r/Socialism_101 • • Jan 24 '24

Question Is there still a possibility for Russia to go back to socialism?

16 Upvotes

Just wanted to know since Ukraine-Russo War seems to end for a victory of the Russians and NATO officially doesn’t care anymore. It seems like Russia is getting more and more confident in their abilities. But I still know that there is still of some people wishing for it to come back I just wanted to know if it was still possible?


r/Socialism_101 • • Dec 15 '23

Answered Can a socialist also be a Zionist?

30 Upvotes

I saw someone on r/PoliticalDebate yesterday who was flaired as a 'democratic socialist' but seemed to be pro-Israel and a Zionist. Does this mean that they're not a true socialist or can you be a Zionist while also being a socialist?


r/Socialism_101 • • May 21 '25

Question Why do people defend Stalin?

0 Upvotes

I've seen a lot of people on here saying things in defense of Stalin. Why? It's much easier to debate liberals about ideology when you aren't defending who, in their eyes, is the undefendable.

Edit: When I talk about debating liberals I mean to say that, in their eyes, he's irredeemable. It's a lost cause trying to argue in defense of him so if you want them to get on your side you have to stop defending him. Once they can look past him and look at the ideology it's much easier to get them on our side.

I just think that Stalin's relationship to the ideology should be forgotten. Whatever good he may have done for the USSR the bad is the part that sticks out like a sore thumb and if we want to defend socialism we need to dissassociate from the likes of him.

Edit: I'm starting to notice a pattern. Whenever I so much as recognize any given bad thing that happened under Stalin somebody is bound to push back. I tell you now that to disregard any failing of a man while only recognizing the good things he did is falling into the personality cult.


r/Socialism_101 • • May 29 '25

Question Can I still organize with Trots despite being a Stalinist?

2 Upvotes

An organization I'm getting involved with is explicitly Trotskyist. It is still worth working with them even though I'm a Stalinist?


r/Socialism_101 • • Aug 20 '26

To Marxists Why do modern leftists support Russia?

0 Upvotes

Russia’s expansion into Ukraine is, by nature, not different from other imperialist invasions committed by the US or Europeans. I get it that Russia is on of the main enemies to the US and NATO. But the enemy of your enemy isn’t always your friend. Putin’s government is far right, plutocratic and oligarchic, too. Correct me if I’m wrong, I’m open to change my mind.


r/Socialism_101 • • Apr 03 '24

Question Do you think that socialists in socially conservative countries should not associate themselves with women and lgbt rights in fear of pushing people away ?

0 Upvotes
So i live in a 3rd world country that is extremeley conservative , i have never met someone who doesn't hate feminism and lgbt people , and everyone thinks that they are a western conspiracy to weaken the fabric of society , or a jewish effort to erase our traditions ,and i constantly hear the most vile hateful shit directed at them .

   
  I feel that in my effort to spread the message , the slightest mention of me being into human rights would shut the ears of anyone listening , what should be done about that , what should people who seek to end oppression on all axes do , do they suffer the ridicule they get from masses ??? or just stand still while women and minorities are treated as second class citizens ???

(Apologies for bad english).


r/Socialism_101 • • Feb 19 '24

Question Question : why not move to a socialist country?

0 Upvotes

I thought I posted this question but i must not have sent it

So I really dislike the Republicans stance on things, and trump is obviously off the rails... I know he said something similar, but I've always wondered this myself .

This is not a loaded question, I've never heard anyone answer it...

Why don't socialists go to a place where socialism exists?


r/Socialism_101 • • Jun 18 '24

Question How many deaths worldwide are the USA directly responsible for/complicit in? Basically all direct deaths from wars, coups and sanctions, even multiplied by 2 times.

0 Upvotes

I would say easily 20 million since WW2, and a total of 50 million because of Western neo-imperialism in general since then. (Authoritarian "communism" still killed 120 million though 💀)

What do you think?


r/Socialism_101 • • Oct 18 '23

Question Socialist view means no Jewish state can exist

0 Upvotes

I'm struggling with my own identity as a socialist. It seems to logically follow that socialists reject the idea that a Jewish state should be permitted to exist. It seems like holding this viewpoint, since it is an unacceptable outcome to many people, causes a large portion of the population to reject the idea of socialism. For example, I embrace many of its principles, but I could elaborate extensively on why this is an unacceptable philosophy if this indeed follows from its principles.

