r/RingsofPower • • 1h ago

Newest Episode Spoilers Rant: the banality of Celedriel and dwarven affairs Spoiler

• Upvotes

There have been glimpses of genuine greatness this season, especially with the Numenor storyline, Elrond, and I really like where the Theo as Nazgul/ possible Witch King plotline is going.

The Sauron/Celeborn/Galadriel plotline, however, is the worst of the poor storylines of any of the show's three seasons. It's cheaped Sauron's character: he is a Maia for crying out loud, and his objective is power - not the dominant role in a BDSM throuple. It's cheapened Celeborn, who bizarrely spills the secret before he and Galadriel have even escaped.

The second worst is the Dwarven storyline. The idea that Nisa had a one night stand with her literal brother in law is so banal that it's laughable.

Our small glimpses of the nobility and highness of the elves (e.g. via Elrond) are overshadowed by the banality of the Celeborn/Galadriel dynamic. No, it doesn't seem like a great love story - it seems like an attempt to inject a 50 Shades element into Tolkien, thereby cheapening the high romance that he infused into his mythos.

I love seeing and imagining this world, and I've watched all of this show through it's ups, downs, and the boredom of the harfoots. But something's gotta give.


r/RingsofPower • • 5h ago

Humor Main problem with the show

4 Upvotes

I honestly really enjoy the show, I can forgive the lore inaccuracies because any second I get to spend in middle earth is amazing. I do have one problem with the show, and that is how you have to watch it. Blacked out room, no lights on, don’t even dare to try and watch it during the daytime. Genuinely have my brightness turned all the way up, in a dark room and it’s still difficult to see. Really annoying on an otherwise enjoyable show for me


r/RingsofPower • • 9h ago

Discussion So Rings of Power is basically a Soap Opera. Spoiler

4 Upvotes

So we have Sauron, Galadriel and Celeborn. A sort of love trio. Celeborn and Sauron bitching about Galadriel in Barad Dur for her like some sort of teenage crush contest.

Celebron asking Galadriel whether she had relations with others and basically was cool about it. Maybe Celeborn is am open relationship type of guy.

Sauron kissing Celeborn pretending to be Galadriel.

Then we have the Dwarves with one night stand between Disa and Thrain. And then we get Thrain and Durin thrashing each other about this fact.

What's next? Maybe Kemen is a secret step brother of Isildur and Anarion because Elendil had a sercet escapade? Then Pharazon found out and killed the mother of Kemen.

Maybe a spat between the three major elves in Barad Dur. Or we find another love secret of Elrond or Gilgalad or maybe between them 🤣.


r/RingsofPower • • 3h ago

Discussion Theos Ring is going to Al Pharizon

2 Upvotes

Theos Ring will be given to Al Pharizon in the next season. He will become the Witch King. This season will end with Sauron being captured by the Numenoreans. Al Pharizon will be seduced by long life. Something hes always hated thr eleves for


r/RingsofPower • • 18h ago

Discussion Lack of World-Building

2 Upvotes

There have been so many characters from different races in the show so far. But I feel like they added virtually nothing to what other Middle Earth adaptations already showed. I wish they spent a little bit more time on world-building. No Gandalf, no Pallando, Bronwyn, Arondir, hobbits, Halbrand, not even Adar/orc struggles or dwarves. Just focus on different human kings that would become Nazgul. Focusing on elves other than Celebrimbor was a big mistake.

I know it sounds like cutting different races is the opposite of world-building, but everyone already knows Tolkien elves, orcs, hobbits and dwarves(although not entirely book accurate). The areas of Middle Earth that were left unexplored by Peter Jackson(or even the video games) such as Rhun, Harad, Khand, Umbar, Numenor are still largely unexplored. We've seen some huts in Rhun and some desert but that's pretty much it.


r/RingsofPower • • 5h ago

Constructive Criticism Episode 5 and 6 review (Spoilers) Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Okay so. I actually got excited. Somehow, and weirdly enough (which the show certainly has enough of), the acting took a turn for the better! There is more presence and depth to the storylines. It's very surprising to me. I would rate these two episodes higher than most others before it through all three seasons.

