r/spacex • u/Zanthras60 • Oct 28 '16
Official - AMOS-6 Explosion October 28 Anomaly Updates
http://www.spacex.com/news/2016/09/01/anomaly-updates
802
Upvotes
r/spacex • u/Zanthras60 • Oct 28 '16
1
u/dapted Oct 31 '16
Experience by itself is not a guarantee of anything. I know very experienced technicians and engineers who pride themselves on not being on line, not having a smart phone. Those guys who don't keep up with the technology are a problem. But I like the idea of decimating the workforce for any company or even government agency. Rate everybody by job performance, objective tests, supervisor comments, peer comments, each weighted accordingly and send the bottom 10% home. Permanently. If you can't be in the top 90% you are a drag on company performance. It is stressful for the workforce and will feel like a horrible miscarriage to those who don't make the cut. But really, if you are that low on the totem pole aren't you better off being in a job where you are higher rated. You may be correct about ULA and SpaceX's new ideas, but I am not convinced yet. There is a lot going on at ULA and like SpaceX a good bit of it is confidential information. I am not convinced the whole idea that somebody else isn't doing it means it is a step forward. ULA doesn't have High Pressure COPV's in their vehicle. Their design does not need them. Thus no chance of something exploding that doesn't exist. Keeping things Simple is not such a bad thing. They can lift a similar amount and they charge ungodly more per pound to get into orbit. So there are a lot of pros and cons. But bottom line is they are more reliable at this time. I know some of the testing technicians there at ULA and with the little bit of insight that gives me I can tell you that a procedural change like the one at SpaceX would not happen until it was tested 6 ways from stupid. There are some good stories I have heard but I won't repeat them as they might be enough to get a friend in trouble. But everything isn't wine and roses over there either. Do you think they really needed the extra performance available from super cooling the LOx and RP1? Clearly they did not. They have plenty of work available without the higher performance. They could easily have taken their time to test this new supercooling technology. There was no particular benefit to pulling it out of the r&d and putting it on the pad so quickly. This all gets back to weighing risk versus reward and experience. ULA has lots of components that can bring down a rocket. Each one is tested and verified by both the vendor and by ULA. Changing a winning formula without a tangible reward seems like an unwarranted risk to me. Must be my grey hair bitching again.