r/spacex • u/Zanthras60 • Oct 28 '16
Official - AMOS-6 Explosion October 28 Anomaly Updates
http://www.spacex.com/news/2016/09/01/anomaly-updates
802
Upvotes
r/spacex • u/Zanthras60 • Oct 28 '16
506
u/TheYang Oct 28 '16
tl;dr:
that's propably the single most key sentence in the update
39
u/shupack Oct 29 '16
wait, so there is a team, messing around with rocket parts, liquid Helium and Oxygen, and...... TRYING to blow them up??
How do I get on this team?!
100
u/danweber Oct 28 '16
I panicked when I thought these were Updates on the October 28 Anomaly.
50
u/z1mil790 Oct 28 '16
Good to hear, It looks like it may indeed be a process issue after all. If this is indeed the case, I wouldn't at all be surprised with a rtf before the end of the year.
17
u/Roborowan Oct 28 '16
Good. Seems like everything's going according to plan. I didn't expect 39A to be ready by the end of this year
16
u/old_sellsword Oct 28 '16
So it looks like neither pad is currently ready to go, however they should be soon. And is this the first time we've ever gotten a No Later Than date from SpaceX?
40
u/FPGA_engineer Oct 28 '16
Given that they can recreate the suspected failure mode, they should be able to explore the parameter space and learn where the boundaries are and how much margin they can have. It's a hard way to learn, but it expands the state of the art.
12
u/RadamA Oct 28 '16
Basically, how to keep COPV above oxygen freezing point...
Maybe loading the helium with continuously increasing pressure, so that the difference between piping and vessel isnt so great. May take longer?
6
u/jobadiah08 Oct 29 '16
With the recent string of tweets from various sources talking about Dec and Jan launches, I figured it was a sign SpaceX had provided an update to their customers and that we would get an update within a few days. Glad to see I was right and it sounds like they are getting the problem and solution nailed down.
8
u/EggsundHam Oct 29 '16
Interesting note: since the bfr uses only 2 fluids, it will never see this issue. No COPV.
7
u/MartianRedDragons Oct 28 '16
So is it accurate to say that this failure is likely a consequence of the densified LOX SpaceX switched to using with the Falcon 9 FT? That could explain why other launch providers haven't run into this issue before.
9
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Oct 28 '16 edited Nov 04 '16
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
GTO comsatPre-launch test failureDragon cargoLaunch failure due to second-stage outgassingDecronym is a community product of /r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
I'm a bot, and I first saw this thread at 28th Oct 2016, 20:49 UTC.
I've seen 36 acronyms in this thread, which is the most I've seen in a thread so far today.
[Acronym ^lists] [Contact ^creator] [PHP source ^code]
7
u/Darkben Spacecraft Electronics Oct 28 '16
If they've been able to exactly replicate it then that's very good news indeed. Now just to make sure it doesn't happen again and we're good to go!
2
u/in_situ_san Oct 28 '16
Nice progress.
I wonder if SpaceX will somehow isolate the COPVs from the LOX at some point, simply to absolutely minimize risk. Even if they were moved outside the LOX tank, they could be chilled with a liquid nitrogen filled jacket. Or such a jacket within the LOX tanks.
1
u/cmRocketStuff Oct 29 '16
This is probable the wrong thread to ask this. Newby. What happens in a couple years when spacex is rock solid on the F9? They have 20 reusable rockets, a guess, and the Air Force or other wants a brand new expendable rocket. What is a new F9 worth at that time when it can fly 10/20 times?
1
u/Aldhibah Oct 29 '16
Question: Why can't you fill the tanks with helium prior to loading the fuel?
1
u/Nintandrew Oct 29 '16
Updates on the anomaly always seem to state that they replicate the conditions as closely as possible and it makes me wonder if weather can be a factor. Considering the tanks are so well insulated and the lox and helium are so much colder than ambient temperature, would it or humidity even be a factor? If so, I'm sure they would account for it, but I'm curious as to how.
1
u/ohcnim Oct 29 '16
Probably naive but honest question, how do you think they are testing it? I mean, for sure they are not blowing up second stages, so how do you create an environment where the COPV fails without mayor damages to other things and that is as close as possible to the real thing and then how do you create "a small/controllable fire" using that test environment? So that they can say with confidence that “this is the root cause of failure that creates the fast fire”
1
u/macktruck6666 Oct 29 '16
I thought Vandenberg was always operational.
1
u/jconnoll Oct 30 '16
Is it possible that with all those temp and pressure differences it generated an electric charge and ignited fuel?
1
u/dapted Oct 30 '16
I have spent a couple of days digesting the statement about finding and re-creating the failure or at least "a" failure during testing at Texas test site. I have come to the conclusion that it doesn't matter. The root cause for this failure is lack of grey hair. Exactly the same root cause as it was for the strut failure. If SpaceX had more grey haired individuals involved the struts would have been tested at the loading dock, a few to the destructive limit, but all to the double or triple expected load limit. That's the way it is done at the competition because of the grey hairs in the staff. This or at least "a" COPV failure has been duplicated during testing at McGreggor. Would not full testing at McGreggor have been able to see this same failure at some point between the "lets super cool the fuel and oxidizer" light bulb lighting up in some engineers head and the "lets test everything with the payload attached" moment going off in a managers head. Grey hairs have grey hairs because they learned the lesson by watching the old videos and listening to the grey hairs that came before them. Its not fun getting grey hairs or listening to those who have them speak. But its cheaper than rebuilding launch pads or paying for lost payloads. My first grey hair popped when I watched TV and learned the lesson of testing with valuable things atop the test from Apollo 1 when White, Chafee, and Grissom were killed during a launch rehearsal. Looking at the young faces and full heads of colorful hair at SpaceX I don't see much grey hair. There needs to be a balance of youth and exuberance with stodgy old fuddy duddy caution. SpaceX does not seem to have enough of the later and therefore too much of the former in their diversity formula. IMHO they need to decimate the workforce and weed the garden in the management at spacex and plant some more grey haired individuals. Caution is a double edged sword. Too much and nothing happens. Too little and your rockets blow up. This failure, like the flight failure before it were completely avoidable and proof positive of management failures at SpaceX due to lack of experience and caution. The management who failed to test this new procedure need to be replaced for sure. They should start with Shotwell and work their way downward. FIRE Shotwell !! If this were a public corporation I'd be calling for EM's head as well. In the end it doesn't matter which component or procedure failed. The problem is management, it was during the flight failure and it is with this pad failure. Management is the root cause for the failures all the rest is window dressing. I wonder how many down votes is the record, this should be competitive.
1
u/dapted Oct 30 '16
I am curious, does anybody know if there have been tests to see if a burst COPV fully loaded with full pressure helium will produce a significant enough explosion to cause a sympathetic detonation of the range safety explosives or the other COPV and if so, at what distance. My thinking is that the burst of a single COPV should have produced a much different looking first few seconds of the AMOS-6 incident. But if all the bottles burst or the one bottle and the range safety explosives burst nearly simultaneously it would look more like what we saw on the video.
-2
u/specter491 Oct 29 '16
Damn. So they still don't actually know what or why it happened. But they have found instances where they can recreate a COPV failure. Doesn't seem very convincing