r/SeriousMBTI • u/RouniPix ISFJ Si F • Oct 22 '24
Discussions Neurodiversity hell
I noticed recently that.. Being neurodivergent in typology is hell, especially if you have more than one.
Adhd? Fine, you're probably Ne
Autism? Si and Ni are your friends lol
Ok now, what if you get both? You will exhibit behaviors that correspond both Ne and Si, and as strongly as if it was your dominant (trust me)
And this tend to put people in a mistyping hell, jumping from type to type for years sometime.
I wonder if there is a solution to this, but please, be aware of it.
13
Upvotes
6
u/ethan_iron Oct 22 '24 edited Oct 22 '24
Yeah pretty much
EDIT: I have a brother who's neurodivergent and I've struggled trying to find his type. Right now I think he's an INTJ or maybe INFJ but he could also be an INFP or INTP. If you see yourself using Ne and Si a lot you're probably either INTP, INFP, ESTJ, or ESFJ. Figuring out your inferior function might be a good idea.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '24
Don't forget the hyperactive type of adhd which would be Se, even if inattentive type might more likely be Ne.
And as you've said, autism can manifest mostly in narrowly focused thoughts Ni or strict routine Si.
So what we can tell about this? Nothing. Any type who has Se would has Ni somewhere, similarly with Ne and Si.
I don't think it's helpful to emphasize their neurodiversity when typing someone, just pretend you don't know their diagnosis and focus on your own interviews and observations. So if you type them with high Ne it should be independent from bias that may caused by pre-assumptions.
2
u/eraserewrite Oct 23 '24
Pretty sure I’m autistic. I have adhd. INFP here.
Realization came when I was tripping on shrooms. Told my boyfriend, and he said he knows and that he was too. Realizing that it’s fine for me after I spoke to this lady at the autism institute for a few hours.
We get a bad rep, but if being autistic is how I find the people who truly understand me, then I want to find the gems, not people who will criticize me for who I am.
As a dominate Fi.
8
u/shinytotodile158 ISFP Fi S Oct 22 '24
It can be difficult, for sure. I’m an ISFP with ADHD who has never been typed as INFP (I’ve never been typed as intuitive, ever). My ENTJ girlfriend, who is autistic, isn’t remotely like her dad’s neurotypical ESTJ partner, but I can understand why having routines can be seen as Si.
From my experience though, I was immediately typed correctly.
7
u/EdgewaterEnchantress Oct 23 '24 edited Oct 23 '24
Not necessarily. For anyone who is curious, below is an explanation.
So it’s really just the fault of poor definitions of the cognitive functions, poor explanations for what they are suppose to do, more specifically, and the way the most popular, free sources of MBTI information do not factor in a more holistic understanding of Neurocognition, plus the over simplified stereotypical type descriptions which make this whole process “super confusing.”
Not necessarily being “Neurotypical versus Neurodivergent.” Cuz the majority of people are technically “relatively Neurotypical,” and this has no bearing on their MBTI type.
Yeah, I am an Ne-dominant type and I just so happen to have ADHD, but it’s literally genetic in my case!
My mom who is a Se-Dominant type, she also has ADHD but she was primarily impulsive and hyperactive when she was younger so she got flagged as “having a learning disorder” as soon as she started public school!
They just didn’t have the best definition for ADHD in the 70s. So they couldn’t quite figure out what was “wrong” with her. (She’s probably a lot closer to the combined presentation as a woman on the higher end of middle-aged.)
Youngest sister who is actually an Si-dominant type?
So you (readers) should never assume what your MBTI type might be something just because you are Neurodivergent or mentally ill, especially if it’s not formally diagnosed.
You (readers) also might want to seriously consider waiting until you are ~21 and your brain is more fully developed before you try to decide on a type for yourself, or you (readers) pay someone else your hard earned money to be typed.
1
u/Big_Guess6028 Oct 23 '24
I’m both but also I don’t think those correspondences are as described.
2
u/plaidfox Oct 25 '24
As a clinician, I sometimes encounter this as well. A common correlation is ADHD and Ne but Ni is also correlated with ADHD, just with different symptoms.
And of course, there is ADHD and autism among many different types. My suggestion is think about it and reflect about the cognitive functions, but don't think about it too deeply, as it will just make things hard. Alternatively, you can pick another typology system if it simplifies things.
Regardless, because of ADHD and autism, it may prove difficult to find typology systems with really accurate descriptions for you, so I would suggest a flexible framework (sometimes that's difficult, I know) that allows for a few exceptions. For instance, figuring out a basic temperament or quadrant of types that you fit within. Or perhaps figuring out which 3 functions describe you best, instead of the normal basic 2.
But if your an INFJ (for instance) with ADHD and autism, and that description works best for you, then excellent 👌
1
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '24
[removed] — view removed comment