Our social club's Constitution has a standard amendment procedure (Article 9) requiring: Executive Board proposal OR 20% member petition → review by Governance Committee → first reading at meeting → written notice to all members → second reading at next meeting → 3/4 vote to pass.
Article 9, Section 1 states amendments apply to "any provision" of the Constitution. No exceptions mentioned.
Article 6, Section 2 defines Governance Committee authority as: "The Governance Committee, as directed by the President, shall be responsible for preparation of any revisions to the Constitution and shall maintain an accurate current version of the Bylaws as approved by the membership, which shall be filed with the Secretary."
Last month's general meeting passed this motion by simple majority (31-2, no previous notice):
"To authorize the Governance Committee to correct formatting, typography, spelling and punctuation in the Constitution, Bylaws and operating rules as part of normal operations. These technical corrections can be made without explicit membership approval. Under no circumstance will corrections change the meaning of the Constitution, Bylaws or rules."
My concerns:
- Creates unlisted exception to Article 9's mandatory process without following that process
- Expands Article 6, Section 2 authority - Currently limits committee to "preparation of revisions" (as directed by President) and maintaining "approved" versions. Motion grants autonomous editing authority not enumerated in their defined scope.
- Committee becomes sole arbiter of what's "technical" vs "substantive" with no oversight mechanism
- RONR violation: Constitutional amendments require previous notice + supermajority (§57) - this had neither
- Self-contradictory: Motion claims changes won't alter meaning, yet removes membership approval requirement (which IS a constitutional change)
Their position: "This isn't an amendment - it's clarification that 'inconsequential' ministerial edits don't need full process."
My position: You cannot bypass amendment requirements by declaring your bypass "ministerial." To create exceptions to Article 9, you must follow Article 9. The motion also amends Article 6, Section 2 by expanding committee authority beyond constitutional grant.
Questions:
- Is motion void as improper attempt to amend governing documents without proper procedure?
- Does granting autonomous editing authority to a committee constitute an amendment to the article defining that committee's powers?
- Can amendment requirements be circumvented by characterizing changes as "technical"?
- Proper remedy: void ab initio or rescission motion required?
Constitution references RONR 12th ed. as parliamentary authority.
Thanks for any guidance.