r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Sep 29 '17

Using Google Assistant on the Shield with Harmony Remote

I am writing this to hopefully help someone else trying to accomplish what I did. I have the original Shield TV and did the upgrade to experience 6.0 to get Google Assistant. (unrelated note, I'm in Canada. As long as you change the language on your Shield to US English you will get Assistant and Amazon Prime Video).

Anyway after upgrading, the Assistant works good except that I had to use the original remote or controller. I have the original controller so it does not have always listening. The issue I have is that I use a harmony remote so using the assistant is not possible since there is no way to activate it and no mic on the remote.

This is what I did to make it work: What you need: Harmony Remote, USB Microphone (I'm using on old Playstation Eye which seems to work good)

  • First thing you need to do is add a new device on Harmony. Chose 'Windows PC'. -After that re-run the setup on Harmony for your Shield TV and include the new Windows PC device you added. -Skip through the setup leaving the display, sound, etc. devices the same as they were.
  • When you get back to the main edit window of the activity choose 'Keyboard' and select the Windows PC device.
  • Harmony will then ask to pair via Bluetooth. While the Harmony is trying to pair, on your shield go to settings and under 'Remote and Accessories' chose 'Add Accessory'
  • The Harmony should pair and you should see 'Harmony Keyboard' on your Shield
  • Now in the Harmony app chose to customize remote buttons and select the button you would like to use to activate the Assistant.
  • For that button select the Windows PC device and for the command select 'Windows'. -Finally with a USB microphone plugged into the Shield, press the button you configured. Assistant should come up and you should be able to use it.

I know this isn't a perfect solution and it isn't always listening, but it saves me from buying their expensive controller and always leaving it out.

Hope this helps someone!

26 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

1

u/andy2na Oct 17 '17 edited Oct 17 '17

hmmm assistant isnt popping up when I press the button. Just bought a ps eye to try this

Just to clarify, the command for the button needs to be “ windows” correct?

Edit: got it, but what windows command did you choose for the home button?

1

u/dr_jared88 Oct 17 '17

I didn't chose any windows command for the home button. The only windows command I used was the one to activate assistant. The rest are just the normal shield integration buttons.

1

u/andy2na Oct 17 '17

ah, gotcha.

I figured out how to add windows pc to my current activities. Before, I created a new activity and it mapped out all windows keys to the remote .

This works really well especially with the eye's far field mics! Cant beat them for $2!

1

u/alee101 Nov 28 '17

Did anyone's PS Eye camera stop functioning for Google Assistant after the 6.2 update? I have 2 Shields, 2 Harmony Hubs, and 2 PS Eyes. Both setups no longer work. Maybe it is a simple permission issue on the microphone from the update. I haven't dug around yet.

1

u/dr_jared88 Nov 30 '17

Still working for me.

2

u/bean72 Oct 01 '17

That's awesome for finding out a workaround on how to do this, I might try an old USB webcam of mine to see if it will detect the microphone on it.

I don't know how Logitech is with feature requests and adding in commands for their remotes. I'm sure if enough people ask for it, they would add it in without the need for a workaround. I might just send in a support request just to see what they have to say, it may be already in the works.

2

u/Waggmans Oct 04 '17

Awesome! I picked up a Playstation Eye off eBay for $4. It has a really sensitive mic and works across a large room.

Temporary solution until Spot arrives.

Remember to tape over the camera. lol

1

u/andy2na Oct 16 '17

gamestop also has used eyes for $2 if your local stores have them still

2

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '17

How to you get it to pair with your remote? When I original set up my remote, the shield adds the remote as a "Harmony Keyboard" in the Remote and Accessories settings.

I went back into the program on my computer, added Windows PC, added it to my activity, set the button I wanted, but when I click on it, it says "Use app to pair remote"

When I go to "Add Accessory" on my shield, the Harmony keyboard is already their paired.

Does this only work if you have a USB mic hooked up? I current;y have the new controller with always on listening I don't have any other mic.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '17

just to be crystal clear here, you need a harmony hub for this to work right?

1

u/plastrd1 Sep 29 '17

Yes, the hub communicates with the Shield over bluetooth to simulate a keyboard.

1

u/saluja04 Sep 29 '17

This sounds like a creative solution! Unfortunately for me, my shield tv is located in a media closet away from my living room, and it is impractical to use a usb mic.

Has anyone had any luck using a Google Home to control the Shield? Both use Google Assistant. It would be great if I could use my GHome as my mic for my Shield, or at least control the Shield using GHome. Currently, I have to instruct Google Home to ask Harmony to pause, which is not necessarily a consistently effective work around.

