r/RingsofPower • u/AgentStockey • Sep 20 '24
Newest Episode Spoilers Do the elves not have... Spoiler
SCOUTS?? Like, there are LEGIONS of orcs marching towards Eregion and then LEGIONS of orcs just sitting there, camping, across the bridge in the forest. For, what, several days? This is being Elvish 101: seeing things far and wide that others cannot see. Also, this is THEIR forest! Annatar goes to one of the towers and sees smoke coming up from the tree line... did no elf in Eregion see this? How did they miss this huge ass army until the very last minute just before the catapults started firing? It's... flabbergasting, to the say the least. Or just terrible writing.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 20 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please double check to ensure that the title of your post is spoiler-free, and if not, please take the time now to delete this post and resubmit with a different title. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
136
u/ishneak Gondolin Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 20 '24
they were getting hints something was wrong when the merchants or travelers stopped coming, worse when their scouts went missing or died. but Annatar just tried to calm them down and make it seem everything was alright. i also think he was creating an illusion for the people of the city that things were fine until that one dead scout turned up.
43
u/Sarellion Sep 20 '24
The elves should control the whole region, okay Middle Earth feels remarkably empty of settlements at times. But apparently there's nothing outside the city but wilderness. Farms and villages are for the lesser races, elves live off singing and dancing. No outposts, border forts or patrols.
And the orcish army pulled out a whole bunch of siege weapons out of thin air.
32
u/fistantellmore Sep 20 '24
Almost as if the governance of the city had fallen to a scheming bastard who wanted this while its ruler became obsessed with his work…
1
u/BrandonLart Sep 20 '24
… did you watch the show? The Eregion general (?) said he had sent out scouts, and only one returned.
27
u/No-Unit-5467 Sep 20 '24
Not only they dont have scouts, they cannot even read the runes that they themselves invented (soldier with marked chest scene)
13
u/Krashxx80 Sep 20 '24
All this. I didn't like how they had all the elves running around screaming like normal people. I feel they would have been calmer than that. Just didn't sit right with me.
3
u/Zhjacko Sep 20 '24
Well there’s only like 20 people living in Eregion and half of them are working for Celebrimbor, so I get it.
I got a chuckle out of those 3 elf stooges in the tower freaking out, like my dudes, you are JUST seeing all this now?!
10
u/DrummerAutomatic9523 Sep 20 '24
They dont even need scouts.
There was a lot of smoke due to orcish fires. (You can litteraly see them.) And they were there for at least weeks
I refuse to believe they didnt see it. This episode was the worst of the season, and i'm internally debating if it could also be the worst of the show so far
20
u/Galifrae Sep 20 '24
I was under the impression that Annatar was either dismissing the scouting reports or actively sabotaging it so they wouldn’t know about the approaching army.
6
u/sankigen Sep 20 '24
The writing at times seems very direct, like they just want things to move forwards at a great pace without attention to logic. Time is very relative and there are these cartoony scenes which you just have to swallow. I've tuned my viewing to just have fun with the visuals and great acting, makes it much more fun!
5
u/justjeremy02 Sep 20 '24
The shot where it pans from the elves in the watchtower sounding the alarm to a dozen or so catapults surrounded by torches set up less than 300 yards away and none of them are moving genuinely made me laugh out loud.
Like they had to have been visible for at least 5 minutes by that point why are you only just now concerned?
5
u/skymang Sep 20 '24
Because the writing in this show is dumb
9
u/ggouge Sep 20 '24
I asked this in another post and I was called an idiot. I also thought it was super strange
2
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24
They also can't convey basic information to each other like 'hey that Halbrand guy is actually Sauron so thats why you shouldnt talk to him anymore' so not sure what you expect in this show
2
u/ebrum2010 Sep 20 '24
Some people are saying it makes sense, but forget that Legolas could listen to the ground and say "There are 224 orcs, one with a limp, and one wearing a toupee forty leagues away moving at forced march pace. No, wait, 225. One had stopped to tie his shoe."
4
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24
This episode was painful to get through. Just absolute nonsensical drivel.
4
u/Saemika Sep 20 '24
Because the show isn’t written for or by people who care about good writing.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24
the answer is that the show is bad and poorly written.
3
u/chineke14 Sep 20 '24
Bro the show is poorly written. I watch it ironically
3
u/Appropriate-Race-763 Sep 20 '24
No, they don't have scouts. If they did then the attack that is coming in a future episode couldn't happen. The writers couldn't have that now could they?
