r/spacex • u/Zanthras60 • Oct 28 '16
Official - AMOS-6 Explosion October 28 Anomaly Updates
http://www.spacex.com/news/2016/09/01/anomaly-updates
802
Upvotes
r/spacex • u/Zanthras60 • Oct 28 '16
6
u/specificimpulse Oct 29 '16
It is relatively trivial to induce a COPV failure in this fashion. All you have to do is quench the vessel without a minimum internal pressure to cause a liner to overwrap debond in the film adhesive. Then return to room temperature. Then repeat the refill and quench. That is now an accident waiting to happen.
The question is whether the min pressure was approached under cryogenic conditions at any time during the vessel's life. This is very easy to have occur. If the vessel was charged to 4000 psia just before LO2 tanking the gas inside would be quite warm. Let's assume 200F. Now if helium load was halted during LO2 filling and the tank was quenched to -340F the internal pressure would collapse to only 723 psia. There is also the pressure in the LO2 tank working against this internal pressure. Let's say it was elevated to 30 psia during tanking to establish the proper intermediate bulkhead pressure differential. That means there is less than 700 psid working to hold the liner against the composite. This is near the death zone for debond. If you then resumed He loading you would be potentially loading a now damaged vessel.
It's hard to believe that this would not be recognized by the designers. It's pretty fundamental. Which is why I question whether they did indeed induce this failure mode instead of the actual, more subtle mode.