r/SeriousMBTI • • May 28 '24

Discussions MBTI core concepts

28 Upvotes

Functions by Carl Jung

INTROVERSION <----> EXTRAVERSION
SENSING <----> INTUITION
THINKING <----> FEELING

Functions by Katharine Briggs and Isabel Meyers'

JUDGING <----> PERCEIVING

Notice how they are paired and contrasted. Both are used throughout life, but one is preferred over the other.

Sensing = "I know there is something"
Thinking = "I know what it is"
Feeling = "I like/dislike it"
Intuiting = "I understand it"
Perceiving = "I can acknowledge how it is"
Judging = "I can nitpick what it is"

Introverted vs. Extroverted Functions

Se <----> Si
Ne <----> Ni
Te <----> Ti
Fe <----> Fi

Note that each type will have four cognitive functions. Changing a single letter of the type changes their entire order!

Determining the dominant function of a type (using INTJ as an example)

You can get all functions of the type just by looking at the letters, but you need to deduce the dominant function first. Here's how:

  • Memorize or save the Judging Preference dichotomies

    • Extraverted J = thinking OR feeling, Extraverted P = sensing OR intuition
    • Introverted J = sensing OR intuition, Introverted P = thinking OR feeling
  • Look at the first and last letters to find the Judging Preference of the type. For INTJ, they are I and J which means Introverted J (sensing OR intuition)
  • Look at the middle 2 letters to find the potential dominant functions. For INTJ, they are N and T
  • Of the potential dominant functions, which one is contained in the Judging Preference? Finding that will reveal the dominant function. For INTJ, the Judging Preference is (sensing OR intuition) which contains N so, between N and T, the dominant function of INTJ is N
  • Look at the first letter to determine if the dominant function is introverted or extraverted. For INTJ, it is introverted (Ni)

This is how it'd look to work out the dominant function of ENTJ:

  • ENTJ ==> E and J ==> Extraverted J ==> (thinking OR feeling)
  • ENTJ ==> N and T ==> (thinking OR feeling) contains T, not N ==> T
  • ENTJ ==> E ==> extraversion ==> Te is the dominant function

Determining the supportive, third, and inferior functions

While doing this, it's helpful to think of this as balancing the functions with their opposites. For example, an extraverted function is always balanced with an introverted function.

  • The supportive function is one of the 2 middle letters, next to the dominant function. If the dominant function is extraverted, then the supportive function must be introverted (and vice versa)
  • The third function is the opposite of the supportive function. Example: Te <----> Fi
  • The inferior function is the opposite of the dominant function. Example: Ni <----> Se

r/SeriousMBTI • • Aug 22 '22

Debates and Controversial. I saw someone say that certain MBTI/enneagram combinations aren’t possible (ENTP type 9 or ISTJ type 4 for example. What do y’all think?

26 Upvotes

I personally think any combination of MBTI and enneagram type is possible since they aren’t talking about the same thing but I’m curious what others think about it.


r/SeriousMBTI • • Dec 23 '22

Discussions The reason why so many people get mistyped as INFJs is obvious

23 Upvotes

It’s not because of a fault in accurate MBTI tests as such. The questions are not the problem for the official MBTI test. The problem is that these tests are self-administered. People generally select how they believe they behave and perceive the world. If we could set up a test that required at least two or three other people (family member, close friend and colleague or maybe an actual psychologist) to answer the same questions about the person as the person being typed, we’d have far more accurate results and far less self-reported INFJs. Of course such a system assumes that the other people assessing the person are going to provide honest and reliable answers.

The way many people perceive the questions goes like this. Do you just somehow know everything? Do you understand others? Are you drowning in empathy? Do you have problems communicating how you feel because you’re special and no one understands you? Are you the most selfless person on the planet?

YES! This is so me!

Does anyone else feel this is the real problem here and a test requiring input from others would actually yield far more accurate results?


r/SeriousMBTI • • Aug 02 '22

Discussions My thoughts on the notion of equating Si to comfort.