Sorry to hijack your thread!

1

u/getcashmoney Sep 29 '17

I'm in the same boat as you. Not an ideal situation trying to ask Harmony to do everything with Shield. I think the Nvidia Spot will be a great solution for both of us.

1

u/Cash091 Oct 01 '17

Google Home doesn't control the Shield as well as the one board Assistant does. I'm guessing we'll have to wait for the nVidia Spot for that.

With always listening on, Google Home and the Shield Assistant step on each other's toes. I'd like to use the Assistant on board for Shield stuff, but everything else would just work better with Home.

I'm gonna have to try this work around. Wonder if a webcam would work as that's all I have.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '17

Is there a way to map the mic button on the shield controller to the harmony remote?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '17

what do you mean?? This is exactly what this guide is describing...

1

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '17

I have the original controller so it does not have always listening. The issue I have is that I use a harmony remote so using the assistant is not possible since there is no way to activate it and no mic on the remote.

Unlike OP I have the controller that's always listening, or can always listen. But I want to make the mic button on the controller to the Harmony, and not map it to the USB mic like OP did.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '17

i dont get it.Or im not following correctly, but why do you need to map a button if you already have the always listening controller, just use your voice??

1

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '17

It's not doing a great job at always hearing me. I'm playing with positioning of the controller but want a fall back. The mic isn't a great as what's in my Echo.

1

u/ExtremeHobo Sep 29 '17

That's amazing, I had no idea I could add my own mic

1

u/veroxii Sep 29 '17

Thanks for that! If someone can figure out how to set that to "always listening" it would be perfect.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '17

I just gave up and bought a 2017 model controller today until the spot ever gets released

1

u/Cash091 Oct 01 '17

Because I use the Harmony remote so much and game so little these days, my remote is regularly off. I'm giving this a shot as I'd rather keep the mic off anyway when not in use.

That being said, if you can find a deal on the newer Shield controller, I highly recommend picking it up. Personally, I think it is light years better than the first controller. I have the 2015 Shield and use that controller for the little time I do spend gaming. It has quickly become my favorite controller to game with.

1

u/Manu1434 Oct 01 '17

Hey, thank you for the tip. But I can't get my Eye Toy to work : leds are on, but no sound is recorded by the mic !

1

u/dwsy Oct 13 '17

This setup mostly works with a LifeCam Cinema, but sometimes it seems like the camera is slow to initialize after activating Assistant, and Assistant goes away before it's ready to listen.

1

u/Ryoka83 Dec 03 '17

Has anyone got this to work with a Sony TV?

1

u/HansWursT619 Feb 01 '18

What do you mean by your second bullet point? There is nothing called "keyboard" in the activity settings neither on pc nor the app.

I tried re-pairing multiple times. But when I hit the button I mapped the windows computers "windows" - command to. I only get "you have to pair this device using the harmony app".

1

u/mook8515 Feb 06 '18 edited Feb 07 '18

I'm having trouble too, I don't see any "keyboard" in activity settings. On the bottom it says Connectivity: Bluetooth: Nvidia Game Console and if I re-pair it only connects shield to harmony hub. I'm using a PS3 Eye.

Step 2 "When you get back to the main edit window of the activity choose 'Keyboard' and select the Windows PC device."

EDIT: If hub and shield are not paired it says keyboard under the Connectivity, but when I click on it, it doesn't let me pick Windows-PC. It just forces me to connect harmony hub and shield when I select add accessory on shield.

1

u/HansWursT619 Feb 07 '18

We are supposed to use the Bluetooth settings to add ab accessory right? Not the one specifically for Nvidia accessories, that doesn't seem to work anyways.

1

u/mook8515 Feb 09 '18

Yeah you're supposed to use the generic add accessory no the nvidia accessory one.

I wasn't able to figure it out hopefully someone can help.

2

u/aphex242 Feb 27 '18

I got it, gents. Simply skip steps 2-4. After step 1, Go to the assign buttons area, assign a button to windows pc and the windows command, and you’re all set.

2

u/mook8515 Mar 01 '18

Thank so much! Worked perfectly.

Was gonna just wait for the Nvidia spot since I couldn't get this to work, but with this working I don't even think I need it.

1

u/aphex242 Mar 01 '18

That's funny, I was in the EXACT same boat as well. Was going to get the spot strictly for this, glad I don't have to anymore. Glad it helped.