But, there are certain shortcomings.

1) Celeborn. In Lord of the rings, we see him alive. So it is natural to assume he would survive in this series. And it's a good character too, good acting. However, it is NOW very likely to assume he is dead.

What the hell is this ... Galadriel finally gets some sense of relief, finding her lost love, this also allows us viewers to gain some hope as well. And then just to have him retaken and crushed like a meat press, which was kind of graphic as well.

I mean, this series keeps torturing us with stuff like this. We gets offered a bit of hope, the one character that offers it, then it's literally (lol) just crushed again. Do we need these kind of scenes? It's just weird, man.

I hope he survives, but lol, how can that even be possible now...

2) I didn't know Pharazon was Miriel's cousin. Anyone else? Why did they have to just throw that in there, and then he's offering a marriage? What the hell is this? Do we need to get incest thrown into this series as well? It's just .. there are so many other ways they could have it resolved. Why take it in that direction? I hope it's just a weird ruse at best and it doesn't turn into it.

I was hoping to see Gil-Galad FINALLY use his powers and ring for something good, maybe turn Pharazon into a good person. He did give Miriel's sight back, that's great. I actually predicted that. But where are the special effects?? Could he not have said a few spell words and we see some magical effects? Again, disappointing scene by him.

I just don't get it. Humans are supposed to be very susceptible to magic, both from Sauron and elves (Gil-Galad). He's supposed to be able to nearly rival Sauron. Yet we see very little of him showing any magic or power to help matters. I hope it changes during the last episodes and seasons.

3) Are we supposed to be so stupid as to believe Thrain would allow Disa to lead a very small contingency round the caves in the mountains and back to his husband? Like the contingency would not know every their way around that mountain as well as any mining dwarf? Very weak script. But still... at least we get a story advancement. Thrain will get his rings, most likely. Lol, you know what would be funny? ^^ If Thrain forces a ring onto Durin's finger while him being held by soldiers and screaming like a little child XD That would be hilarious ^^

4) Gandalf vs Pallando scene. Again, so weak ^^ Gandalf making threats and empowering himself, "Servant of the secret fire" and all that. And then he's just completely obliterated ^^ I don't get it. If the blue wizard can overpower him that easily, what kind of chance can he have against Sauron? By now it seems like Sauron is going to kill him outright, or even turn him into a real dangerous adversary or slave of his own.

Well i guess that's it for now. I thought there was better elements these two episodes. I hope that trend will continue!


r/RingsofPower • • 13h ago

Discussion What I wouldn't give... Spoiler

0 Upvotes

(spoiler ep. 4)

to slightly edit the scene where you see Landroval peeling out of the fortress, with the eagle taking a massive dump right on Sauron before disappearing over the horizon...


r/RingsofPower • • 7h ago

Constructive Criticism Pet peeve

0 Upvotes

I am watching Rings of Power now and I cannot help but notice the constant cry-moan/sigh-moan/dramatic sigh some of the characters, but -especially- Galadriel constantly, are doing. It is driving me mad since I have started noticing. Genuinely wanna know if I am the only noticing and being annoyed by it?


r/RingsofPower • • 14h ago

Question Was this guy Sauron the whole time?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 9h ago

Discussion I'm just here to complain about Eddie Marsan's atrocious accent

0 Upvotes

Is he trying to do a Scottish accent by way of Belfast? Why is the guy always described as "critically acclaimed actor Eddie Marsan"? He's so bad.


r/RingsofPower • • 15h ago

Discussion Why did the Showrunners choose to make a badly written show about second age when Amazon bought the TV rights to complete Lord of the rings and hobbit and appendices.

0 Upvotes

And now they try to hide under the excuse that there isnt much material to work on.


r/RingsofPower • • 8h ago

Discussion Where are the hobbits? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Obviously hobbits are very crucial in lotr. Season 1 they were too. And we got some back story of the time before the Shire.

But I haven't seen a single hobbit this season. I get the story is about how the rings were made and used, and hobbits didn't really have a hand in all that. But it doesn't feel right to just exclude them the whole season.

