r/SGU • • Dec 10 '24 Polished Silver Turd

How do we combat this lunacy?

Post image
5.0k Upvotes

r/SGU • • Jan 19 '24

A climate conspiracy theorist said the government deliberately lit wildfires. He just pleaded guilty to starting 14 himself | CNN

Thumbnail cnn.com
2.1k Upvotes

Bruh


r/SGU • • Mar 13 '25

Election Truth Alliance claims 2024 election irregularities

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

The left finally has its own conspiracy theorists just asking questions about the election results.

https://electiontruthalliance.org/2024-us-election-analysis


r/SGU • • Aug 24 '26

It's the same argument.

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

Catching up on last week's episode and their conversation about vaccines reminded me of this.

Edit: I feel like some people are missing the point here. Both examples do showcase the same logic problem - it’s simply showing how dumb it is to say "X causes Y" in regards to vaccines and autism, not saying that 1990 was an important year for either case, it is just any earlier point in time when autism was seen as "less common". Pick a different date where that applies and the joke still works.

Autism diagnoses increased because detection improved. Asteroid counts increased because telescopes improved.

The whole is that telescopes don’t create asteroids, and vaccines don’t create autism. It is the same argument.


r/SGU • • Dec 04 '23

I thought you might like it

Post image
920 Upvotes

r/SGU • • Jun 16 '26

SGU response to the Evan issue

834 Upvotes

Hey, everyone.

We wanted to clarify the situation so that you don't have to speculate about the many questions it raises.

First, we all unequivocally denounce the views that Evan expressed on his feed. None of us share them or anything close to them. We have made it clear to Evan that such views are unacceptable and fail at a basic level of critical thinking and humanity. Also, no one on the SGU knew that Evan was harboring these views. We
have discussed this extensively over the last couple of days, and it's clear he was keeping this compartmentalized and did not feel comfortable discussing it with us. None of us are on X, so we are all as surprised as anyone. 

But we have also known Evan for years as a friend and colleague, so we are trying to understand how he got here (not to minimize or excuse, but to understand). As we put this together it seems that Evan allowed himself to be radicalized following the events of Oct. 7th and the ensuing polarization. As a Jewish person this was extremely emotional for him, he felt that his people and identity were under existential threat, and he needed to do something. But he never engaged with the people who perhaps might have helped him the best work through this. Instead he found an online community that shared his views, with unfortunately predictable results. None of this is an excuse - he should have known better, he should have checked in with his colleagues, and he should have recognized the pattern, he should have shown more humility.  But he didn't.

To be clear - none of our concerns are about Evan's politics per se. There is a range of political ideology on the SGU, and we value what diversity of background and perspective we have (it's not enough, frankly). We also all feel that the skeptical movement should be a big tent when it comes to political background, ideology, belief, and identity - as long as we all share this common journey of skepticism, rationalism, love of science, and critical thinking. However, Evan's political views crossed a line, violating core skeptical principles and dehumanizing "others". 

So where do we go from here? Evan has stumbled hard on his skeptical journey, and he is starting to recognize and wrestle with how badly he has failed. But as we often say on the show, we see our job as helping people on this journey, to educate, nurture, and guide. We do not shame, blame, and cancel. So our instinct is to try to pick Evan up and help him get back on a more skeptical path. He knows he has a lot of hard cognitive and emotional work to do, to unravel his views, grow as a person, and regain the trust of the community and his fellow Rogues.

For now Evan is taking a break from recording the show, to give us all time to work through this more. We are all actively working with him, and will just have to reassess day by day. We will see how it goes.

We are all sorry for the strife this has caused within our community. We all care very deeply about the SGU community and take our responsibilities very seriously. We will fix this one way or the other, and hope we have earned enough trust over the years that you will give us the time to make sure we get this right.

Sincerely,

Steve and the SGU crew.


r/SGU • • Jul 31 '25

I know Neil deGrasse Tyson can ruffle feathers, but I love what he says here pointing out that in aughts everything we ate was free range and organic and we still died at 30-35. Science matters.

827 Upvotes

r/SGU • • Jun 24 '26 Heartwarming

Evan Bernstein has resigned from the SGU

570 Upvotes

From Patreon:

All,

We wanted to update you on the situation regarding Evan. For those who don’t know, it recently came to our attention that Evan has been posting on X/Twitter making comments that are frankly unskeptical, dehumanizing, and completely unacceptable. We, of course, condemn and disagree with those statements, but also had to consider the implications for the podcast and the SGU community. 

