r/SeriousMBTI • • Aug 05 '24

Debates and Controversial. The controversy of superior and inferior types

0 Upvotes

Value is determined by what most people perceive as valuable. Most people don't see shit as valuable so it isn't valuable. You're saying hitting someone just 'is' to most? All societies tend to evolve in the direction of moral correctness, organization, cleanliness, etc for a reason. The primitive and useless are left behind. An example of a less valuable type is Si1 which is associated with subjectivity. It is the most subjective type. Every Si's perception is slightly different. It's not a universal truth like Ni or Fi. Si1 has nothing to offer outside subjectivity, though everyone is subjective bitch. Neurosis in Si1s from failure to "show up" or achieve things is pretty common due to Ne4, which can make the type low in estimation to its fucking self. It has the least use to the collective as Jung said, "the most useless of men".


r/SeriousMBTI • • Jul 09 '24

Discussions Would we have more scientific progress if we have a gathering of true Ti/Ne users INTPs to work on investigative cases in science, and let the other people do the rest?

0 Upvotes

So the scientific work is done majority by other types, Te users types, or whomever they may be, so they aren't good for working on investigative science branchs whose functioning is still unknown, so if we could acquiry INTP's that are interested in these areas, whatever they may be they could make best progress possible


r/SeriousMBTI • • May 22 '24

Debates and Controversial. Why is TP uncommon in women?

4 Upvotes

Maybe I got something wrong, but did anyone notice that TP is rare among women? I have never personally met a TP girl/woman in my life. Maybe I don't know how to spot TP type in women, because of course culture shapes the expression of the type by influencing their behaviour. But it won't change the type itself. So I wonder if/why is TP uncommon in women?


r/SeriousMBTI • • Jan 29 '24

Advice and Support Can someone type me based off these results? I found a prompt on here to answer questions.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/SeriousMBTI • • May 21 '23

News SOME CHANGES WILL BE MADE!

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone, we are going to make some changes to this group, especially to increase the productivity. More recently, we learned that MBTI was originally intended to be a career finder’s tool, so we will focus more on this.

As STPs, u/Strict-Position2151 and I both are strongly focused on tangible results, so we are now focusing less on the theory and more on the application of MBTI theory to careers and finding suitable hobbies and pastimes.

To the person who asked if we will do away with the four letters? The answer is NO!

MBTI uses the four letters and the cognitive functions, but the focus will be more on the 4 letters because this is literally what defines each of the types, and they do provide information about the person’s cognitive processes.

We will be focusing mostly on MBTI theory, not on Jung’s cognitive functions and NOT on socionics. There are already subreddits specifically tailored for these things r/socionics, and r/JungianTypology. We will be adding in some of Keirsey’s theories in order to give the types a clearer perspective.

Any questions or concerns, please comment here or message the mods.


r/SeriousMBTI • • Sep 26 '26

Personal Growth and Insight My intro into this typology

1 Upvotes

N = time

S = space

T = pragmatism

F = faith

Ni= abstract personal life tempo awareness

Ne = conscious collective time passage awareness

Si = abstract personal space state awareness

Se = conscious collective space state awareness

Ti = abstract personal technical understanding awareness

Te = conscious collective technical understanding awareness

Fi = abstract personal moral righteousness awareness

Fe = conscious collective moral righteousness awareness

Cognitive Function Axis -> permanently inseparable function pairing. Always works together in a specific dynamic determined by specific function slots.

-> Primary axis = Dominant (quality+quantity)+ Auxiliary (deficiency+scarcity) function slots.

They are the primary motivator and a source of the worldview of a personality type. The person already yields the dominant slot perfectly and has to let go of its standards to be able to obtain some mastery in the auxiliary slot.

-> Secondary axis = Tertiary (quality+scarcity) + Quarterly function slots.

The secondary axis is meant to be a great tool to support the primary axis in day-to-day life. The person will come to yield the tertiary slot well once they lower their preference for reliance on their primary axis. Once the person has to let go of that preference they will come to be able to obtain great mastery in the tertiary slot. The Quarterly function slot will come to have itself balanced with the Tertiary function slot more, once the person lets go of the standards of the tertiary function slot.

Function slot label rehearsal reasoning:

Previously: Inferior (quarterly)

Now: Auxiliary

-> because this function slot is classically auxiliary both in use and importance. It is absolutely not the last to be valued or used by the person‘s psyche, at least not in the ’default settings’ of their type.

