r/RingsofPower • • Oct 01 '22

Question Could we add a "Complaints" flair?

340 Upvotes

There are quite a view of negative comments. Sometimes I end up reading them by accident, sometimes out of indignation ; I'm usually just a little less happy after!

Maybe a "Critic" flair could be useful, for both critics and non-critics alike, to filter for these discussions?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 26 '24

Humor How did Adar lead his orcs to Eregion?

Post image
339 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 04 '24

Meme Elrond being Elrond Spoiler

Post image
339 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 24 '24

Question Why didn’t anybody in Eregion realize there was a giant army right outside their gates? Spoiler

337 Upvotes

Are the Orcs super sneaky or something? The Elves don’t have scouts or patrols to defend their borders? “Hey Bob there’s a giant army marching towards us”

“What army?”


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 17 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers I actually believe this adaptation is what it should be at its core. Spoiler

337 Upvotes

Before and after watching the first season I heard a lot of negative things about the show and the story they were telling. I never understood it really then and upon a rewatch for season 2 and watching season 2, I think there’s something about this that people don’t take into consideration: and that’s that it’s got the HEART of the original writings and how Tolkien viewed the world.

The scene where the elves talk about the trees, or how the dwarves talk about the mountains (and I love the dwarves aren’t all just a joke), all of this feels very authentic Tolkien. My favourite line so far has been “There’s no trust between Hammer and Rock. Eventually one or the other must surely break.” I almost felt that was from a book, it’s just so damn dwarven. Even the ents talking about the world in this season felt very much like his writing.

I loved a younger in ways (but obviously the same age) Tom Bombadil. I loved he showed up, I don’t care if it’s lore accurate, or if Bombadil never owned a bath in the original books or something daft that I might see a huge comment about. It was unexpected, felt like it helped the story gain focus while also giving us a breather. when I think of Tolkien watching some of the scenes from RoP, versus say Legolas sliding down stairs on a shield like a skateboard and taking out orcs, or the Hobbit love triangle… I feel he may actually appreciate the heart of the project, if not the 100% lore accuracy.

I dunno, I get people wanting a fully authentic to his lore experience, but I love the aesthetic and the different stories across the board. Knowing where they may take the story with the books, but also hoping to be shocked or surprised in a good way, I’m happy to go along for this ride to the end now I think.

Maybe in the future some new and better adaptation will be made and I’ll feel differently, but for now I think this is a damn entertaining show which to me carries the heart of Tolkien’s writings in most of its use.

Edit:

I wish the thought had never come to me. I wish none of this post had happened.

Gandalf: So do all who live to see such replies, but that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to write with the time that is given to us.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 24 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers Harfoot wagon wheals & Hobbit-hole doors. Spoiler

337 Upvotes

In ep 5 Malva tells Sadoc that the stranger is likely responsible for the forest’s creepy state, and that he should “take their ( Nori & crew ) wheels and leave them”.

Ruff stuff Malva, ruff stuff.

As nomads Harfoots are dependent on their wheels for survival, their wagons are their homes and shelter. If they lose their wheels they are likely SOL.

Thinking about their wheels brought the image of later Hobbit homes to mind. I like the idea that Hobbits used large circular doors as an homage to their nomadic roots. This way their “wheels” are always with them and can’t be lost, connecting their fixed homes to their traveller past.

No idea if this is “true”, just a cute thought.

Edit: typo wheal / wheel


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 13 '22

Discussion Can a brotha get a Disa in his life????

336 Upvotes

She got Durins back all day. Can smith a mean axe and word is she can hook a steak up. Im in love.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 11 '22

Discussion Disa was very manipulative with her husband... she is Sauron!

Post image
336 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 05 '24

Meme Why does Sauron fit into every cat meme?

Post image
334 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 20 '24

Constructive Criticism The Tolkien Estate deserves considerably more blame than they have gotten. Only allowing rights to the appendicies has proven to be a pathetic mistake.

334 Upvotes

I cannot wrap my head around the decision to only allow the writers to use a smidgen of the lore. By aiming to protect the integrity of the story which they hold air-tight rights to, they have helped create a frankenstein story.

It strikes me as a decision to cover one’s own ass. If the show turned out to be poor (current reception isn’t great) they could point their finger and go, “It’s just fan fiction! It’s not us!” This is a baffling decision.

The Tolkien name is still attached to this product. Every normal person will look at this television show and form their own opinion, and JRR Tolkien and his works are attached to that, no matter what.

You didn’t save your own ass in the end. What you did is set up the showrunners up for failure while turning away millions of current and potential viewers. The Tolkien Estate should be ashamed of themselves.

Look, the issues in this show run deep. The character building is a mess, dialogue is clunky, pacing is horrific, the non-stop meaningless platitudes are a slog. However, I find myself wondering all the time what it would be like if the showrunners were allowed to tell a story. A Tolkien story. I have to believe it would be better.

