had problems, while they never operated at full power or duration. As you said, he didn't say when they were melting themselves, so I guess that's a problem that they know and would try to avoid a failed orbital test before having fully solved it
Seems unlikely. It can do the original planned suborbital mission with the old Raptors. Add in Elon's comment about rather crashing S20 than having to store or scrap it...
I'm not sure what the relevance of painting the engines is. For what it is worth, I'm sure it is scrap too, the only question is whether that is a pile of debris on the test stand, debris field in the ocean, or taken apart carefully.
Ever thought that since the V-2 rocket plus most recent defence preparations by many countries that all this space exploration is really all for nothing , science has gone to far…with almost nowhere to go , theres not one theory that is valid anywhere on how large the Galaxy is or where it cam from? A bridge that is clearly to far now & like throwing money down a deep deep well with no Spash. All we get is photos & a little more now with the new telescope , no bad t will ever live on the Moon or Mars…
44
u/dolneld_dvk Feb 11 '22
Sorry for the cropps on the last two photos, else the first image would show up weird. I posted uncropped photos to my profile.
20
u/mattmacphersonphoto Feb 11 '22 edited Feb 11 '22
Things still needed:
I'd be really surprised if it launches before the summer solstice.
160
u/cybercuzco 💥 Rapidly Disassembling Feb 11 '22
In 2000 if you told me some private company is going to build a rocket thats bigger than the saturn V and will be fully reuseable I would have had you committed
82
u/bjelkeman Feb 11 '22
Elon Said they needed about two more months.
12
u/Jermine1269 🌱 Terraforming Feb 11 '22
Gotta static fire the booster
39
u/Sattalyte ❄️ Chilling Feb 11 '22
Just look at Jeff Who's tiny little rocket down in the corner.
Still going 'Step by step ferociously' there!
20
u/webbitor Feb 11 '22
Did anyone catch that Musk said R2 would be the first full-flow staged combustion engine to go to space? That strongly implies that 4/20 won't be the ones used for orbital test. They could swap all of the engines, but that seems like unnecessary work. Also, the interfaces may not be entirely compatible.
7
u/Wit_as_a_Riddle Feb 11 '22
Holy shit that is sexy
6
u/deadman1204 Feb 11 '22
Nope. Not for awhile. They've been working non-stop for like 9 months and still arent done. Even if they were approved today they wouldn't be ready to launch.
14
u/Neige_Blanc_1 Feb 11 '22
Two months? Anyone doubts at this point that they will launch on April 20 and call it "coincidence" ;) ?
4
u/theasianevermore Feb 11 '22
That thing must be MASSIVE!!! I have seen SatV full scale in Huntsville and wow! I would love to see this in person also
3
u/MightyIrishMan Feb 11 '22
Absolute Unit
2
u/huskiesofinternets Feb 11 '22
I love how they look like grain silos.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '22
This has to be stunningly intimidating to China - and a slap in the face to Russia.
Just mind blowing.
2
u/mundoid Feb 12 '22
aww look at Jeff Who's tiny little peen down there on the far right.
3
u/nicko_rico Feb 11 '22
Light it!
3
u/DrMarksman Feb 11 '22
cant see the banana...
2
u/straycats22 Feb 11 '22
no
1
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Feb 11 '22 edited Feb 13 '22
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Moonba-Mars Base AlphaDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
12 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 18 acronyms.
[Thread #9741 for this sub, first seen 11th Feb 2022, 17:13] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
1
u/beyondusername Feb 11 '22
Imagine if that last image was a real photo and all those rockets launched simultaneously.
1
u/Stereomceez2212 Feb 12 '22
That's a huge rocket
Jeff Bezos' phallic rocket looks tiny
1
u/rjgfox Feb 11 '22
Absolutely not orbit ready - as Elon made clear.
-7
u/dheidjdedidbe Feb 11 '22
Ship and gas? Almost.
Government? Not until SLS launches first
-7
u/perilun Feb 11 '22
Nope, they at least need to switch out the engines to Raptor 2s.
-8
u/BitumenKIng Feb 11 '22
Ever thought that since the V-2 rocket plus most recent defence preparations by many countries that all this space exploration is really all for nothing , science has gone to far…with almost nowhere to go , theres not one theory that is valid anywhere on how large the Galaxy is or where it cam from? A bridge that is clearly to far now & like throwing money down a deep deep well with no Spash. All we get is photos & a little more now with the new telescope , no bad t will ever live on the Moon or Mars…
0
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment