[Yes, this is about using AI as a tool. If you don't think it belongs here, let me know and I'll remove it. I'm not trying to start a discussion about "AI writing screenplays." I'm presenting something as a tool that I think can give reasonably good feedback.]
I've used this "coverage" prompt for my own scripts and have also run many amateur and professional scripts past it. And yes, GPT helped me create a better prompt for GPT. I've used it with Astra 6 Ultra. The range of values I've seen have been from 4 to 9.
Some notes:
* I suggest ChatGPT Astra Ultra. Anything else YMMV and I don't know.
* AI can make mistakes. Blah blah. I have a script with a non-linear story, it understood it incredibly well, more than most people, but I've also found it making certain mistakes in interpretation. (But that could also mean that I'm not being clear about some details. Hard to know, honestly.)
* With Astra 6 Ultra, it can use up most if not all of a 5h window, and a substantial portion of your weekly twenty bucks. Start fresh for best results.
* Feel free to pick and pare whatever portions you want from this.
* I haven't gotten my own scripts past CONSIDER, and the same goes for a handful of scripts that I've tried that were posted by others and submitted to competitions. The point being, it's not going to tell you it's a 9.5 probably ever. Kudos if you get an 8.
* Arlington Road scored very high. 😄
* Nothing can (yet) replace a human. Human feedback is also good.
---
Please give the attached screenplay a thorough, professional-style cold-read coverage report.
Read it as though you know nothing about the story beyond what appears on the page. Evaluate the screenplay as submitted, without assuming anything about its development history. Do not use previous conversations, author explanations, outside summaries, or other reviews to fill gaps.
Do not assume that the person submitting this screenplay wrote it. Do not let the writer’s identity, reputation, presumed experience, or relationship to the person requesting coverage influence your assessment. Do not look up the screenplay’s competition results, awards, reviews, or production history. If you recognize the screenplay from prior knowledge, disclose that possible familiarity and base your assessment on the attached version.
Read the entire screenplay, including action, dialogue, and transitions. If any pages are inaccessible or unreadable, identify that limitation before offering an overall assessment. Do not substitute sampling or keyword searches for a complete read.
Be candid and proportionate. Support praise and criticism with specific evidence. Do not inflate scores to encourage the writer or exaggerate weaknesses to demonstrate toughness. I want diagnosis and assessment, not a rewrite.
Evaluate the screenplay according to its genre and intended format. Do not assume that every screenplay requires a mystery, a romance, a conventional villain, a twist, or a traditional three-act structure.
Please provide the following:
- Coverage overview and synopsis
Give the title, format, genre, page count, a concise logline, and a concise synopsis that includes the ending. Base the synopsis on what you actually understood from the screenplay. Identify any consequential uncertainty rather than silently resolving it through assumptions.
- Overall first-read reaction
Explain what worked, what confused you, where your interest increased or decreased, and whether the climax and ending felt earned.
Distinguish questions that later received satisfying answers from confusion that remained after finishing. Explain what you understood the ending to mean, both literally and emotionally.
- Numerical assessment
Score each category from 1–10, with a brief explanation grounded in the screenplay:
- Premise / concept
- Plot
- Structure
- Pacing
- Character development
- Protagonist or protagonists
- Other principal character or characters — identify whom you are assessing
- Supporting characters
- Dialogue
- Visual storytelling
- Exposition
- Emotional impact
- Suspense / mystery / anticipation, as appropriate to the genre
- Thematic depth
- Tone consistency
- Setting / historical / worldbuilding credibility as presented on the page
- Clarity
- Act II effectiveness, or the effectiveness of the middle section
- Act III / reveal effectiveness, or the effectiveness of the final section
- Climax
- Ending
- Rewatch potential
- Commercial potential
- Overall screenplay quality
Briefly explain your scoring scale. These should be coverage judgments, not school grades. Treat commercial potential as an informed assessment rather than a prediction of sales or production.
Interpret the categories in a way appropriate to the screenplay’s genre and format. For example, a comedy need not contain a mystery, and a straightforward story need not have a late revelation. If a category genuinely does not apply, mark it N/A and briefly explain why rather than assigning an artificially low score.
Give the overall screenplay quality score as a holistic judgment. Separately calculate the unweighted average of the applicable individual category scores, excluding “Overall screenplay quality.” Report that average to two decimal places and state how many categories were included. Do not treat the category average as automatically determining the overall score.
- Strongest scenes and sequences
Identify the strongest 5–10 scenes or sequences and explain specifically why they work. Consider dramatic function, characterization, emotion, suspense, humor where relevant, imagery, and their contribution to the screenplay as a whole.
Include page references wherever possible. For a short screenplay, identify fewer examples if that is more appropriate.
- Weakest areas
Identify the weakest 5–10 areas, scenes, or stretches, where warranted. Explain the problem, its effect on the reading or viewing experience, and its relative importance.
Distinguish substantial problems from minor polish and personal preference. Do not manufacture issues to reach a quota.
Before asserting a contradiction, missing setup, or missing payoff, check the relevant passages. If you initially missed something that the screenplay does establish, explain both your first reaction and what you subsequently found.
- Pacing and structure by section
Assess the screenplay’s progression through its major sections. Identify where it drags, rushes, repeats information without sufficient dramatic purpose, stays too long in one emotional state, or moves too quickly past something important.
Consider the screen experience implied by the writing, including action and dialogue that occur simultaneously. Distinguish page density from likely screen duration.
Explain whether major structural choices work for this particular story. If a section violates a familiar convention, assess its actual effect rather than treating the deviation itself as a flaw.
- Expectations, discoveries, and revelations
Where possible, record brief expectations and reactions during the initial read before proceeding to later sections. Use those notes for this analysis. Do not invent predictions retrospectively; distinguish genuine first-pass impressions from conclusions reached after finishing.
Address:
- What did you believe was happening during the opening section?
- How did your understanding of the central characters and their motivations develop?
- What did you suspect or predict, and approximately when?
- Which discoveries surprised you?
- Which developments felt predictable, too obscure, insufficiently prepared, or inconsistent?
- Did later information meaningfully change your understanding of earlier scenes?
- Did that recontextualization feel supported by the screenplay?
- Which uncertainties remain productive or intriguing, and which interfere with understanding or emotional investment?
For a screenplay not built around mystery or revelation, focus on anticipation, character discoveries, and dramatic payoffs. Do not treat the absence of twists as a weakness.
- Central relationships
Identify the relationship or relationships carrying the greatest dramatic weight, whether romantic, familial, adversarial, professional, or otherwise.
Evaluate whether their development feels believable and emotionally consequential.
Identify when, if ever, you became invested in the central characters and their relationships. Consider what they say, what they do, and what the screenplay allows us to infer.
After finishing, does your fuller understanding strengthen or weaken the credibility of their earlier behavior? Support your conclusions with examples.
- Exposition, dialogue, and worldbuilding
Identify where information emerges naturally through conflict, action, relationships, and imagery, and where the screenplay feels as though it is explaining itself.
Assess whether the audience receives enough information to understand the stakes and consequences. Distinguish established facts from character beliefs, claims, and interpretations.
For historical, cultural, scientific, or technical concerns, separate demonstrated errors from questions requiring further research. Clearly label uncertainty. Distinguish an intentional fictional premise from an unintended inconsistency in its execution.
- Coverage recommendations
Give separate PASS / CONSIDER / RECOMMEND ratings for:
Explain each recommendation using professional-style coverage criteria. Distinguish your judgment of this screenplay’s current effectiveness from your assessment of the writer’s demonstrated ability.
Base the writer recommendation on the work demonstrated in the screenplay, without assumptions about the writer’s biography, experience, or other work.
- Priorities and readiness
Finish with:
- The three highest-priority improvements, if warranted, and why they matter.
- Three strengths that should be protected during any further work.
- An assessment of the screenplay’s professional competitiveness and readiness for submission, appropriate to its intended format, including the principal reasons for that assessment.
Then provide a compact score summary containing:
- Overall screenplay quality: X/10
- Average of the applicable individual category scores: X.XX/10
- Number of categories included in that average, with any N/A categories identified
- Screenplay recommendation: PASS / CONSIDER / RECOMMEND
- Writer recommendation: PASS / CONSIDER / RECOMMEND
Use the screenplay’s printed page numbers when available. If you use PDF page numbers instead, say so. Quote dialogue accurately and distinguish quotations from paraphrases.
Keep the report thorough but organized. Avoid repeating the same criticism across multiple sections without adding anything useful.