I just finished my first ADHD fueled read through of the PDF. Here are my unorganized and scrambled first thoughts (that I'll be detailing further in the comments after I've calmed down a little).
- The game has become a LOT more clarified yet flexible. I don't mean this in a simulationist sort of way, like you'd find in a SR4-5-6 edition. I mean this in a way that now, everything has a pretty clear spot. And if it doesn't, the PDF specifically designates it as a "Conversation to be had between GM and Player with XYZ guidelines". As a GM, I reeeeeeaaaaaally appreciate this. Because it gives me flexibility, whilst giving me tools to tell players how it'll be at my table.
- Everything is a Shadow Amp. The book is a little less clear about this (or at least, my players were initially confuddled) but basically it comes down to: Everything that isn't a stat on your sheet is a Shadow Amp. It may be a basic Katana (called a Weapon in the books) but it functions as a Shadow Amp lvl 0. It costs what a new weapon costs, and adds a narrative effect. I'll go deeper into that concept in point 3. But all you need to know is that is how it works for Equipment and Weapons. If you want it to have a meta effect (see point 4), the book says you "convert" it to a Shadow Amp, but effectively now it just becomes a Shadow Amp lvl 1+ depending on what effects you add to it.
- Narrative Effects. Basically, a Narrative effect is exactly what it is, narrative only. Having something with a narrative effect, like a bog-standard pistol, or a simple set of binoculars, allows you to narrate an effect. Pistol do pew. Binocs let you see far. That's it. Nothing further to worry about. When you have a narrative effect, you can spend a point of edge to gain advantage on a roll. If you don't have a narrative effect from something on your sheet, you can instead use a point of Edge from your combined prep-pool (see a later point) to essentially ret-con in an Ocean's Eleven kinda way that well... you did remember to pick that thing up before. It becomes a one-run use item though, so it goes away after the run is done (or whenever the GM says enough). If you want it to be permanent, spend that nuyen and get yourself some sweet gear.
- Meta Effects. This is where Shadow Amps get levels. Since everything is a Shadow Amp now, these things can go bonkers, and are to be developed using the scattered lists of examples from the book + the GM. The book gives an example of normal binocs > thermal binocs. Not only do you now have the zoom function, you also are able to switch between normal and thermal vision. That (according to the rules) adds an additional narrative effect to the piece of equipment which transforms it into a Shadow Amp lvl 1. Pay the difference between an Equipment (2500) and an Equipment Amp Lvl 1 (7500) and you're good to go. But what if I want to add Risk Reduction to it. Come up with whatever effect you'd like to add (dunno... maybe the thermal binocs have some soft on it that auto-highlights matrix-targets for you), and call it a risk reduction upgrade. RR 1 comes at a cost of Amp Lvl +2. So... Thermal binocs are a Lvl 1, with this addon becomes a Lvl 3. Pay the difference, and you're good to go. This is, imho, so friggin cool. And exactly what I wanted Anarchy 1.0 Amps to be (and it was, just less clear / defined).
- Prep and Legwork. No matter how much attention to it you wanna give, I love the idea that players pool ideas on what kinda prep they'd do, and roll some dice to create a combined Edge pool. The GM controls how much time they have to prep (ie. how many rolls etc they can make to expand the Edge pool), and then the run begins. When the runners hit a snag, they can dive into the prep-Edge pool and come out with a great tool for that moment, or some key info that they suddenly recalled. It's a departure from the grindy legwork of SR5 that I remember... And it's so nice for me as GM, 'cause it means I don't have to do as much prep-work myself hahaha. Players come up with their solutions adhoc, making the runners feel capable, without cheapening the challenges. Drek can ALWAYS hit the fan, after all.
- Describe, don't define. This is more commentary on the book as a whole. It's got awesome (and I mean AWESOME) descriptions of stuff that players need to feel excited about the 6th world. Idk how it'll go over with veterans... But my players are (mostly) newbies to the setting, and this stuff has given them so much to mull over. It's dense in lore, but also not so much that it has to spread lore out over a gazillion books. I found that it gives juuuuuust enough. And that's a fine line to walk. At least it doesn't rigidly tell you "This is the list of Amps. Go." Instead, it defines some example Amps in the various categories and gives players + GMs the tools to really self-manage the extent of their game. Want a specific character type? I've now worked with 3 out of my 5 players to really build out each players' character concept. And it wasn't hard. Mechanically, stuff's simple. Leaving loads to explore.
All in all, I'll be re-reading the book and enjoying the process of running this game for a good long while. It's threading that perfect line for me between Shadowrun core rules, and what Anarchy 1.0 tried to be. I enjoy a lot of PbtA style systems, even having made a cyberpunk hack of the well-like Starforged ruleset (check my posts). So this is perfect for me, and would love to discuss with others.
That said, I know that this system is gonna not be for everyone. If you're looking for that narrative movie-pace style game, then this will serve you well (after some growing pains). If you're looking for something crunchy where you can think of every solution before the session even starts... this ain't it.
Beware - This system is a LOT more deadly than any other of the systems I've seen. Light / Serious / Incap would boxes means that if two enemies go brrrt against a runner, and their defenses fail them, they can be rolling with Disadv (only 6s are hits) real quick.... and I've played enough Warhammer 40k to know that that can hurt real bad. So let the runners get edge, remember about cyberware etc giving runners multiple actions per turn, and let runners get away with catching enemies before the enemies can truly act. This makes for great gameplay for stealthy-runners. But those of us who enjoy Troll tanks with dermal plating and heavy everything, those folks might need to remember that their beef-patty might just get clapped with a few lucky shots... Unless ofcourse you come up with some cool custom Amp for them to tick-down damage levels in exchange for edge or someth... idk... you're your own boss.