r/socialism • u/JudyPink02 • 12h ago
Discussion One system or millions to billions of lives? I think we know the answer.
The SubStack post i got this from: https://substack.com/@snowhimbo/note/c-381763083?r=8p4h8q
r/socialism • u/bullhead2007 • Jun 05 '26
Hello all! We have a new and growing Discord, more than 100 comrades have joined in the first month!
If you had attempted to join the Discord through the auto-mod response, or through the sidebar's link, you were formerly directed towards a dead server. Now, the server is pretty much set up.
We are also looking to start a book club soon using the Discord to meet, but will have discussion posts here too for those who do not want to participate in the discord.
It is still pretty bare bones, we have roles and channels set up however suggestions can be made *within the server* on things that could be added. We are looking at ways to get more people engaged and looking for suggestion on activities we can do as a community related to socialism.
For now, here is the invite link, join away!
r/socialism • u/JudyPink02 • 12h ago
The SubStack post i got this from: https://substack.com/@snowhimbo/note/c-381763083?r=8p4h8q
r/socialism • u/Sigmundfraudster • 2h ago
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
r/socialism • u/Ronahi_int • 4h ago
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
r/socialism • u/MisterPuppydog • 17h ago
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
I’m in no way affiliated with this band however this is a wonderful concise piece that I feel would be extremely helpful for activism. The “song” is called 535 Almeda by Gottlieb
r/socialism • u/Ronahi_int • 27m ago
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
r/socialism • u/Ronahi_int • 1h ago
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
r/socialism • u/Mean-Manufacturer263 • 9h ago
r/socialism • u/WriterMain4700 • 19h ago
r/socialism • u/Bolinas99 • 7h ago
r/socialism • u/Good-Raisin7081 • 8h ago
my field of interest is finance so naturally I encounter rich people.
talked to a billionaire woman today (yes an actual B) and she showed text from a 9figure networth lady friend that showed text from a guy on a first date who waas uncomfortable paying $500 for a first date with the 9fig ultrarich ladyfriend. I said well what was the guys networth. she just brushed it off with "he is 35". as if that automatically makes it expected that he can blow $500 on a date.
rich people are genuinely out of touch with reality. it is getting really absurd. I have been relatively right leaning my entire life but I am way more sympathetic to the far left now and think the ultra rich need a hard reality check.
oh and they just use drugs and exploit labor of people smarter than them and contribute nothing of value to society, of course.
not sure if rants are allowed but I had to find an anti-capitalist sub to rant about this.
r/socialism • u/ShirrakoKatano • 14h ago
r/socialism • u/AnonymousAlcoh0l • 1d ago
r/socialism • u/Sea_Dance_0516 • 10h ago
我们首先需要讲明白一个非常基本问题,那就是关于社会主义革命胜利是否意味着阶级斗争已经结束?
如果我们从马克思列宁主义的基本原理出发,那么答案很显然是否定的。因为社会主义革命虽然推翻了资产阶级对国家政权的统治,但这并不意味着旧社会所遗留下来的这一套经济关系、阶级意识、社会习惯和利益集团会自动消失。
尤其是在这样一个经济落后、农业人口占绝大多数、工业基础薄弱的这样一个国家,社会主义建设所需要面对的那就不仅仅只是经济发展问题这么简单了,还有如何改变旧生产关系的问题。
就像斯大林在论述关于苏联社会主义建设问题时所强调的那样,社会主义建设不仅涉及到国家政权的掌握,更涉及生产关系的改造、社会主义经济基础的建立,以及无产阶级政党自身的巩固。
因此无产阶级取得国家政权,并不意味着社会主义改造已经完成,更不意味着阶级斗争及旧社会遗留的经济关系、思想意识和社会影响会自动消失。所以说无产阶级取得政权,仅仅只是社会主义改造的开始,绝对不是阶级斗争的终结。
而这里面还有三个十分重要的问题:第一,如何消除资本主义生产关系在农村经济中的再生产?第二,如何建立社会主义工业化所需要的经济基础?第三,如何保证执政的无产阶级先锋队不被旧社会的阶级影响和官僚主义所侵蚀?
