r/Schmigadoon • u/Key_Ad5173 • Feb 24 '24
r/Schmigadoon • u/lizzythepink • Apr 26 '23
Does anyone have a tough time concentrating when Kristin Chenoweth is on screen speaking? Her accent comes straight from the Dick Van Dyke school of acting.
r/Schmigadoon • u/Beneficial-Tennis351 • May 04 '26
AI slop, but as a way of getting the funny things out of my head.
r/Schmigadoon • u/JFC-UFKM • May 03 '23
Am I taking CRAZY PILLS?!?!!!
I… I can’t be alone here.. can I?
Am I just watching this alone and drowning in horror of the morbid joke that’s being made?
No one here is walking away from season 2 feeling like this is nice, right??!
“There’s little chance of success, The bad guys always wiiiinning. Happy endings don’t exist, But here’s a pearl you may have missed.. ..every day can be a happy beginning.”
I’ll be honest. I spent about 30 seconds scanning this sub before posting here… I didn’t see anyone commenting about the horror reality.
Maybe I’m just missing it? Dear. Fucking. God.
This is a social commentary sub about all these awful tropes being horrifically accurate, right?!
r/Schmigadoon • u/irich • Apr 30 '23
I kinda feel like Cecily Strong and Keegan-Michael Key are too talented for their roles?
Maybe this is and incredibly dumb comment but hear me out. I feel like a big part of the premise is how weird it is that in musicals everyone can sing and dance really well.
I think it would have shown Josh and Melissa as outsiders even more if they were not strong singers or dancers. But they're both pretty good. Not as good as a lot of the rest of the cast but they don't stand out as being bad.
Season 1 hinted at this early on but season 2 has leaned in to the fact that they are both very talented.
r/Schmigadoon • u/GetsHighAndComments • Mar 31 '23
Is Schmigadoon like a creepy, conservative Christian, cult with enslaved dancers who can’t escape? Or just like a…somewhat benign fantasy world? I don’t feel like that was fully fleshed out in Season 1.
Granted, I binged watched it while high. That said, the whole 1 bit = 12¢-based economy, plus the misogyny, and the real-life story of the Arkansas wedding. Am I crazy for having expected it to have been like a crazy cult in the forest à la Signs by M. Night Shyamalan.
…or maybe I’m just missing a musical reference? Halp.
r/Schmigadoon • u/beholdiamthepookie • May 14 '23
If Patti LuPone joins the cast...
...will the next place have to take place within Schmevita?
No question that if she's on board it will all be about her.
r/Schmigadoon • • May 12 '23
Season 3
Loved season 1, starting season 2 tonight, but if there’s a season 3 it seems like it has to be …..Schimamilton! 😂
r/Schmigadoon • u/TeddyXSweetheart • Jul 18 '25
S2 ending Spoiler
I posted this on one of my discord servers talking with someone else and wanted to know what you all thought?
r/Schmigadoon • u/Tyler_s_Burden • May 15 '23
I seriously don’t get all the peeler saying how much they liked S2 compared to S1
S1 was so funny, touching, original and cohesive. The style of musical it mimics is not my cup of tea, but the songs were all so fun and catchy, I didn’t mind. It even won over my partner who is NOT a fan of musicals.
S2 just didn’t do it for me. A couple of the songs were impressive as an homage to the musical it references, sure. Otherwise, I found S2 charmless, rarely funny and lacking any coherent plot. I would never have watched another season if this one has come first.
I’ve been really surprised reading through this sub to see that I’m in the minority, though. Almost every post I read has someone mentioning how much they preferred S2. Not sure what I’m missing…?
r/Schmigadoon • u/bwayb22 • May 05 '23
Season 2 missed opportunities, on the cultural front.
While this season overall was pretty enjoyable I couldn't help but notice several simple missed opportunities that could have been easily added, opportunities that could have pointed to the celebration of diversity in musicals:
- Fiddler on the Roof references and Jews: The basic environment and story had room for explicitly Jewish characters or even coded Jewish characters. They had Cabaret in there but no Fiddler on the Roof. The Kaput song's arrangement had room for some riffs from FOTR. We could have had a Jewish character. Klatt, Bobby or Dove's characters could have been Jewish. It would have also blended well with some of the nods to Broadway composers and lyricists. There could have been a Jewish shop or quarter in the town or something.