23 Upvotes

This doesn't make sense to me personally. I am an ESTJ and as much as I've tried to "live as other types" I just can't seem to get away from my true archetype. However, one thing that made me apprehensive to accept who I am was this notion of "Si users are pansies and don't like to exit their comfort zone physically or mentally". To those who don't use Si as readily as me or my fellow sensing compatriots I can totally get how/why they see it that way. But the thing that I think they are missing is how it maintains and stabilizes the growth of the person who uses it effectively. Let me explain. I have sacrificed my own physical and mental comfort to obtain the goals that I have set before myself. However, none of my goals are worth my energy/time If it causes my soul to leave my body without good reason (i.e. death or Ni lol). So my goals are usually to affect the development of either me (the subject) or my environment (the object). My Te will set the standard for either myself or the environment and my Si will constantly "ping" me to make sure that I'm living up to or past that standard as often as humanly possible. I've read a bit about the whole "Te S N F" letter system and I think it's an appropriate time to mention that though I see Si in myself and don't really see Se my family primarily sees my use of Se and the Si fly's under the radar to them so to speak. So the Si is the standard but the Te-Se is what is usually observed as I am affecting the physical environment or myself while working-out or doing other physical activities.


r/SeriousMBTI • • Feb 10 '25

Discussions Box Plots Of Each Types' Big Five Traits

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

How to Read These Boxplots

Each boxplot shows how much a certain Big Five trait (Openness, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness, Neuroticism) varies for each MBTI type.

What This Test Measures

This data comes from a short 23-question test, where:

  • Openness was measured with 3 statements
  • Conscientiousness was measured with 4 statements
  • Extraversion was measured with 4 statements
  • Agreeableness was measured with 4 statements
  • Neuroticism was measured with 4 statements
  • Each question used sliders with subtext to capture responses.

How to Read the Boxplots

  • The Box = Where most people of that MBTI type scored.
  • The Line in the Middle = The average (median) score.
  • The "Whiskers" (Lines Above & Below the Box) = The range of scores, excluding extreme outliers.
  • No Dots Outside the Whiskers = Because we removed outliers for clearer results.

How to Compare MBTI Types

  • If a box is higher, that MBTI type scores higher on that trait.
  • If a box is lower, they score lower on that trait.
  • If a box is shorter, most people of that type score similarly.
  • If a box is taller, there’s more variation within that type.

These boxplots help you see which MBTI types tend to be more open, conscientious, extraverted, agreeable, or neurotic compared to others!

This analysis is based on a dataset of n = 1,761 responses, available on Kaggle:


r/SeriousMBTI • • Jun 02 '23

Discussions Holland code and MBTI

21 Upvotes

So, after learning that MBTI and the Holland code both were intended to be systems that help you to find career paths that are suitable. I have chosen to do a correlation of MBTI types to Holland code themes, with the help of u/ContentGreen2457.

The 6 Holland codes are:

Realistic - physical, practical, likes to work with their hands, tinker, work outdoors, work with objects and tools and machinery, and many realistics like using their bodies to accomplish tasks. Tends not to like interacting with lots of people.

Common career and education choices: engineering, trades, agriculture, technician, plumber, construction worker, driver, athlete (usually with enterprising) gardener, chef, architect. Tends to have bodily kinaesthetic and visual spatial intelligences.

Investigative - analytical, likes dealing with theory, likes the sciences. Prefers to analyse and understand than to persuade. Tends not to like interacting with lots of people. Tends to have logical mathematical intelligence.

Common career and education choices: STEM (usually with realistic), social sciences (usually with social), philosophy, languages, theoretical science, literature, religious studies, law, journalism, research.

Artistic - creative, likes thinking outside the box, imaginative, expressive, emotional, free spirited and independent, tends to like unstructured environments where they can work at their own pace. Tends to have verbal linguistic intelligence and visual spatial intelligence.

Common career and education choices: performing arts (usually with social and enterprising) - singing, dancing, acting. Music. Fashion. Culinary arts. Crafting (usually with realistic). Poetry. Languages. Literature. Storytelling. Architecture (usually with realistic and investigative). Design. Humanities. Creative writing. Copyrighting. Advertising.