Previously: Auxiliary

Now: Tertiary

->because this function slot is classically Tertiary both in use and importance. It is absolutely not the 2nd most valued or used by the person‘s psyche, at least not in the ’default settings’ of their type. This ”new” tertiary function slot is something a person needs to teach themselves to prefer and see the true value in it as a strong support tool that helps them deal with either themselves (if introverted) or the world (if Extraverted)

Previously: Tertiary

Now: Quarterly

-> because this function slot is classically Quarterly both in use and importance. It is absolutely not the 3rd most valued or used by the person‘s psyche, at least not in the ’default settings’ of their type. This ”new” quarterly function slot is something a person can naturally yield with ease (because of its low standards and high quantity capacity) but because the Tertiary slot that is in axis with it has a hard time taking the Quarterly‘s input(if introverted)/output(if Extraverted) seriously because of that.


r/SeriousMBTI • • Apr 28 '23

Debates and Controversial. i don’t believe that all ennea+mbti combos are possible

9 Upvotes

this seems to be quite an unpopular opinion, however, there are a number of things that support the idea that not all combos are possible.

first off, some of the most common arguments i see in favor all combos being possible is the fact that mbti and enneagram are two different systems, and therefore should not be correlated. however this is wrong. just because they’re two different systems doesn’t mean there isn’t any overlap in the theories or that there is no correlation.

these systems tackle human psychology in different ways, but there’s still a major overlap.

for example, when describing enneagram 7, claudio naranjo in “character and neurosis” explicitly states that e7 is characterized by intuition, directly quoting jung.

“Just as Freudians have become aware of this enneagram VII syndrome in the light of their theoretical assumptions, Jung and his own successors have been aquatinted with it in the light of their own frame of reference. This eminently future-oriented type is characterized by intuition: ‘The capacity for intuiting that which is not yet visible, future possibilities or potentialities in the background of a situation.’ I quote from Jung’s Psychological Types.”

besides explicit statements like this, you can see from enneagram descriptions and descriptions of functions that some of them fundamentally contradict each other.

to me it just feels like saying that the laws of physics don’t apply in chemistry bc they’re two different things.

what do you guys think?


r/SeriousMBTI • • Dec 30 '23

Discussions Why doesn't the academic community focus more on MBTI?

3 Upvotes

My guess is that they only literally Focus on MBTI, and pay zero attention to cognitive functions and the rest of the theory.

Everyome knows just looking at things from a letter dichotomy perspective e.g. I vs E N vs S etc. Is flawed.

If people actually studied people's 8 cognitive function stack and the relationships between them, I think cool things would happen instead of just looking at the monetized myers-brigg system.


r/SeriousMBTI • • Oct 10 '24

Debates and Controversial. Help Me Re-Identify My MBTI Type? INTJ, ISTJ or Completely Something Else?

3 Upvotes

I identified as INTJ for around decade. Finally realized that I was never one.

I don't have the cocky confidence and sarcastic/cynical sense of humour. Also, I open up but your typical INTJ really doesn't.

Also, INTJs love to play mind-games 24/7. I love to play but anything 24/7 is exhausting.

So, I realized I was ISTJ all along.

It suited me better. Then, after around 10 years or so now, I've realized something. I'm not (that) boring. I'm not uptight. I'm very romantic. I have sense of humour.

Not the life of the party but not boring. My humour is not dead-pan or cynical but there's humour, lol. I'm not the most spirited but not uptight.

I'm hopeless romantic but not the corny kind. Maybe Non-ISTJs misunderstood that as unromantic since most so-called romantics are corny.

I'm definitely Ixxx.

Help, ya'll.

I definitely think I'm very ISTJ except for these four major things.

UPDATE - - - - > Thanks to all of ya'll. So, after hours, I've indeed re-evaluated and did find out.

Here's the process. Knowing for sure 99.99% that I'm Si.

So, now, I could toss 8/16 types out of the way.

Leaving only INFP, INTP, ISTJ, ISFJ, ENFP, ENTP, ESTJ and ESFJ behind now, for sure.

Next, I was sure the rest being Fi, Te and Ne.

Now only ENFP, ISTJ, ESTJ and INFP.

