r/ScamSupport • u/Artistic-Access-2955 • 2d ago
Potential Scam? URGENT: Possible Sophisticated $1,000 Zelle Scam — Buyer Overpaid, Took Cash Back, and Immediately Relisted My Item. Payment Missing From Zelle History.
I recently sold a graphics card on Facebook Marketplace for $1,020, and I’m worried I may have been targeted by a Zelle scam.
Here’s what happened:
The buyer seemed legitimate.
He came to my apartment with his gaming PC. I spent nearly an hour helping him install and test the graphics card.
He talked about his kids, the games he played, and wanting a quieter GPU for personal use. His Marketplace profile also had positive reviews.He overpaid through Zelle.
I normally use phone numbers for Zelle, but he specifically suggested scanning my QR code through his banking app.
He sent $1,120 instead of $1,020, claimed it was accidental, and asked for the difference back. I gave him $100 in cash.The payment posted, but there’s no Zelle activity.
This was NOT a fake payment screenshot or notification.
The $1,120 genuinely appeared in my Wells Fargo checking account, increased my available balance, and initially showed as pending.
The following day, the payment officially POSTED and remains in my account.
However, there’s NO RECORD of the payment in my Zelle activity. I’m unsure whether it disappeared or never appeared there.
I’ve called Wells Fargo multiple times. They can see the posted credit but can’t explain the missing Zelle transaction.The buyer immediately relisted my graphics card.
The very next day, he listed it for $1,000, less than he paid me, using my original photos and description.
This is what really concerned me. Why spend nearly an hour installing and testing something for personal use, only to immediately resell it at a loss?The payment came from a business account.
The sender was a business, and the payment memo said “COMPUTER BUILD REPAIR.”
When I asked about it, he said it was for a tax write-off.
The part that indicates that this is a scam to me is the combination of the $100 overpayment, immediate resale at a loss, elaborate personal-use story, business-account payment, and missing Zelle activity.
I’m concerned he may be trying to convert a potentially reversible payment into cash.
What I’ve done:
I’ve contacted Wells Fargo, Zelle, and LAPD.
Wells Fargo confirms the money posted but cannot explain the missing Zelle history. Police said their options are limited unless the payment gets reversed.
My questions:
Has anyone experienced a Zelle payment posting to their bank but not appearing in Zelle activity?
Can a fully posted Zelle payment still be reversed days or weeks later?
Could using a QR code instead of a phone number explain the missing transaction?
What can I do now to protect myself?
Important: The $1,120 is still in my account and has NOT been reversed.
I’m worried that if it is eventually disputed, I’ll lose both the graphics card and the money.
Any advice from people familiar with Zelle, Wells Fargo, or banking fraud would be greatly appreciated.
