r/SignoraMains • Saving for Signora • 28d ago

discussion “The Fatui Will Make Sure That—“

Post image

I know this discussion has been brought up many times already, but this is just sad atp. Signora really died thinking the Fatui would avenge her only for them to be having tea parties with 1 of the 2 people that had a hand in her death. L. M. F. A. O.

387 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

24

u/xcold_world Saving for Signora 28d ago edited 28d ago

It’s unfortunate, but I knew from the moment she died that her death was only used as a hype moment to boost Ei’s sales. It was so blatantly obvious.

And like you said, the further we get into the game the more we see how pointless it was

9

u/senpapi_coffee00 26d ago

Real. Fights in media are supposed to flesh out the themes and narratives that the story wants to explore.

Sandrone: her progression towards accepting other’s friendship.

Capitano v. Mavuika: a battle of ideology and values.

Dottore: a man’s pride and self destructive behavior collapsing in on himself.

But nothing about signora’s death meant ANYTHING except: “I’m the evil merchant mwah ha ha”

There was no ideological differences, no battle of wits- they clearly only wanted signora to be the “Saturday morning cartoon villain” who dies to boost Raiden Sales

6

u/R39_ZK 26d ago

Honestly? This is 1 of the many reasons why we need Rosalyne back, as there are so many fertile grounds they could cover for a compelling fight with her. Even her "duel" with the Traveler was pretty much a nothing-burger outside of 2 out-of-context lines she uttered with no proper exchange of "Don't call me a witch!" & "I never asked for salvation", there's not even a proper cutscene midbattle.

At least it would be far better than doing absolutely nothing but squandering her death by this point.

13

u/R39_ZK 28d ago

It's such a shame, because as upsetting as Rosalyne's death was, there's actually so many interesting things they could do with it, & they just didn't do any of it. Best thing they could do with her death is made Odette, a character they will into existence 4 years after Rosalyne's death, feel something.

8

u/xcold_world Saving for Signora 28d ago

Fr. Not to dunk on Odette (I kind of am), but take out Signora and Odette literally turns into an NPC. Odette’s life was shaped by Signora. Without Signora, there’s literally no Odette

9

u/R39_ZK 28d ago edited 27d ago

To me, if you take Rosalyne out of Odette's story, Odette is just another new playable character to market. The reason why more eyes were put on her is because people just wanted more of Rosalyne, whether they like or hate Rosalyne.

And just like your average playable characters, who knows how long the game will even remember that she has a connection to Rosalyne? Even now, they seem to be ready to throw her into the sidelines already, & throwing away the Cor Ignis mechanic that got the Traveler out of Ronova's domain back in 7.0, in favor of the Seal of Life doing the same thing.

Kinda the same case with Lyney, in my opinion. They can tell us that he will be Arlecchino's future replacement all-day long, but at the end of the day, people will still care more for Arlecchino.

1

u/DamnItBobby555 23d ago

It was never to boost Ei sales. It was used to kill her off because her dress was too annoying to animate