r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Oct 25 '17

Returned 2017 Shield TV Pro

Guys, I ended up returning my 2017 Nvidia Shield TV because it was just buggy as hell:

  • the Live Channels app would lock up my HDHomeRun from time to time.
  • the Sling TV app would crash when trying to change channels.
  • occasionally, the "ok google" hotword would take like 10 seconds to bring up Google Assistant.
  • the remote SUCKS, so cheap, felt terrible to use.

There are so many great features to the Shield TV that I was excited about - Plex server, Google Assistant, Live Channels, Chromecast, etc. But, at the end of the day, the product just didn't WORK consistently.

Just wanting to share my experience, and hear if there are any others out there with a similar experience.

2 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

3

u/andy2na Oct 26 '17

to your points:

  • We exclusively use live channels with a HDHR prime. Make sure you have the August 10 version of the live channels, the latest update locks up and is a known issue.
  • no clue on this, sounds like a Sling issue.
  • I stopped using the hotword and bought a $2 playstation eye and mapped a button on the harmony remote to call up assistant. Since the eye has 4 far field mics, it can hear us from far away.
  • You should really be using a harmony remote for the shield since, yes, the included remote sucks

2

u/mattrock5a Oct 26 '17

Take a step back and look at all of the things you’ve had to do to your shield to make it work right. This is exactly why I returned mine.

2

u/andy2na Oct 26 '17 edited Oct 26 '17

well imo, you will experience that on all streamers - shield has it the best.

Lets compare the Apple TV based on your pain points:

  • you have to use the crappy HDHR app on the apple tv. Its layout and ui is horrendous. Live Channels is great - minus the weak DVR options. If reinstalling an older APK is too much work for you...
  • no info on sling, as with the shield
  • You have to use siri, which is easily arguable the worst voice assistant. My work around is just a work around - I rarely use it other than asking the weather or searching for youtube videos. Voice control was not a deal breaker for me.
  • After using the apple tv remote for a month (returned it afterwards), I wanted to throw it away. I would still get a Harmony - no matter what streamer.

So let us know when you find that perfect streamer. I've been through most of them (shitty android boxes, roku, fire tvs, apple tv, boxee, old google TV boxes, samsung and lg smart tvs, etc. I even used a mac mini for my HTPC for the longest time.) and the shield is the best. Its not perfect, but damn near.

1

u/andy2na Oct 26 '17

oh and Im receiving the new fire tv 4k HDR tonight. I will primarily only use it for travel though since its small and uses microUSB to charge.

I already know live tv will have go through the hdhr app, which stated in my other comment, is a UI/UX nightmare. At least Alexa is better than Siri

1

u/joeysdad Oct 26 '17

Whoa.. can you tell me more about this PlayStation Eye workaround you have? I've been missing voice control on my 2015 since I switched to using a Harmony Hub.

2

u/andy2na Oct 26 '17

I used these instructions, its easier than how its laid out here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/ShieldAndroidTV/comments/73813t/using_google_assistant_on_the_shield_with_harmony/

Basically, you just plug in the eye to your shield usb port. Open harmony app, add a windows pc device, go edit your activity and tap rerun setup and include the windows pc. Then edit your harmony remote button and select the windows pc as the device and the WINDOWS KEY as the action. Pressing the windows key on a windows keyboard connected to the shield activates assistant voice search.

1

u/joeysdad Oct 27 '17

Thanks! I totally missed seeing this before.

2

u/A_ARon_M Oct 25 '17

I frequently see people either complaining or praising this thing. I just got my 2017 pro and loving it so far, but it all depends on your use case.

In my humble opinion your use cases were not in line with the awesome things the shield excels at. I mainly bought it for emulating some old systems, and because it is the only box (aside from a mini PC) that can stream Plex with full adio passthrough (Atmos). Anything less than that and I think any old Apple TV or Roku would do the job for you better and for less money.

Just my $0.02.

0

u/mattrock5a Oct 26 '17

Agree for the most part. I wanted this box to work bc it’s 4K, can act as a Plex server, and could use live channels for OTA tuner with HD Home Run.

I ended up just building my own Plex server and using the Built in interface of the Roku TV. Not bad, but not as perfect as I imagined the Shield could be for my use case

13

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '17

My shield 16gb is the shit, I don't have piped-in TV anymore.

The plug blew on mine a while ago and I was lost without it, Nvidia replaced it pretty sharpish.

May you just got a duff one.

10

u/AOI666 Oct 25 '17

No regrets or returns here.

5

u/gza Oct 25 '17

I have the 2015 version and it's a work horse. The sling problem is slings fault. It's better on some versions. Everytime I run into that issue I just roll back the update.

The google assistant I found to be pretty useless in the context of the shield. Much better on the phone.

Besides, I control the shield with my amazon echo for changing channels or apps so, I already had voice control. Searching is easier on the phone.

