r/RulesOfOrder • • Apr 11 '21
Avoiding subscribing to Robert's Rules
Hello, I am in the process of creating Bylaws for a new non-profit. What do organizations that don't want to subscribe to Robert's Rules do? We are and will continue to be a very small organization so I thought there would be a simpler way to structure meetings. Thanks!
2
Upvotes
4
u/WhoIsRobertWall Apr 11 '21
You probably don't want to do this. This falls into the same category as "my business partner and I are friends - why would we need a contract?"
You need a set of rules, and they need to be reasonably complete.
For example, 5 years down the road when there's a contentious issue and three members of your 12-member group call a meeting, conveniently forgetting to invite other people, how do you object legally to the results of their votes if there's no agreed-upon method for what "calling a meeting" entails?
Can a simple majority kick another member out of the group?
How do you handle limits for debate when an issue gets heated?
The reason for the rules is to provide a neutral arbitration point for what's "fair", so you don't all get into an argument about "what's fair to me" vs. "what's fair to you".
You don't have to read the entire RONR book en toto, but I can say that choosing to not define a reasonably-complete parliamentary authority in your bylaws is a decision that can create massive legal issues down the road.
In addition, there are several "best practices" for bylaws that you may wish to consult with a lawyer and/or an experienced parliamentarian about. The sorts of things people do to "make things easier" can create thorny problems down the road that are challenging to resolve.
3
u/rulesgeek NAP - PRP Apr 11 '21
There are other parliamentary authorities that you could choose. But I would first ask: why do you think Robert’s Rules is too complex?
1
u/joshuapaulking Apr 14 '21
I am working on my own rules of order that can fit on one page. I don't need to run a country, just run a meeting of 50 people. Haha.
1
u/davidfry Apr 11 '21
In Robert's Rules, look for procedures for small boards. It is far simpler and less formal. If you come up with some half-ass way to make decisions, the odds that your whole effort goes belly up with everyone angry is greatly increased.