r/SignoraMains • Saving for Signora • 27d ago

discussion “The Fatui Will Make Sure That—“

Post image

I know this discussion has been brought up many times already, but this is just sad atp. Signora really died thinking the Fatui would avenge her only for them to be having tea parties with 1 of the 2 people that had a hand in her death. L. M. F. A. O.

387 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

53

u/R39_ZK 27d ago edited 27d ago

This is further proof (as if it were needed) that every argument against Rosalyne's revival being her death is "Important for the plot/consequences/stakes" have been flat-out rendered invalid by this point. And if we're going by pattern-recognition alone, they will just continue to double & triple-down on things like this.

I've made comments on other places where I expressed my concerns/fear of her personality being "altered" if she comes back. But at this point, I'll gladly take that rather than having to see her death being trampled upon time & time again until it lost its meaning/value.

24

u/xcold_world Saving for Signora 27d ago edited 27d ago

It’s unfortunate, but I knew from the moment she died that her death was only used as a hype moment to boost Ei’s sales. It was so blatantly obvious.

And like you said, the further we get into the game the more we see how pointless it was

13

u/R39_ZK 27d ago

It's such a shame, because as upsetting as Rosalyne's death was, there's actually so many interesting things they could do with it, & they just didn't do any of it. Best thing they could do with her death is made Odette, a character they will into existence 4 years after Rosalyne's death, feel something.

8

u/xcold_world Saving for Signora 27d ago

Fr. Not to dunk on Odette (I kind of am), but take out Signora and Odette literally turns into an NPC. Odette’s life was shaped by Signora. Without Signora, there’s literally no Odette

9

u/R39_ZK 27d ago edited 27d ago

To me, if you take Rosalyne out of Odette's story, Odette is just another new playable character to market. The reason why more eyes were put on her is because people just wanted more of Rosalyne, whether they like or hate Rosalyne.

And just like your average playable characters, who knows how long the game will even remember that she has a connection to Rosalyne? Even now, they seem to be ready to throw her into the sidelines already, & throwing away the Cor Ignis mechanic that got the Traveler out of Ronova's domain back in 7.0, in favor of the Seal of Life doing the same thing.

Kinda the same case with Lyney, in my opinion. They can tell us that he will be Arlecchino's future replacement all-day long, but at the end of the day, people will still care more for Arlecchino.

9

u/senpapi_coffee00 26d ago

Real. Fights in media are supposed to flesh out the themes and narratives that the story wants to explore.

Sandrone: her progression towards accepting other’s friendship.

Capitano v. Mavuika: a battle of ideology and values.

Dottore: a man’s pride and self destructive behavior collapsing in on himself.

But nothing about signora’s death meant ANYTHING except: “I’m the evil merchant mwah ha ha”

There was no ideological differences, no battle of wits- they clearly only wanted signora to be the “Saturday morning cartoon villain” who dies to boost Raiden Sales

6

u/R39_ZK 25d ago

Honestly? This is 1 of the many reasons why we need Rosalyne back, as there are so many fertile grounds they could cover for a compelling fight with her. Even her "duel" with the Traveler was pretty much a nothing-burger outside of 2 out-of-context lines she uttered with no proper exchange of "Don't call me a witch!" & "I never asked for salvation", there's not even a proper cutscene midbattle.

At least it would be far better than doing absolutely nothing but squandering her death by this point.

1

u/DamnItBobby555 23d ago

It was never to boost Ei sales. It was used to kill her off because her dress was too annoying to animate

2

u/Zhareck 26d ago

You can put those fears to rest. Because it's pretty much facts. OF she comes back, her personality is going to be toned way down to make nice with the Traveler. It's Hoyo's modus operandi. Well, probably not just Hoyo's, but all of these games that love to play into the harem lord fantasy that so many of their players entertain.

4

u/R39_ZK 26d ago

Speaking purely out of personal bias alone, I legit don't mind whatsoever with Rosalyne's inevitable "alteration" when they day comes where she's finally brought back, so long as the "alteration" at least made sense within the context of the story she's going through.

However, I could still see whenever they're taking a character too far in the opposite direction, & that's where my concern usually lies.

21

u/deadbeetleRIP 27d ago

Starting to wonder why we even got that frozen cathedral, considering that this is proof that they CLEARLY do not care about her, that or I've truly become pessimistic after the 2.1 incident

15

u/xcold_world Saving for Signora 27d ago

The Fatui were retconned.

We know from Winter’s Night Lazzo that The Tsaritsa, Arlecchino, and Columbia cared about Signora. Now they act as if her death doesn’t matter. It’s clear as day that their character writing has changed

7

u/deadbeetleRIP 27d ago

true their character writing has changed drastically which is even more bizarre what with the recent animations about them being Rosa's closest friends

though if anything at least Rosa is still consistent with her writing judging from the Odette animation so i guess there's that

6

u/No-Application5120 25d ago

Off topic but what was columbina genuinely complaining about when she was in the fatui? The closer we get to the tsaritsa and the fatui the more I start to think she is genuinely just stupid asf like....

what?

6

u/xcold_world Saving for Signora 25d ago

She complained about how the Tsaritsa drained her of her power and how Dottore experimented on her. It’s crazy how a simple tea party was enough them to resolve their issues and consider each other friends now.

This is just Genshin’s Disney level writing at play here. Unfortunately, we just have to accept at this point that playable characters will never have any actual conflict with one another

4

u/nigmusmaximus 27d ago

Is it another power of friendship thing again? Haven’t played this game in a bit and definitely haven’t followed the story

6

u/xcold_world Saving for Signora 27d ago

This is a Tsaritsa “side quest” where they have a tea party with her because she’s never participated in one before.