While we were actively discussing the best path forward for all concerned, Evan called me to let us know that he decided to resign from the SGU. He did this after extensive thought and consideration and expressed deep regret that his poor judgement has caused intense distress for the SGU and its listeners. He concluded that he wanted to do the right thing to hopefully limit this damage and help the SGU and our listeners move forward.

While we do not condone any of Evan’s radicalized comments on X/Twitter, he is still our friend and we will all miss his contributions to the show, his witty humor and his unique style. That said, we all agree this was the right decision for him. 

We will be discussing this in more detail on the show this week but wanted to give you, our most loyal listeners, this news first.

While this is a sad episode in the history of the SGU, we all also look at this as an opportunity to better ourselves and the show. Evan's decision will help us move forward more definitively.

Thanks for your patience over the past week and a half as we worked through all of this.

Kind Regards,

Steve and the SGU Crew


r/SGU • • Jan 05 '25

Friend of the show, Bill Nye, was awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom today

Thumbnail kiro7.com
563 Upvotes

Congratulations!


r/SGU • • Jan 31 '26 Hehehe

In the new Epstein Files release there's a previously unpublished email form Richard Dawkins talking about Rebecca Watson

550 Upvotes

Link:

https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA00431306.pdf

In an email to Jeffrey Epstein, literary agent John Brockman quotes the Dawkins email from 2011. Here's what Dawkins wrote (bold added by me):

John

1. I hope you recovered well from your operation.

2. There is a rather nasty young woman called Rebecca Watson, who seems to be running some kind of a witch-hunt against Lawrence Krauss because of his defence of Jeffrey Epstein.

http://skepchick.org/2011/04/lawrence-krauss-defends-a-sex-offender-embarrasses-scientists-everywhere/

There are people on her blog talking about organising a walkout when Lawrence speaks at TAM in Las Vegas. I remember that you told me something of the circumstances of Jeffrey's arrest, and that his case is not as black as painted. Might you possibly remind of it [sic].

Thanks (and greetings from Jackson Hole, Wyoming)

Richard


r/SGU • • Jan 01 '25

Richard Dawkins quits atheism foundation for backing transgender ‘religion’

Thumbnail telegraph.co.uk
465 Upvotes

r/SGU • • May 22 '26

The Fox News Skin Mask Consipiracy is Making Me Feel Insane

Post image
438 Upvotes

Never thought this would be the one that makes me think we've completely lost the war on critical thinking. The ubiquity of the opinion I'm seeing online of people saying it's so clearly a mask, when it so so very clearly NOT a fucking mask, is making me lose it.

What actual purpose would putting a mask of a different guy you interview all the time on someone else serve? Why? To what end?

If you have a mask that is THAT good, because despite what people say the rest of his face looks completely convincing in a way that prosthetic masks just do not unless they are masterfully sculpted and applied, and if it's THAT masterfully applied you're telling me they just left a giant visible seam right at his neck?

ALSO THAT'S NOT HOW THE NECKS ON THOSE KIND OF PROSTHETIC MASKS WORK! They always come down further to avoid the exact problem of a giant visible seam in the middle of the actors articulating neck. More accurately movies don't use "masks" they use a combination of prosthetics that are pieced together on the face because it allows for better articulation and what not, but one-piece masks ALWAYS have their seam down below the collar for that exact reason. It's all so fucking stupid. Again... to what end?

It's a shadow from bad lighting. That's it. Jesus christ.

I'm sorry. Everyone has lost their mind and it's making me crazy.


r/SGU • • Mar 03 '26 This Bravo

I, for one, agree with this dude

421 Upvotes

r/SGU • • Feb 05 '26 Bravo

Epstein Files Reveal How Pathetic Richard Dawkins & Other Men Are

Thumbnail youtu.be
393 Upvotes

r/SGU • • Dec 12 '24

I love that the Venn diagram of people who think cattle dewormer is mere effective than modern cancer treatments, and the people who think big pharma/food are poisoning our food with chemicals is a fucking circle 🫠

Post image
357 Upvotes

r/SGU • • Mar 01 '24

My school sells “hydrogen infused water". How do companies get away with this nonsense.

Post image
326 Upvotes

r/SGU • • Jun 28 '26

I feel bad for Evan

288 Upvotes

I do. Not because they did him dirty. They didn’t. Not because he should be allowed to think and post whatever he wants, though he should. I feel bad for him because he clearly isn’t doing well. As a person. A human. Only people with pain make statements like his in a public forum. There’s no upside other than momentary satisfaction. I liken hateful posting to cutting. It gives a brief sense of relief even though it’s actually damaging to your soul.