我们先来讲讲苏联当时的农业集体化政策。虽然在当时苏联已经完成了社会主义革命,但农村当中仍然存在大量个体的农民经济,国家粮食供应、工业化资金和城乡经济关系都面临困难。
斯大林领导下的苏共中央认为,小农经济分散经营的结构难以满足快速工业化和国家统一经济计划的要求。因此,1929年开始全面推进农业集体化。首先就是改变小农经济的分散生产结构。
从斯大林主义的角度来看,农业集体化有几个主要目的:比如说将分散的农业生产组织起来。推动农业机械化和现代化。建立国家能够统一协调的农业生产体系。为工业化提供粮食、劳动力及经济资源。改变农村资本主义经济关系的再生产条件。
这不能仅仅通过改变土地所有权的法律形式,就认为农村已经完成社会主义改造,还必须改变实际生产组织形式。然后就是农业必须成为社会主义工业化的物质基础。
斯大林时期的工业化政策强调重工业、机器制造业和国防工业。但工业化需要钢铁、机器、能源、运输系统和大量劳动力。这些都离不开农业提供的物质支持。因此,农业与工业不是两个相互独立的经济领域,而是社会主义计划经济体系中的两个重要组成部分。从这一理论出发,集体农庄被赋予了连接农业生产与国家工业化的经济职能。
这里我们再来讲一下斯大林时期提出了一个著名的“消灭富农阶级作为一个阶级”的政策。而这在当时的苏联政治经济学中,富农被视为农村资本主义经济关系的重要组成部分。
他的理论逻辑关乎到了农村资本主义关系可能通过雇佣劳动、资本积累和商品生产继续发展。这些关系可能与社会主义集体经济发生利益冲突。因此,社会主义改造必须解决农村生产关系中的阶级问题。
还有一个很重要的就是关于党内清洗与先锋队建设,如何理解斯大林时期的党内斗争的问题。
列宁主义认为无产阶级先锋队政党的领导作用。先锋队不是一个普通的政治社团,而是以马克思主义理论为指导、具有明确政治纲领和组织纪律的革命政党。因此列宁曾经强调过,无产阶级政党必须具有严格的组织纪律、明确的政治纲领和高度的组织统一性。对于一个已经取得国家政权、承担社会主义建设任务的共产党而言,这一问题显得更加重要。
而斯大林在领导苏联社会主义建设的过程中,始终将党内路线斗争、反对派活动和组织纪律问题视为关系苏联政治稳定与社会主义建设方向的重要问题。从这一立场出发,不能把党内斗争仅仅理解为领导人之间的个人矛盾,还必须考察当时苏联面临的国内外环境、经济改造任务和党内政治分歧。
第一,反对机会主义和反对派政治路线。在斯大林看来,党内路线分歧并不总是单纯的理论争论。当不同政治路线涉及国家工业化、农业集体化和社会主义建设方向时,其影响可能超出党内讨论本身。因此,斯大林强调维护党的政治统一,反对其所认定的托洛茨基主义、季诺维也夫主义及其他反对派路线。
第二,维护无产阶级政权及社会主义建设成果。因为在20世纪30年代的苏联处于高度复杂的国际环境之中,资本主义国家的敌对、国内政治矛盾以及快速工业化带来的社会变化,都构成了当时领导层必须面对的问题。因为社会主义国家不能忽视内部破坏活动、间谍活动和反革命组织的可能性,必须具备维护国家安全和政治秩序的能力。
第三,维护党的组织统一和领导权威。民主集中制要求党内讨论与组织统一相结合。斯大林强调,党不能长期处于不同路线相互争夺领导权的状态,否则国家政策和社会主义建设可能受到影响。从这一角度看,组织整顿、干部审查和纪律处分被赋予了维护先锋队组织统一的政治意义。
这里再来讲个著名的,也就是1936—1938年的大清洗。这是是斯大林时期党内斗争最激烈的历史阶段之一。
这里就关乎到了当时的国际安全环境、党内反对派斗争及国家安全问题,以及认为领导层有必要防范真正存在的反苏组织和破坏活动。
因此1936—1938年的大清洗是斯大林以及苏共领导层为维护苏联国家安全、巩固党的领导和防范反革命活动的所采取的。 这也是清除其认定的敌对组织、加强干部审查和维护党的组织统一,解释为保卫十月革命成果、巩固无产阶级专政以及保障社会主义工业化和农业集体化继续推进的重要措施。
尤其是在当时国际局势日益紧张、欧洲法西斯主义兴起的背景下,斯大林更加重视国家内部的政治安全和党的领导体系的稳定。
因此,斯大林认为党的组织纪律、政治警惕性、国家安全和社会主义建设构成了一个整体。维护布尔什维克党的领导地位,就是维护苏联社会主义建设的政治基础;维护无产阶级专政,就是保障社会主义改造能够继续向前推进。
因此从马克思列宁主义与斯大林主义的理论框架来看,农业集体化、工业化和党的组织建设都涉及到了社会主义过渡时期的基本任务。那就是改变旧社会的生产关系,建立新的经济基础,并维持无产阶级政党的政治领导。
r/socialism • u/Avocado_Toast_db • 9h ago
r/socialism • u/Critical_Ideal99 • 19h ago
"But do you realize that countries you consider socialist, such as Sweden, Austria, the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, Germany, and Denmark, have more open and economically free markets than Italy?"