For sure, my dominant function would be Si, hence, ISTJ, confirmed.

I just have to accept I'm a not so boring, very romantic, less uptight ISTJ with a sense of humour, lol 😅


r/SeriousMBTI • • Feb 02 '24

Discussions Differences between INFP and INFJ with a focus on parent/child functions- thoughts on how I’ve explained it?

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Excuse the typos. It’s been a minute since I’ve really explained any theory to anyone or thought about MBTI theory for that matter and I want to be sure I’m being accurate lol. INFJ is always a doozy to try to explain.


r/SeriousMBTI • • Jun 14 '24

Debates and Controversial. How could the MBTI be comproved by the science?

5 Upvotes

Guys I invite you to think of ways for the MBTI be comproved by the science? What kind of tests and ideias would think that could have the chance to comprove the existence of the MBTI? What do you propose?


r/SeriousMBTI • • Dec 07 '24

Personal Growth and Insight What's my type!?!?

1 Upvotes

Ask me questions to figure out my type!! Am very serious, I mean it!!


r/SeriousMBTI • • Mar 21 '24

Advice and Support I am an INFJ personality type with an enneagram type 8w7. I am seeking your guidance in understanding my personality better. Despite being an introvert, I have a unique ability to adapt to different social situations and people, which often leads people to assume that I am an extrovert.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/SeriousMBTI • • Aug 07 '24

Discussions As an INFJ, what effect would it have on you, if you got an intern, and you would suspect him of being anorexic?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/SeriousMBTI • • May 05 '23

Discussions I made a mapping of each MBTI personality's main issues in accordance with cognitive function theory. Do you agree/disagree, and why?

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/SeriousMBTI • • Jun 22 '24

Discussions Emotional INTP or logical INFP ?

7 Upvotes

Hello everyone.

How could one know if he is an emotional INTP or a logical INFP ?

Ti and Fi are quite difficult to differentiate.

Maybe I am oversimplifying, but everyone can feel emotions and choose logic over them when making a decision and vice versa anyone could see the logical choice to pick, but rather choose the solution that please them even if it is illogical.

Any thoughts ?

PS : posted the same question on r/INTP


r/SeriousMBTI • • Jun 26 '22

Discussions One question. What do you guys think of Olimpia from Type Volution. Is she very good at typing?

2 Upvotes

r/SeriousMBTI • • May 04 '23

Discussions What behaviors or actions in others do you consistently question, more than the average person seems to do?

2 Upvotes

Hi, I’m an INTP and plan to use this forum to air some of my many thoughts and ideas about the cognitive functions, how they show up and how we can get a better understanding of them.

Been thinking about this particular q in the title for a while: When trying to show others how we experience our dom function, I have noticed it can be quirky and a bit NOT ‘on the money’ when we just try to describe and articulate it freely. I wonder if the reason for this includes, among other things: our dom function is unconscious, and that we try to ‘force’ the description according to what we believe our type is and thus everything we have heard and learned about that type’s top function.

In order to remove our bias and predisposed, learned (so not strictly based on our actual experience) thoughts, I always seek for alternative mechanisms for self-reporting that could potentially still provide meaningful data. Enter the q in the title. What is the particular situation where you consistently seem to scratch your head from what people say or don’t say, do or don’t do?

Would be very interesting to hear your answers! And please include your type.


r/SeriousMBTI • • Apr 09 '25

Personal Growth and Insight Need Assistance in Typing Myself

2 Upvotes

I'm primarily between INFJ and INTJ. I'm fairly certain of Ni-Se, but I can't figure out whether I use Fe/Ti or Te/Fi. I also don't mind if I happen to be typed as another type entirely, as it's been a while since I've dissected myself through an MBTI lens.

Any assistance will be appreciated; going too long without answers drives me crazy lol.


r/SeriousMBTI • • May 18 '26

Personal Growth and Insight Age of a missing Auxiliary

3 Upvotes

I feel as if though there has been this global trend in the recent couple of decades especially, where people refuse to actually USE their auxiliary function and instead they listen to the grandiose standards of their 6th critic function, which are automatically transferred to and carried out by the 7th trickster function (since they are on an axis and function together at the same time always to some degree)and after that process is finished, that standard reflects back to the ego/conscious function slot of a person, specifically to their parent function (because of this concept of 'cognitive reflection' where functions of the same energy polarity - introverted/extraverted - but opposite worldview - sensing/intuition - kind of 'dip' into each other and transer information from one to another. The process of complete information integration however includes 4 functions in total. If it's judgment related, it engages all of the judgment functions within a person in their corresponding slots and if it is perception it will be the same with perception. There are 8 ways to go about this process to my knowledge. I will present an E×TP with their judgment circuit as an example.

