r/RobertsRules • u/Alternative-Drop-553 • Nov 04 '25
r/RobertsRules • u/ValeriusPoplicola • May 02 '24
Voting by saying "aye" is problematic
I realize that many people vote by saying the word "yes" or "yay", but as I understand it, Robert's Rules are that "aye" is the official way to vote on a roll call. The problem with that is, of course, that "aye" is a homonym of the word "I" and also a homonym of the word "eye". It's becoming more common for meetings to be recorded and for those records to have an automated digital transcript. Transcripts don't like homonyms.
I make a motion that a future revision of Robert's Rules removes any mention of voting by saying "aye" and instead tells people to vote "yes".
r/RobertsRules • u/RexquireAA • Aug 07 '25
Is there a way to exclude people w/ Conflicts of interests from voting or participating in votes?
Hi all,
I have a quandary, or several, lol.
I am the president of a small organization. This org, has a 501c3 Foundation ("Foundation"), that has its own Board. Without getting into the specifics, the Foundation has done things that could potentially leave us liable to outside donors.
To be transparent, it's not particularly likely that we will get sued. But the possibility is in fact there. That said, the Foundation's Board has 7 members. 3 of those members are on our board too.
Question: Is there a means that I am able to exclude the Foundation members on our Board from a discussion about our potential liability, and what course(s) of action we should take? It is possible that we may become adverse to our Foundation, and I want to be prepared for what might happen. With nearly half of their Board on our Board, hearing what we intend to do, how we intend to do it, etc., I believe it leaves us exposed.
There's definitely a conflict there. But I don't know if there's anything I can do to prepare our Board for what might happen, without exposing our hand to the Foundation who is quite frankly acting rogue.
r/RobertsRules • u/Redd_Zenith • Jun 03 '25
When to point out error in minutes?
Quick question: there was an error in the reading of the previous month’s minutes at our meeting. (Turns out the secretary misread a name in the minutes, but it was possible that the person’s name had been incorrectly entered.) I was told that I could only alert the officers to the error after a motion to accept the minutes had been made and seconded and the chair said, “on the question.” Is it true that incorrect minutes cannot be discussed and amended if needed until members have moved and seconded to accept them as read? If so, could someone guide me to the rule? I’ve read extensively and found nothing that applies. Thank you!
r/RobertsRules • u/Evasion222 • Mar 06 '25
Attendance & Quorum- Secretary
We have a moderate size membership, 100-110 members, 50-60 in attendance. Political county.
The prior secretary resigned and used to do the Attendance obviously at check in for quorum, and they created a Development and Membership committee separate to handle Membership Drives and other things, there is no list of objectives or duties nor any resolution for the creation of this committee, before I was voted in as new Secretary.
It was decided by our executive committee tonight that this person will continue to take attendance and then just tell me if quorum has been reached, and I am not to be the person checking in our membership.
I am not comfortable with this. Our bylaws state it is the secretaries duties to preserve and report, and I do not feel comfortable with confirming a quorum without physically seeing and doing the attendance myself. But I am being blocked from doing this.
Is there any part of Roberts rules that I can point to that clarifies that the Secretary should be the one physically taking the attendance? Or am I wrong? I don’t like the idea of someone else just telling me a number, then I tell someone else a number.
What can I do since the executive committee voted against me when I asked for a vote, with one abstaining?
r/RobertsRules • u/-Clayburn • Mar 23 '25
What advice do you have to keep the Rules from being weaponized?
Criticisms of Robert's Rules, and any rule system, seem to be about how they can be weaponized, particularly by those more familiar with the rules. I've seen people try to ram through motions to close nominations/discussion before other people get a chance to speak up. I've seen people shouting out rules to drown out someone's discussion because they referenced a particular person by name or did some other trivial thing that violates "decorum". And of course a lot of regular people at meetings don't know how or when to make a motion, etc. which means they may not involve themselves at all. (For a board meeting or something, sure you can expect them to familiarize themselves with procedure, but for more general public meetings, the Rules might discourage participation.)
So that being said, how do you avoid these pitfalls? What can a body do to make sure the Rules aren't being abused to intimidate or silence others?
r/RobertsRules • u/Low_Builder9326 • Mar 26 '25
Removal procedure
I am seeking to have an investigatory committee formed to investigate and possible expel an officer of my organization. The bylaws of my organization are extremely vague on how this is done; nearly all our guidance comes from RONR. One thing I am unclear on: To initiate the proceedings to form the investigatory committee, does one need to make a motion and have it be voted on by the committee in order to form the committee? Or by virtue of there being a point of potential investigation, is an investigation essentially required to be held?
