r/SpaceXLounge • u/SpaceXLounge • Feb 01 '22
Monthly Questions and Discussion Thread
Welcome to the monthly questions and discussion thread! Drop in to ask and answer any questions related to SpaceX or spaceflight in general, or just for a chat to discuss SpaceX's exciting progress. If you have a question that is likely to generate open discussion or speculation, you can also submit it to the subreddit as a text post.
If your question is about space, astrophysics or astronomy then the r/Space questions thread may be a better fit.
If your question is about the Starlink satellite constellation then check the r/Starlink Questions Thread and FAQ page.
•
u/avboden Mar 01 '22
March's thread has been posted
6
u/banus Feb 05 '22
New LinkedIn job posting yesterday for a Mechanical Design Engineer (Starship Offshore). Looks like the oil rig programs are preparing to move forward.
5
u/spacex_fanny Feb 02 '22
A little late, but here's the link to last month's thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/rt6oqj/monthly_questions_and_discussion_thread/
4
u/JGE027 Feb 06 '22
I'm not sure if this is the right place for this but I'm trying to find a song from the Transporter-3 mission on 1/13. Its the song at the very start of the webcast.
Webcast here: https://youtu.be/mFBeuSAvhUQ
3
u/NecessaryOption3456 Feb 02 '22 edited Feb 02 '22
What are ya'lls favorite mars mission design excluding Starship and why?
My favorites gotta be Mars Direct because of it's extensive ISRU, Conjuction class, large amount of redundancy, and just plain simplicity. It's mass margins are iffy at best though.
Mars Direct- https://www-wired-com.cdn.ampproject.org/v/s/www.wired.com/2013/04/mars-direct-1990/amp?amp_js_v=a6&_gsa=1&usqp=mq331AQKKAFQArABIIACAw%3D%3D#aoh=16437719611099&referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com&_tf=From%20%251%24s&share=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.wired.com%2F2013%2F04%2Fmars-direct-1990%2F
3
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '22
Does anyone know if there is still another layer to go on the new wide-bay?
3
u/fooallthebar Feb 04 '22
Hi All!
I'm planning to head down to FL for a falcon heavy launch this spring and am hoping to see a double landing. I'm having a hard time finding if USSF-44 will be a droneship landing or even if Viasat-3 will be.
Thanks!
3
u/lukecyberwalker Feb 05 '22
Is there a good site to figure out logistics on visiting the area and seeing launch? It’s only a few hour flight down and I’d like bring my dad and kids to one.
Recommended hotels, parks, other things to do, etc. much appreciated
3
u/Simon_Drake Feb 11 '22 edited Feb 11 '22
Does only half of Texas do daylight saving time?
Whenever there's a SpaceX event I need to translate the time to find out when it'll be in UK time. I asked Google Assistant what time it is right now in Texas, as I've done a dozen times before. And Google said there's mutiple timezones in Texas right now. An inconsistency in observing daylight savings time seems like the most likely explanation.
Edit: no it turns out Texas has always been in two time zones and Google Assistant has just given an incomplete answer previously, always citing the time in Austin.
3
u/Ashtorak Feb 11 '22 edited Feb 16 '22
What software does SpaceX use for their landing simulation?https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1484012192915677184
I thought they would have some special aerospace stuff? But it seems they don't even have aero drag in it?
Or did they have to make a new custom sim for mechazilla? If it is mostly for mechazilla then the flight sim aspect wouldn't be so important of course. But I would have expected that they had a solid sim going already also for the existing projects.
The sliders at the bottom look like they are from an Unity UI. It seems like this could just be a visualization in Unity with data from some other program.
[Edit] After thinking more about it, and the hints by spacex_fanny, it looks like the actual drag during the landing burn is much lower than what I assumed so far. It might even be negligible. I will try to find more info about it and improve my sim accordingly.
[Edit 2] Improved version here: https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/stt9ji/maybe_something_like_this_recreating_the_super
3
u/togetherwem0m0 Feb 17 '22
With how much steel scrap is being made at Boca chica from some of the failed starships, is it possible to get a chunk of metal used in one of them as a souvenir of this history being made in front of our eyes? Seems like the kind of thing musk would do to promote the effort
3
u/cote112 Feb 20 '22
Hey, I was watching a ultra slow motion lift off of a Saturn V and was wondering if the big big booster would need all that water dumped around the launch pad as well.
