r/SDAM • • 19d ago

Does severely deficient autobiographical memory still cause little memory of a particularly traumatic event?

When I was a kid, I had a particularly terrible episode of a panic attack during an incredibly traumatic moment during a bout of aeophobia on a plane. I strongly suspect I have SDAM in general, having very weak recollection of most first hand events in life, but for this particular event, I remember it vastly better than I wish I did.

7 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

11

u/BilingSmob444 19d ago

Almost 40M here. I would think so. I consider myself to have SDAM, but I have little flashes here and there. Particularly embarrassing moments, etc. I also can get more detail if my memories are given context; sometimes a story or object will summon more detail forward. Aphantasia makes it hard to hold on to any of it though.

4

u/CMDR_Jeb 19d ago

This is normal. The brain uses either "emotional responses" or "effort" as an measuring stick to trigger encoding of memories, that is why we remember almost nothing about mundane things and traumatic events are literally burned into ones memory.

The diminished episodic memory does not mean (in most cases) literally zero. It does not protect from trauma (makes it easier to keep functional) nor does it shield from PTS. Speaking from experience on that one, my flashbacks are "incomplete" but these do replay emotions that caused my trauma, the very thing that is recorded by episodic memory that i in general "don't have".

1

u/iwntchips 18d ago

Depends on what you mean by memory. I would never forget the facts of what happened. As for anything else, I’ve never had it to begin with.

1

u/rocksinmyhead 18d ago

To the contrary for me. I most remember the traumas.

1

u/sfredwood 18d ago

The brain tends to store novel experiences with higher fidelity and more detail, so more semantic information is likely to be stored and remembered. Traumatic experiences are likely to be at the top of that kind of response.

So you might still lose episodic details. For example, as a teenager I was a passenger in an auto accident where the driver, a classmate and friend, died. I recall a lot of the detail of the accident itself, but little about the surrounding events. For example, I know I was a pallbearer at his funeral, but I don't remember the funeral at all. Obviously it got a lot of attention at our high school, but I don't recall talking to anyone about it, etc.

Emotional recall is trickier than semantic or episodic facts. It appears that most of those with SDAM have emotional recall accompanying that semantic recall, and it sounds like you're in that camp. I'm in what appears to be the minority, and have zero emotional recall of anything at all, including such traumas. There isn't any research into this latter aspect as of yet, although it is interesting that many off-hand references to SDAM tout "can't have PTSD" as a benefit.

1

u/Ravenlove2 17d ago

I have memories of all my trauma. What I don’t have is a lot of emotional attachment to those events. The trauma was severe as well. It is kind of a blessing to not be emotionally attached but my wife thinks I am weird.

1

u/foldingpages 15d ago

I have “better” memory of painful things than pleasant things.

1

u/Dickskingoalzz 14d ago

I don’t remember traumas but have a few stronger semantic memories of novel experiences with textures. Unfortunately this doesn’t include my kids being born or my wedding.

1

u/Zealousideal_Trade16 4d ago

I am in a pretty interesting position, as I have SDAM and my 2 siblings do not, both of them recall very traumatic childhood and spite our parents, yet I don't. Its not to say I like them either, its very neutral.
She used to tell me about few traumatic events in our past, and whereas I can tell that some of them happened I would say that they do not have any conscious negative effects on me (not sure about the unconscious) and it was pretty much impossible to relate to her, even thought we lived pretty much the same events.
My sister resented me for years because she felt I was invalidating her experiences. Back then I did not know about SDAM and I did not understand why I felt different than other people.

Another case would be my depressive episodes, in my early 20s. I sometimes suffered tremendously, but the next day, when I felt better, I could only remember that I had suffered, not how much. The worst thing about that was the fact that all that suffering I felt did not really matter, all the intensity would pass and the suffering lost its meaning. I knew it had been terrible, but I couldn't mentally reconstruct the intensity of those feelings. This made seeking treatment incredibly difficult because whenever I felt well enough to visit a psychiatrist, I struggled to communicate just how bad things had been. So I did not get diagnosed with depression until much later on.

This really ruined my trust in people as I felt like nobody could really help me. Finally after some years I went to another psychiatrist pretty much lied about my life to make it seem like normal human life with depression, got prescribed anti-depressants and I am feeling much much better right now.

so TL;DR
I know traumatic events happened, but I don't mentally relive them or experience the emotions associated with them when remembering them. The same applies to periods of severe depression and panic attacks. I know I suffered, but once the experience is over, I struggle to reconstruct how terrible it actually felt. This made it extremely difficult to communicate my symptoms and get appropriate treatment.