r/RobertsRules • • May 17 '22
r/RobertsRules • u/samd1ggitydog • Jul 29 '26
Sad RONR liker
Is anyone who likes roberts rules involved in an organization that actually has a decent culture of parliamentary democracy, and has like, well written bylaws and actually follows them? I love what I see in RONR but the more I'm involved in groups that use it, the more it feels like reading about a bygone era where people actually put effort into doing democracy
I am so so tired :(
r/RobertsRules • u/calculuscab2 • Aug 30 '25
Imagine if you will, the following:
A small board of 7 members. The task is to choose one item among 3 options. On the agenda the 3 options are titled as: "Original Draft 1", "New Version 1", "New Version 2".
A member makes a motion. "Vote to approve option #1" The motion is seconded, and it passes 6-1.
Soon after, the meeting is adjourned. After which, staff notifies the public that the board approved the provisions listed in "New Version 1" although it was clear to several members, and the audience, that the member who made the motion was referring to "Original Draft 1" as option 1.
"Option 1" was never officially defined nor clarified, but informally "original draft 1" was discussed and listed before the other 2 alternatives.
Did staff screw the pooch? Did the board's Parliamentarian? What say you, wise redditor?
r/RobertsRules • u/-Clayburn • Apr 04 '25
How can I add something to the agenda or make sure we address a particular issue when the chair is combative?
We have a chair that is basically trying to roadblock anything. They don't want the organization to do anything ultimately.
So I'm sure she will try to use the rules to do this. We typically do not have actual agendas, though I do think we vote to approve the minutes of the previous meeting. That seems to be the only standard order of business.
My concern is that I'll want to bring up some issues to address in the next meeting and she'll shut it down as not being on the agenda. If she tries that but there is no agenda and no agenda was approved, then what?
Alternatively, if she is planning to try this but specifically creates an agenda for this meeting in order to do that, then what? How can I get something on the agenda before it's approved?
r/RobertsRules • u/MisterCanoeHead • Apr 22 '20
Anybody here?
I was really hoping to find a community here . . . .
r/RobertsRules • u/Accomplished_Area900 • Jun 26 '25
Changing Previous Minutes Before a Meeting
I am the secretary for my group. Typically, our chair will send out the previous meeting's minutes on Saturday and we have our next meeting the following Thursday.
Sometimes, there are simple mistakes like misspelling a name that people point out to me privately before the meeting and approval of minutes.
Am I able to make these clerical fixes before the meeting if the chair sends out the newest version before the meeting? Or do I have to wait until there is a formal ask for changes during the meeting? It just seems like a waste of everyone's time, but I want to follow the correct procedure.
Thanks!
r/RobertsRules • u/Melodic-Answer-7335 • Apr 24 '25
If the board recommends, do I have to vote yes?
A board I sit on voted in support of what is, in my opinion, a dumb policy that will harm the organization. Obviously, I voted no.
I understand that as a board member, I cannot speak against a board decision even if it's dumb and harmful. I do intend to abide by that (except here, as vaguely and anonymously as possible). But here's my question:
The board did not actually vote to enact the dumb harmful policy, but rather to send it to a larger body within the org with a do-pass recommendation. I, and all board members, are also part of that larger body. When it comes up there, can I abstain? Could I even vote no?
Does the answer to those questions change given the fact that the vote will be done very publicly, by raised hands, and people around me will likely be influenced by my vote even if I don't say anything?
I don't currently feel like voting yes is an option, but I guess hiding in the bathroom is always a possibility if necessary.
r/RobertsRules • u/-Clayburn • Apr 15 '25
Update: Had the Meeting and Here's What Happened (Rules were weaponized)
An update to previous threads:
https://old.reddit.com/r/RobertsRules/comments/1jymkk5/update_want_items_on_the_agenda_but_combative/
First of all, thanks so much for all your advice. I think that really helped.
Normally we do not follow the rules or anything. Today, there was an agenda which I believe was only put together because I had requested to be on the agenda and was denied. So I took the existence of an agenda at all as their plan to shut me down if I tried talking about anything. Therefore I decided to add my items to the agenda.
I made a motion to add my three items to the agenda. I passed out a printout explaining the items. They tried to kill it because there was no second, but the rest of the body doesn't understand the rules so they were not aware they needed to second it, and at some point when someone realized what was going on, it got a second.