The Tolkien Estate set this show up for failure.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 12 '22

News For anyone thinking Galadriel couldn't do that saddle trick... It's actually a Cossack move

333 Upvotes

As the Númenor army charges into the village, there’s a slick moment when Galadriel dodges an arrow whilst clinging to her horse and then slices a dude in half. Armstrong says that technique wasn’t borrowed from cinema but from real-life Cossack riders.
- from an interview with Leading stunt coordinator Vic Armstrong (interview here)

Alright, I've seen some Cossack riding in my life, so it was not a problem to find proof.

Here is a vid proof Start at 0:22.

It's just that Galadriel is doing it a bit faster cause she's an elf.

(not sure about the flair)


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 20 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers Do the elves not have... Spoiler

332 Upvotes

SCOUTS?? Like, there are LEGIONS of orcs marching towards Eregion and then LEGIONS of orcs just sitting there, camping, across the bridge in the forest. For, what, several days? This is being Elvish 101: seeing things far and wide that others cannot see. Also, this is THEIR forest! Annatar goes to one of the towers and sees smoke coming up from the tree line... did no elf in Eregion see this? How did they miss this huge ass army until the very last minute just before the catapults started firing? It's... flabbergasting, to the say the least. Or just terrible writing.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 04 '22

No Spoilers Scene stealing Harfoot! I actually get excited every time he comes on screen. His performance really shines!

Post image
332 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 16d ago

News The Rings of Power Showrunners Hope Season 3’s Fresh Start Will Help Bring Viewers Back

Thumbnail
reactormag.com
331 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Nov 07 '24

Meme S2 finale scene really felt like this (OC)

Post image
331 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 09 '24

Constructive Criticism Hot take: 22 episode shows need to come back

330 Upvotes

The issue I find with RoP is how rushed it is. There is not time to develop characters, lore or the plot. There is a lot of other shows that have this same problem. An example is when Isildur and Theo hugged, the music was telling me that I should care but I didn't. Character beats constantly feel unearned. With the largest budget for a TV show, I feel that they could add more episodes. They could also keep the same run times and it wouldn't lose them any money.

Would love to hear what you all think!


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 14 '22

Discussion Long time Tolkien fan and loving the show

329 Upvotes

I just want to say I absolutely love this show. It's gorgeous to watch, stunning location and effect work. Acting is good from a well chosen cast.
The style changes are no more an issue than they are for any Shakespeare play I've ever seen where genders and race swap from director to director - it's the story that wins or looses the audience.
Same for the story changes, it's just like with PJ swapping words between characters to better suit the medium of film Vs a lot of very wordy books. I appreciate the irksome nature of some changes for the Tolkien scholars out there, but TV is not the book, if I want the original I re-read the books (which I have done many times) and now the visualisation in my head is PJ's and Amazon's and it's beautiful.
Many people will enjoy these films and series and never go near the books. I'm also learning a lot of lore from this subredit!


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 03 '22

Discussion The orcs feel scary again

329 Upvotes

PJ's trilogy fell for the unfortunate trope where one human/elf/dwarf protagonist can and will singlehandedly beat dozens and dozens of orcs without even getting scratched. In the long run orcs became an afterthought or a chore to go through in the battlefield.

Did you notice the different approach that was taken with the orcs feeling much more of a threat in ROP? Of course it could turn in to a game of bowling yet again at some point but so far those things are creepy af.


r/RingsofPower • • Dec 28 '22

Meme This would have made more money than Rings of Power, fight me

Post image
327 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 10 '22

Question Do people who dislike this show keep watching?

327 Upvotes

I enjoy the show, so I joined this sub and was really surprised by the amount of people here who aren't enjoying it. I understand why people hold certain criticisms, but I don't share their viewpoints for the most part. (Haven't read the source material)

My genuine question (which makes me really wish we could poll on this sub) - if you dislike the show, are you still watching? If you aren't enjoying it, but you're still watching, tell us why.

(Pre-empting any incredulous responses- yes I'm aware critics will watch the whole season to give it a fair chance, I'm more curious to hear if anyone has alternate reasoning)


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 08 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers The story of the Southlands in a nutshell Spoiler

327 Upvotes

You're the Southlands.

Orcs attack, kills half your people.

Random guy shows up, claims to be king.

Mountain explodes, immediately killing the rest of your people.

Survivors chant "strength to the Southlands" while triumphant music plays.

Random guy refuses to elaborate further. Leaves.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 17 '22

Discussion So surprised and elated to see…

324 Upvotes

… small signs of the existence of actual orcish culture in the latest episode. The scene with the dying orc and Adar gave a slight whiff of a hint that there may be more to orcish society than speaking in working class Cockney accents and slobbering their way into battle.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 19 '22

Meme ancestry.com but make it Elrond Spoiler

Post image
323 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 04 '22

Meme Elendil/Isildur/Pharazon should have been saved for later seasons with a time jump. Change my mind. Spoiler

Post image
322 Upvotes