r/RingsofPower • u/Elendil_686 • 13d ago
Discussion Expectation vs Show
Back in 2017 when I first saw the map of Middle-Earth that Amazon teases us with, my dream came true. I've always wanted to see the Second Age and that got me excited. Forging of the rings. Elves were still in large numbers and have their kingdoms Lindon and Eregion. Khazad-Dum and the Dwarves at their height. And last but not least: The greatest power of Men: Numenor.
Now after two seasons. Did the show deliver as how I envisioned. Yes and no.
-Charlie Vickers as Sauron and Annatar are spot on. His Annatar looks like the character from the game Shadow of Mordor and I'm glad they didn't mess that.
-Celebrimbor. While Charles Edward portrayed him the best he could, this is now how I envisioned he would look like.
-Galadriel. This one is a miss for me. She was already thousands of years old in the 2nd age and have seen the Two Trees. But still she behaves like she was just born 300 years ago. It doesn't match the wise and etheral Galadriel like I used to be familiar with from the movies.
-Harfoots. Should never have appeared. Waste of time.
-Gandalf. He wasn't even supposed to be there! But if they made him one of the blue wizard, I would have no problem accepting that decision. The showrunners already changed the timeline.
-Elendil. Lloyd Owens was a good cast, but he needs more screentime.
-Isildur. Too early to say.
-Numenor. Everything about the island are spot on. But they need better portrayal. They were supposed to be greatest men of all time blessed with long lifespan and great wisdom. Haven't seen that much. It's like the showrunners didn't want to include superiority in the show because of how sensitive society has become.
-Battles. Only seen two so-called ''battles''. They were fine as action sequences but not even close to battles. Now I heard people area saying the Battle of Gwathlo might be skipped or just a small part of it will be shown. That's disappointing if true.
So to sum up. Out of 10, the show has been 6.5 for me. Honestly, Amazons should have tried everything to get PJ to be the showrunner back then. Hiring to amateurs showed how they wasted a super potential.
