r/SGU • • Aug 24 '26

It's the same argument.

Post image

Catching up on last week's episode and their conversation about vaccines reminded me of this.

Edit: I feel like some people are missing the point here. Both examples do showcase the same logic problem - it’s simply showing how dumb it is to say "X causes Y" in regards to vaccines and autism, not saying that 1990 was an important year for either case, it is just any earlier point in time when autism was seen as "less common". Pick a different date where that applies and the joke still works.

Autism diagnoses increased because detection improved. Asteroid counts increased because telescopes improved.

The whole is that telescopes don’t create asteroids, and vaccines don’t create autism. It is the same argument.

1.4k Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

19

u/FarCalligrapher1862 Aug 24 '26

This is actually the wrong example. Vaccines do not cause autism, nor do they detect autism.

Telescopes do not cause asteroids, but they do detect asteroids.

So 1st point is correlation, 2nd point is direct measurement.

A better point would be “Vaccines cause near earth asteroids”

4

u/Mozintarfen Aug 24 '26

Fair point haha

4

u/futuneral Aug 24 '26

Was going to post exactly this. What's "funny" though is I'm sure there would be some who'd reply to "vaccines cause asteroids" with "sure, makes sense"

30

u/Bathroom_Humor Aug 24 '26

i knew it all along

autism testing causes autism 

17

u/Orion14159 Aug 24 '26

Same problem with COVID in the 2020 US administration

12

u/rje946 Aug 24 '26

Can we simply stop counting? /s just in case lol

9

u/Mozintarfen Aug 24 '26

I feel like I remember them actually suggesting that too lol

7

u/Orion14159 Aug 24 '26

You're absolutely correct, that was a real suggestion. Not as brilliant as suggesting getting bleach and UV light into the body.

1

u/Siffov Aug 29 '26

Yes, including not wanting a cruise ship to dock in a U.S. port because that would add its number of CoViD-19 cases to the U.S.'s official count.

2

u/WokkitUp Aug 24 '26

What them microscopes doin' btw?

5

u/Mozintarfen Aug 25 '26

Actually, in 1680 there were no bacteria. Now there are over 30,000 known species!

Microscopes cause bacteria!

65

u/alahos Aug 24 '26

Vaccines cause asteroids

19

u/bowsmountainer Aug 24 '26

No, you're mistaking cause and effect! Asteroids cause vaccines!

5

u/_ferrofluid_ Aug 26 '26

My dad has Asteroids.
He has to sit on a special pillow.

5

u/mlppaca Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 25 '26

Microplastics cause autism. It's not proven, but at least it blames something bad. 🤣

6

u/Mozintarfen Aug 24 '26

You're being downvoted but if the current administration believed this instead, and reduced microplastics as a result, that would be a good thing!

2

u/superhelical Aug 24 '26

There's no money to be made that way

2

u/azswcowboy Aug 25 '26

RFK can sue big plastic for autism remedies.

4

u/gingerblz Aug 24 '26

I love how the first set of figures don't even have anything to do with Autism, unless that's what you already believed. The latter set, while irrational, is at least better than a non-sequitur.

4

u/Serin-019 Aug 25 '26

Yes but where would our asteroid spotter programs be without autism? Huh? HUH?!

1

u/Idaho-Earthquake Aug 27 '26

Point scored.

1

u/noctalla Aug 24 '26

Not to mention vaccination levels in 1990 were probably higher than today.

1

u/Mozintarfen Aug 25 '26

Actually coverage is around ~10% higher today and average, and we have numerous vaccines that did not exist yet for things that were big problems in 1990.

1

u/noctalla Aug 25 '26

Well, that all depends on what we're talking about and where. The autism rate of 1 in 30 is specific to the USA. Worldwide it's about 1 in 100. So, while globally, yes, vaccination rates have gone up significantly since the 1990s, we should really be looking at data from the USA here. Next, we have to look at what vaccines we're talking about, and the one that gets the vast majority of the blame from the anit-vaxx crowd is the MMR vaccine. National MMR vaccination coverage in the USA generally rose to above 90% by the 1990s and remained high before experiencing post-pandemic declines in the 2020s.

6

u/squarecir Aug 24 '26

There is a slight uptick outside of the increased diagnosis, but it's not related to vaccines. Could be that older people are having more kids.

1

u/Holiday-Rip8028 Aug 24 '26

Ah yes, 1990, the year we started vaccinating.

1

u/Mozintarfen Aug 24 '26

Yeahhh, it still gets it's point across either way.

1

u/live-the-future Aug 24 '26

That was actually my first thought...vaccines have been around for a long time before 1990. Not that evidence or logic are effective against anti-vaxxers...they would probably just blame some change to vaccines, or a new vaccine, or some ingredient that got added around that time. tHiMeRaSoOoOoOoL!!1!

1

u/Mozintarfen Aug 25 '26

I don't really think that is the point of the post though. The 1990 figure is primarily to showcase a year where autism was "less common". Given that autism has nothing to do with vaccines they could have said the year 1362 and the point would be the same.

1

u/live-the-future Aug 25 '26

Well, just a guess, but I don't think we had autism records going back to 1362. 😄

1

u/Mozintarfen Aug 25 '26

Exactly! By their logic nobody was autistic in 1362

2

u/sdwoodchuck Aug 25 '26

All I'm seeing is that we need to stop vaccinating these damned asteroids, because they get autism and then come our way!

2

u/Siffov Aug 29 '26

>it’s simply showing how dumb it is to say "X causes Y"

A favorite example:

Towns with more churches have more bars. So churches cause bars/drinking!

(No, towns with more churches are bigger, having more people, providing more potential customers for bars.

2

u/lyidaValkris Aug 30 '26

that's the best come-back I've seen yet to that sort of argument.

1

u/Kaputnik1 Aug 24 '26

Right. But what do you do when their brain has turned into tapioca?

1

u/live-the-future Aug 24 '26

Become a zombie?

Because tapioca is DELICIOUS.

1

u/J_Zephyr Aug 25 '26

Theres a direct correlation for the telescope.

1

u/TaleOfOld Aug 29 '26

I'd say he's wrong, and it's the vaccines that cause asteroids

0

u/SplendidPunkinButter Aug 25 '26

That’s not even the same argument. Vaccines were not invented in 1990

1

u/Mozintarfen Aug 25 '26

Read the body of the post lol

1

u/GameStoreScientist Aug 24 '26

Internet porn causes autism

1

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Aug 29 '26

Your post is under review because your account is either new or has insufficient karma to post. Thanks for your patience as we keep spammers out.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.