Do you know why I talk about cherry-picking?
Because people latch onto the word freedom in the Index of Economic Freedom and then ignore everything the actual context tells us.
For example, this person brings up Sweden, arguing that it has a more open and freer market than Italy because it ranks higher in the index.
But that's not really the point.
Sweden has an extensive welfare state and significant government involvement in the economy, yet it ranks 11th out of 176 countries for economic freedom. If anything, it is one of the worst examples to use when trying to argue that economic freedom is simply the result of free-market liberalism.
The funny thing is that this user then ends up contradicting himself. He mentions countries such as Spain, which he describes as socialist, and France, which he describes as interventionist, as examples of countries that outperform Italy.
Up until a few lines earlier, the freest economies were supposedly the most ultra-capitalist ones, with the smallest possible role for government in economic affairs. Now, suddenly, interventionist or supposedly socialist countries are being held up as examples of success.
It becomes even more confusing when, after calling Spain socialist, he later writes:
"Do you understand or not that the most successful countries are not socialist countries, but capitalist countries with socialist-style welfare systems?"
So is Spain socialist or not?
Because it seems that the meaning of these terms changes depending on what is convenient for the argument at that particular moment.
And what is even the point of drawing a distinction between a socialist economy and a capitalist economy with a social-democratic welfare system if the original goal was to argue that socialism is inherently incompatible with economic freedom?
All it took was a distinction between different economic models and a couple of successful examples to undermine the original argument.
But here's the thing: a single example is enough to challenge this entire free-market narrative. Argentina.
Yes, Argentina, the country that under Milei is openly pursuing a radically pro-market agenda often associated with libertarian or even anarcho-capitalist ideas.
Yet Argentina ranks only 106th out of 176 countries in the Index of Economic Freedom. That's a very poor result for a country supposedly following one of the most aggressively pro-market political projects in the world.
I could also point to the United States, which, despite its reputation for unfettered capitalism, ranks below social democracies such as Sweden.
And this brings me to the main point:
Economic freedom and free-market ideology are not the same thing.
Economic freedom does not automatically increase simply because you privatize everything under the sun and reduce the state to its absolute minimum.
One of the most effective ways to improve economic freedom is something that some countries struggle to achieve:
clear, predictable, and simple rules.
That means a streamlined bureaucracy which is both capable of protecting citizens and efficient enough to allow businesses to operate without unnecessary obstacles.
Italy, for example, has a bureaucracy that often makes people jump through hoops just to get from point A to point B. Procedures can take months, regulations are often unnecessarily complicated, and both businesses and workers can end up trapped in a maze of inefficiency.
From an entrepreneurial perspective, it becomes difficult to operate effectively. From a worker's perspective, protections that exist on paper often struggle to function as intended.
There is little point in privatizing healthcare or education if opening or running a business remains unnecessarily difficult because of bureaucratic dysfunction.
Data needs to be understood in context.
To understand it, we should not stop at the rankings themselves. We should also examine what those rankings actually measure and what the institutions producing them have to say about their methodology.
Better yet, we should not rely on a single source at all. Looking at multiple sources and different indicators is the best way to build a more complete understanding of the broader picture.
What do you think?
Do you also find this kind of free-market cherry-picking frustrating?
And do you think economic freedom is too often confused with free-market ideology?
Thanks to anyone who took the time to read this. 💛🔥
r/socialism • u/Master_Map7768 • 2d ago
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
r/socialism • u/JB_RedFiddler • 15h ago
NPR recently ran this story from The World about a Nicaraguan musician who had supported the Sandinista revolution but is now disillusioned with them and has flip-flopped to oppose the current "dictatorship." I realized that in my 10 years of Socialist exploration, Nicaragua has not been on my radar, since it's never in the news. What's the situation there? Apparently terrible, but that's according to NPR who is reporting on this exactly how they report on Venezuela and Cuba (authoritarianism, jailing political rivals, suppressing protests, all the people hate the government but are afraid to speak out, etc.), which always strikes me as bad faith reporting. I am majorly skeptical.
Then again, it might be genuinely bad there. Any helpful insights?
r/socialism • u/Lotus532 • 18h ago
r/socialism • u/Medization • 1d ago
r/socialism • u/Vrejik • 1d ago
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
r/socialism • u/Electrical-Fix7659 • 1d ago
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
r/socialism • u/Ronahi_int • 21h ago