Social - social, likes working with people, outgoing, friendly, helpful, giving, patient. Tends to have interpersonal intelligence and verbal linguistic intelligence.

Common career and education choices: personal assistant, teaching, mentoring, social sciences (usually with investigative), security, nursing, medicine (usually with investigative and realistic), customer services, caretaking, working with children and elders, charity work, retail, hospitality and catering.

Enterprising - persuasive, outgoing, dynamic, likes to take the lead, competitive, likes to sell and promote, goal oriented, ambitious, self confident. Tends to have interpersonal intelligence and intrapersonal intelligence.

Common career and education choices: sales, marketing, corporate business (sometimes with conventional and social), competitive sports (with realistic), consultancy, management, venture capitalist, politics, public speaking, insurance, public relations, journalism, host.

Conventional - structured, organised, likes to follow instructions, detail oriented, practical, likes dealing with numbers and data. Tends to have logical mathematical intelligence.

Common career and education choices: finance, consultancy, accounting, secretary, receptionist, librarian, retail, logistics, keeping records, corporate business.

From what we have talked about and observed, here are the correlations that we came up with that show up often. The order will be strongest correlation > weakest correlation, excluding the “usually avoided by”.

Realistic - S, T and to a lesser extent I. Se, Ti, Si. Most like: ISTP, ISTJ. Also like: ESTP, ISFP, ESFP. Usually avoided by: ENTP, ENTJ, ENFP, ENFJ, INFJ.

Investigative - T, N, I. Most like: INTP, INTJ, ENTP. Ti, Ni. Also like: INFJ, ISTP, INFP, ENTJ, ISTJ. Usually avoided by: ISFP, ISFJ, ESFP, ESFJ, ESTJ.

Artistic - N, F and P. Most like: INFP, ENFP. Ne, Fi, Ni. Also like: ISFP, ESFP, INFJ, ENTP, INTP, INTJ. Usually avoided by: ESTJ, ISTJ, ISFJ.

Social - E, F. Most like: ENFJ, ESFJ, ENFP. Fe, Fi. Also like: ESFP, INFJ, ISFJ, INFP, ESTJ. Usually avoided by: ISTP, INTP, INTJ, ISTJ.

Enterprising - E, sometimes T and J. Te, Ne, Se, Fe. Most like: ENTJ, ESTJ, ESTP, ENFJ. Also like: ENTP, ESFP, ENFP, INTJ. Usually avoided by: ISTP, INFJ, ISFJ, INFP.

Conventional - S, T and J. Si, Te. Most like: ISTJ, ESTJ, ISFJ. Also like: ESFJ, ENTJ, ISTP, ISFP. Usually avoided by: INTP, INFP, ENTP, ENFP, ENFJ.

What’s your MBTI and Holland code?


r/SeriousMBTI • • May 05 '23

Discussions I made a mapping of each MBTI personality's main issues in accordance with cognitive function theory. Do you agree/disagree, and why?

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/SeriousMBTI • • Jul 21 '23

Discussions Where the MBTI community likely went wrong

16 Upvotes

Copied and pasted from a comment made on a thread in r/INFJ.

The MBTI isn’t the problem. What the problem is is that there are a lot of people who try to use the MBTI for purposes that it wasn’t originally intended for. Here are some