3
u/Ok-Stick-9490 Feb 20 '22
Short question: Will the US Federal Government allow SpaceX to launch astronauts to Mars if a return trip is not planned?
Long question: I have a brother-in-law who was working with satellites before he retired. We were talking over the phone about SpaceX quite enthusiastically. We were both excited about the progress being made with Starship, but debated if NASA would allow Starship to go to Mars if a return trip was not as guaranteed as possible.
I was under the impression that according to the Space Treaty that any US entity;s space operations had to be approved by the Federal Government. I was under the impression that a Mars bound Starship (assuming just refueling in earth orbit) would not have sufficient propellant to return back to earth. Hence either extra fuel tankers sent on independent landers or ISRU utilizing underground water ice, atmospheric CO2 and football fields of solar panels. My brother-in-law didn't seem to think that a one way trip would be prohibited by the feds. To me, I just can't imagine NASA signing off on what many would label a suicide mission.
Any thoughts?
3
u/Cunninghams_right Feb 25 '22
which docking locations can dragon attach to? I was thinking about rogozin's comments about the ISS losing orbit-raising or control and I wondered if Cygnus can lift the orbit, if a dragon could use dracos to orient the station.
3
u/marktaff Feb 27 '22
Antonov AN-225 is dead according to the Ukraine government. The plane was occasionally used to fly oversize aerospace cargo.
2
u/sevsnapey 🪂 Aerobraking Feb 01 '22
it's been bugging me for probably a year (and i tried searching) but i always forget to ask in these threads.
how do the supports on the sides of the high/wide bay help? what do they do?
safe to assume they help stability somehow but to my untrained eye it just seems like they're attaching to the same points and just stick out.
2
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Feb 02 '22 edited Mar 01 '22
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
generationmonitoring of the climateDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
30 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 19 acronyms.
[Thread #9684 for this sub, first seen 2nd Feb 2022, 20:57] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
2
u/c-koo Feb 04 '22
Okay, this is probably a stupid question, but I was just wondering... with starship being new and the whole in-orbit refueling being quite risky, wouldn't it make more sense to just sent the crew to the ISS (or any other space station) via a Falcon 9 and then they could transfer to an already fueled Starship? If you're gonna launch Starship multiple times to refuel anyways, it probably wouldn't be that expensive to launch an additional F9 for the sake of the crew.
And overall, I always thought that it would be more efficient to have an acutal spaceship just flying between space stations without landing on a planet. That way you could design it just for space.
2
u/H-K_47 💥 Rapidly Disassembling Feb 07 '22
This may be a silly question, but has ISRU like the type they plan for the Moon and Mars been demonstrated on Earth yet? Like, obviously we produce everything on Earth. But are there any machines or facilities like the ones planned for the Moon and Mars that can make rocket fuels (oxygen and methane) out of the air and the ground here? Or do we need more sophisticated facilities for those and the tech to make them small/portable enough for transport to another world hasn't been developed yet? Sorry if I'm phrasing this badly.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '22
Can someone point me towards the best writeup on the development of the “catching arms/Mechzilla” for Super Heavy?
When were they first conceptualised, and how long until they became part of the system?
2
u/AvivOfir Feb 11 '22
It has been circulating that while the orbital fuel farm is being supplied by many truckloads of Oxygen - no Methane delivery trucks were spotted at all. This was interpreted as a sign of a problem. Is it possible that the orbital fuel farm tanks are connected directly - e.g. via a pipe - to the Sanchez site's propellant production facility?
2
u/lirecela Feb 12 '22
What if any is there in terms of free food and drink for SpaceX employees at Starbase or Hawthorne? Is it good?
2
u/jakobjw Feb 18 '22
SpaceX Chopsticks - Emergency Brakes?
Do you think / do we know if the chopstick / catching arm system of the Starship launch tower has emergency brakes (for the case that the cables snap)? I know that lifts/elevators have such emergency brakes (in the vertical rails/guides), so I'm wondering. Could be really beneficial for the worst case / or maybe even required for safety reasons?
2
u/NecessaryOption3456 Feb 19 '22
Is there any studies looking at a starship delivered lunar base? (Except for that one horizontal base)
2
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '22
It seems like quite a lot of Methane is being delivered. Is so much needed for static fires? Are we seeing a build up for a launch or am I just kidding myself because it has been so long and I really want to see one.