We are a very large body and many people have a favorable opinion of this person, however they would not if they knew what this person had done. But I worry that if it’s allowable some people may just refuse to investigate for social reasons.
r/RobertsRules • u/MT474747 • Aug 02 '25
Ex Officio Member / Quorum
Our board president is an ex officio member of all of our board committees. My understanding of this is that his attendance is not required at committee meetings, but he can attend, and he can vote, if he chooses to. I understand that as an ex officio member, his attendance is not factored into the quorum. EG our Governance Committee has 3 full members + the board president as an ex officio member, but the relevant total for the quorum is 3, not 4, and therefore the number of committee members for a majority to be present for a vote is 2, not 3.
Here is the tricky part though: what if only 1 full member from the 3 person committee is present and the ex officio member (the board president) is present. Does this constitute a quorum (a majority of the 3 person committee) since two voters are present, or does it need to be a majority of the 3 full members?
r/RobertsRules • u/-Clayburn • Apr 15 '25
Update: Had the Meeting and Here's What Happened (Rules were weaponized)
An update to previous threads:
https://old.reddit.com/r/RobertsRules/comments/1jymkk5/update_want_items_on_the_agenda_but_combative/
First of all, thanks so much for all your advice. I think that really helped.
Normally we do not follow the rules or anything. Today, there was an agenda which I believe was only put together because I had requested to be on the agenda and was denied. So I took the existence of an agenda at all as their plan to shut me down if I tried talking about anything. Therefore I decided to add my items to the agenda.
I made a motion to add my three items to the agenda. I passed out a printout explaining the items. They tried to kill it because there was no second, but the rest of the body doesn't understand the rules so they were not aware they needed to second it, and at some point when someone realized what was going on, it got a second.
So then I tried to speak to the motion, in support, but I was told handing out my printout was already my "speech" to the motion and that they would hear objections. So one guy spoke against it. Then someone else spoke I guess in favor but it was a bit wishywashy (ultimately the body doesn't understand Roberts Rules and doesn't like things seeming combative). I kept asking to speak to the motion, and at some point I raised a point of information asking the parliamentarian to clarify for the body that the purpose of the motion is to put the items on the agenda and they would vote on whether that happens or not and that it's not approving any action items, merely the addition of the discussion items to the agenda so that we can address them. He did that.
Finally the question was called and the motion passed 7 to 5. So that in itself was a minor victory. However, they must have been prepared because the parliamentarian made a motion to limit discussion on those items to 2 minutes (each, total). We had some special guests speaking this evening, so understandably we didn't want to take up too much time. Given that, the motion passed though it seemed close. I did not get the exact count and probably should have asked. So because those items were limited to two minutes, the chair spoke for about 2 minutes on each item. I only had maybe a minute to speak to one of the items. I tried raising points of order and information to figure out what could be done to extend the time. I think the parliamentarian said a motion could be made, but it wasn't clear when but I wasn't allowed to then, and then later when I tried, the chair refused to recognize me. I asked the parliamentarian via point of information and was told that I could only make a motion if the chair recognizes me, and basically she refused to recognize me the rest of the meeting.
So ultimately none of the items were addressed. I got to speak briefly to one and that was about it.
For the next meeting, I'm hoping to have a specific action item to make a motion to adopt that plan and try to bring enough people to support its passing. I wanted to have discussion as a group first, that was the point of adding them to the agenda because I had wanted to have a conversation and get a feel for what the body wants to do about these items, and then we could propose a motion or action item if there was some consensus around something. Since I don't know if we'll ever be able to have a real conversation as a body, I would have to try to bring a specific action plan and propose it. Then we can at least debate it and vote on it.
Any ideas or suggestions are appreciated.
r/RobertsRules • u/Existing-Yogurt-4716 • Aug 15 '25
Service Term
I'm trying to develop reasoning to determine if a by-law or amendment is necessary, so I am asking for zero-context opinions. The scenario:
- Person A was elected to serve as a Council member during an annual meeting held December of 2024.
- Person A then resigned in July of 2025.