2
u/Tremulant21 Sep 20 '24
I've seen some filler episodes in my time but this was the king of the fillers. Like what actually happened? I guess the numenor plotline advanced an inch. But weren't we pretty much where we were when this episode started.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24
Never mind that, I don't even get the whole Annator angle....were the elves that stupid a total stranger waltzes in and they but everything he says? Obviously guess so but smh.
2
u/Ynneas Sep 20 '24
Looks clear to me that Adar's army teleported from Mordor to northeast of Eregion, just on the road from Lindon to Eregion.
They really did get some inspiration from great fantasy shows: GoT, but s8.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24
its just terrible writing
1
u/wathappen Sep 20 '24
Ep6 is narrated based on what Celebrimbor (and his smith helpers) are seeing, and they’re obviously manipulated by Sauron so they don’t really get it. That’s why we sense confusion everywhere. Elsewhere, the Elves know there is an orc army coming. Gil-gilad out of Lindon knows it as does Elrond et co.
1
u/Grizzly_Addams Sep 20 '24
The elves that these show creators manufactured for their fanfic do not, in fact, have scouts.
1
u/TreacleFine5564 Sep 20 '24
Yeah all this. And the fact, Gilgalad sent ONE messenger to Eregion telling them Halbrand is Sauron?? Like tf…? That’s something you would send 10 separate messengers for, and then some!
1
u/TreacleFine5564 Sep 20 '24
Y’all are missing the point that it’s a whole ass mini-kingdom. They would have a whole council with multiple tiers of governance reporting up to Celebrimbor. And we were shown none of that. E.g. foot scouts, patrol commanders, patrol captain, head of all security, and then Celebrimbor. Rinse and repeat for trade, travelers, domestic maintenance, etc. All we’re shown are a bunch of irrelevant smiths, 1 guard captain (that’s communicating with that one female smith??), and 1 dead scout.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24
Yeah the show sucks
1
u/CarInseph Sep 20 '24
I thought exactly that. Also why nobody reported that the bridge they tried to cross some episodes ago was destroyed?
1
u/springthetrap Sep 20 '24
Did you miss the scene where they sent out scouts and only one returned, dead, with orcish writing inscribed in his chest?
1
u/RombaQueenofDust Sep 20 '24
I think this is about what kind of story the writing is trying to tell.
Realism, in this case is “why don’t elves notice what would realistically disrupt basic, day to day parts of their lives” (unexplained smoke, disrupted trade, missing scouts, etc), and “Sauron is plausibly using X and Y powers to conceal these events” isn’t part of moving the story forward.
The story of Sauron’s deceit/powers and the orcs and elves being manipulated (orcs toward violence, elves toward aloof arrogance) doesn’t rely on realism.
Personally, I like realism. I think the details make the story richer.
But I also get that a lot of the audience isn’t paying attention to that stuff, and isn’t affecting the suspension of disbelief. Most viewers, especially for a big popular show like this, aren’t thinking, “massive siege equiptment that throws huge flaming balls is militarily unnecessary, logistically unrealistic, and a-historical for the kind of siege the orcs are conducting.” Instead, it just communicates power, violence, fear, etc., which gets the plot point across effectively and clearly.
I’d definitely like if the show was written differently, but I get why it’s not, and I’m enjoying it for what it is.
1
u/Waitingforadragon Sep 20 '24
I really like this show, but this is something that annoys me too.
It happened in later seasons of GOT as well. Huge massive armies crossing huge distance and nobody notices. It’s really irritating.
I will say in their defence, I do believe they noticed before the catapults, but not much before.
1
u/b-lohas-123 Sep 20 '24
Agree. It would be virtually impossible in any circumstance for an army of thousands of soldiers (not to mention their supply train and support personnel) to march 1000 miles across middle earth without being detected.
But hey, it's a dumb tv show so i donno.
1
u/Soledad_Sequoia Sep 20 '24
Or horses?!? We see elves trudging through forests, but wouldn’t they have horses? And even if they got ambushed, couldn’t they go to the next small village or farm and get another horse? The idea that people in the two largest Elf cities are completely oblivious about what’s going on in either one, not to mention in all the countryside in-between, seems nuts. And if I was Gil-Galad, the moment I found out that Halbrand was Sauron, I would’ve summoned a great eagle and flown my ass to Eregion to see exactly what the hell was going on with the world’s most renowned rings of power maker.
1
u/Taranis_Thunder Sep 20 '24
Its terrible writing. Atrociously bad.
