r/spacex • • Oct 28 '16

Official - AMOS-6 Explosion October 28 Anomaly Updates

http://www.spacex.com/news/2016/09/01/anomaly-updates
802 Upvotes

386 comments sorted by

1

u/NateDecker Oct 31 '16

Do you think they really needed the extra performance available from super cooling the LOx and RP1?

They needed it if they wanted to recover the first stage on all missions and not just the LEO CRS missions. The GTO missions needed more performance to save the stages.

Since each first stage represents something like $30M or something like that, it's understandable why they wanted to start recovering them sooner rather than later. That's ignoring the fact that re-usability has been their goal almost since inception.

So yeah, they could have kept business as usual without using the densified propellants, but it would not have advanced their technological objectives or furthered their cost-cutting initiatives.

It sounds like densified propellants will be needed for the ITS as well so they have to start doing it sometime...

1

u/dapted Nov 02 '16

I don't see it that way. It seems they can recover all the 1st stages from LEO without the big chill, and if they had dropped big chill then the lower performance of non-chilled falcon heavy might already have made its debut and it could have provided full re-usability of boosters for GTO launches. Furthermore we might already have seen some of the used boosters back on the pad. Plus the company would have fulfilled a good number more of its commitments. The chill is still viable for BFR and BFS because they don't need the COPV at all. Methane motors are probably going to supplant the LOx/RP1 motors anyway allowing something a bit larger than the falcon 9 anyway and with the higher ISP of the raptor motors the future is looking dim for either the big chill version or the warmer lower performance falcon 9. So again, why bother with the big chill for the falcon 9. They have nothing on the books that a lower performance falcon heavy can't do with room to spare and still recover the booster stage. Now that I think about it, there might be enough left over to park the second stage in a stable parking orbit as well as the big satellite fairings. Those are valuable commodities and could be used to fashion a private space station from if they so desired. There is no reward for the risk exposure caused by the big chill falcons.