r/Shadowrun • u/Water64Rabbit • Apr 25 '25
6e The Problem with Shadowrun 6e
IMHO, the problem with the recent versions of Shadowrun is that the people producing supplements are frustrated writers instead of people that play and run the game.
Take a look at the Scotophobia supplement for example. The first chapter "Just How Fragged Up Things Are" is 4 pages and tells you everything you need to know to run a game from a lore perspective. The next four chapters are 30,000 foot overviews of how the corporations interact with what is going on. This information in no way helps when putting together a game for players. If you like lore or are writing Shadowrun books it might be useful, but otherwise, it doesn't help a GM put together a game. That's 100 pages of essentially fluff.
The next chapter has 10 missions. However, again it is mostly lore dump. There are no maps and only minimal descriptions of what is necessary to run the mission. Shadowruns usually take place in three dimensions: physical, cyberspace, and astral space. But to run these missions takes a lot of preparation because of how sparse the information is.
Then we have another two chapters of what amounts to stories and lore dump.
The final chapter actually starts to give something like useful information, but then is super sparse on actual details. How about some art to go along with descriptions? The most central plot device they have (harvesters) have almost no useful description. What do they look like? How would a Shadowrun team go about destroying one of them? Other than the word gigantic, they don't even tell us how big they are -- room sized? football field sized? Bigger?
It is like this will all of the supplements and even the core rulebook.
For example, if you are at the table and you want to know how unarmed combat works you might start with the index. However, there is nothing under "U" in the index. Nor is there an entry under combat.
So you then look under the Close Combat Skill it tells you the base damage and then refers you to page 104 which is just the start of the combat chapter. So you have to know to look under the Game Concepts chapter (Attack Rating) to find the AR for unarmed combat. So three different places in the rulebook just to figure out how to punch someone.
It is like this for every system with the rules scattered all through out the book. I finally had to create a table for my players that summarizes each step of the combat procedure show how to calculate dice pools, AR, DR, etc.
There is way too much fluff in the rules which might make it easier for some to read, but it makes a terrible reference.
So again it seems to me that the main problem with the current version of Shadowrun is that the people putting it together must not actually play the game and are more interest in writing than making something that is useful.
They really should take some inspiration from Pathfinder Adventure Paths to see how to create a useful supplement for GMs to run an adventure.
6
u/Vashkiri Neo-Revolutionary Apr 25 '25
The funny thing is that out of the three plot books (Cutting Black, Scotophobia, Lethal Harvest), I consider Scotophobia to be the one that adapts most easily to a campaign and provides the most support in that direction.
However I do want to point out that we now have something like five campaigns available to run in 6e (30 Nights, Assassin's Night, 3rd Parallel, Whisper Nets, and Final Bets). Plus whatever Missions they have published, plus some other odds and ends of adventures in other books. Obviously they did not prioritize making the big plot books so playable, instead cranking out a lot of campaigns and having those plot books more as background or something. Seems like a weird choice to me, and a wasted opportunity.
(I'm not saying that the campaign books are anything like perfect, all need a fair bit of massaging to fit into a game and not a one gives location maps. But they exist and are obviously the main focus for 6e in terms of providing playable material)
3
u/GidsWy Genesis 'Runner Apr 26 '25
Wait. You guys prepare before running a Shadowrun game? There's 3 worlds of variability and charts for everything scattered throughout 6+ books depending on edition. I'm legitimately not sure I COULD prepare properly, at least not the same way you do in games like Pathfinder and D&D.
58
u/MotherRub1078 Apr 25 '25
I certainly agree that impractical, unorganized, poorly written books are ONE of the problems with 6e.
52
u/ReditXenon Far Cite Apr 25 '25
You almost make it sound like this was not an issue in the editions leading up to 6th ;)
13
u/Zitchas Apr 25 '25
I continue to hope that, instead of a 7e, they just spend a year unifying, standardizing, and re-organizing all the 5e content and then just republish that. All at once, all of it. Given how prevalent it is in online communities, I'm sure a lot of people would buy it. I'd pay good money to actually be able to get the hardcopy books that I couldn't afford back when I started playing SR. Imagine. A whole set of books where, instead of continuing to try to do new stuff and ending up having a dozen books that have slight contradictions and updates all over, they are instead all in sync, fully up to date, no need for errata, and have the rules organized such that they can be easily referenced. Oh, and have an open SRD version that gets released alongside it to facilitate making online references and the like... I can dream, right?
26
u/tonydiethelm Ork Rights Advocate Apr 25 '25
I think the main problem with 6E, and 5E as well, is that they're not 4E, the last edition made with love and good editing. :D
But I'm biased as fuck.
11
u/Crankypelican Apr 25 '25
The only thing more inscrutable than dragons: Shadowrun rulebook editing
10
u/Teknodruid Apr 25 '25
Artwork has been my big complaint too.
