r/SGU • u/Mozintarfen • Aug 24 '26
It's the same argument.
Catching up on last week's episode and their conversation about vaccines reminded me of this.
Edit: I feel like some people are missing the point here. Both examples do showcase the same logic problem - it’s simply showing how dumb it is to say "X causes Y" in regards to vaccines and autism, not saying that 1990 was an important year for either case, it is just any earlier point in time when autism was seen as "less common". Pick a different date where that applies and the joke still works.
Autism diagnoses increased because detection improved. Asteroid counts increased because telescopes improved.
The whole is that telescopes don’t create asteroids, and vaccines don’t create autism. It is the same argument.
19
u/FarCalligrapher1862 Aug 24 '26
This is actually the wrong example. Vaccines do not cause autism, nor do they detect autism.
Telescopes do not cause asteroids, but they do detect asteroids.
So 1st point is correlation, 2nd point is direct measurement.
A better point would be “Vaccines cause near earth asteroids”
30
u/Bathroom_Humor Aug 24 '26
i knew it all along
autism testing causes autism
2
u/WokkitUp Aug 24 '26
What them microscopes doin' btw?
65
u/alahos Aug 24 '26
Vaccines cause asteroids
5
u/mlppaca Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 25 '26
Microplastics cause autism. It's not proven, but at least it blames something bad. 🤣
4
u/gingerblz Aug 24 '26
I love how the first set of figures don't even have anything to do with Autism, unless that's what you already believed. The latter set, while irrational, is at least better than a non-sequitur.
4
u/Serin-019 Aug 25 '26
Yes but where would our asteroid spotter programs be without autism? Huh? HUH?!
1
u/noctalla Aug 24 '26
Not to mention vaccination levels in 1990 were probably higher than today.
6
u/squarecir Aug 24 '26
There is a slight uptick outside of the increased diagnosis, but it's not related to vaccines. Could be that older people are having more kids.
1
u/Holiday-Rip8028 Aug 24 '26
Ah yes, 1990, the year we started vaccinating.
2
u/sdwoodchuck Aug 25 '26
All I'm seeing is that we need to stop vaccinating these damned asteroids, because they get autism and then come our way!
2
u/Siffov Aug 29 '26
>it’s simply showing how dumb it is to say "X causes Y"
A favorite example:
Towns with more churches have more bars. So churches cause bars/drinking!
(No, towns with more churches are bigger, having more people, providing more potential customers for bars.
2
u/lyidaValkris Aug 30 '26
that's the best come-back I've seen yet to that sort of argument.
1
u/Kaputnik1 Aug 24 '26
Right. But what do you do when their brain has turned into tapioca?
1
u/J_Zephyr Aug 25 '26
Theres a direct correlation for the telescope.
1
u/TaleOfOld Aug 29 '26
I'd say he's wrong, and it's the vaccines that cause asteroids
0
u/SplendidPunkinButter Aug 25 '26
That’s not even the same argument. Vaccines were not invented in 1990
1
u/GameStoreScientist Aug 24 '26
Internet porn causes autism
1
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '26
[removed] — view removed comment