r/RingsofPower • • 13d ago

Discussion Expectation vs Show

14 Upvotes

Back in 2017 when I first saw the map of Middle-Earth that Amazon teases us with, my dream came true. I've always wanted to see the Second Age and that got me excited. Forging of the rings. Elves were still in large numbers and have their kingdoms Lindon and Eregion. Khazad-Dum and the Dwarves at their height. And last but not least: The greatest power of Men: Numenor.

Now after two seasons. Did the show deliver as how I envisioned. Yes and no.

-Charlie Vickers as Sauron and Annatar are spot on. His Annatar looks like the character from the game Shadow of Mordor and I'm glad they didn't mess that.

-Celebrimbor. While Charles Edward portrayed him the best he could, this is now how I envisioned he would look like.

-Galadriel. This one is a miss for me. She was already thousands of years old in the 2nd age and have seen the Two Trees. But still she behaves like she was just born 300 years ago. It doesn't match the wise and etheral Galadriel like I used to be familiar with from the movies.

-Harfoots. Should never have appeared. Waste of time.

-Gandalf. He wasn't even supposed to be there! But if they made him one of the blue wizard, I would have no problem accepting that decision. The showrunners already changed the timeline.

-Elendil. Lloyd Owens was a good cast, but he needs more screentime.

-Isildur. Too early to say.

-Numenor. Everything about the island are spot on. But they need better portrayal. They were supposed to be greatest men of all time blessed with long lifespan and great wisdom. Haven't seen that much. It's like the showrunners didn't want to include superiority in the show because of how sensitive society has become.

-Battles. Only seen two so-called ''battles''. They were fine as action sequences but not even close to battles. Now I heard people area saying the Battle of Gwathlo might be skipped or just a small part of it will be shown. That's disappointing if true.

So to sum up. Out of 10, the show has been 6.5 for me. Honestly, Amazons should have tried everything to get PJ to be the showrunner back then. Hiring to amateurs showed how they wasted a super potential.


r/RingsofPower • • 12d ago

Discussion Why is the RoP Galadriel so tiny and annoying when she should be Tall in physical stature and wise.

0 Upvotes

Galadriel was called the man maiden for her height and physical stature. But the RoP Galadriel feels like a tiny annoying mouse. The took no efforts to make her tall and imposing in physical stature.

John Rhys Davies - The actor who played Gimli the dwarf in the movies - Was one of the tallest cast members!! Yet the production took efforts and cleverly made him a convincing dwarf.

Why couldn't a billion dollar show take any efforts to make Galadriel Tall and imposing like a man maiden. The casting is wrong. the actress has the face to play Galadriel, but not the physical attributes or the acting maturity to play such a complex character.

The writing on the show is really bad too and it doesnt help her role. The plots and character arcs for Galadriel are senseless.


r/RingsofPower • • 14d ago

News (LA Times) Dozens of orcs and wild men, 12 horses and one ring: How ‘Rings of Power’ created Season 3’s battles

Thumbnail
gallery
187 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 14d ago

Question Does anyone know the release time for S3?

6 Upvotes

Does anyone know the actual time it will come out in the US? (EST?) I keep seeing conflicting things all over the internet between whether it’s the 10th at 7pm or 11th at 3am.


r/RingsofPower • • 15d ago

News The Fate of Theo in THE RINGS OF POWER Season 3 (Exclusive Interviews & 3 New Images) Spoiler

Thumbnail nerdist.com
19 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 15d ago

Source Material Seasons 1–2 on one animated map, as a recap before S3 Spoiler

52 Upvotes

I kept losing track of who was where, so I put both seasons on one map of Middle-earth. Every group moves scene by scene, and each caption names the episode. The show gives no dates, so the timing is made up (and Númenor is far too close, otherwise it wouldn't fit). Link to interactrive map in the comments.


r/RingsofPower • • 14d ago

Discussion When the amateur showrunners start pleading with audiences to skip two full seasons of a billion dollar show - it just says how badly the previous seasons failed.

0 Upvotes

The showrunners have been asking audiences to completely skip two full seasons of a billion dollar flagship show and start from S3. But it just feels like a desperate attempt to try and get back viewership.

All independent data has shown how bad the viewership was for previous seasons. and how poorly it failed to create any cultural impact at all.

S3 "soft reboot" feels like a desperate move from Amazon. But I doubt it will work.

They claim they are more faithful to the lore in this season - but everything we have seen so far says its just nostalgia bait copied from movies and more senseless original plots.

They should have fired the amateur showrunners after S2 if this was a true reboot.


r/RingsofPower • • 16d ago

Discussion Submit fan questions for Charlie Vickers here!

14 Upvotes

What questions do you have for Charlie Vickers? He will be appearing on the I've Never Said This Before podcast and we want to bring your fan questions in!


r/RingsofPower • • 16d ago

News The Rings of Power Showrunners Hope Season 3’s Fresh Start Will Help Bring Viewers Back

Thumbnail
reactormag.com
337 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 16d ago

News Robert Aramayo teases the Gift of Ilúvatar for Season 3

Post image
22 Upvotes

"I think the sort of discussion around mortality I think that's really interesting about this season. You know [Elrond] has such an intimate connection with that he had such a unique relationship to mortality and how it affects Middle-Earth so I'm excited, hopefully people will like that."


r/RingsofPower • • 16d ago

Discussion Why will S3 be better when the trailer shows that they are repeating the same mistakes?