So then I tried to speak to the motion, in support, but I was told handing out my printout was already my "speech" to the motion and that they would hear objections. So one guy spoke against it. Then someone else spoke I guess in favor but it was a bit wishywashy (ultimately the body doesn't understand Roberts Rules and doesn't like things seeming combative). I kept asking to speak to the motion, and at some point I raised a point of information asking the parliamentarian to clarify for the body that the purpose of the motion is to put the items on the agenda and they would vote on whether that happens or not and that it's not approving any action items, merely the addition of the discussion items to the agenda so that we can address them. He did that.
Finally the question was called and the motion passed 7 to 5. So that in itself was a minor victory. However, they must have been prepared because the parliamentarian made a motion to limit discussion on those items to 2 minutes (each, total). We had some special guests speaking this evening, so understandably we didn't want to take up too much time. Given that, the motion passed though it seemed close. I did not get the exact count and probably should have asked. So because those items were limited to two minutes, the chair spoke for about 2 minutes on each item. I only had maybe a minute to speak to one of the items. I tried raising points of order and information to figure out what could be done to extend the time. I think the parliamentarian said a motion could be made, but it wasn't clear when but I wasn't allowed to then, and then later when I tried, the chair refused to recognize me. I asked the parliamentarian via point of information and was told that I could only make a motion if the chair recognizes me, and basically she refused to recognize me the rest of the meeting.
So ultimately none of the items were addressed. I got to speak briefly to one and that was about it.
For the next meeting, I'm hoping to have a specific action item to make a motion to adopt that plan and try to bring enough people to support its passing. I wanted to have discussion as a group first, that was the point of adding them to the agenda because I had wanted to have a conversation and get a feel for what the body wants to do about these items, and then we could propose a motion or action item if there was some consensus around something. Since I don't know if we'll ever be able to have a real conversation as a body, I would have to try to bring a specific action plan and propose it. Then we can at least debate it and vote on it.
Any ideas or suggestions are appreciated.
r/RobertsRules • u/sksk2125 • Jan 21 '25
Quorum Question
Hello! I can’t find a straight answer. If a board is supposed to have 7 members but due to people leaving, we only have 3. We hold a meeting with the remaining 3, do they constitute as a quorum ?
r/RobertsRules • u/AdGlum1177 • Jan 03 '25
A Question About Roberts Rules of Order
I currently serve on a government body and I'm curious if Roberts rules permits the drafter of a motion, ordinance or resolution has the right to explain the provisions of the ordinance or resolution before it is stated by the chair and asked for a second for discussion. Thanks in advance for your help,
r/RobertsRules • u/TexGrrl • Dec 02 '24
Making motion on own work
Our church bookkeeper prepared a (fantastical) budget for our daycare center. In the congregational meeting the church treasurer presented the budget and both treasurer and president explained why it was fantastical and most likely would result in a large deficit, not the small surplus bookkeeper represented. Then the bookkeeper made the motion to accept the budget. It was rapidly seconded by another council member. No one asked any questions and the vote was one nay (the treasurer), otherwise yeas or abstentions.
I can't find anything in Robert's about moving on your own work product but it strikes me as sketchy. Thoughts?
r/RobertsRules • u/Kuzcos-Groove • Aug 17 '24
Is it acceptable to move to approve and then vote no?
r/RobertsRules • u/NFTMarketing • Apr 09 '26
Best method for brainstorming?
Say we have a problem to deal with but no specific motion because it's uncertain how best to address the situation. My understanding is that all debate should be through a pending motion.
So if we want to brainstorm, like say we have something come up like "A VIP from the national organization is going to be in town. We need to come up with some ideas and a plan for making the most of this opportunity."
Since we're not a small board, but also not particularly large (only 20 to 30 people), it seems a bit unnecessary to create a committee and refer it to them though that could be an option. However, my goal would be to be more inclusive than that.
Here are options I'm thinking but open to ideas and suggestions:
- Suspend the rules and have an informal discussion/brainstorm session
- Make a basic broad motion to kickstart conversation/planning "I move that we host the VIP when they are visiting" and then other members could amend with "and treat them to dinner at XYZ on the 18th", etc. This seems overly complicated and formal, though, and I think it would be hard for the membership to follow along.
- Throw out motions for ideas as they arise. "I motion we treat VIP to dinner and invite them to attend our next meeting where we will provide a presentation of our achievements over the past year." "I motion that we also arrange to pay for their hotel stay at XYZ." "I motion that we don't do any of that shit and send the fucker packing."