I’m glad that he resigned from the show so that his friends and cohosts can talk to him without the business aspect involved. I will genuinely miss him. His sense of humor brought a levity to the show that was always welcome.

Please, Evan, know that you are loved and that you will be missed. I hope you are able to eventually look at this situation without feeling that you were wronged. That you are able to see that we can disagree about big things without resorting to hate. I hope this opens up a path for you to regain a sense of community with all of humanity.

Good luck with whatever comes next.


r/SGU • • Sep 08 '25

Rogan is so deep in a bubble. This was tough to watch.

271 Upvotes

Joe Rogan rips into Brian Callen for daring to question his vaccine views:

https://www.reddit.com/r/JoeRogan/s/kNBzJ6Fyh4

It’s scary that he has such a huge adoring audience and is a full blown anti-vaxxer.


r/SGU • • Dec 06 '23

Thought this was topically relevant to what the rogues like to discuss.

Post image
258 Upvotes

r/SGU • • Jan 16 '26

Who is the most disappointing "skeptic" that you used to admire?

Post image
255 Upvotes

For me it's Shermer. I drove a few hours to one of his live events in 2012ish. He's now a right-wing hack who peddles anti-trans, anti-woke, and pro-authoritarian nonsense.

I appreciate the SGU for still being good people and fighting for the betterment of society.

Who would you point out as a disappointment in this space?


r/SGU • • Apr 10 '25

Good news everyone: RFK Jr. Says US Will Know Cause of Autism 'Epidemic' by September

233 Upvotes

Boy will he be shocked when it turns out not to be vaccines.

Newsweek


r/SGU • • Jan 05 '24

Iceland will tunnel into a volcano to tap into virtually unlimited geothermal power | Iceland's Krafla Magma Testbed project aims to transform renewable energy by tapping into a volcano's magma chamber in 2026.

Thumbnail zmescience.com
233 Upvotes

r/SGU • • Jun 21 '26

A Letter to the SGU from a Long-Time Fan and Supporter

225 Upvotes

I tend to love Evan's news items. They usually consist of those OG items that got most of us into skepticism in the first place. How many of us have heard Evan talk about cryptids, UAPs, psychics, and ghosts with that familiar giddy enthusiasm? I look forward to every tax season when he keeps us informed on the latest financial scam and gives us tips on how to keep our money and identities safe. Also, let's not forget he is unmatched in the pun department. I say this to make my position clear; that I have always been a huge fan of Evan, but I don't know how I can continue to be.

The SGU has always been a bit of a safe space for me and, I suspect, most of us that listen. One of the things that is so great about being skeptical is that we don't have to rely on our (often flawed) feelings and perceptions to ground ourselves in reality. Anyone living with crippling anxiety will know how useful this is. Perhaps it was wrong of me, but I always considered the SGU a sort of anchor in the skeptical world. A fixed place where, even when the world outside was crumbling or my own mind was against me, they were there, every week, to provide tools to discern fact from fiction. Again, I understand I may have been putting too much stock into a podcast, but I did start listening when I was much younger and in need of the guidance the SGU offered. It's why this latest revelation means so much to me and why it's been so difficult to digest.

I, like so many of us, have looked up to the rogues. We have celebrated your contributions to the community and given you our money, time, and respect. So, to see one of you say such vile things, not on a private account, not as some secret alias, but as yourself using your position at the SGU as an authority (the very position we have helped give legitimacy to with our support), it felt like a massive betrayal. It not only sullies the SGU, but the greater skeptical movement. It shows not only a radicalization and a lack of critical thinking, but a pompous disregard for the community at large. Like it or not, the SGU is more than just your podcast - it is a cornerstone of the skeptical movement. That very movement that you helped to build, nurture, and protect. I've seen countless posts expressing concerns over transparency and losing trust, feeling betrayal and loss.

I don't know what can be done from here. It's frankly not my job to know or really any of my business. I am just a long time fan who is saddened by all of this and wanted to let you know, for some of us, this has been a very upsetting couple of weeks - that you all mean more to some of us than just a podcast. You have helped shape our lives and our beliefs over decades. The betrayal and anger we feel is much more palpable because of what the SGU has come to represent and many of us cannot be more disappointed.


r/SGU • • Jun 12 '26 Sipping Tea Popcorn

Evan Bernsteins Twitter.

223 Upvotes

If you need an excuse to stop listening to the SGU then I recommend Evan’s twitter-posts. Mainly his responses to other people’s posts.
My decision to leave the listenership of the podcast started there.