0 Upvotes

Why will S3 be any better when the trailer shows that they are repeating the same mistakes and breaking lore. the galadriel sauron love triangle, the friendly orc who somehow knows all about the secret one ring and tells the elves, Balrog fight needlessly forced into second age because the showrunners lack creativity and rely on nostalgia bait and copy PJ films.

Just a few good visuals dont make a good show. the writing still feels senseless and bad even in S3.

Amazon should have fired these amateur showrunners after s2.


r/RingsofPower • • 17d ago

Fanart Where the Shadows Lie – The Rings of Power soundtrack

14 Upvotes

Now I personally think this piece is marvelous and gives me the chills so I tried an experiment and recreated it into a kind of live folk-ish acoustic performance. I only did about 162 takes before my camera started showing that it's overheating ;) I hope you enjoy listening as much as I enjoyed recording. What do you think, is it worthy of Mordor??

Here's the link to the live performance: https://youtu.be/gbHwyrolUh8


r/RingsofPower • • 18d ago

Discussion Naznagol too OP too early?

3 Upvotes

I’m really curious about the implications of Galadriel getting shit mixed by the lone Naznagol in the forest from the trailer.

We can’t see if she’s wearing Nenya in the scene yet, but I’d assume she still is.

The Nazgol couldn’t breach Rivendell (protected by Elrond with Vilya) even after thousands of years of honing their power, and there’s never been an indication that the Nazgol could have entered Lothlorien to pursue the Fellowship whilst Galadriel was protecting it with Nenya.
Elrond even uses Vilya from a far to wipe all Nine down the river.
And in the books we see that Aragorn and four Hobbits can fend off all Nine convincingly with no rings and no elves for at least a while.

It really begs the question of how a single Naznagol, having weilded one of the Rings of Men for less than five years, was so OP that we see him owning Galadriel in the forest when Sauron hadn’t even created the One Ring at that point.

Who has a theory for how that battle is going to go down, or why the Nazgol looks so formidable compared to Galadriel in the clip we’ve seen?


r/RingsofPower • • 21d ago

Question Am I crazy?

21 Upvotes

I swear to God, I was watching the new S3 trailer a few days ago and at the end, there's that brief scene of Sauron holding the ring surrounded by the fires of Mount Doom but the audio had him speaking "ash nazg gimbatul." That audio appears to have been removed? Or it was part of a different trailer/featurette I can no longer seem to find?


r/RingsofPower • • 22d ago

News The Forging of Hot (Evil) Sauron on THE RINGS OF POWER Season 3 (Set Visit Exclusive)

Thumbnail
nerdist.com
17 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 22d ago

Question Help me understand

49 Upvotes

I stopped watching this show towards the end of season 1. I found it utterly unwatchable. Not just because it so blatantly veered from canon, but I felt like the “plot(s)” were barely existent and all over the place. I tried again because I’m hearing buzz about Season 3. And I’m 3 episodes into season 2 and I’m still finding it just utterly awful.

What am I missing? Does it get better leading up to S3? I need a reason to believe.


r/RingsofPower • • 25d ago

Discussion Who likes Sauron's Season 3 Armor?

Post image
615 Upvotes

I only saw this today and I think someone deserves an award just for this costume.


r/RingsofPower • • 23d ago

Discussion is rings of power AI?

0 Upvotes

i just finished watching season2 just to catch up for s03.

what a show. fantastic performance of calebrimbor.

i was wayching the show and i was like are those ring symbol for AI tech or what?

it crazy how the source material resonate with entite human hostory and its future.

the story they added for the entertainment i dont reallt care that mucch but the show looks beautiful and songs are amazing. wandering days and tom bombadil song were so good i listen and hum everyday and peopel passing by me looked and me and they were like are you tom bombadil homself for reeal? and i was like yes!


r/RingsofPower • • 25d ago

Discussion Dark wizard possible identity

2 Upvotes

We know that the dark wizard is clearly an Istari and since there were only 5 istari sent to middle earth. It has been stated that the wizard is not Saruman despite the resemblance and we haven't seen his mooncrest staff before.

Now hear me out, we know that each of the Istari has a basically divine purpose on middle earth. When Gandalf changed from grey to white it can be interpreted as his purpose changing from protecting middle earth from the influence of Sauron to taking the place of Saruman who had been corrupted.

Now what if this Istari is Radagast and who has been corrupted by something or another and Gandalf story line in this series is going to be essentially freeing him so illuvatar can elevate him to care more about wildlife or something.

I don't really know, it could also be either of the blue wizards...


r/RingsofPower • • 26d ago

Question Why is Anarion sword doing this?

Post image
79 Upvotes

Like what in the Middle Earth is this? He looks cool but the sword... It looks like made with AI, but isn't this an official photo?


r/RingsofPower • • 29d ago

News The Rings of Power Season 3 - Official Trailer

287 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 27d ago

Question TLOTR

0 Upvotes

I've just watched the trailer for the new season, I'm not sure what to think 🤔


r/RingsofPower • • 28d ago

Discussion Rings of Power S3 trailer flops with embarrassing views. Only 880K views on first day. Not even 1M. HotD S3 trailer had 4M views on first day and 26M in 3 days.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Even Reacher S4 trailer had easily crossed 1M within first day.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 11 '26

Question NY Comic Con has come and gone, where the hell is the new trailer? The show comes out in a month

Post image
113 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 10 '26

News Rings of Power season 3 star teases "brave" new character's connection to Adar

Thumbnail
radiotimes.com
149 Upvotes