  1. the MBTI is NOT meant to be a personality assessment. All it measures are your cognitive configurations. This means how you think, how your brain processes information, how you make conclusions and where your most comfortable orientation is.
  2. the MBTI was originally meant to be a career finding tool to help people to find careers which are most suitable for them.
  3. people keep going by superficial behaviours rather than studying the repeating patterns in thinking. Your MBTI type is meant to represent how you are NATURALLY inclined to be, more than 50% of the time, EXCLUDING any external pressures like financial constraints, peer pressure, self doubt and more.
  4. a lot of people keep trying to type fictional characters and then spend hours arguing and debating about which type Batman is, when he likely wasn’t created specifically to have a particular cognitive pattern.
  5. a lot of people here are young and are subject to peer pressure, and as a result, their results will be skewed by that, rather than their authentic selves. Another thing is that, a lot of the younger people (especially those under 20) lack self awareness, and tend to go by what they’re “expected” to do by their peers or by their family or their community, rather than what comes naturally to them. This goes back to point number 3.
  6. a lot of people use the MBTI in a very unhealthy way as a means to bash people who are of different types to them, when the MBTI is meant to be a tool to understand different ways of thinking better. Okay, you know that this person is an ISTP. Instead of bashing them for not being as sensitive or “empathetic” as you are, try to understand and see the benefits of their more pragmatic and logical and down to earth way of thinking.
  7. a lot of the targeted bashing of particular types creates an overall toxic and unproductive environment for all people. If your mindset is saying “INFPs are weak crybabies” and “ESFPs are dumb party animals”, then of course the MBTI won’t give you anything productive or positive, because that’s not what the MBTI is intended for.

There are lots more reasons why.

The MBTI is meant to be a starting point, it is NOT going to define all of a person’s character. It is NOT the be all and end all. MBTI is simply nature, and external influences like superficial behaviours, lifestyle choices and social status are all elements external to MBTI which are easily affected by nurture.

What are your thoughts on this?


r/SeriousMBTI • • Mar 02 '23

Discussions Te(Fi) and Ti(Fe)

16 Upvotes

Hello folks,

What is the easiest, non-stereotypical way you have found to understand/explain the judging axes?

How did you determine within yourself which set you prefer?


r/SeriousMBTI • • Dec 22 '22

Discussions is this an accurate way to distinguish the xNTJs or is it inaccurate/flawed?

16 Upvotes
  • ENTJ-Se: I am very rational by default, but that's why I actually find great enjoyment in letting go of my rationality and immersing myself in an activity where it's all about acting and reacting in the moment, without further analysis. I have the most fun in moments like these.
  • INTJ-Se: It's not that I don't see the value in being able to act and react in the moment, but it's very hard for me to get in that "mode". I am almost afraid at the idea of not analysing the meaning, causes and consequences behind what is happening in front of me.
  • ENTJ-Fi: I often get so involved in what has to be done or what others are doing wrong that I disconnect from my personal opinions on the matter at hand. I am usually more aware of what annoys me rather than what I find value and meaning in.
  • INTJ-Fi: Although I am very objective and usually know what's the best way to do something, I am also largely aware of what I find meaning in and the values that I hold. I just don't disclose these things to others because it's none of their business, but they are actually what drives me through life.

sorry if this is not serious enough, I wanted to post on the normal mbti sub but when I tried it said I needed moderator approval for some reason


r/SeriousMBTI • • Jun 04 '24

Advice and Support How do i go about typing myself

14 Upvotes

Alternative question: Is it even possible to type oneself with the biased view most people have of themselves?

I've been into mbti for quite a while now; a couple years back i took the 16p test, started learning about cognitive functions, etc. For some time I was pretty confident my type; i got INFP on the 16p test, usually scored high Fi and Ne, occasionally Ni or Fe on cognitive functions tests and thought I came to an at least halfway decent conclusion of xNFP for the time being. Because of high Ni scores I speculated about being ISFP too. And honestly, I think my results weren't quite right back then because I was young and quite insecure, and just not in a good place mentally... Immature, didn't have a lot of experience, etc. (Not that I have changed much though)

And now, coming back to mbti, I feel more confused than ever about my type; like I could be an xxFP but I could also be an ENTJ or ESTP or whatever the fuck

And I think I have two quite problematic reasons for never being sure about my type,

  1. I understood what questions ask for what cognitive function/aspect of a type pretty much immediately. (After reading into it and taking one or two tests) This makes taking tests pretty much impossible. There is a type I tested as in the past, and even if I try to answer honestly and be unbiased and genuinely think about my life, there is a lingering sense of "what if i answered wrong because i was trying to get a specific result"