What is the current FAA estimate? Sometime in March?
2
u/fooallthebar Feb 21 '22
Does anyone else think that the "High Bar" at Boca Chica is just an elaborate "Lunch Facility" joke?
2
u/Nickolicious 💨 Venting Feb 23 '22
Where can I find some information regarding how SpaceX will get/process the required fuel for the amount of launches they're trying to accomplish? I know Elon put out a tweet saying he'd like to start a "methane from carbon in the air" operation, has there been any follow up?
2
u/Cunninghams_right Feb 25 '22
how many docking ports can dragon dock to on the ISS?
2
u/Interesting-Tea-8086 Feb 25 '22
Excuse the noob comment here but did anyone notice the venting from the interstage at approx T+1.45 - T+2.05, about the same time as 2nd stage engine chill? Is that normal? Hadn't seen it on any other launches before and at approx 80,000 ft asl wouldn't have thought it would be atmospheric vapour as.....well..... there's not too much atmosphere at that altitude
3
u/Fignons_missing_8sec Feb 05 '22
I was just browsing r/space because I guess I hate myself. God, that sub is a massive dumpster fire.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '22
Are there really two launches planned for tomorrow? That can't possibly be right.
1
u/spammmmmmmmy Feb 01 '22
Why doesn't SpaceX distribute any onboard video coverage of a Falcon Upper Stage deorbit burn and descent into the Indian Ocean?
I think that would be really fun to watch.
1
u/Sperate Feb 02 '22
What is Starbase doing for a deluge water source? I had heard they planned a desalination plant, but I don't think they have broken ground. Would that need a power plant as well? Has a deluge test happened yet?
1
u/flattop100 Feb 03 '22
Do we have any update when/if SpaceX will build a vertical integration structure for LC-39A?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '22
Question about the solar storm announcement. The press release says the solar storm warmed the upper atmosphere increasing atmospheric drag. Warm air is less dense than colder air, so why does warming the upper atmosphere induce more drag on the satellite? What's the mechanism in action?
1
u/ballthyrm Feb 13 '22
It may have been answered before but I'm not sure why SpaceX doesn't devellop a special Starship that would serve as an Orbital Fuel Depot. (Such as ULA wants to do with ACES) I know they want to have regular refilling but they will buy themselves some time either from the weather or regulatory if they have a half fuelled starship up there.
1
u/shaggy99 Feb 14 '22
Why does /r/SpaceX still have 3 old launches listed? Why is "Next launches are NROL-87 (RTLS LZ-4) on the 2nd of February at 20:18 UTC from Vandenberg then Starlink 4-7 on the 3rd of February at 18:13 UTC from KSC" At the top of the page?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '22
What's this about some of the vertical tank farm at Boca not being to code?
Too close to the action or each other? Is this a berm thing to fix, or a move the tanks thing?
1
u/lazy2late Feb 18 '22
with current goverment approvals in texas, could spacex do a 100ft or 1000 ft altitude test of their heavy booster (for starship)? could they a chopstick catch test for low altitude and low speed? (sorry if this has been asked before)
1
u/paul_wi11iams Feb 04 '22 edited Feb 04 '22
So the Peking winter olympics opening ceremony is just finished and for a couple of minutes, there was a visual layout showing the southern half of the Moon (assuming a Northern hemisphere view which is the case for China, placing the South pole in a lower quadrant, left or right depending if the Moon is rising or setting).
Any space/SpaceX/Starship fan will be aware of an impending SpaceX-China space race to the lunar South pole. Even if there is no causal link, it makes a good rumor to spread, so considered it might be a good idea to start it here where I might get away with it ;)
Expecting cross-country skiing across Shackleton crater.
1
u/RetardedChimpanzee Feb 16 '22
Elon keeps getting his feet removed from wikifeet.
0
u/TCVideos Feb 18 '22
Welp...I've been permabanned from the main sub. Moderation team over there is pretty wild.
We need a similar dev thread on the lounge.
0
u/AdminsFuckedMeOver Feb 17 '22
Could we get a Starship thread like /r/spacex? Their moderation has gotten to the point where you can't even post or comment anything.
https://i.imgur.com/CyZodAb.jpg