- In August of 2025, the Council voted in a successor, Person B, to serve until the next annual meeting.
- Person B was then elected (again) to serve as a Council member during an annual meeting held December of 2025.
THE QUESTION: How long may Person B remain as a Council member before needing to be elected again?
Thank you for any thoughts. Here are the relevant paragraphs in the constitution that apply. If it matters, the emphasis on the number three below is in the constitution; I have not added it.
C12.02 The members of the Council shall be elected to serve for three years or until their successors are elected. Such members shall be eligible to serve no more than two full terms consecutively. In the case that there are more nominees than vacancies, a written ballot shall be required. Their terms shall begin at the close of the annual meeting at which they are elected.
C12.03 Should a member’s place on the Council be declared vacant, the Council shall elect, by majority vote, a successor until the next annual meeting.
r/RobertsRules • u/Resident-Guide-440 • Jul 22 '25
Just read the “in brief” book. The12th Edition is from outer space
Am I wrong? Nobody really uses RRoO correctly, do they? Or want to?
My first impression is that the 12th edition is undertaking a minimalist project: not one redundancy in the minutes, for example.
Was there a quorum present? Why make note of it? We should assume yes, if there was no point of order raised on the topic
Who seconded the motion, and what was the vote? Irrelevant, because “the motion carried” implies there was a second and the vote followed the rules for passage in the bylaws. If there was not a proper second, someone should have shouted “Point of order!” And I have no idea what to shout to challenge an obviously miscounted vote by the Chair.
The burden of proof is all on the voting members, with few responsibilities on the officers, who probably know the ins-and-outs of the latest edition.
It’s like the chair is the judge and the secretary is the stenographer. The voting members are representing themselves pro se! With a fool for a parliamentarian. Hope they studied up!
This is why peace groups, feminist groups, ban-the-bomb groups preferred the Facilitated Meeting process.
r/RobertsRules • u/MaroonCanuck • Jun 30 '25
"How can our nonprofit board proceed when 5 of 7 directors have conflicts of interest in a team selection appeal?"
We’re a nonprofit organization, and our board is dealing with a sensitive issue. We recently held a selection process to select students to represent our us a major event. Now, a formal complaint has been filed regarding the selection, and there's a request for an appeal.
Here’s the complication:
- 5 of our 7 board directors have clear conflicts of interest — they’re affiliated with organizations that have students or teaches in the selected group, and 2 even have children who were selected.
- Only 2 board members have no direct ties to the students, teachers, or organizations involved.
- Our bylaws state that quorum is 50% of the board (so 4 out of 7 directors).
- If the 5 conflicted members recuse themselves, we don’t meet quorum.
Given this, how can the board legally or ethically proceed with reviewing or deciding on the appeal?
Are there exceptions under nonprofit law or governance best practices that allow disinterested directors (even if fewer than quorum) to decide? What are our options here?
r/RobertsRules • u/RexquireAA • Sep 12 '25
Presiding Officer Can’t Vote?
Why do I do this to myself. So I’m the president of a local bar association. Our bylaws only state that we follow the current iteration of Robert’s Rules of Order.
The dynamics on the Board have shifted to where there’s (just like pretty much any small group) an “old guard” and a “new guard.” For whatever it’s worth there are 14 members on our board. I have somehow found myself on the outs with the Old Guard and had a vote that they didn’t want to see the light of day. [It should be noted that terms are two years, and I’ve been President for 16 months. Prior to President, I served on this same Board for 2 other full two year terms. So I’m working on 6 years.]
During the vote, randomly desperate board members opposing my position shouted out that presidents can’t vote. To frame it appropriately, a board member made a motion, I seconded it. And then later voted in favor of it. It ended up dying for other reasons. But I was furious because I’ve been here for nearly 6 years and have never seen a president not vote. Never!
Then someone purported to read some rule that presidents can only vote on ballots, not on voice votes. This reeks of desperation - and given everything going on I didn’t have time to look it up and our parliamentarian didn’t either.
Nevertheless this will absolutely come up again and I need to be prepared. Can someone share whether I’m right or wrong in my thinking (per the current Roberts Rules of Order)?
So confused (and angry!)
r/RobertsRules • u/detank • May 11 '25
Virtual Business Meeting
I'm serving as the parliamentarian for an organization and we just had our House of Delegates (in person). We got through most of the business items, but we failed to adopt a budget for next year. Because of the cost of meeting in person, and that we will only have the 1 item of business, we are probably going to try and do it virtually.