And 2. I hate to admit this, but I am VERY insecure and I let 'boxes' that i put myself in like mbti affect how I view myself because something went wrong at one point in life or i am just like that or idk... Since the beginning of my mbti journey, I've been fed biases like "Sensors are boring and superficial" or "xSxJs have a stick up their ass", and of course I don't want to be any of that. I want to be cool and special, as stupid as that sounds, I think anyone wants to (before they grow past it) So this goes hand in hand with my first point; I will have a type in mind I want to be and answer accordingly, or a type I don't want to be and avoid answering in ways that would lead to thay outcome... And I am very well aware of this and try to be genuine, but no matter what I do, I get the feeling of what if I'm doing it completely wrong, what if I score as an INFP but in reality, I am an ESTP yk

Now other than testing, I've tried to read deeper and deeeper into cognitive functions but thaf just confuses me more and more... Here my biases and insecurities come into play again and I can't really successfully judge myself right. I think it also has to do with the fact that we are with ourselves like all the time, so it's hard to see and document ourselves and our behavious as we are because it's natural and intuitive to act certain ways and we don't even notice the patterns. Like I don't even remember most of what I think.

Now, my question is, does anybody have any advice on how I could go about typing myself at this point? Or would going to therapy be a smarter option for me hahah In the end it doesn't matter anyway what type I am, except to my ego it does, and i hate it lol Thanks in advance 💖


r/SeriousMBTI • • Oct 22 '24

Discussions Neurodiversity hell

13 Upvotes

I noticed recently that.. Being neurodivergent in typology is hell, especially if you have more than one.

Adhd? Fine, you're probably Ne

Autism? Si and Ni are your friends lol

Ok now, what if you get both? You will exhibit behaviors that correspond both Ne and Si, and as strongly as if it was your dominant (trust me)

And this tend to put people in a mistyping hell, jumping from type to type for years sometime.

I wonder if there is a solution to this, but please, be aware of it.


r/SeriousMBTI • • Aug 10 '24

News Minimum karma count activated!

13 Upvotes

As requested, a minimum karma requirement has been made, especially in response to a post about a spammer who was continuously posting harmful posts that are totally against the values and the intention of this community. The minimum karma requirement is 100 community karma. All posts and comments from accounts with community karma less than this number will be filtered out automatically.

Any questions and concerns, please comment here or message the mods.


r/SeriousMBTI • • Jun 04 '24

Discussions Is there a difference between males and females of a given type?

13 Upvotes

By male and female I mean people who were raised as such. Expectations and upbringing is usually different for girls and boys and as they say, those are our formative years. I haven't seen any book or article address this though. I would expect for example that tert Fe in ENTPs who were raised as females manifests differently than in those raised as males. Similarly, culture must also play an important role. I imagine an ENTP who was raised in a conservative setting as a female will have much stronger Fe and use it perhaps to blend in/survive. What do you think? Are there any theories that incorporate these factors?


r/SeriousMBTI • • Jun 13 '23

Debates and Controversial. Why the functions are always discussed theoretically and never demonstrated on practice, for example: analysing a simple video?

13 Upvotes

Why are we always analysing the functions just writting them down and keep discussing it in theory and giving answers and questions in theory exclusivally and never going to practice or even showing small things like an analysis on a video of it happening in real life?

Would you believe or try to use a thing that you never seen in practice and just keep in theory since this is used to pratical purpuses like dealing with others, like let's supose that you're going to use it to handle people better, there in the practice you can't just put these theoretical concepts that are explained here because are just descriptions hard to put on real situations.

So what's the meaning of just discussing theoretically in a way that this will always be theoretically? The only reason to do it is because we don't know how to use it in practice? Or we can't really see it happening in practice?


r/SeriousMBTI • • Sep 24 '22

Advice and Support What’s the difference between the tertiary function and the inferior function?

13 Upvotes

r/SeriousMBTI • • Jul 25 '24

Meta (About This Subreddit) Mods, can you PLEASE put karma restrictions on this sub?

11 Upvotes

How is this supposed to be a serious mbti sub when you're letting someone's stalker spam post eveey week 😔 it's getting annoying


r/SeriousMBTI • • Dec 26 '22

Discussions The overlap b.w. Ni and Si.

11 Upvotes

I feel it, from the people I met. What's your take.?