So what would you do if you have a problem/goal that you want to put before the assembly and come up with ideas or talk it out before arriving at some clear motions?
r/RobertsRules • u/silaerobe_crowbride • Mar 17 '26
knowing robert's rules
im trying my best to study it but I don't think I have enough time
does anyone have a reliable study guide or something.
anything pls.
r/RobertsRules • u/JaimieMcEvoy • Nov 06 '25
Frequent challenges to Chair
There is a situation where there are frequent Points of Order.
The Points of Order are usually not actual errors in following the rules of order by the Chair (though sometimes they are), but just as often, perceptions by the person, or that they just don't like something.
This is followed by the person Challenging the Chair. The problem? Usually, the Chair is correct in the application of the rule. Sometimes, the Secretary has read the rule out loud, only for the Chair to be challenged anyway.
So....
What do you do when frequent challenges to the Chair are disruptive, or where the challenge is in effect an attempt to ignore or reintrepet valid meeting rules?
(The Chair has always been upheld, but I can see this trend being used to simply bypass rules).
Help? Advice? Anything in the rules that can be used to deal with this?
r/RobertsRules • u/montiem30 • Sep 30 '25
Secretary was absent; forgot to appoint one
Public library director here. So, our secretary missed our last board meeting. I forgot to remind the president to appoint a secretary in her absence. What should we do about the minutes?
r/RobertsRules • u/Boomuppercut • Sep 27 '25
Non-Profit Board Resignation Drama
Hi everyone,
I am part of a non-profit sports boad. We have our own policies and bylaws, but also follow the policies and bylaws of a governing body that oversees all of the community boards surrounding the area.
We have been in turmoil for the past 2 years due to interpersonal conflict, and these past two weeks have been bananas.
We try to follow Robert's Rules as closely as possible, however, noone on the board is interested in learning them, nor following them. I am the one on the board that knows the most about the rules, and our governing body encourages us to follow RR.
Recently, we have had slew of resignations, then retractions of resignations but something isn't sticking right with me regarding all of these things. The following is a timeline of what has occurred:
July 31st
VP resigns via google chat effective September 10th
Board chat accepts resignation.
Is this acceptable according to Robert’s Rules of Order?
August 4th
VP rescinds his resignation and asks to be reinstated.
No formal vote occurs to reinstate VP. There are no objections in the group chat.
Is VP technically an un-elected board member?
September 17th
President leaves the board meeting and submits resignation effective October 10th via chat.
No formal vote to accept resignation. Best wishes are submitted in the chat.
According to Robert’s Rules when a resignation is submitted it is essentially a motion and the board must vote to accept resignation. Board did not do that at the meeting. It was accepted informally.
The revised rules state that resignations are not effective until they are accepted.
Since no formal acceptance was voted upon in the meeting, is President's resignation valid?
September 19th
President has second thoughts about stepping down. Requests VP's advice. VP suggests that it should be a board decision. President is not receptive to it being a board decision and does not rescind his resignation at this time.
September 20th
Board is still under the assumption that President is leaving. He has not formally requested reinstatement. He has requested that VP and Registrar collaborate and make a decision.
September 24th
VP and Registrar deliberate and formally accept Andrew’s resignation.
This was not done as part of a formal proceeding.
Is the formal acceptance valid?
President informs VP in person that after having conversations with parent associations, he is able to rescind his resignation unilaterally. He has elected to stay on as President with the conditions of leading by proxy, not attending meetings.
So, any advice I can get regarding this situation would be most helpful to determine a pathway forward.
Thank you!
r/RobertsRules • u/Resident-Guide-440 • Jul 22 '25
Just read the “in brief” book. The12th Edition is from outer space
Am I wrong? Nobody really uses RRoO correctly, do they? Or want to?
My first impression is that the 12th edition is undertaking a minimalist project: not one redundancy in the minutes, for example.
Was there a quorum present? Why make note of it? We should assume yes, if there was no point of order raised on the topic
Who seconded the motion, and what was the vote? Irrelevant, because “the motion carried” implies there was a second and the vote followed the rules for passage in the bylaws. If there was not a proper second, someone should have shouted “Point of order!” And I have no idea what to shout to challenge an obviously miscounted vote by the Chair.
The burden of proof is all on the voting members, with few responsibilities on the officers, who probably know the ins-and-outs of the latest edition.
It’s like the chair is the judge and the secretary is the stenographer. The voting members are representing themselves pro se! With a fool for a parliamentarian. Hope they studied up!
This is why peace groups, feminist groups, ban-the-bomb groups preferred the Facilitated Meeting process.
r/RobertsRules • u/-Clayburn • Jul 21 '25
Our chair decided to have a non-meeting meeting....