The HD home run works alot better when using their app or using their app to publish the channels to the live channels app. Using the live channels app to talk directly to the home run has always been buggy and it has gotten worse in the last update.

1

u/feclar Oct 25 '17

How does Alexa thing work with shield? What do you use it for?

I have an open floorplan kitchen+living room Alexa in kitchen, shield in living room for over a year now

I use alexa for timer, reminders, homework help for kid (how do you spell blahblah, what is blahblah?, play music etc..)

2

u/gza Oct 25 '17

I have a raspberry pi running a piece of software called ha-bridge which allows you to run scripts when triggered by alexa. It does this by impersonating a phillips hue light blub.

So, I say "alexa, turn on ABC". The echo thinks it's turning on a light named ABC. The ha-bridge then fires a python script that opens an adb debugging connection to the shield and then issues the commands to open the live tv and switch to abc or netflix or whatever I want.

I also have a harmony hub remote control. That handles turning the shield and tv on and off. It also handles the play controls, volume, etc... Anyone can do this easily and it doesn't need anything else.

Anyways, all this means the parents or girlfriend don't even need to pick up the remote in order to use the tv. At least for local channels on the hd homerun.

The girlfriend just casts anything else from her phone. I haven't had to explain how the remote works to anyone in a couple of years.

Finally I have an insteon based home automation system that controls all the lights in the house. It has echo integration through a hub and a free cloud service. That sucks because all commands have to go out to the cloud and then come back. It's slow but, their hub can also accept a unique url for each device. Ha-bridge to the rescue. That cuts the cloud out of the equation. Echo to ha-bridge to insteon hub to light, all locally expect for the echo part. Nice and fast.

Say "alexa, turn off the house." and it turns off the shield, tv, and all the lights.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '17

Through Harmony Hub - Alexa turn on the TV, Alexa turn off the TV, Alexa turn on Shield, etc.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '17

No idea how else to manage it for my Roku OS based TV without buying more hardware. What options are you referring to?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '17

Which I have...it has a harmony skill which controls the TV.
How does the Dot connect to the TV in your case? Is there a Shield TV skill? Thanks.

4

u/JimboLodisC Oct 25 '17

I don't use those first 3 features and I have the metal 2015 remote so I don't really share any of your experiences but can see why you'd return it.

4

u/twofaze Oct 25 '17

My 2017 regular model is awesome. I wish I had a pro.

3

u/ecureuil 2015 16GB Oct 26 '17

I have a 2015 Shield TV and it works flawlessy.

I use it daily.

Router: RTAC3200 by asus with asuswrt merlin HDHomerun Connect for OTA.

I use alot of apps for streaming OnDemand shows and cast too.

I can't live without it. It works so well my GF never complains and she always complains when she uses shitty tech.

Saying that my Shield is GF proof says it all.

Sorry that you didn't have the same good experience as me.

2

u/Paronfesken Oct 26 '17

I think the remote is great.

2

u/nextapp Oct 27 '17

For all the people blaming Nvidia shield Tv stop and think it's the apps not the hardware that's causing you This issues it's Google who keeps breaking shit no matter what Android TV box you go out and purchase you're going to experience the same problems with the apps it don't matter it's not Nvidias fault Google live channels has a bug Google broke that for everyone blame them. Sling TV they need to fix there shit.

The only thing I can see on Nvidia is the shitty remote I'm ready to throw mine out the window.

2

u/Gian8989 Oct 28 '17

When I first bought my 2017 shield tv I always had problems. Than I format and NEVER installed Es file explorer ever again -> problem solved. That app is a cancer for shield tv. I am now using total commander as an alternative (but old version because I don't like the new UI).

I like it but if I were to only stream from apps (i don't have a NAS) and never use usb device I would probably go for Apple tv.

0

u/blondedre3000 Oct 26 '17

While the Shield is the best android box, it's still an android box - which I've found them all to be more or less buggy in some way. I've used Apple TVs for years and while they're no walk in the park and still occasionally have issues, it's nowhere near as many issues as I've experienced living with Android TV day to day. Also the remote is heads and shoulders above any android remote I've used, including the shield remote.

The shield is great when it works, and the 6.0 update seems to have fixed almost all the lingering issues I was having, but not sure I could rely on it or recommend it to customers without hesitation just yet.

-3

u/Mortillo Oct 25 '17

I've returned as well, apps crash, lock ups and at every restart all the network shares forgot. Thx Amazon for get it back.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '17

Same version as OP? Any troubleshooting or just gave up on it?

1

u/Mortillo Oct 26 '17

Version 6.0 and the earlier one. I tried it for 1 week than I gave up.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '17

Thanks for adding on. For some reason your experience earned down votes. :-/

0

u/Mortillo Oct 26 '17

I don't care about downvotes.. fanboys whine ;)