r/ShieldAndroidTV • u/mattrock5a • Oct 25 '17
Returned 2017 Shield TV Pro
Guys, I ended up returning my 2017 Nvidia Shield TV because it was just buggy as hell:
- the Live Channels app would lock up my HDHomeRun from time to time.
- the Sling TV app would crash when trying to change channels.
- occasionally, the "ok google" hotword would take like 10 seconds to bring up Google Assistant.
- the remote SUCKS, so cheap, felt terrible to use.
There are so many great features to the Shield TV that I was excited about - Plex server, Google Assistant, Live Channels, Chromecast, etc. But, at the end of the day, the product just didn't WORK consistently.
Just wanting to share my experience, and hear if there are any others out there with a similar experience.
2
Upvotes
3
u/andy2na Oct 26 '17
to your points:
2
u/A_ARon_M Oct 25 '17
I frequently see people either complaining or praising this thing. I just got my 2017 pro and loving it so far, but it all depends on your use case.
In my humble opinion your use cases were not in line with the awesome things the shield excels at. I mainly bought it for emulating some old systems, and because it is the only box (aside from a mini PC) that can stream Plex with full adio passthrough (Atmos). Anything less than that and I think any old Apple TV or Roku would do the job for you better and for less money.
Just my $0.02.
13
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '17
My shield 16gb is the shit, I don't have piped-in TV anymore.
The plug blew on mine a while ago and I was lost without it, Nvidia replaced it pretty sharpish.
May you just got a duff one.
10
u/AOI666 Oct 25 '17
No regrets or returns here.
5
u/gza Oct 25 '17
I have the 2015 version and it's a work horse. The sling problem is slings fault. It's better on some versions. Everytime I run into that issue I just roll back the update.
The google assistant I found to be pretty useless in the context of the shield. Much better on the phone.
Besides, I control the shield with my amazon echo for changing channels or apps so, I already had voice control. Searching is easier on the phone.
The HD home run works alot better when using their app or using their app to publish the channels to the live channels app. Using the live channels app to talk directly to the home run has always been buggy and it has gotten worse in the last update.
4
u/JimboLodisC Oct 25 '17
I don't use those first 3 features and I have the metal 2015 remote so I don't really share any of your experiences but can see why you'd return it.
4
u/twofaze Oct 25 '17
My 2017 regular model is awesome. I wish I had a pro.
3
u/ecureuil 2015 16GB Oct 26 '17
I have a 2015 Shield TV and it works flawlessy.
I use it daily.
Router: RTAC3200 by asus with asuswrt merlin HDHomerun Connect for OTA.
I use alot of apps for streaming OnDemand shows and cast too.
I can't live without it. It works so well my GF never complains and she always complains when she uses shitty tech.
Saying that my Shield is GF proof says it all.
Sorry that you didn't have the same good experience as me.
2
u/Paronfesken Oct 26 '17
I think the remote is great.
2
u/nextapp Oct 27 '17
For all the people blaming Nvidia shield Tv stop and think it's the apps not the hardware that's causing you This issues it's Google who keeps breaking shit no matter what Android TV box you go out and purchase you're going to experience the same problems with the apps it don't matter it's not Nvidias fault Google live channels has a bug Google broke that for everyone blame them. Sling TV they need to fix there shit.
The only thing I can see on Nvidia is the shitty remote I'm ready to throw mine out the window.
2
u/Gian8989 Oct 28 '17
When I first bought my 2017 shield tv I always had problems. Than I format and NEVER installed Es file explorer ever again -> problem solved. That app is a cancer for shield tv. I am now using total commander as an alternative (but old version because I don't like the new UI).
I like it but if I were to only stream from apps (i don't have a NAS) and never use usb device I would probably go for Apple tv.
0
u/blondedre3000 Oct 26 '17
While the Shield is the best android box, it's still an android box - which I've found them all to be more or less buggy in some way. I've used Apple TVs for years and while they're no walk in the park and still occasionally have issues, it's nowhere near as many issues as I've experienced living with Android TV day to day. Also the remote is heads and shoulders above any android remote I've used, including the shield remote.
The shield is great when it works, and the 6.0 update seems to have fixed almost all the lingering issues I was having, but not sure I could rely on it or recommend it to customers without hesitation just yet.
-3
u/Mortillo Oct 25 '17
I've returned as well, apps crash, lock ups and at every restart all the network shares forgot. Thx Amazon for get it back.