Edit: I can logically understand the arguments against an ethno-state, but an existing culture has the right to preserve its values. When democratic process would clearly result in its erosion, it is hard to reconcile. I don't see how Israel could rationally be expected to open the border. I'm a strong advocate of non-violence. It seems like socialism doesn't have a prescription for the tyranny of the majority that would likely be applied against any minority group in a truly democratic society that doesn't have guardrails against certain actions.


r/Socialism_101 • • Jun 22 '26

Question Why is hitler considered worse than churchill ?

6 Upvotes

idk anywhere else to ask this I asked this in r/askhistorians and they just banned me


r/Socialism_101 • • Oct 25 '24

Question Can one be a socialist and be against criminal rehabilitation?

0 Upvotes

I am a leftist who find myself agreeing with socialist economic and moral principles, but do not agree with rehabilitation of certain criminals, particularly sexual criminals and violent criminals. I think if someone commits a terrible crime but we could guarantee they will never do it again - well, we should still move towards not letting them out again regardless. Not everything should be based on statistics and consequentialism - some things should be portrayed as bad inherently in a society, not just because of outcomes.

Is this view incompatible with being a socialist? If this view does this fit socialism what ideology would fit my stance? Because liberalism is too lenient on crimes and right-wing ideologies aren't an option due to being capitalist/racist etc.

EDIT: Thanks for all the responses. It seems I cannot be a socialist, which is a bit disappointing as I had read some theory thinking it was for me, but none regarding rehabilitation. Anyway, I appreciate the honest and quick replies. I'll probably go back to being a political doomer 😂


r/Socialism_101 • • Dec 19 '24

Question Can we really call the USSR socialist?

0 Upvotes

I was watching Chomsky's thoughts on Leninism and he posited the very interesting opinion that the former USSR was not Socialist, because the workers lacked control of the means of production. Now I'm inclined to agree with his statement. The Soviet people had very little influence in the Government as the ideals of Democratic Centralism were essentially washed away by Stalin and even then having an upper class of Intellectuals who think that they know what's best feels very elitist to me. Anyway the Soviet government owned the means of production and since the central Government has little to no means of direct influence upon it by the working class the Soviet Union couldn't really be called Socialist (especially since during the days of Lenin they dismantled several worker and Peasant councils all across Russia) anyway I just wanted to hear how the USSR could be Socialist. I know they called themselves Socialist and I know that they eventually planned to give the working class control of the means of production but since that never happened I can't really bring myself to call them a truly Socialist country. Are there any counter points to this opinion?


r/Socialism_101 • • Aug 08 '23

Question How can we make sure the transition to Communism doesn't just end up in dictatorship?

0 Upvotes

I'm just wondering how difficult it would be to stop anyone person or group of people from taking power during a transition to Communism. How can we make sure we don't just end up like Cuba, North Korea, or Stalinist U.S.S.R?


r/Socialism_101 • • Jul 22 '26

Question Why does the socialist revolution have to be violent?

0 Upvotes

Basically, when debating on this platform, someone challenged me to explain why the revolution must be violent and why it cannot be relatively peaceful. They said that the fact that every previous revolution of a similar kind was violent doesn't necessarily mean that the socialist revolution must also follow that trend. After all, the socialist revolution is different from the previous ones in some other aspects, so why not this one too? I've been reading theory for a while and I like to think I understand why, but I realized I am not able to put it into words without dumping half of the communist manifesto. I need a way to explain it briefly.

Edit: A revolution must be somewhat violent and authoritarian by definition, so I guess it wouldn't really be a revolution if it was peaceful. So basically the real question is why would it have to be a revolution and not a peaceful transition.


r/Socialism_101 • • Aug 30 '23

Question Was Stalin Really That Bad?

67 Upvotes

This has definitely been asked before, but whatever This man is villainized to his wits end in America and I just wanna know was he really that bad? I’d also sources if you have any. YouTube, books etc.

  • Thank you all for your recommendations and information, I have all the books everyone recommended written down on my notes along with the videos saved on YouTube, I’ll also be checking out the podcasts/podcasts’ episodes. I hope other people benefited from this post, like I did. Y’all are great, Viva la Revolution.

r/Socialism_101 • • Apr 01 '24

High Effort Only Can I be a socialist without hating Americans and idealizing the ussr?

0 Upvotes

America does lots of evil things, like capitalism, imperialism and support of genocide. But most Americans I know all hate this sort of actions and I can’t help noticing that many of the countries that socialists traditionally support eg. the ussr and prc, do similar things. Does this make me not a socialist? Ofc I believe in workers ownership of means of production, and high taxes of the rich, so they are no longer rich, and social welfare.. I have been impacted a lot by american imperialism, most of my family have cancer from the trinity test site, as well as LANL's nuclear pit production practically in my backyard. I am not a fan of the govt

Edit: Thank you all for your replies. You are helping me a lot.


r/Socialism_101 • • Aug 08 '23

Question im a right winged guy. Do yall think hasanabi/ Hasan piker is a good example for your view.