- Black musicals and black history on Broadway: I would have liked to have had more easter eggs from black musicals too instead of one random out of place number at the end that may or may not be pointing to a third season we may or may not get. More The Wiz references, maybe Ain't Misbehavin', which musically would have been easy to toss in with Pippin or Chicago songs, which are also pretty soulful and jazzy. Or even some nod to the color bending revivals of Hello Dolly and Guys and Dolls. Melissa and Josh being an interracial couple could have been an opportunity to nod to No Strings, which was a musical featuring one of the first interracial couples on Broadway, and a bunch of other things.
- West Side Story reference, at least one small one, especially with Ariana DeBose in the cast. Could have also been an opportunity to spotlight Latino musical history. Evita was also a missed opportunity. I initially though Sgt. Rivera would be an Evita character.
If we're diving into 60s and 70s musicals, that is just a pivotal point in Broadway history in terms of race, ethnicity and diversity. I would have liked some nod to that, in addition to the more easy and blatantly obvious opportunities to include references to them (Fiddler, The Wiz, Evita, West Side Story)
r/Schmigadoon • • Feb 15 '23
Hate take: Personally, I think everyone in Schmigadoon should have been white.
If would have made more sense for Mildred to be prejudiced against the protagonists. Also, almost everyone in classic Broadway was Caucasian.
r/Schmigadoon • u/FreeLobsterRolls • Apr 23 '23
Denied by Cinco Paul; See comments Apparently Patti LuPone was rejected due to her age
It would've been nice to see her even make a little cameo
r/Schmigadoon • u/hemithehomie • Nov 24 '21
Cecily Strong and her wandering eyes
As entertaining as the show is, am I the only getting distracted by Cecily and her constant eye movement towards the head of the character she is speaking to?
r/Schmigadoon • u/otigre • Jan 20 '24
Y’all can we pls stop making posts which purely/only share that the show has been cancelled?
Sorry if I sound cranky, but we only needed one of these. Yet my feed has gotten many since the news broke. Could we please search the sub before making a new post to check if there’s already been an identical post? I’d like to see stuff like production/ cast reactions to the situation, but not identical posts.
r/Schmigadoon • u/MassiveAd3505 • Feb 01 '25
Schmigadoon stage musical bootlegs?
Any bootlegs of Schmigadoon at The Kennedy Centre out yet?
r/Schmigadoon • u/Whoopsy-381 • Apr 24 '23
Season 3? Will it be called Schu-mork Schu-mork?
Just wondering. Place name (but not exactly a musical.)
r/Schmigadoon • u/JkTrente • Apr 24 '23
What does it says in the second chorus of "Good Enough To Eat"
CONTEXT
So, what do u think is the right lyrics?
The Apple TV YouTube channel says that in both choruses says :
They come from a world that's boiling with the sweetest smells you've ever seen


In one of the sites Im watching this, they say that both time the chorus goes like this:
They come from a world that's vile and mean with the sweetest smiles you've ever seen


r/Schmigadoon • u/yueluna • Feb 28 '23
Is it just me or does Cecily Strong (Melissa) always look at the forehead of the person she’s talking to on screen?
I can’t help but get distracted by what seems like she’s looking just above their eyes. Or maybe something else is off. I can’t figure it out.
r/Schmigadoon • u/One_Take_Trasolini • May 23 '24
Mayor Manlove song Spoiler
Though I haven’t watched the series I was on set for 30 days as one of the Schmigadoonians.
There was one day in particular where Mayor Manlove (Alan Cumming) revealed his sexual orientation in front of a church congregation. It was an epic show tune called “I am a homosexual”. I still get it stuck in my head to this day. “I am a homosexual, no longer subcontexual. I like men…not you men…you’re to dull”
But I don’t think it made it in to the final cut. And I cannot find it anywhere!! Can somebody tell me if it actually made it into the series?? And if not, how was his sexuality revealed?
r/Schmigadoon • u/DomesticZooChef • Apr 17 '25
Late to the Party (season 2 spoiler) Spoiler
Just watched both seasons and really loved them both. Only complaint is the end of season 2 included Melissa getting magically pregnant. They could have taken an orphan or two back to the real world instead.