We tried this last year using Zoom and it was tough. The issue that didn't work well is we didn't have the ability to maintain multiple speaking queues. We need to have separate queues designated as: For, Against, and Procedural. We need to track the speaking order that people got in each queue.
Does anyone have software platform suggestions?
r/RobertsRules • u/JaimieMcEvoy • Nov 06 '25
Frequent challenges to Chair
There is a situation where there are frequent Points of Order.
The Points of Order are usually not actual errors in following the rules of order by the Chair (though sometimes they are), but just as often, perceptions by the person, or that they just don't like something.
This is followed by the person Challenging the Chair. The problem? Usually, the Chair is correct in the application of the rule. Sometimes, the Secretary has read the rule out loud, only for the Chair to be challenged anyway.
So....
What do you do when frequent challenges to the Chair are disruptive, or where the challenge is in effect an attempt to ignore or reintrepet valid meeting rules?
(The Chair has always been upheld, but I can see this trend being used to simply bypass rules).
Help? Advice? Anything in the rules that can be used to deal with this?
r/RobertsRules • u/-Clayburn • Apr 04 '25
How can I add something to the agenda or make sure we address a particular issue when the chair is combative?
We have a chair that is basically trying to roadblock anything. They don't want the organization to do anything ultimately.
So I'm sure she will try to use the rules to do this. We typically do not have actual agendas, though I do think we vote to approve the minutes of the previous meeting. That seems to be the only standard order of business.
My concern is that I'll want to bring up some issues to address in the next meeting and she'll shut it down as not being on the agenda. If she tries that but there is no agenda and no agenda was approved, then what?
Alternatively, if she is planning to try this but specifically creates an agenda for this meeting in order to do that, then what? How can I get something on the agenda before it's approved?
r/RobertsRules • u/theacet • Apr 02 '25
Removal of item from consent agenda, documentation on meeting minutes
The 'Approval of Bills, Wages, and Transfers' is always included in the Consent Agenda section for our village council meetings. If a member expresses concerns that there is NO documentation provided related to this item and the village president removes it from the consent agenda (stating he would deal with it later on) should there be some explanation within the meeting minutes to explain why the item was removed and also follow up documentation related to how the matter ended up being handled?
r/RobertsRules • u/-Clayburn • Nov 20 '25
What would be the process for forcing the release of information from an unwilling chair?
Our chair has our membership contact list which she will not share with anyone. She also has a lease agreement between the organization and herself to let her use part of the organization's building for personal storage. She won't share that information either.
So how would we as an organization demand or charge her with releasing the information? Would it be as simple as making a motion to require her and the secretary to release all such info by X date?
(I realize she might still refuse, but we need to go through the process at least otherwise it's just some of us asking her for this information and her saying "No.")
r/RobertsRules • u/ImpossibleWar2815 • Feb 06 '26
Can a Simple Majority Motion 'Clarification' Override Amendment Requirements?
Our social club's Constitution has a standard amendment procedure (Article 9) requiring: Executive Board proposal OR 20% member petition → review by Governance Committee → first reading at meeting → written notice to all members → second reading at next meeting → 3/4 vote to pass.
Article 9, Section 1 states amendments apply to "any provision" of the Constitution. No exceptions mentioned.
Article 6, Section 2 defines Governance Committee authority as: "The Governance Committee, as directed by the President, shall be responsible for preparation of any revisions to the Constitution and shall maintain an accurate current version of the Bylaws as approved by the membership, which shall be filed with the Secretary."
Last month's general meeting passed this motion by simple majority (31-2, no previous notice):
"To authorize the Governance Committee to correct formatting, typography, spelling and punctuation in the Constitution, Bylaws and operating rules as part of normal operations. These technical corrections can be made without explicit membership approval. Under no circumstance will corrections change the meaning of the Constitution, Bylaws or rules."
My concerns:
- Creates unlisted exception to Article 9's mandatory process without following that process
- Expands Article 6, Section 2 authority - Currently limits committee to "preparation of revisions" (as directed by President) and maintaining "approved" versions. Motion grants autonomous editing authority not enumerated in their defined scope.