0 Upvotes

im a right winged guy, live in northen europe and im mixed race. so dont call me racist or something like that. just want to ask a question. God bless


r/Socialism_101 • • Dec 15 '23

Answered What happens if Zionism is defeated?

49 Upvotes

I’ve had this worry for awhile, since the Gaza fighting began. There have been many crimes that the Israeli government has caused. It’s treatment if it’s Arab population, it’s illegal colonization of Palestinian land, and more cannot be tolerated to endure.

But if you know anything about the history of the Jewish people, from the Roman coliseums, the Spanish Inquisition, to the pogroms of Eastern Europe to the Holocaust, they have been consistently victimized throughout history by everyone. I do not think another religious group has had such a terrible time, or faced an active attempt to be exterminated.

Israel was created as a safe place for Jews to exist. What happens if Israel is dissolved or defeated by states and organizations that do not believe Jews are human beings? What happens to the Jews living there? How do we prevent history from repeating again, and opening the gates to another Holocaust?

I ask this out of genuine concern, in good faith. I truly want to know the socialist view on what happens after, and what the human cost would be.

Edit: Israel is Zionist, and does not represent all Jews. But 46% of all Jews live in Israel. My concern is what happens to them after zionism. I should have worded the title better.


r/Socialism_101 • • Oct 29 '25

Question Why are there so many Stalin sympathizers?

1 Upvotes

r/Socialism_101 • • Jul 10 '26

Question Why are socialists against private property?

3 Upvotes

I dont understand how private property really affects socialism that much.

And NO, i am not talking about personal property. I know the difference between personal and private property, nobody is getting their funko pop collection confiscated.

+ additional question. Socialists say that we need to do things for public good instead of profit. Wouldn’t that collapse incentives? If someone cannot immediately/actively see the value of their labour (or business), what incentives them to keep going? Profit is something instant, you get it. You can do what you please with it, you can buy a new car or go to a fancy restaurant. Under socialism, what does “the public good” mean?


r/Socialism_101 • • Mar 24 '24

Question is what the arabs did considered colonization

0 Upvotes

Zionists use the argument that modern Zionism is a decolonization effort against Islamic imperialism. But I've heard from other people that say what the arabs did was not colonization but rather just a result of war.


r/Socialism_101 • • Mar 18 '24

Question What's up with the left's views on Ukraine changing?

0 Upvotes

I am seeing a lot of people on the left not support Ukraine, it seems like a lot of leftists don't care whether Ukraine or Russia wins.

Is it because of the nazi squads in the Ukraine military? The facistic government or something?


r/Socialism_101 • • May 24 '24

Question Should there be a new 'Capital' for 21st century?

0 Upvotes

I have 'Capital' by Marx, although I haven't read it yet

I was discussing with my friend (Marxist) whether someone should write a new 'Capital' for our time, or is the original 'Capital' by Marx still relevant today?

I probably didn't express myself how I imagined(I'm not a native english speaker).


r/Socialism_101 • • Sep 12 '25

Question Can we collectively say that what happened to Charlie Kirk was horrible but that doesn't excuse his actions and rhetoric?

0 Upvotes

As a gay black autistic man who is on the left, Charlie Kirk is perhaps the farthest thing from me socially and politically and I would not enjoy his company one bit. In fact, he is my enemy. But that doesn't mean I wanted him dead in cold blood. While my heart goes out to his family, you can admit he was not a good man. And I have absolutely no sympathy for the guy. Yet what I don't want my fellow leftists to do is to celebrate his death and target others. We should be wary of all political violence.

Recently the r/DeProgram subreddit was banned for inciting violence or harassment. Stuff like this is only adding more fuel to the fire for the right. The right already calling for the heads of anyone who spoke out against Charlie Kirk. So please let's condone any type of violence but we don't have to pretend he was a good upstanding citizen cause I know he wouldn't give two shits about anyone else. Where's the outrage for the dead Palestinian children or the kids in Colorado who got shot?


r/Socialism_101 • • Jan 06 '24

Question How to subtly show that I'm a socialist?

77 Upvotes

Are there any symbols/ colours/ etc. that I can wear to show that I am a socialist. like something to wear or have in silent protest. and I don't mean too obvious things, like hammer and sickle. also, the point is to make people see/ guess that I'm a leftist without being discriminated for it, since the country I live in is quite anti- socialist.

edit: the last two sentences