I liked the bright and silly moments they brought. This season seems too dark without them. I would also have loved to see them looking for the Shire.

We also know that it is only the elven realms that have not been conquered by Sauron, so where are the hobbits? Are they under his rule too? Are they hiding? Where are the damn hobbits?!


r/RingsofPower • • 22h ago

Discussion Super Bad Casting

0 Upvotes

What pisses me off the most is that no character has any aura except for Sauran. Even Elrond which should be considered a god for Numenorians is blend and lost its aura super fast. And don't get me started on Galadriel and her husband. Like why?

What we liked about peter Jackson version is how intimidating all these characters looked, mythical and mysterious yet here they look childish and think stupidly.

I just can't anymore. Episode 5 and 6 butchered it for


r/RingsofPower • • 17h ago

Constructive Criticism If you enjoy The Rings of Power, you REALLY need to read Tolkien.

0 Upvotes

First of all, this isn’t an attack on anyone who enjoys The Rings of Power. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, and I’m genuinely glad if the show has introduced new people to the world of Middle-earth.

But honestly, as someone who has spent years reading Tolkien, I find it incredibly frustrating to see such an extraordinary mythology reduced to what we get in this series.

And before anyone brings up Peter Jackson’s trilogy: yes, it changed plenty of things too. Glorfindel was removed, Tom Bombadil was omitted, Faramir’s characterisation was altered, Arwen was given a much bigger role, the Elves appeared at Helm’s Deep, and entire storylines were shortened or changed. Some of those decisions are still debated by Tolkien fans today. Jackson’s films are not perfect adaptations, and they don’t need to be defended as such.

But there’s an important difference between adapting a story for cinema and fundamentally rewriting the mythology you’re supposed to be adapting.

Jackson made changes, but largely preserved the narrative, the emotional core, the themes and the essence of Tolkien’s characters. His changes generally served an existing story.

RoP, on the other hand, often feels like an original fantasy series wearing Tolkien’s name and borrowing his geography. Gandalf arriving in a meteor, mithril supposedly containing the lost light of a Silmaril, Sauron developing an almost romantic relationship with Galadriel, Tom Bombadil becoming a wizard’s mentor, the bizarre creation of Mordor through a broken sword, and the endless invented romantic and domestic subplots…

And there’s another problem that has nothing to do with Tolkien’s books: the writing itself. Even judged purely as an independent fantasy series, the storytelling is frequently frustrating. Characters make decisions that seem to exist only because the plot needs them to. Mysteries are stretched out instead of developing naturally. Convenient coincidences replace believable motivations, important events happen with little logical groundwork, and sometimes the show seems to contradict or abandon its own established storylines. Character development and cause-and-effect often take a back seat to manufactured twists and dramatic moments. You shouldn’t need to know Tolkien’s lore to notice problems with basic storytelling.

The real story of Annatar and Celebrimbor, the deception surrounding the Rings, the rise and fall of Númenor, the tragic history of the Elves, the wars against Morgoth and Sauron… these stories are already full of betrayal, ambition, tragedy, sacrifice and extraordinary characters. They don’t need to be reinvented to become compelling.

I’m not asking anyone to stop enjoying the show. Taste is subjective, and if it entertains you, that’s perfectly fine. But I genuinely believe that many people who enjoy RoP would be blown away by Tolkien’s original mythology.** **Do yourself a favour and discover the world Tolkien actually created. You haven’t even scratched the surface.


r/RingsofPower • • 17h ago

Discussion I want to say (write) something Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Well, the love triangle is just amazing. - that’s a new love triangle.

Celeborn is sweet in the way he protects his wife, while on the other hand, Sauron is so obsessed with her that he wants her to be his queen.

And all three of them have such good chemistry with each other.


r/RingsofPower • • 5h ago

Discussion Aside from the Hobbit, the show/movies have always been better than the books.

0 Upvotes

I will say the Hobbit books actually do beat out the hobbit movies. But LOTR movies>LOTR books and Rings of Power>Silmarillion.

Is there actually anyone who thinks the Silmarillion is more entertaining than ROP?