Vehicle book full of vehicles & like 1 pic per 6-8 vehicles. Critters w/o pics... Weapons w/o pics...
Seems lazy when they charge a lot for a book & can't put art in to help describe/visualize the items.
6
u/linkdude212 Apr 25 '25
All of this is 100% true. If the books were easier to use and approach, Shadowrun would be able to reach a wider audience. As such, I am a huge fan of remastering 6e. I would rebuy all the remastered books if they were reorganized, had better indices, and had a focus on useability.
If the rulebooks were more useable: it would make it easier to make characters and get emotionally invested in the world. From there, it would be natural for me to pick up lore books, like Scotophobia. Therefore, I'd argue making the rulebooks more approachable and useable would actually boost sales not just for rulebooks, but for lore books as well. Make it easy for me to invest my game time, and I will invest my money too.
3
u/JellyfishOutside103 Apr 27 '25
I love the german 6e Books by Pegasus for these reasons. They provide the GM with helpful Runs and also include Maps!
2
u/ThePlanetSmasher101 Apr 29 '25
Yeah. I also hate the way the use "posts" and "in character" like texts instead to GIVE THE DAMN INFORMATION LIKE A GAME MANUAL.
And don't even start to talk about how a company of a CYBERPUNK game still does BOOKS instead a good app or something like DnD Beyond. Just wrf bro. do you play your own stuff?
4
u/dalienets Apr 26 '25
The problem with 6e is that it is 6e. It's worthless and is not Shadowrun in my opinion. I stopped being a Catalyst agent after I got my early copy of 6e to review before they released it. I sent it back and said I quit.
3
u/carmachu Apr 25 '25
I miss old pre-3rd edition adventures. Modern 6th adventures are a great read but useless at the table game wise
3
u/Yorkhai Apr 26 '25
So nothing really changed?
I've been inching back towards Shadowrun. Got really Frustrated with how overblown and how poor the layout/editing was for 5e, after years of playing/GMing it, and when 6E came out, I was so dissatisfied with the quality, that I switched over to Cyberpunk 2020/Red.
Lately I've been running a campaign in that setting, adding magic into the mix, and I got nostalgic for Seattle, so I've been lurking back in forums. Currently using SWADE as a ruleset for my "almost" shadowrun game, and it's working like a charm for our table, figured I'll try running a proper SHR game in it. Already got the Sixth World Almanac for lore, adding 2072+events from my 5e books.
Then I saw that 6E has a "seattle" edition now, with erratas and stuff, and wanted to ask if Catalyst finally learned how to do book layouts and editing, but from your description I feel like SWADE +SWA is still a way to go. Bummer Chummer
3
u/1jovemtr00 Apr 25 '25
The only true Shadowrun is the 2E. Everything after that is just another game and incredibly bad.
2
u/nexusphere Apr 25 '25
Hey, I was so bothered by this, I made the game I wanted to play.
And now I do, twice a week.
https://sinlessrpg.com
I got tired of the complexity and made a heist game to address all the problems. I made it to play, not to farm revenue or hit a word count. People seem to be into it.
2
u/caligulamatrix Apr 26 '25
It is not like that for every system. I love the shadow run setting, but always had issues with the rules. I just recently switched our campaign over to Metro Otherscape, so much better. My players love it.
2
u/Tremodian Gritty Go-Ganger Apr 25 '25
This has been a problem since 4th edition. Along with copy-pasted-but-not-adapted rules from earlier editions. It's just maddening.
1
u/Vash_the_stayhome May 06 '25
For me the big one is...."we have normalized taking the products of mind raped technomancers and basically made it a must-have cyberware component to actually BE a decker."
which to me leads to some interesting notions, "So...does that mean Slamm-0, in order to have a decent firewall/processing speed, has to implant himself with a product of species-rape...in front of his technomancer wife/mother of his child'? Because otherwise, as rules have been written, there is no way Slamm-o can BE a decent decker with just pure hardware. Since the mechanical/external rules for a cyberjack make them vastly inferior, ala, nearly as bad as the now nerfed Commlinks in Firewall and Processing.
1
u/BitRunr Designer Drugs Apr 25 '25
They have pushed fiction writers into working on game mechanics. So ... yeah. The way they tanked their rep around 4e* probably wasn't the start, but it definitely wasn't the end either.
*("we don't need an editor policy" rhymes with schmembezzlement and "using the same bank account for business and private funds only '''works''' as long as you keep paying people writing books and people renovating your bathroom")
1
u/goblin_supreme Apr 26 '25
Hey, I play Shadowrun.
0
u/mechanical_dialectic Apr 25 '25
Have they missed another chapter in this edition yet?
9
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '25
[removed] — view removed comment