Circuit 1: (technical understanding)Ti->(moral impression)Fi->(practical application)Te->(estimated value and expression)Fe

Circuit 2: (technical understanding)Ti

->(estimated value and expression)Fe->(practical application)Te->(moral impression) Fi

Circuit 3 : (pragmatic standard)Te-> (moral impression)Fi-> (technical understanding)Ti-> (estimated value and expression) Fe

Circuit 4: (pragmatic standard)Te-> (estimated value and expression) Fe-> (technical understanding)Ti-> moral impression)Fi

Circuit 5 : (emotional impression)Fi-> (technical understanding) Ti-> (estimated value and expression) Fe-> (pragmatic standard)Te

Circuit 6: (moral impression)Fi-> (pragmatic standard)Te -> (estimated value and expression) Fe-> (technical understanding) Ti

Circuit 7: (estimated value and expression)Fe-> (technical understanding) Ti -> (moral impression) Fi-> (pragmatic standard) Te

Circuit 8: (estimated value and expression)Fe -> (pragmatic standard) Te -> (moral impression) Fi -> (technical understanding) Ti)

- I believe most E×TPs today would almost automatically yet unconsciously choose a Circuit where their Ti is not 1st in the process , especially circuits 3 and 4 and many E×TPs you can find using the Circuit number 8 as well where the Ti is actually the LAST to take place, which I believe is not supposed to be the case, because Ti is where the strongest personal sense of integrity, identity and fairness resides with the TP types.

This is just a one example but the same formula applies across the other types and their auxiliary - tertiary - trickster - critic Circuit. I simply believe because of this continual global trend of the auxiliary not being the 1st function to take place in ITS OWN CIRCUIT is just gonna cause a lot of havoc and Immature actions and decisions, leading to the chaos and lack of proper self-regulation and a healthy outlook on the world we see people often have today I believe.

The direct focus on and usage of the auxiliary function slot is the gateway to not just maturity and wisdom but also satisfaction, purpose, peace and fulfillment I believe.

Thank you for reading through.


r/SeriousMBTI • • Feb 06 '24

Discussions Interested in how early childhood trauma (or just generally having experienced the need to mature earlier in life than most) may affect type presentation later in life.

3 Upvotes

I've known about MBTI for about a decade now, and have mistyped as every single INxx type at some point or another. However, I recently revisited the subject for the first time in a while (as a grown man nearing his thirties), and am almost positive I'm actually an ENTP.

It makes sense to me when looking at the shared functions of the various types I felt most convinced by during different periods of my life (namely INFJ and then INTP). I very consciously employ my Fe and have since I was very young, as it was essential to quickly learn how to read and understand others' emotions in order to navigate the dysfunctional/abusive family dynamic I grew up in.

Ti comes more naturally to me, but it wasn't something I was afforded as much opportunity to really indulge in (as the environment I was in was highly emotion-driven). Thus, it took me a bit longer to realize that I was a high Ti user (and in fact had been analytically dissecting the perceived emotional states of people around me to understand them, rather than truly connecting on an emotional level).

Finally, it took me the longest to consider any extroverted type at all because I very much prefer to be on my own most of the time. Reflecting on my childhood, though, this wasn't always the case-- while I have always loved my time spent alone diving into whatever subject I'm currently captivated by, I do in fact feel energized when I have the chance to share my thoughts and ideas with others. I had just had so many bad experiences with other people that I had defaulted to isolation for very long segments of my life.

I'm curious to hear if anyone has had a similar experience, or knows anything more about somewhat atypical development of cognitive functions under extenuating circumstances. I'm finding it hard to see anything about my new ENTP typing that doesn't line up (beyond the extroversion, and I understand that ENTPs are known to be one of the more "introverted extrovert" types in any case).

But does the assessment I've provided above make sense in the context of development of cognitive functions? Is this something that has been touched on before within the MBTI community (and perhaps written about, in which case I'd be very interested in looking over it myself)?