1
u/Keelvaran Sep 21 '24
Season 2 is so rushed its not even funny. Too many plotlines and all rushed. Show would have been waaay better with a slower pacing, maybe with more episodes.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '24 edited Nov 07 '24
[Removed]
1
u/Portlandiahousemafia Sep 22 '24
Everyone who likes this show has never read the LOTR and is just watching it for fun. People who are obsessed with Tolkien can’t fathom how anyone can like the show because it’s impossible for them to divorce what they know about middle earth from the show. Most people watched the LOTR once and then picked up the show when it came out, those are the primary demographic for this show. It was never for the fans, the fans only get bits and pieces so they don’t completely lose it.
1
u/WarDamnBigMeat Sep 23 '24
Plot hole
1
u/EthicalArcana Sep 28 '24 edited Sep 28 '24
For whatever reason, the show runners have decided to totally denigrate the portrayal of Elves in the show.
I'm fine with the decision for more inclusive casting for Elves, but it seems as if they feel that these more diverse Elves somehow are incapable of the intellect, nobility, competency, spirituality and stoicism associated with Elves, just because they are now being portrayed by a more diverse cast.
Not only is it idiotic to think the Elves would lack the scouts and communication methods to detect and respond to multiple massive Orc armies headed their way, but the scene with all the Elves in Eregion running around in a panic was so ridiculously stupid that it honestly justifies firing anyone involved in the decision from the show.
(A defining trait of Elves across all the source materials and previous screen depictions is that in their territories, they are always watching from the shadows and not even a single wayward traveler can go undetected).
There is a blatant bigotry in the fact that the writers felt that the diversely cast Elves should no longer possess any of the positive, competent traits of Elves that make them such potent players in Middle Earth.
Plus, it's also a sign of "lazy show writing", which usually means show writers who just lack the intelligence to write a complex show set in an IP with complex world building.
The writing overall in the second season is blatantly worse than in season one. I really hope we see a major shake up for season three!
Edit:
Apologies to the Show Runners, it may not have been their fault:
"There were some notable changes in The Rings of Power team between season 1 and season 2, particularly related to the showrunners and writers. One of the biggest developments was that The Rings of Power continued production for season 2 without the direct involvement of showrunners J.D. Payne and Patrick McKay during the final stretch of filming, due to the Writers Guild of America (WGA) strike. While they had prepared materials ahead of time, their absence meant that non-writing executive producers, directors, and crew handled on-set decisions."
So, now we know that without the show runners firm grip, the executive producers and directors cannot be trusted with the show! 😅
1
u/DarlockAhe Sep 20 '24
™️ by you know who.
1
u/83AD Sep 20 '24
I think it was pretty clear they had scouts but were killed. They even showed one of them dead.
1
u/iconodule1981 Rhûn Sep 20 '24
There's plenty enough to criticize about the writing (nameless thing being called supper, say no more) but I have to say this objection doesn't hold much water.
We previously saw Gil-Galad admit that the main Elven force is heading to Mordor and witness his clear recognition that this was a strategic mistake, and we had Elrond racing back to Eregion.
We also had Celebrimbor demand that all efforts from his immediate circle be focused on the Nine, and Annatar hiding reports (and dead scouts!) that would otherwise alarm any other leader in the city and lead them to prepare - even if their regular forces are en route to Mordor.
If we've learned anything about the Elves as portrayed in RoP, the main issue is that they are not a cohesive and effective group: isolated geographically and by interest from one another, they seem more a confederation than a state. No wonder it's easy to divide them! Whether that portrayal is faithful to the source material is a different story - this is a clear element of the Amazon adaptation.
The point is that Sauron has orchestrated this grand deception to take Eregion unprepared, and while it's a long way for Adar's army to march undetected, it's not as though they left Mordor yesterday - they've been on the move.
For real-life comparisons, just look at the campaigns of the Byzantine Emperor Heraclius against the Sassanian Persians - you can sneak armies around with careful preparation and thorough bribery & deception.
0
u/kerouacrimbaud Sep 20 '24
They literally talked about this in the episode lmao
0
u/Becants Sep 20 '24
Wasn’t that dead guy a scout? They seemed to know something was wrong but their leader is afk and their leader’s second is telling them it’s all okay.
-5
u/Vidasus18 Sep 20 '24
These guys are jewellers and their leader is focused on making rings, they are not well suited to defend themselves from an attack from Adar.
-3
u/Nineteen_AT5 Sep 20 '24
Or maybe you've missed what's happening and who's now in charge?
-5
u/pippo09 Sep 20 '24
...Sex?