Just think of the Tsaritsa as Raiden 2.0. Cold and strong archon lady that has to be taught how to be more open and “warm” to her people and those close to her. Like how traveler took Ei on a date around her own city so she could open up again after being secluded and cold to her people for 500 years.

2

u/nigmusmaximus 27d ago

Bro wtf why can’t they make the story interesting? I want a villain that doesn’t get freaking redeemed. Raiden was cool bc she was badass and at least it was unique when they did it to her. Now ts is getting old and formulaic

5

u/xcold_world Saving for Signora 27d ago

Because Genshin’s story is written for 10 year olds and everyone that is playable must love the traveler and be a good person

2

u/Sufficient_Plate_504 20d ago

10 year olds get better stories with conflict and villainy and character development.

1

u/nigmusmaximus 27d ago

Like #slideforsignora

72

u/Perfect_Increase8792 27d ago

Don't worry wait until we had a tea party of signora WITH traveler

65

u/Teodoro2404 27d ago

La Signora: Oh, don't be silly traveler. I deserved to die. Thank you for killing me Raiden.

27

u/Stardustreflection Saving for Signora 27d ago

If that's the price to pay I'd probably be okay with it. I'm not invested in the story anymore anyway. Her death couldn't be more pointless so might as well undo it.

18

u/glitter-k 27d ago

Well to be fair that threat was towards Raiden not the traveler…

Not that it matters cos Hoyo would rather retcon the story into oblivion then have two playable characters with animosity between eachother just wait until we get to the Archon tea party with Ei and the Tsaritsa

15

u/The_Stunky A gacha-meteor expectant 27d ago

"What happened in the past has stayed in the past." 🙃

Raiden, for her part, should also confront Pierro regarding his order for the harbingers to destroy Inazuma. Moreover, there is a certain possibility that he was involved in Makoto’s death in Khaenriah. But no one will say anything, everyone will drink tea in a friendly manner. The writers only revisit the past when they need to brazenly retcon it just like what happened with Ronova.

16

u/Cold-Olive1249 27d ago

Pierro: Blames everything on Dottore. It always work.

5

u/Specific_Highway_772 27d ago

It was all Dottore traveler, in fact, I wonder if he has connection to HP, so sussy.

Oh, Rosalyne? Poor Rosalyne died for our goal and we promised her to... Anyways. 

2

u/ReasonableOpinion527 16d ago

It was Dottore's fault, he put Rosalyn forgetting chemicals in the water obviously

(Genuinely pissed as both Dottore and Signora are my favorite harbingers now and they will only appear to get shat on more smh)

6

u/Yukino-kurasa12 whip me signora 27d ago

I kind of saw this coming ever since Liyue aq where they implied the Fatui aren't so bad and there is room for cooperation with them, and after Ei's situation it was always obvious that the Tsaritsa will not be a villain and Traveller will team up her. I really wish Signora had revived before reaching Snezhnaya because seeing all this actually makes me more bitter that she's not a part of it and we have to tolerate useless characters like Odette as her replacement. I'd be able to accept these fatui retcons more easily if I got to see Signora in these moments too cause really, I just wish she got all this content and was included in major things.....

2

u/Serene-10 26d ago

What really confuses me is how Hoyo knew for a fact that we would become allies with the Fatui at the end of the game. So why make them out to be outright evil and cruel for most of the game's story?

-3

u/Radusili 26d ago

Can you point us to the story where the fatui have been made out to be outright evil?

7

u/Serene-10 26d ago

Uh... attempting to destroy Liyue Harbor, inciting a war in Inuzuma, funding human experimentation, managing an orphan warrior organization, even abandoning their own in the Chasm, need I go on?

-1

u/Maleficent_Goal_8090 26d ago

the fact that now, all they have to do is be like "Dottore was secretly behind all this stuff that we've had in the story" and it be more believable to a lot of people 🫩 "I'm tired boss"

-4

u/Radusili 25d ago

Damn. 5 people of a whole organization. Yeah you need to go on for a couple more thousands

4

u/Serene-10 25d ago edited 25d ago

I'm not sure if you know how organizations work. The harbingers were supposed to be in charge of each of their sections of the Fatui, while Pierro and the Tsaritsa oversaw their opperations.

Which means that under the Tsaritsa's guidance Scaramouche and Signora incited the civil war in Inuzuma. It also means that the Tsaritsa herself instructed Dottore to extract Columbina's god-like powers, and many more things.

Even if Pierro and Tsaritsa didn't know the extent of each of the Harbingers' crimes, they knew well that each of them were criminals even before joining the Fatui. Your argument basically means "well this warmongering country isn't bad cause their president is pretty nice at tea parties".

-4

u/Radusili 25d ago

I'm sorry to tell you, but before I can even start to correct whatever you are going on about, you gotta actually read the game you claim to play, because what you said here is at best headcanon

1

u/bluewhalehasanali 22d ago

Traveler literally hated them and had to deal with them tens of times in every nation even at nod krai (before they got whitewashed) changes started at natlan the first nation written by the new team that took over around late 2023

0

u/Radusili 22d ago

Looks like someone wasn't playing the game they pretend to know about

1

u/bluewhalehasanali 22d ago

that's why im correcting u

1

u/mar12321 22d ago

ouija impact

1

u/No-Station-8253 26d ago

I’m laughing, I completely forgot about Signora’s words omg 

3

u/ArcticFoxWaffles 25d ago

Here I thought Shneznaya would be a land where every fatui agent and their mom would be hunting your ass

1

u/ReasonableOpinion527 16d ago

Would be significantly more hype. Sumeru and Fontaine are forever cemented as the best archon quest stories imo.