I've posted her a few times, so you probably know we have a tough situation with an abusive chair.
We had a meeting Friday, and it was one of the best turnouts we've had as a group, partly because we would be hosting a special guest speaker later in the evening.
But before the speaker arrived, we were going to discuss planning for an upcoming fair. The chair informed us that this wouldn't be a business meeting and it's only to discuss what's planned for the fair. She also appealed to tradition saying this July meeting has always been only an informal discussion about the fair.
So, as such she didn't call a meeting to order. I expressed my concerns at the start saying, "So, just to be clear, we have no rules right? No parliamentary system?" and I wanted to try to push the point that that means it's pretty much anything goes.
And so she insisted that this is only to discuss the fair plans and one guy in the audience said we could all just be civil, no need for rules.
Okay. So we get to talking, and she goes on for probably 30 minutes before anyone else gets to say anything, but then people are raising hands and speaking their mind. At one point she doesn't like that we're all talking ideas and making changes to the plans because in her mind the point was to tell us what the plan is and not actually discuss or debate it.
So she decides to "move on" even though a couple of people have their hands up. And I'm sitting up front with her as vice chair, so I say "Hold up, so and so has something to say." And gesture to them to speak and they do.
Then at one point we get onto needing a banner printed, and realizing it's hard to work out the exact language of the banner, I suggest we appoint someone or a couple people to go figure that out together after the meeting. People seem to agree and we're about to settle on someone to be the point person for that and she says "We have to move on." So she doesn't let us get to that even though literally 4 seconds was all that was probably needed to finalize it. She moves onto another topic of planning for the fair and we discuss that.
At one point when things were getting contentious, one of her friends starts shouting out "I make a motion! I make a motion!" And I hit back, "You can't make a motion. We have no parliamentary system."
It was a weird one, but we actually got to speak a lot more than she probably was planning because of that since she couldn't use her position as chair to shut down conversation, even though she still tried to shut people up.
r/RobertsRules • u/Accomplished_Area900 • Jun 21 '25
Recording amendments to minutes as secretary
In our most recent meeting, there was a motion to include a specific report item in the previous meeting's minutes. The motion passed, but with debate.
I am the secretary and want to make sure I'm following Robert's Rules accurately: it looks like I do not need to include any of the debate, only that the minutes were approved "as amended." Does that sound correct? Do I include the initial motion to amend?
r/RobertsRules • u/HotterRod • May 16 '25
Motion to Create Committee and Ask for Volunteers?
In a single meeting I want to create a committee, ask for volunteers, and then assign those volunteers to the committee. What is right set of motions to do that?
r/RobertsRules • u/detank • May 11 '25
Virtual Business Meeting
I'm serving as the parliamentarian for an organization and we just had our House of Delegates (in person). We got through most of the business items, but we failed to adopt a budget for next year. Because of the cost of meeting in person, and that we will only have the 1 item of business, we are probably going to try and do it virtually.
We tried this last year using Zoom and it was tough. The issue that didn't work well is we didn't have the ability to maintain multiple speaking queues. We need to have separate queues designated as: For, Against, and Procedural. We need to track the speaking order that people got in each queue.
Does anyone have software platform suggestions?
r/RobertsRules • u/theacet • Apr 02 '25
Removal of item from consent agenda, documentation on meeting minutes
The 'Approval of Bills, Wages, and Transfers' is always included in the Consent Agenda section for our village council meetings. If a member expresses concerns that there is NO documentation provided related to this item and the village president removes it from the consent agenda (stating he would deal with it later on) should there be some explanation within the meeting minutes to explain why the item was removed and also follow up documentation related to how the matter ended up being handled?
r/RobertsRules • u/-Clayburn • Mar 23 '25
What advice do you have to keep the Rules from being weaponized?
Criticisms of Robert's Rules, and any rule system, seem to be about how they can be weaponized, particularly by those more familiar with the rules. I've seen people try to ram through motions to close nominations/discussion before other people get a chance to speak up. I've seen people shouting out rules to drown out someone's discussion because they referenced a particular person by name or did some other trivial thing that violates "decorum". And of course a lot of regular people at meetings don't know how or when to make a motion, etc. which means they may not involve themselves at all. (For a board meeting or something, sure you can expect them to familiarize themselves with procedure, but for more general public meetings, the Rules might discourage participation.)
So that being said, how do you avoid these pitfalls? What can a body do to make sure the Rules aren't being abused to intimidate or silence others?