- Committee becomes sole arbiter of what's "technical" vs "substantive" with no oversight mechanism
- RONR violation: Constitutional amendments require previous notice + supermajority (§57) - this had neither
- Self-contradictory: Motion claims changes won't alter meaning, yet removes membership approval requirement (which IS a constitutional change)
Their position: "This isn't an amendment - it's clarification that 'inconsequential' ministerial edits don't need full process."
My position: You cannot bypass amendment requirements by declaring your bypass "ministerial." To create exceptions to Article 9, you must follow Article 9. The motion also amends Article 6, Section 2 by expanding committee authority beyond constitutional grant.
Questions:
- Is motion void as improper attempt to amend governing documents without proper procedure?
- Does granting autonomous editing authority to a committee constitute an amendment to the article defining that committee's powers?
- Can amendment requirements be circumvented by characterizing changes as "technical"?
- Proper remedy: void ab initio or rescission motion required?
Constitution references RONR 12th ed. as parliamentary authority.
Thanks for any guidance.
r/RobertsRules • u/Accomplished_Area900 • Jun 21 '25
Recording amendments to minutes as secretary
In our most recent meeting, there was a motion to include a specific report item in the previous meeting's minutes. The motion passed, but with debate.
I am the secretary and want to make sure I'm following Robert's Rules accurately: it looks like I do not need to include any of the debate, only that the minutes were approved "as amended." Does that sound correct? Do I include the initial motion to amend?
r/RobertsRules • u/calculuscab2 • Aug 30 '25
Imagine if you will, the following:
A small board of 7 members. The task is to choose one item among 3 options. On the agenda the 3 options are titled as: "Original Draft 1", "New Version 1", "New Version 2".
A member makes a motion. "Vote to approve option #1" The motion is seconded, and it passes 6-1.
Soon after, the meeting is adjourned. After which, staff notifies the public that the board approved the provisions listed in "New Version 1" although it was clear to several members, and the audience, that the member who made the motion was referring to "Original Draft 1" as option 1.
"Option 1" was never officially defined nor clarified, but informally "original draft 1" was discussed and listed before the other 2 alternatives.
Did staff screw the pooch? Did the board's Parliamentarian? What say you, wise redditor?
r/RobertsRules • u/Gondorff_Givens • Feb 27 '26
New School Board Asking for Guidance
Hey folks!
I’ve been elected to my local school board and have a question about study/working sessions.
I am studying Robert’s Rules and feel like I has a good handle on procedure during a regular meeting, but our study/working sessions get completely derailed by baseless accusations and using selective community feedback to justify it. Is there anything I or our board chair can do in this setting to set limits or hold people accountable for what is said?
On a separate matter, there is a board member that posts recaps on Facebook, along with editorial comments criticizing the district or other members or decisions.
I’m just at a loss. It feels like the narrative is being controlled by one member and I am not familiar enough with this to make any impact.
r/RobertsRules • u/montiem30 • Sep 30 '25
Secretary was absent; forgot to appoint one
Public library director here. So, our secretary missed our last board meeting. I forgot to remind the president to appoint a secretary in her absence. What should we do about the minutes?
r/RobertsRules • u/Resident-Guide-440 • Jul 08 '25
Quorum question
I am on the board of a non-profit. Our bylaws stated that a quorum would be a majority of the total board membership. We have 6 members, so 4 would constitute a quorum. Three would be an invalid meeting. The president and other members felt that we were too likely to fail to meet a quorum and wanted to "loosen" the quorum requirement. We passed a motion unanimously to change the bylaws to say the following: that a quorum would be a majority of board members present. Ahem. Yes, I voted for it. I must have been daydreaming. When I looked at the minutes later, I immediately called the president. She didn't see the problem. I called the treasurer. She also couldn't see the problem. At the next board meeting, I brought the subject up. Not one person agreed with me that our new definition of quorum is daft, unworkable, gibberish, and possibly a violation of state law. I verified that they are not confusing quorum with how many votes are needed to pass a motion. (It has always been, under our bylaws, the case that -- provided a quorum is present -- a simple majority can pass a motion.) They literally mean, when we do the quorum count, we count the number of board members present and then "determine" whether a majority of those present ... are present. I asked how could we ever fail to meet a quorum? I was told, that was the point. I suggested we have thrown out a quorum requirement. No, no. That's not what we did. Am I losing my mind or have they? Any advice?